https://www.newsroom.co.nz/ideasroom/parking-kills-businesses-not-bikes-or-buses pk_live_8nCMqHeEQgtSCo3OHoXuT22F * --------------------------------------------------------------------- nr logo Contribute to Newsroom and support quality NZ journalism Become a supporter * Facebook * Twitter * Linkedin * Home * About * Contact * Donate * Newsroom * Newsroom Pro * LockerRoom * Sustainable Future * Investigations * ReadingRoom * Video ideasroom Newsroom Expand search [ ] SEARCH SIGN IN TO PRO SUBSCRIBE TO PRO Newsroom SIGN IN TO PRO SUBSCRIBE TO PRO * Facebook * Twitter * Linkedin * Home * About * Contact * Donate * newsroom * newsroom pro * lockerroom * sustainable future * investigations * readingroom * video * Expand search [ ] SEARCH SUBSCRIBE TO PRO SIGN IN [ ] * newsroom * newsroom pro * lockerroom * sustainable future * investigations * readingroom * video * About * Contact * Donate Far more people cycle to the shops than business owners realise. Photo: Lynn Grieveson Far more people cycle to the shops than business owners realise. Photo: Lynn Grieveson First published NOV 5, 2021 Updated Nov 8, 2021 Dr Timothy F. Welch Dr Timothy F. Welch Dr Timothy F. Welch is a Senior Lecturer in the School of Architecture and Planning at the University of Auckland's Faculty of Creative Arts and Industries. Show more Transport Parking kills businesses, not bikes or buses Dr Timothy F Welch explains how digging deep to address our massive car addiction might yet save local businesses Auckland Council recently announced plans to start removing on-street parking along certain arterials. The move, as expected, garnered an immediate and visceral response from many groups, but perhaps none so vocal as business associations. The groups were alarmed by the potential impact such a move might have on local businesses. The typical war cry - with some paraphrasing - rang out, "removing parking will kill local businesses". Understandably, such groups and business owners are concerned about the policy. Many business owners believe that a significant portion of their patronage arrives by car, and thus removing parking will force customers to shop elsewhere. This perception is common, but it is also misguided. Studies from across the globe have found that shop owners consistently overestimate the number of shoppers that arrive by car and vastly underestimate the number of people who arrive by other modes. [gugwmclnv2] In a study of Parkdale Village in Toronto, a quarter of business owners estimated that over half their customers drove to their business - in reality, just 4 percent drive. The rest biked, walked or took public transport. This misconception often occurs because business owners overestimate how far people travel to shop in their stores. A study in Berlin found that shop owners believed only about 12 percent of customers lived within 1km of a shopping street when more than 51 percent of customers lived within that walkable distance. Local shops attract local customers, and those customers rarely drive. Both the Toronto and Berlin studies found that people on foot, on bikes or taking public transport spend more money when they go to local shops and visit much more often than those who travel by car. In the case of Berlin, people who did not drive were responsible for more than 90 percent of weekly spending. Replacing kerb-side parking with bus or bike lanes does not hurt local businesses, and in some cases, it can increase patronage. Bikes and buses don't kill businesses - parking does. In addition to being relatively unimportant to local business, on-street parking can be wasteful and harmful. The availability of free or under-priced parking encourages excessive auto-travel. During the few peak periods when most of the on-street parking is in use, drivers will circle the block searching for a free or cheap car park in a behaviour known as cruising, which adds to congestion and increases vehicle emissions. People parking vehicles and getting in and out of those cars pose a significant risk to people on bikes. Bike lanes are typically painted between moving traffic and kerb-side parking. When drivers dart in and out of parking spaces, they can neglect to look for cyclists or not see them approaching, leading to serious vehicle-cyclist collisions. Even more common, drivers often fail to check their mirrors before opening their door; this can lead to cyclists hitting the door and suffering severe injuries or even death in an event known as dooring. Kerbs, like streets, are public spaces and should be put to use to benefit the greatest number of people. On-street parking benefits a couple of dozen individuals. Dedicated bus lanes and protected bike lanes benefit many thousands of people, including drivers. A single 1.8m bike lane can accommodate 12,000 people per hour, and a local bus lane can carry up to 5000 people per hour. Many people view parking in front of their residences as their space. However, property ownership ends at the berm, long before reaching the area reserved for on-street parking. Expecting free parking in front of one's house is like cordoning off a section of the beach and never allowing anyone to enter. The space along the kerb belongs to all of us. We should use it in a way that benefits all of us. Cars spend the vast majority of their lives parked. More than 95 percent of the time, cars are simply parked in one location or another. Given that New Zealand has the fourth highest number of cars per capita in the world (about 837 vehicles per 1000 people), it's no wonder we get so upset about parking - our vehicles need a lot of it, a lot of the time. Parking is, however, just a symptom of our massive car addiction. Removing parking addresses one of these symptoms, but at the same time, we should be working to address the underlying issues causing our parking woes, which include land uses that have spread out so far that we need a car to complete our daily activities; systematic underinvestment in public transportation and infrastructure for active modes; under-pricing driving and infrastructure (including parking); and over-investment in roads of all kinds. AT's update to their 2015 Parking Strategy is a move in the right direction, but if we want to meet our climate goals - the stated purpose of this new policy approach - we'll need to dig much deeper to treat our addiction. In doing so, we may yet save local businesses. Help us create a sustainable future for independent local journalism As New Zealand moves from crisis to recovery mode the need to support local industry has been brought into sharp relief. As our journalists work to ask the hard questions about our recovery, we also look to you, our readers for support. Reader donations are critical to what we do. If you can help us, please click the button to ensure we can continue to provide quality independent journalism you can trust. Become a Supporter JOIN THE CONVERSATION Post comments with a Newsroom Pro subscription. Subscribe now to start a free 14-day trial. SUBSCRIBE TO PRO SIGN IN TO PRO View our subscription options Most popular on newsroom An Ode for .. Dr Ashley ReadingRoom An Ode for .. Dr Ashley Performative bard Victor Billot farewells Dr Ash Victor Billot Victor Billot 5 hours ago An overlooked danger of climate change Health & Science An overlooked danger of climate change Blood-feeding arthropods, like mosquitoes, insects and ticks are increasingly sharing their environments with humans due to the climate - with chronic results. 360info 360info 6 hours ago Gorsebusters of Okarito Lagoon Environment Gorsebusters of Okarito Lagoon The phenomenal work ethic of a volunteer army has the gorse scourge at a West Coast beauty spot in retreat. Lois Williams Lois Williams 5 hours ago Recommended reads Wanted: a building sector with 'courage' Housing 6 Wanted: a building sector with 'courage' to make housing climate friendly. Whichever way we look, the construction sector is spiked onto the horns of nasty dilemmas. In spite of housing affordability being in crisis mode, construction prices soar at eye-watering rates; greenfield... Lindsay Wood Lindsay Wood Nov 03 2021 Govt's 2 months to make $14.6b call Auckland 2 Govt's 2 months to make $14.6b call A third-time lucky proposal for a multi-billion dollar light rail project across the Auckland isthmus reaches decision-point Tim Murphy Tim Murphy Oct 29 2021 Millions in new charges for rail freight users Transport 5 Millions in new charges for rail freight users Forestry and dairy sectors 'blindsided' and warn it jeopardises shift from road transport emissions Jonathan Milne Jonathan Milne Oct 15 2021 mail Daily Briefing Start your day with a curation of our top stories in your inbox [ ] [ ] With thanks to our partners hyundai logo spark logo bellgully logo sky logo catalyst logo vic uni wellington logo University of Auckland logo uni otago logo Kiwi bank logo creative-nz logo hyundai logo spark logo catalyst logo bellgully logo sky logo vic uni wellington logo University of Auckland logo uni otago logo Kiwi bank logo creative-nz logo mail Daily Briefing Start your day with a curation of our top stories in your inbox [ ] [ ] Newsroom logo logo * Facebook * Twitter * Linkedin * Contact Us * Terms and Conditions * Privacy Policy * Pro FAQ * New Zealand Media Council * Commenting FAQ * Pro Community Rules DESIGNED AND POWERED BY PAGEMASTERS PUBLISH * Newsroom * Newsroom Pro * LockerRoom * Sustainable Future * Investigations * ReadingRoom * Video placeholder image Dummy text