http://jpkoning.blogspot.com/2022/01/yemens-bifurcated-monetary-system.html Moneyness Monday, January 17, 2022 Yemen's bifurcated monetary system Over the last five years Yemen has stumbled into a unique monetary situation. I initially wrote about Yemen's odd currency status two years ago. Here is a quick update. In brief, Yemen has split into two warring sides: the Houthi rebels in the North and the Saudi-backed government in the South. This split has also torn the nation's central bank into two branches - the Aden branch and the Sana branch. Likewise, it has separated Yemen's stock of Yemeni rial banknotes into two different types of banknotes. The Houthi rebels in the North (who run the Sana branch of the central bank) have adopted rial banknotes printed before 2016. The officially-recognized Aden regime in the South controls all notes printed after 2016. (Read the original blog post for the full story.) As a rule banknotes of different vintages, or years, are equal to each other. Put differently, cash is fungible. But not in Yemen. The value of the North's pre-2016 notes and the South's post-2016 notes began to diverge in 2019. Below is a chart published by the Cash Consortium of Yemen (which I've modified for clarity) showing how far that divergence has preceded. The value of rebel's old notes relative to the U.S. dollar has stayed stable at around 600 rials to US$1 (see red line). But the value of the official Aden government's post-2016 notes has inflated. A new rial is now worth less than half a pre-2016 note (green line). [AVvXsEik0CBmVpDrUhhIxH011-Fg_gzRQvIxXKxawcNToIYUvltxopGg7sVbzIiZdMjBvz3W5lFNfHa9zfInMtpmn1] The reason for this growing gap is that the rebel North can't increase the supply of pre-2016 notes. The supply of old notes is locked. The supply of new notes, however, is not fixed. The South has been printing up new paper money and spending it into circulation. It would be as if the northern & southern U.S. states had a civil war, the North adopting pre-2016 Federal Reserve notes and the South post-2016 notes. The South keeps printing new notes to finance itself, but the North is stuck with a fixed stock of notes. So the U.S. dollar bifurcates. A currency war of sorts developed last summer in Yemen. It began with the Aden government printing up new notes of the same size, shape, and appearance as the rebel's pre-2016 notes and then spending them. You can see why the Aden government would want to adopt this strategy. If it could spend the replica notes at the same purchasing power as old notes, which are more valuable, the Aden government would extract twice as much goods & services than it otherwise could. If Aden's replicas succeeded in filtering into the Northern economy, we'd expect the old notes--so stable till now--to finally succumb to price inflation. The price gap between old notes and new notes would collapse. But this didn't happen. The Northern rebels reacted by banning Aden's replicas on the basis of serial number, according to the Sanaa Center. Notes with a serial number starting with the letter (') would be accepted, the rebels said, but those starting with the letter (d) would not be, presumably because d notes are all replicas. (According to the Sanaa Center, the government reacted by printing up serial numbers starting with '.) The exchange rates illustrated in the chart above suggest that the North's efforts to filter out the replicas was successful. The Northern rial notes are still worth just as much as before, around 600 rials to the U.S. dollar. Meanwhile, Aden's notes have inflated dramatically, from around 950 rials to 1290 rials per US$1. My hunch is that some of the rebel's success may be due to the relative quality of the North's banknotes. Given years of active use, Northern rial notes must be relatively filthy right now. Crisp new notes from the South would immediately stand out. After Aden's new notes have circulated for a few years, it may become easier for them to pass as the rebel's old notes. Only then will the price gap start to shrink. Posted by JP Koning at 7:41 AM # Email ThisBlogThis!Share to TwitterShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest Labels: cash, fungibility 4 comments: 1. [blank] yyyJanuary 17, 2022 at 10:34 AM Have you found information on the balance sheet of the central bank of the south? Is inflation explained by an accounting imbalance between assets and banknotes? And the north does not have a central bank? No assets to "back" the banknotes? It should be worse, right? ReplyDelete Replies 1. [oneVariabl] JP KoningJanuary 17, 2022 at 12:26 PM Alas, the central bank's website hasn't been updated in years: http://centralbank.gov.ye/newslettar.aspx?keyid=127&pid=46& lang=1&cattype=6 I suppose that the best way to think about the Yemen's banknotes is to think of them as securities (say bonds) issued by each of the two ruling governments (rather than a note issued by a central bank). Given their respective fiscal outlays, the rebel government in the North has a better capacity to repay its bonds than the Aden government. And this is reflected in the relative stability of Northern rials relative to Aden rials. Delete Replies Reply Reply 2. [blank] rsmJanuary 18, 2022 at 9:39 PM So do people starve in the north due to lack of money, in the south due to faith in the Quantity Theory of Money, while Iran and Saudi Arabia keep supplying each side with free weapons, regardless? ReplyDelete Replies Reply 3. [blank] RothJanuary 20, 2022 at 5:58 PM Its somewhat interesting how despite all the potential problems associated with using old paper notes, especially considering that they don't have their own currency printing press, they're still persisting with old bank notes rather than the numerous blockchain or digital currency technologies that have become rampantly popular with speculators. Of course its not rocket science to understand that you'd need a stable supply of power, computing devices, and an internet connection at minimum to make any use of such systems. Perhaps it is inevitable that there be no realistic way for physical currencies to be minted in a decentralized manner with the exception of value dense materials like gold or silver being minted into coinage. Perhaps something like Starlink providing internet services to more areas will change circumstances, but for now many of those that proponents of crypto aim to integrate into their financial systems will be kept out by a lack of infrastructure. ReplyDelete Replies Reply Add comment Load more... Newer Post Older Post Home Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom) Follow @jp_koning BTC: 1DbXZibSVJrs1MABEZKBXpMTqiApV8GyzL XRP: rMpB2AsrDTdbynCB48hg8MwHLD4wtXJfRJ The Moneyness discussion board is here. I design financial/economics infographics here. Contact me here. I also write for the Sound Money Project, Breaker, Coindesk, and Bullionstar. Popular Posts * The fallacy of bitcoin and renewable energy In my previous post on proof-of-work several commenters suggested that bitcoin, the biggest proof-of-work coin, is good for society becaus... * [AVvXsEik0C] Yemen's bifurcated monetary system Over the last five years Yemen has stumbled into a unique monetary situation. I initially wrote about Yemen's odd currency status two ye... * [AVvXsEhgiX] Why Henry III's gold penny failed English gold penny minted by Henry III in 1257 A lucky metal detectorist just discovered a Henry III gold penny , one of the first English ... * [starbucksC] Starbucks, monetary superpower I recently spent some time on Twitter discussing the monetary wonders of Starbucks. In this post I'll bring a bunch of tweets togeth... * [AVvXsEiAav] A tax on proof-of-work The world is overpurchasing proof-of-work (POW) blockchains. How do we fix this? Let me quickly outline the argument for why the world is b... * [AVvXsEjjAl] Should central bankers be afraid of crypto? As crypto continues to move into the public's consciousness, curious people who aren't familiar with it often ask me if central bank... Subscribe To [arrow_drop] [icon_feed1] Posts [subscribe-] [subscribe-] [icon_feed1] Atom [arrow_drop] [icon_feed1] Posts [arrow_drop] [icon_feed1] Comments [subscribe-] [subscribe-] [icon_feed1] Atom [arrow_drop] [icon_feed1] Comments Labels * cash (107) * bitcoin (90) * Federal Reserve (74) * stock market and equities (65) * liquidity premium (46) * inflation (44) * unit of account (44) * Nick Rowe (43) * fintech (42) * coins (41) * zero lower bound (41) * medium of exchange (40) * clearing and settlement (35) * Bank of Canada (34) * ECB (33) * gold (33) * moneyness (33) * fiat money (31) * anonymity (30) * charts (27) * David Glasner (24) * Target2 (24) * open market operations (24) * Miles Kimball (23) * demonetization (23) * history of thought (23) * Gresham's Law (22) * Scott Sumner (22) * fungibility (20) * Paul Krugman (18) * credit cards (18) * medium of account (18) * nominal interest rates (18) * quantitative easing (18) * stablecoin (18) * sticky prices (18) * Stephen Williamson (17) * chartalism (17) * dollarization/euroization (17) * gold standard (17) * payments (17) * John Maynard Keynes (16) * Mike Sproul (16) * Bank of England (15) * Fedcoin (15) * George Selgin (15) * central bank independence (15) * intra-Eurosystem credit (15) * seigniorage (15) * store of value (15) * David Andolfatto (14) * lender of last resort (14) * Bill Woolsey (13) * Fedwire (13) * Lars Christensen (13) * bills of exchange (13) * deflation (13) * legal tender (13) * Milton Friedman (12) * NCB (12) * Ripple (12) * SNB (12) * debit cards (12) * free banking (12) * market monetarism (12) * uncertainty (12) * Ethereum (11) * Irving Fisher (11) * Reserve Bank of India (11) * Tyler Cowen (11) * Zimbabwe (11) * collateral (11) * convenience yield (11) * fundamental value (11) * personal finance (11) * David Beckworth (10) * Ken Rogoff (10) * Larry White (10) * Ponzi schemes (10) * backing theory of money (10) * censorship resistance (10) * central bank digital currency (10) * liquidity options (10) * Bob Murphy (9) * Iran monetary blockade (9) * Ludwig von Mises (9) * MMT (9) * Riksbank (9) * hot potato effect (9) * money laundering (9) * reflux (9) * zero-sum games (9) * DeFi (8) * Great Depression (8) * Liquidity insurance (8) * Perry Mehrling (8) * Robert Shiller (8) * TIPS (8) * bimetallism (8) * cross border payments (8) * federal funds rate (8) * interdistrict settlement (8) * natural interest rate (8) * overdraft facility (8) * quantity theory of money (8) * sanctions (8) * short selling (8) * Adam Smith (7) * Bank of Japan (7) * Borges problem (7) * Carl Menger (7) * Gavyn Davies (7) * John Cochrane (7) * barter (7) * business cycle (7) * chain letters (7) * crude oil (7) * debt (7) * own-rates (7) * tax evasion (7) * Billion Prices Project (6) * Danmarks Nationalbank (6) * ETF (6) * SDR (6) * counterfeiting (6) * currency (6) * large value note embargo (6) * real interest rate (6) * ACH (5) * Bank of Greece (5) * China (5) * Dror Goldberg (5) * Ireland (5) * Larry Summers (5) * Narayana Kocherlakota (5) * SWIFT (5) * Silvio Gesell (5) * Steve Waldman (5) * System of National Accounts (5) * Warren Buffett (5) * Willem Buiter (5) * William Hutt (5) * William Stanley Jevons (5) * counting money (5) * equity deposits (5) * ghost money (5) * gift cards (5) * gold lease rates (5) * metallism (5) * money illusion (5) * money market mutual funds (5) * new monetarism (5) * sterilization (5) * technical and fundamental analysis (5) * Alfred Marshall (4) * Antoin Murphy (4) * Argentina (4) * Austrian economics (4) * Barry Eichengreen (4) * David Laidler (4) * FT Alphaville (4) * Friedman rule (4) * Hans-Werner Sinn (4) * Henry Dunning Macleod (4) * IMF (4) * L. Randall Wray (4) * Michael Woodford (4) * Neil Wallace (4) * Paul Samuelson (4) * Reserve Bank of New Zealand (4) * Unidad de Fomento (4) * card networks (4) * chopmarking (4) * drachma (4) * efficient markets hypothesis (4) * financial inclusion (4) * forward guidance (4) * futures theory (4) * monetary policy (4) * real bills doctrine (4) * real estate (4) * savings (4) * scrip (4) * Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (3) * Fischer Black (3) * Friedrich Hayek (3) * Greg Mankiw (3) * James Hamilton (3) * James Tobin (3) * Japan (3) * Libra (3) * London Bullion Market Association (3) * Marvin Goodfriend (3) * Nobuhiro Kiyotaki (3) * People's Bank of China (3) * Piero Sraffa (3) * Richard Cantillon (3) * SOMA (3) * Steve Horwitz (3) * Van Court's Bank Note Reporter (3) * Weimar hyperinflation (3) * asset shortage (3) * augmentation/diminution (3) * compensated dollar (3) * consumption (3) * corporate voting (3) * endogenous/exogenous money (3) * hysteresis (3) * inflation swaps (3) * investment (3) * microfoundations (3) * narrow banking (3) * search theory of money (3) * secular stagnation (3) * stock lending (3) * stocks and flows (3) * usury (3) * ABCT (2) * Arnold Kling (2) * Brad DeLong (2) * CNH (2) * CNY (2) * Divisia (2) * Don Patinkin (2) * Eugene Fama (2) * Exchange Stabilization Fund (2) * Fritz Machlup (2) * GOFO (2) * George Berkeley (2) * Henry Thornton (2) * Hong Kong (2) * James Steuart (2) * John Locke (2) * Kaushik Basu (2) * Kurt Schuler (2) * LETS (2) * NGDP targeting (2) * Neo-Fisherism (2) * ON RRP facility (2) * Peter Stella (2) * Randall Wright (2) * Section 13(3) (2) * Thomas Sargent (2) * US Mint (2) * Walter Bagehot (2) * William Barnett (2) * Yanis Varoufakis (2) * autarky (2) * capital key (2) * censorship (2) * cheques (2) * corralito (2) * coupon money (2) * currency vs banking school (2) * free coinage (2) * interbank market (2) * labour (2) * legal restrictions hypothesis (2) * monetary optionality (2) * postal banking (2) * productivity norm (2) * required reserves (2) * shoe leather costs (2) * symmetallism (2) * taxation (2) * term premium (2) * the moral economy (2) * wash trading (2) * ways and means advances (2) * yuan (2) * Bank of Italy (1) * Ben Bernanke (1) * Benjamin Anderson (1) * Bretton Woods (1) * De Nederlandsche Bank (1) * FATF (1) * Fed Treasury Accord (1) * Fred Lavington (1) * GDP and net worth (1) * ICU (1) * ISLM (1) * J. Laurence Laughlin (1) * John Law (1) * Ludwig Lachmann (1) * New Monetary Economics (1) * Norges Bank (1) * RTGS (1) * Reserve Bank of Australia (1) * Robert Clower (1) * South Africa Reserve Bank (1) * agio (1) * bribery (1) * coexistence puzzle (1) * complete preferences (1) * cooperative banking (1) * depository receipts (1) * fiction (1) * greenbacks (1) * helicopter money (1) * mercantilism (1) * mobile money (1) * notgeld (1) * ransomware (1) * regulation (1) * unions (1) Blog Archive * V 2022 (7) + V January (7) o DeFi needs more secrecy, but not too much secrecy,... o Why Henry III's gold penny failed o Yemen's bifurcated monetary system o The fallacy of bitcoin and renewable energy o Tether vs the New York stablecoins o A tax on proof-of-work o Should central bankers be afraid of crypto? * > 2021 (32) + > December (3) + > November (3) + > October (3) + > September (2) + > August (3) + > July (3) + > June (4) + > May (2) + > April (3) + > March (3) + > February (1) + > January (2) * > 2020 (34) + > December (3) + > November (3) + > October (3) + > September (2) + > August (3) + > July (3) + > June (3) + > May (3) + > April (3) + > March (2) + > February (2) + > January (4) * > 2019 (32) + > December (5) + > November (5) + > October (3) + > September (2) + > August (3) + > July (1) + > June (2) + > May (2) + > April (3) + > March (3) + > February (1) + > January (2) * > 2018 (33) + > December (3) + > November (3) + > October (2) + > September (3) + > August (3) + > July (2) + > June (2) + > May (3) + > April (3) + > March (4) + > February (1) + > January (4) * > 2017 (37) + > December (3) + > November (3) + > October (3) + > September (4) + > August (3) + > July (3) + > June (4) + > May (2) + > April (2) + > March (3) + > February (3) + > January (4) * > 2016 (45) + > December (3) + > November (4) + > October (4) + > September (5) + > August (2) + > July (3) + > June (4) + > May (4) + > April (3) + > March (4) + > February (5) + > January (4) * > 2015 (49) + > December (4) + > November (4) + > October (4) + > September (3) + > August (3) + > July (4) + > June (5) + > May (4) + > April (4) + > March (5) + > February (4) + > January (5) * > 2014 (52) + > December (4) + > November (4) + > October (4) + > September (5) + > August (3) + > July (3) + > June (5) + > May (4) + > April (5) + > March (5) + > February (5) + > January (5) * > 2013 (90) + > December (3) + > November (6) + > October (6) + > September (6) + > August (6) + > July (3) + > June (6) + > May (7) + > April (10) + > March (13) + > February (9) + > January (15) * > 2012 (113) + > December (16) + > November (18) + > October (20) + > September (6) + > August (4) + > July (4) + > June (8) + > May (11) + > April (6) + > March (6) + > February (3) + > January (11) * > 2011 (14) + > December (14) My Blog List * The Grumpy Economist * Econbrowser * Confessions of a Supply-Side Liberal * Bill Mitchell - billy blog * TheMoneyIllusion * MacroMania * Cecchetti and Shoenholtz * Alt-M * Stumbling and Mumbling * Uneasy Money * Consulting by RPM || Free Advice Blog * Stephen Williamson: New Monetarist Economics * Worthwhile Canadian Initiative * longandvariable * Liberty Street Economics * Noahpinion * Macro and Other Market Musings * Economist's View * Monetary Freedom * Spontaneous Finance * Great Wall of Numbers Economics Blogs 2022 FocusEconomics Top Economics Finance Bloggers About Me My photo JP Koning Thinking about money is more interesting than making money. View my complete profile Search This Blog [ ] [Search] Simple theme. Powered by Blogger.