https://news.berkeley.edu/2022/06/10/astronomers-may-have-detected-a-dark-free-floating-black-hole/ Skip to content News Search * All news * UC Berkeley * Research + Subcategories in Research o Technology & engineering o Business & economics o Humanities o Mind & body o Politics & society o Science & environment o All Research + Top Stories in Research thumbnails of 7 Bakar Fellows Mind & body Bakar Fellows program names seven new Spark Award recipients + Top Stories in Research field of stars with black hole in center Science & environment Astronomers may have detected a 'dark' free-floating black hole + Top Stories in Research ship labeled 'powered by ammonia' Science & environment Renewed funding for Energy & Biosciences Institute, with focus on sustainable fuels * People + Subcategories in People o Profiles o Awards o Milestones o All People + Top Stories in People a person holds a heart-shaped sign that reads "Trans people belong" Profiles How UC Berkeley became a national leader in trans care + Top Stories in People thumbnails of 7 Bakar Fellows Awards Bakar Fellows program names seven new Spark Award recipients + Top Stories in People Lora Roame's sketchbook and paints lie on a table. Her artwork is of falcons. Profiles Artists near and far find inspiration in UC Berkeley's peregrine falcons * Campus & community + Subcategories in Campus & community o Campus news o Work life o Events at Berkeley o All Campus & community + Top Stories in Campus & community a person holds a heart-shaped sign that reads "Trans people belong" Work life How UC Berkeley became a national leader in trans care + Top Stories in Campus & community A performer on stilts from the Daring Arts Movement performs in front of the MLK Student Union. Campus news UC Berkeley celebrates staff during appreciation carnival + Top Stories in Campus & community Lora Roame's sketchbook and paints lie on a table. Her artwork is of falcons. Campus news Artists near and far find inspiration in UC Berkeley's peregrine falcons * Arts & culture + o Performing arts o Literature o Film o Visual arts o Events calendar o All arts & culture + o Lora Roame's sketchbook and paints lie on a table. Her artwork is of falcons. Visual arts Artists near and far find inspiration in UC Berkeley's peregrine falcons o black and white tryptic of a woman with a bowl Film, Visual arts Filmmaker Trinh T. Minh-ha on the beauty of receiving the world o a rabbi in the 1930s reads books at a table Visual arts Berkeley Talks: Scholars on Roman Vishniac's photos of Jewish life before WWII * Opinion + o Berkeley Blog o Voices o All opinion + o [1230859312] Berkeley Blog Striking a balance between climate despair and magical solutions o solar panels Andrew Campbell: What does being energy independent really mean? o A weathered man sits in what seems to be quiet despair Berkeley Blog Combat homelessness by expanding state-funded housing programs MENU Research, Science & environment Astronomers may have detected a 'dark' free-floating black hole By Robert Sanders, Media relations| June 10, 2022June 14, 2022 * Tweet * * Reddit * Email * Print * June 10, 2022June 14, 2022 Robert Sanders Astronomers may have discovered the first free-floating black hole in the Milky Way galaxy, thanks to a technique called gravitational microlensing. With new observations, they hope to find many more such ghost stars. (Video by Roxanne Makasdjian and Alan Toth, with microlensing animations from Casey Lam and Sean Terry, UC Berkeley's Moving Universe Lab, and image data courtesy of the OGLE collaboration. Additional images courtesy of the National Science Foundation and NASA.) If, as astronomers believe, the death of large stars leave behind black holes, there should be hundreds of millions of them scattered throughout the Milky Way galaxy. The problem is, isolated black holes are invisible. Now, a team led by University of California, Berkeley, astronomers has for the first time discovered what may be a free-floating black hole by observing the brightening of a more distant star as its light was distorted by the object's strong gravitational field -- so-called gravitational microlensing. The team, led by graduate student Casey Lam and Jessica Lu, a UC Berkeley associate professor of astronomy, estimates that the mass of the invisible compact object is between 1.6 and 4.4 times that of the sun. Because astronomers think that the leftover remnant of a dead star must be heavier than 2.2 solar masses in order to collapse to a black hole, the UC Berkeley researchers caution that the object could be a neutron star instead of a black hole. Neutron stars are also dense, highly compact objects, but their gravity is balanced by internal neutron pressure, which prevents further collapse to a black hole. Whether a black hole or a neutron star, the object is the first dark stellar remnant -- a stellar "ghost" -- discovered wandering through the galaxy unpaired with another star. "This is the first free-floating black hole or neutron star discovered with gravitational microlensing," Lu said. "With microlensing, we're able to probe these lonely, compact objects and weigh them. I think we have opened a new window onto these dark objects, which can't be seen any other way." Determining how many of these compact objects populate the Milky Way galaxy will help astronomers understand the evolution of stars -- in particular, how they die -- and of our galaxy, and perhaps reveal whether any of the unseen black holes are primordial black holes, which some cosmologists think were produced in large quantities during the Big Bang. The analysis by Lam, Lu and their international team has been accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal Letters. The analysis includes four other microlensing events that the team concluded were not caused by a black hole, though two were likely caused by a white dwarf or a neutron star. The team also concluded that the likely population of black holes in the galaxy is 200 million -- about what most theorists predicted. Same data, different conclusions Notably, a competing team from the Space Telescope Science Institute (STScI) in Baltimore analyzed the same microlensing event and claims that the mass of the compact object is closer to 7.1 solar masses and indisputably a black hole. A paper describing the analysis by the STScI team, led by Kailash Sahu, has been accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal. a field of orangish stars against a light orange background Hubble Space Telescope image of a distant star that was brightened and distorted by an invisible but very compact and heavy object between it and Earth. The compact object -- estimated by UC Berkeley astronomers to be between 1.6 and 4.4 times the mass of our sun -- could be a free-floating black hole, one of perhaps 200 million in the Milky Way galaxy. (Image courtesy of STScI/NASA/ESA) Both teams used the same data: photometric measurements of the distant star's brightening as its light was distorted or "lensed" by the super-compact object, and astrometric measurements of the shifting of the distant star's location in the sky as a result of the gravitational distortion by the lensing object. The photometric data came from two microlensing surveys: the Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment (OGLE), which employs a 1.3-meter telescope in Chile operated by Warsaw University, and the Microlensing Observations in Astrophysics (MOA) experiment, which is mounted on a 1.8-meter telescope in New Zealand operated by Osaka University. The astrometric data came from NASA's Hubble Space Telescope. STScI manages the science program for the telescope and conducts its science operations. Because both microlensing surveys caught the same object, it has two names: MOA-2011-BLG-191 and OGLE-2011-BLG-0462, or OB110462, for short. While surveys like these discover about 2,000 stars brightened by microlensing each year in the Milky Way galaxy, the addition of astrometric data is what allowed the two teams to determine the mass of the compact object and its distance from Earth. The UC Berkeley-led team estimated that it lies between 2,280 and 6,260 light years (700-1920 parsecs) away, in the direction of the center of the Milky Way Galaxy and near the large bulge that surrounds the galaxy's central massive black hole. The STScI group estimated that it lies about 5,153 light years (1,580 parsecs) away. Looking for a needle in a haystack Lu and Lam first became interested in the object in 2020 after the STScI team tentatively concluded that five microlensing events observed by Hubble -- all of which lasted for more than 100 days, and thus could have been black holes -- might not be caused by compact objects after all. blue light from distant star gets distorted by warped spacetime around black hole This illustration shows how the gravity of a black hole warps spacetime and bends the light of a distant star so that its position is shifted as seen from Earth. This deflection, captured by the Hubble Space Telescope (left foreground), and the associated brightening of the star allow astronomers to discover these otherwise invisible, free-floating objects and calculate their mass and velocity. (Illustration credit: NASA, ESA, STScI, Joseph Olmsted) Lu, who has been looking for free-floating black holes since 2008, thought the data would help her better estimate their abundance in the galaxy, which has been roughly estimated at between 10 million and 1 billion. To date, star-sized black holes have been found only as part of binary star systems. Black holes in binaries are seen either in X-rays, produced when material from the star falls onto the black hole, or by recent gravitational wave detectors, which are sensitive to mergers of two or more black holes. But these events are rare. "Casey and I saw the data and we got really interested. We said, 'Wow, no black holes. That's amazing,' even though there should have been," Lu said. "And so, we started looking at the data. If there were really no black holes in the data, then this wouldn't match our model for how many black holes there should be in the Milky Way. Something would have to change in our understanding of black holes -- either their number or how fast they move or their masses." When Lam analyzed the photometry and astrometry for the five microlensing events, she was surprised that one, OB110462, had the characteristics of a compact object: The lensing object seemed dark, and thus not a star; the stellar brightening lasted a long time, nearly 300 days; and the distortion of the background star's position also was long-lasting. The length of the lensing event was the main tipoff, Lam said. In 2020, she showed that the best way to search for black hole microlenses was to look for very long events. Only 1% of detectable microlensing events are likely to be from black holes, she said, so looking at all events would be like searching for a needle in a haystack. But, Lam calculated, about 40% of microlensing events that last more than 120 days are likely to be black holes. "How long the brightening event lasts is a hint of how massive the foreground lens bending the light of the background star is," Lam said. "Long events are more likely due to black holes. It's not a guarantee, though, because the duration of the brightening episode not only depends on how massive the foreground lens is, but also on how fast the foreground lens and background star are moving relative to each other. However, by also getting measurements of the apparent position of the background star, we can confirm whether the foreground lens really is a black hole." According to Lu, the gravitational influence of OB110462 on the light of the background star was amazingly long. It took about one year for the star to brighten to its peak in 2011, then about a year to dim back to normal. More data will distinguish black hole from neutron star To confirm that OB110462 was caused by a super-compact object, Lu and Lam asked for more astrometric data from Hubble, some of which arrived last October. That new data showed that the change in position of the star as a result of the gravitational field of the lens is still observable 10 years after the event. Further Hubble observations of the microlens are tentatively scheduled for fall 2022. Analysis of the new data confirmed that OB110462 was likely a black hole or neutron star. a background of stars, with 4 boxes showing magnified central stars over a period of 7 years The star-filled sky in this Hubble Space Telescope photo is located in the direction of the galactic center. While monitored the sky in search of stars that dramatically brighten, the telescope discovered one (center) that brightened and dimmed between 2011 and 2017. This may have been caused by a foreground black hole drifting in front of the star, gravitationally brightening it and distorting its position relative to background stars . (Image credit: NASA, ESA, Kailash Sahu (STScI), with image processing by STScI's Joseph DePasquale) Lu and Lam suspect that the differing conclusions of the two teams are due to the fact that the astrometric and photometric data give different measures of the relative motions of the foreground and background objects. The astrometric analysis also differs between the two teams. The UC Berkeley-led team argues that it is not yet possible to distinguish whether the object is a black hole or a neutron star, but they hope to resolve the discrepancy with more Hubble data and improved analysis in the future. "As much as we would like to say it is definitively a black hole, we must report all allowed solutions. This includes both lower mass black holes and possibly even a neutron star," Lu said. "If you can't believe the light curve, the brightness, then that says something important. If you don't believe the position versus time, that tells you something important," Lam said. "So, if one of them is wrong, we have to understand why. Or the other possibility is that what we measure in both data sets is correct, but our model is incorrect. The photometry and astrometry data arise from the same physical process, which means the brightness and position must be consistent with each other. So, there's something missing there. " Both teams also estimated the velocity of the super-compact lensing object. The Lu/Lam team found a relatively sedate speed, less than 30 kilometers per second. The STScI team found an unusually large velocity, 45 km/s, which it interpreted as the result of an extra kick that the purported black hole got from the supernova that generated it. Lu interprets her team's low velocity estimate as potentially supporting a new theory that black holes are not the result of supernovas -- the reigning assumption today -- but instead come from failed supernovas that don't make a bright splash in the universe or give the resulting black hole a kick. The work of Lu and Lam is supported by the National Science Foundation (1909641) and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NNG16PJ26C, NASA FINESST 80NSSC21K2043). RELATED INFORMATION * An isolated mass gap black hole or neutron star detected with astrometric microlensing (arXiv) * An isolated stellar-mass black hole detected through astrometric microlensing (arXiv) * NASA press release * Jessica Lu's The Moving Universe Lab * Tweet * * Reddit * Email * Print * Topics: astronomy and space sciences, press releases Top Stories a person holds a heart-shaped sign that reads "Trans people belong" How UC Berkeley became a national leader in trans... thumbnails of 7 Bakar Fellows Bakar Fellows program names seven new Spark Award... A performer on stilts from the Daring Arts Movement performs in front of the MLK Student Union. UC Berkeley celebrates staff during appreciation... --------------------------------------------------------------------- Related Stories ship labeled 'powered by ammonia' Renewed funding for Energy & Biosciences... The 2021 winners of the Nobel Prize in economics met at UC Berkeley. From left: Guido W. Imbens, Stanford University; David Card, UC Berkeley; and Joshua D. Angrist, Massachusetts Institute of Technology A far-flung economics network celebrates Berkeley... --------------------------------------------------------------------- Trending now * Campus & communityold cars and people walk on a sunny day on campusFilm crew sends UC Berkeley back to the 1940s * Researchfield of stars with black hole in centerAstronomers may have detected a 'dark' free-floating black hole * Arts & cultureLora Roame's sketchbook and paints lie on a table. Her artwork is of falcons.Artists near and far find inspiration in UC Berkeley's peregrine falcons --------------------------------------------------------------------- VIDEOS PODCASTS collage of old photo, dried plant, archivist Amy Buried in archives, Civil War diary inspires... a person looks at his house that was destroyed by a hurricane Berkeley Talks: Climate displacement and remaking... Twitter @bobthesciguy Chinese fossils plucked from the commercial market shed light on the origins of a termite-eating hyena.... https://t.co/6ws4Hm7tI8 about 1 hour ago You Might Also Like Sather Gate UC Berkeley statement on court ruling that leaves student... a pink harlequin toad Losing amphibian diversity also means losing poison... Alex Filippenko teaching in front of a picture of a comet Alex Filippenko honored by astronomical society for... rendering of the James Webb Space Telescope Berkeley astronomers to put new space telescope through its... Browse * All news * Topics A-Z Follow Us * View UCBerkeley's profile on Facebook * View UCBerkeley's profile on Twitter * View UCBerkeleyOfficial's profile on Instagram * View UCZAXKyvvIV4uU4YvP5dmrmA's profile on YouTube * View UCBerkeley's profile on Medium About * About us * Contact the news team * Enroll in our online media training * Find an Expert Subscribe * Sign up for email news alerts * Subscribe to The Berkeleyan, our weekly email newsletter University of California Berkeley Copyright (c) 2022 UC Regents; all rights reserved * Accessibility * Nondiscrimination * Privacy Search * All news * UC Berkeley * Research + Technology & engineering + Business & economics + Humanities + Mind & body + Politics & society + Science & environment + All research * People + Profiles + Awards + Milestones + All people * Campus & community + Campus news + Work life + Events at Berkeley + All campus & community * Arts & culture + Performing arts + Visual arts + Film + Literature + All arts & culture * Opinion + Berkeley Blog + Voices + All opinion Send to Email Address [ ] Your Name [ ] Your Email Address [ ] [ ] loading [Send Email] Cancel Post was not sent - check your email addresses! Email check failed, please try again Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Latest COVID-19 information and resources. [X] Close