https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-says-ai-generated-content-is-against-guidelines/444916/

Skip to content
 
Search Engine Journal - SEO, Search Marketing News and Tutorials
Search Engine Journal - SEO, Search Marketing News and Tutorials

  * SEO
      + All SEO
      + Ask An SEO
      + Beginner's Guide to SEO
      + Ranking Factors
      + Core Web Vitals Guide
      + How Search Engines Work
      + Link Building Guide
      + SEO Strategy
      + Google E-A-T Guide
      + Local SEO Guide
      + Keyword Research Guide
      + On-Page SEO
      + Technical SEO
      + SEO Audit
      + Wordpress SEO
      + Enterprise SEO
      + SEO Tools for Agencies
      + State of SEO
      + SEO Trends
  * PPC
      + All PPC
      + Ask a PPC Expert
      + Digital Advertising
      + PPC Guide
      + Facebook Ads Guide
      + PPC Trends
  * CONTENT
      + All Content
      + Content Marketing Guide
      + Ecommerce Marketing Guide
      + Content Marketing KPIs
      + Holiday Marketing
  * SOCIAL
      + All Social
      + Social Media Marketing Guide
      + Facebook
      + Instagram
      + LinkedIn
      + Pinterest
      + Reddit
      + Snapchat
      + Twitter
      + Youtube
      + TikTok
  * NEWS
      + All News
      + SEO
      + Local SEO
      + International Search
      + PPC
      + Social Media
      + Most Read
  * WEBINARS
  * MORE
    Sections
      + SEO
      + PPC
      + Content
      + Social Media
      + Career
      + News
      + WordPress
      + Shopify
    Topics
      + Enterprise SEO
      + Analytics
      + Digital Experience
      + International Search
      + Link Building
      + Local Search
      + Mobile Search
      + Tools
      + Web Development
    Resources
      + E-Books
      + Google Algorithm Updates
      + Job Board
      + SEJ eSummit
      + SEJ Show + Podcast
      + Webinars
    Advertise
      + Advertising on SEJ
      + ShopSEJ
      + Post A Job
    Company
      + Subscribe
      + About
      + Contact
      + Careers
      + SEJ Merch
      + Privacy Policy
      + Do Not Sell My Personal Info
      + Press Materials
    Perfectly Optimized Content From Start To Finish

    Perfectly Optimized Content From Start To Finish

    DOWNLOAD

Try it Free

  * LinkedIn
  * YouTube
  * Twitter
  *  
    Follow Us
      + Rss
      + Facebook
      + Instagram
      + Reddit
      + Pinterest
  *  
  *  
    [                    ]
    [Search]

Search Engine Journal - SEO, Search Marketing News and Tutorials x
Follow Us

  * LinkedIn
  * Youtube
  * Twitter
  * Facebook
  * Instagram
  * Rss

  * SEO
      + All SEO
      + Ask An SEO
      + Beginner's Guide to SEO
      + Ranking Factors
      + Core Web Vitals Guide
      + How Search Engines Work
      + Link Building Guide
      + SEO Strategy
      + Keyword Research Guide
      + Local SEO Guide
      + On-Page SEO Guide
      + Technical SEO Guide
      + SEO Audit
      + Google E-A-T Guide
      + Wordpress SEO
      + Enterprise SEO
      + SEO Tools for Agencies
      + State of SEO
      + SEO Trends
      + SEO Tools Guide
      + Law Firm SEO Guide
  * PPC
      + All PPC
      + Ask a PPC Expert
      + Digital Advertising
      + PPC Guide
      + Facebook Ads Guide
      + PPC Trends
  * Content Marketing
      + All Content
      + Content Marketing Guide
      + Ecommerce Marketing Guide
      + Content Marketing KPIs
      + Holiday Marketing
  * Social media
      + All Social
      + Social Media Marketing Guide
      + Facebook
      + Instagram
      + LinkedIn
      + Pinterest
      + Reddit
      + Snapchat
      + Twitter
      + Youtube
      + TikTok
  * News
      + ALL NEWS
      + SEO
      + Local SEO
      + International Search
      + PPC
      + Social Media
      + Most Read
  * WEBINARS
  * Sections
      + SEO
      + PPC
      + Content
      + Social Media
      + Career
      + News
      + Web Development
      + WordPress
      + Shopify
  * Topics
      + Enterprise SEO
      + Analytics
      + Digital Experience
      + International Search
      + Link Building
      + Local Search
      + Mobile Search
      + Tools
  * Resources
      + E-Books
      + Google Algorithm Updates
      + Job Board
      + SEJ Show + Podcast
      + Webinars
  * Advertise
      + Advertising on SEJ
      + ShopSEJ
      + Post a Job
  * Company
      + About
      + Contact
      + Careers
      + Privacy Policy
      + SEJ Merch
      + Press Materials
  * SEJ eSummit
  * Subscribe
  * SEJ Merch
  * Do Not Sell My Personal Info

Try it Free
Advertisement

 1. SEJ
 2.  >> 
 3. SEO

Google Says AI Generated Content Is Against Guidelines

Content generated automatically using AI writing tools is against
Google's Webmaster Guidelines, says Search Advocate John Mueller.

Matt G. SouthernMatt G. Southern Matt G. Southern April 6, 2022 5 min
read
Matt G. SouthernMatt G. Southern SEJ STAFF Matt G. Southern Senior
News Writer at Search Engine Journal
Bio  
Follow

  *  
  *  
  *  

 / April 6, 2022  /  5 min read

  * 1.4K
    SHARES
  * 38K
    READS

Google Says AI Generated Content Is Against Guidelines Google Says AI
Generated Content Is Against Guidelines

Google's Search Advocate John Mueller says content automatically
generated with AI writing tools is considered spam, according to the
search engine's webmaster guidelines.

This topic is addressed during a recent Google Search Central SEO
office-hours hangout in response to a question about GPT-3 AI writing
tools.

There's a debate in the SEO community about the use of GPT-3 tools
and whether they're acceptable from Google's point of view.

Mueller says content written by AI falls under the category of
auto-generated content, which could lead to a manual penalty.

However, Google's systems may lack the ability to detect AI generated
content without the assistance of human reviewers.

As we'll explain later in this article, there are practical uses for
AI writing tools and many reputable organizations are using them
without issue.

First, let's look at Mueller's response to the question about how
Google views the use of these tools.

Automatically Generated Content Is Against Google's Webmaster
Guidelines

Regardless of the tools used to create it, content written by
machines is considered automatically generated.

As Mueller is quick to point out, Google's position on auto generated
content has always been clear:

    "For us these would, essentially, still fall into the category of
    automatically generated content which is something we've had in
    the Webmaster Guidelines since almost the beginning.

    And people have been automatically generating content in lots of
    different ways. And for us, if you're using machine learning
    tools to generate your content, it's essentially the same as if
    you're just shuffling words around, or looking up synonyms, or
    doing the translation tricks that people used to do. Those kind
    of things.

    My suspicion is maybe the quality of content is a little bit
    better than the really old school tools, but for us it's still
    automatically generated content, and that means for us it's still
    against the Webmaster Guidelines. So we would consider that to be
    spam."

Can Google Detect AI Generated Content?

A follow-up question is asked regarding Google's ability to identify
content written by machine learning tools.

Can Google understand the difference between content written by
humans and content written by machines?

Mueller makes no claims about Google detecting AI written content
automatically.

Although, if Google's webspam team happens to find it, they're
authorized to take action on it.

    "I can't claim that. But for us, if we see that something is
    automatically generated, then the webspam team can definitely
    take action on that.

    And I don't know how the future will evolve there, but I imagine
    like with any other of these technologies, there will be a little
    bit of a cat and mouse game, where sometimes people will do
    something and they get away with it, and then the webspam team
    catches up and solves that issue on a broader scale.

    From our recommendation we still see it as automatically
    generated content. I think over time maybe this is something that
    will evolve in that it will become more of a tool for people.
    Kind of like you would use machine translation as a basis for
    creating a translated version of a website, but you still work
    through it manually.

    And maybe over time these AI tools will evolve in that direction
    that you use them to be more efficient in your writing or to make
    sure that you're writing in a proper way like the spelling and
    the grammar checking tools, which are also based on machine
    learning. But I don't know what the future brings there."

Mueller clarifies Google doesn't take into consideration how the AI
writing tools are being used.

Using them in any capacity is considered spam, he adds.

    "Currently it's all against the webmaster guidelines. So from our
    point of view, if we were to run across something like that, if
    the webspam team were to see it, they would see it as spam."

To hear his full response, see the video below:

What Does This Mean For Your Website?

Here's some insight from the head of SEJ's editorial team on what
Mueller's response means for your website.

"I think the biggest takeaway from this particular Q&A is that
Google's algorithms aren't able to automatically detect content
generated by language models such as GPT-3," says Miranda Miller, Sr.
Managing Editor here at Search Engine Journal.

"The message here is that if Google detects automatically generated
content, the webspam team could take action. But we aren't talking
about the article spinners of 2003."

"Artificial intelligence is being used by media, universities, and
other organizations for research automation and cross-referencing,
crawling and classifying content in many languages to identify
emerging trends, generating article and paper summaries,
fact-checking, crunching data, and even writing full articles," she
points out.

"The Associated Press began using AI for story generation in 2014.
Putting AI to work in content creation is not new, and the most
important factor here is its intelligent application," Miller says,
noting that using AI can help content creators overcome language and
literacy barriers, improve the quality of their writing, and more.

"These are good outcomes. Wouldn't it be strange for Google to ban
the use of AI by webmasters and content creators for the purposes of
improving user experience when they use it so heavily themselves?"
she adds.

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Featured Image: Zapp2Photo/Shutterstock

Category News SEO
ADVERTISEMENT

Subscribe to SEJ

Get our daily newsletter from SEJ's Founder Loren Baker about the
latest news in the industry!

First Name* [                    ]
Last Name* [                    ]
Email* [                    ]
Job Title* [---                           ]
Topic(s) of Interest*

  * [ ]SEO
  * [ ]PPC
  * [ ]Content
  * [ ]Social

[SUBSCRIBE]
By clicking the "SUBSCRIBE" button, I agree and accept the content
agreement and privacy policy of Search Engine Journal.
[master              ] [https://www.searchen] [https://www.searchen] 
Ebook
Matt G. SouthernMatt G. Southern

  *  
  *  

Matt G. Southern

Senior News Writer at Search Engine Journal

Matt G. Southern, Senior News Writer, has been with Search Engine
Journal since 2013. With a bachelor's degree in communications, ... 
[Read full bio]

ADVERTISEMENT

  * Suggested Articles

Google Says There's No Limit on Title Tag Length Google Says There's
No Limit on Title Tag Length

Google Says There's No Limit on Title Tag Length

Google's Search Quality Raters Guidelines: A Guide for SEO Beginners 
Google's Search Quality Raters Guidelines: A Guide for SEO Beginners

Google's Search Quality Raters Guidelines: A Guide for SEO Beginners

Are Google's Search Quality Evaluator Guidelines A Ranking Factor? 
Are Google's Search Quality Evaluator Guidelines A Ranking Factor?

Are Google's Search Quality Evaluator Guidelines A Ranking Factor?

Subscribe to SEJ

Subscribe to our daily newsletter to get the latest industry news.

[                    ]
[                    ]
[Job Title*                    ]
Topic(s) of Interest*

  * [ ]SEO
  * [ ]PPC
  * [ ]Content
  * [ ]Social

[SUBSCRIBE]
By clicking the "Subscribe" button, I agree and accept the privacy
policy of Search Engine Journal.
[master              ] [/already-subscribed/] [/thanks-for-subscrib] 
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
How To Scale Content Marketing & Improve Organic Search Rankings How
To Scale Content Marketing & Improve Organic Search Rankings

How To Scale Content Marketing & Improve Organic Search Rankings

[                    ]
[SEARCH]
State Of Organic Marketing In 2022: Top SEO Priorities State Of
Organic Marketing In 2022: Top SEO Priorities

State Of Organic Marketing In 2022: Top SEO Priorities

Wednesday, April 13 at 2 pm ET
Advertisement
 Read the Next Article

  *  Linkedin
  *  Facebok
  *  Twitter
  *  Email
  *  SMS

Search Engine Journal - SEO, Search Marketing News and Tutorials

  * Advertise
  * Shop SEJ
  * Privacy Policy
  * Contact
  * About
  * Careers
  * Toolbox
  * Press Materials
  * Do Not Sell My Personal Info

  * SEO Guide
  * How Search Engines Work
  * Ranking Factors
  * SEO Strategy
  * Local SEO
  * Link Building Guide
  * On-Page SEO Guide
  * Technical SEO Guide
  * How to Do an SEO Audit

Subscribe to SEJ

Subscribe to our daily newsletter to get the latest industry news.

[                    ]
[                    ]
[Job Title*                    ]
[                    ]
Topic(s) of Interest*

  * [ ]SEO
  * [ ]PPC
  * [ ]Content
  * [ ]Social

[SUBSCRIBE]
[master              ] [https://www.searchen] [https://www.searchen] 
By clicking the "Subscribe" button, I agree and accept the privacy
policy of Search Engine Journal.
Read the Next