https://appleinsider.com/articles/22/01/29/how-we-ended-up-with-the-pregnant-man-emoji AppleInsider logo * News * Reviews * How-Tos * Videos * Deals + Apple Deals + MacBook Air Deals + MacBook Pro Deals + Mac mini Deals + iPad Deals + AirPods deals + Apple Watch Deals + iMac Deals + iPhone Deals + Apple Authorized Resellers + Apple Student Discount + Macs for Students + Holiday Gift Guide * Price Guides + Apple Prices + MacBook, iMac & Mac mini Prices + iPad Prices + Apple Watch Prices + iPhone Prices + Apple TV & AirTag Prices + AirPods, HomePod & Beats Prices + iPad & iPhone Trade-in Values * Apple A-Z + AirPods + Apple TV + Apple Watch + HomePod + iPad + iPad mini + iPhone + iPhone 12 + iPhone 13 + iPhone 13 Pro + Mac + MacBook Pro + MacBook Air + More... * More + Forums + Podcasts + Contact Us + Advertise * AAPL: 170.33 ( +11.11 ) [ ] Toggle navigation Close Nav AppleInsider Logo [ ] * News * How-Tos * Apple A-Z + AirPods + Apple TV + Apple Watch + HomePod + iPad + iPad mini + iPhone + iPhone 12 + iPhone 13 + iPhone 13 Pro + Mac + MacBook Pro + MacBook Air + More... * Reviews * Videos * Deals + Apple Deals + MacBook Air Deals + MacBook Pro Deals + Mac mini Deals + iPad Deals + AirPods deals + Apple Watch Deals + iMac Deals + iPhone Deals + Apple Authorized Resellers + Apple Student Discount + Macs for Students + Holiday Gift Guide * Price Guides + Apple Prices + MacBook, iMac & Mac mini Prices + iPad Prices + Apple Watch Prices + iPhone Prices + Apple TV & AirTag Prices + AirPods, HomePod & Beats Prices + iPad & iPhone Trade-in Values * Podcasts * Forums * Contact Us * Advertise on AI AAPL: 170.33 ( +11.11 ) Copyright (c) 2022, Quiller Media, Inc. Contact Us | Privacy Policy Editorial How we ended up with the 'Pregnant Man' Emoji Jason Snively's AvatarJason Snively | Jan 29, 2022 article thumbnail 21 Comments FacebookFacebook Twitter Twitter Reddit Reddit AppleInsider is supported by its audience and may earn commission as an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner on qualifying purchases. These affiliate partnerships do not influence our editorial content. With the release of the iOS 15.4 beta comes the inclusion of the Unicode 14.0 standard with the controversial "Pregnant Man" emoji. Here's how Unicode U+1FAC3 came about. The Unicode Emoji Subcommittee Before discussing the emoji itself, we need to examine its inception by the Unicode Emoji Subcommittee (ESC). The ESC is the governing body responsible for maintaining and creating new emojis. They propose guidelines, solicit feedback, and codify the standards for vendors to implement. The working description of ESC, according to the group's website, says it handles: * Updating, revising, and extending emoji documents such as UTS # 51: Unicode Emoji and Unicode Emoji Charts. * Taking input from various sources and reviewing requests for new emoji characters. * Creating proposals for the Unicode Technical Committee regarding additional emoji characters and new emoji-related mechanisms. * Investigating longer-term mechanisms for supporting emoji as images (stickers). The team is a subcommittee of the Unicode Consortium, which comprises all the big tech players you'd expect: Microsoft, Google, Apple, Meta, Adobe, and others. You can find a full list of members here. ZWJ and constructing emoji Since Unicode 12.0 was released in 2019, the official Unicode standard has used three genders: Woman, man, and "gender-neutral." The official definition of the latter has evolved as language has shifted, but in essence, we're talking about male, female, and non-binary -- though you may still see references to the non-binary option by its CLDR name; "person." For those of you asking why three genders were mandated to begin with, here is the official rationale from the standard: It is often the case that gender is unknown or irrelevant, as in the usage "Is there a doctor on the plane?," or a gendered appearance may not be desired. Such cases are known as "gender-neutral," "gender-inclusive," "unspecified-gender," or many other terms. Other than the above list, human-form emoji should normally be depicted in a gender-neutral way unless gender appearance is explicitly specified using an emoji ZWJ sequence. In case you don't speak engineer, that last sentence is saying, " unless it's a special case, all emoji should be gender-neutral by default." The neutral emoji combines with other emojis and a special character known as a zero-width joiner (the aforementioned "ZWJ") to modify the base emoji. For example, how would we go about making an emoji of a woman gesturing "no" with a medium-light skin tone? I would start with the "person gesturing no" emoji (U+1F645), then I would add the medium-light skin tone emoji (U+1F3FC), followed by a zero width joiner (U+200D) alongside the emoji for "female" (U+2640 or U+FE0F). This creates the ZWJ sequence for a woman gesturing "no" with a medium-light skin tone. The system is structured so that each component can be logically snapped together to create the desired result. The more technical of you may know that some emojis do start with a woman or man as the base character instead of a generic person. These are generally a result of emoji that existed in earlier versions of the specification, are part of the exception list, or are more complex and trying to fit in a smaller space. We could have a more technical discussion about byte size encoding for characters, but that is well beyond the scope of this article. There are exceptions in the system, as we will see later. L2/19-101: Priorities for Future RGI Emoji Sequences Now that we know what the ESC does, who it's comprised of, and have a basic idea of how the emoji system works, we can talk about the process that eventually led to the creation of the "Pregnant Man" emoji. This document titled Priorities for Future RGI Emoji Sequences marks the beginning, in earnest, of an initiative at the ESC to start making emoji more representational. We can soon do this, but with emoji: [46753-9113] Arnold Schwarzenegger and Carl Weathers' "epic handshake" from Predator. [20th Century Fox] The ESC defines its roadmap for adding more skin tones, gender options, direction (e.g; left, right, up, down), and color variations in the document. It also proposed a priority for each of these efforts, adding gender-neutral variations a the top of the list, followed by mixed skin tones. The reasoning for this is stated directly in the emoji technical specifications: Both A [gender neutral] and B [mixed skin tones] address gaps within the existing emoji set and as such are considered a higher priority for implementation than C [directionality] or D [color variations] which seek to expand the scope of emoji functionality. Earlier, we demonstrated how the emojis are connected, and the initiatives that received the highest priority make a lot of sense in that context. As the system is designed to snap together like digital Lego, and there are still emoji whose base element uses the "legacy" method, ESC needs to address those before expanding and adding more. There are many interesting things to read in that document, but it's clear the group's goal is to represent the wide variety of humans and their unique experiences. From mixed-race handshakes and couples to same-sex families, they are slowly covering as much ground as possible to make sure everyone can represent themselves if they choose. I've made it this far, tell me about the pregnant man already! We covered how the system works and why it works that way, but we also established clear exceptions for special-case emojis exist. So why isn't a pregnant woman one of those special gender-specific cases? In order to answer that question we need to take a look at document L2/21-055: ESC comments on 2020 Q4 feedback. This document exists for the sole reason of explaining what happened. The original plan, as per standard practice, was to replace the original "Pregnant Woman" emoji (U+1F930) with the non-binary representation and then use the male (U+2642 and U+FE0F) and female (U+2640 and U+FE0F) to modify it to the desired gender. In theory, the system is respected, and everyone is happy. But, the advisory committee got stuck in a stalemate, so nobody was. To ensure the integrity of existing gendered emoji and to preserve a long runway for future additions, "person" based emoji should never be encoded with a sex symbol. As such, the "person" and "man" variants' are in the process of being added as atomic characters In other words, due to the legacy use of the emoji and the importance of gender in its meaning, coupled with no modifier for non-binary because it's supposed to be the default, we are instead getting two additional independent variants. "Pregnant Man" (U+1FAC3) and "Pregnant Person" (U+1FAC4) will live alongside the original "Pregnant Woman" (U+1F930), breaking with convention. Exceptions require workarounds If you read L2/21-055 you may have seen that different names were initially proposed for the gender-neutral and the male version of the emoji: "person with swollen belly" and "man with swollen belly" respectively. Why either of those didn't stick is in plain sight as well. The proposed names of the new characters, "man with swollen belly" and "person with swollen belly", are completely semantically detached from the meaning of U+1F930, which is never the case for emoji that form a gender triplet. Being pregnant and having a swollen belly are not synonymous; one cannot reasonably be used as a substitute for the other. While it is true that U+1F930 is sometimes humorously used to convey a general concept of bloat, this has no bearing on its actual semantics as a Unicode character. U+1F930 was encoded for a very particular purpose - to represent pregnancy and parenthood - and retroactively changing its official meaning to encompass any stomach bloat would be both disrespectful to expecting parents and damaging to existing data To translate: all emoji that contain three gender variations share a common naming scheme, and it didn't make sense to change the name of two of the three representations here. It introduces more irregularity in a system that is supposed to be pretty logical. In addition, changing the woman to a non-binary person to adhere alters the original emoji's meaning, thus breaking backward compatibility. In short, skipping some superfluous conversation between companies, that is how we ended up with an emoji of a pregnant man named "Pregnant Man." Outrage over a fairly logical system Emoji is a system designed to take a non-binary gender as its base component, and it is constantly being iterated upon. When it came time to address the "Pregnant Woman" emoji, which did not fit within the designed system, an exception was made rather than revision for legacy reasons. Due to those same systemic and legacy reasons, the emoji is called "Pregnant Man" instead of "man with bloated belly." I mostly spend my time here at AppleInsider behind the scenes. I'm a developer by trade, not an editor, but we're a small company, so I often spend time moderating comment sections and generally checking up on things. The level of vitriol and outrage I have seen surrounding something as innocuous as an emoji has been awful. The headlines I've noticed that I feel obligated not to link back to, combined with the malice ascribed directly towards people due to their political leaning, gender, or sexual orientation, gave me enough pause to spend my night writing this. I know this is the internet, and outrage is the currency. At the end of the day, we're just talking about a digital stacking system to build multiple emoji from core elements instead of a custom element for each of the thousands of emoji that now exist. No one should be getting threats over emojis. And we're pretty sure we will get some from this article from folks that don't want to read it and are too comfortable with their outrage to read. If you see someone out there get angry because a pregnant man "isn't scientific!" then link them to this article. If you see someone blaming Apple for pushing an agenda, then show them this article. If you see someone praising Apple for pandering or being forward-thinking, then link them to this article. Apple employs some of the people that worked on this, but don't have any illusions that the company put its foot down and demanded this particular chorded emoji combination out of tens of thousands. They have discussions and work collectively with others as a group. There are more people outside of Apple that made this decision than there are participants from the company, by a factor of about 10. The emoji combination was assembled with not an iota of identity politics. The fact that it exists is no more of an ideologically-planted flag than stacking three Lego bricks together. --------------------------------------------------------------------- 21 Comments --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Comments (21) Forum User twlatl twlatl said about 2 hours ago There is nothing logical about a pregnant man. Nice attempt to write thousands of words to legitimize it, but a pregnant man emoji is as useful as a emoji of a fish riding a bicycle. Both are pure fantasy. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Forum User Mike Wuerthele Mike Wuerthele said about 2 hours ago twlatl said: There is nothing logical about a pregnant man. Nice attempt to write thousands of words to legitimize it, but a pregnant man emoji is as useful as a emoji of a fish riding a bicycle. Both are pure fantasy. Or you could read the article, and see how it happened technically. I won't be using the emoji because it's silly, and you're welcome to not use it to signal whatever it is you want to signal, I guess. But, this is how and why it happened from a technical standpoint. There's no "legitimize it" agenda, and reading that into it is ludicrous. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Forum User coolfactor coolfactor said about 2 hours ago Excellent writeup. Anyone without the ability to stop, read and think will continue to complain about something that makes them feel legitimate. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Forum User bobbobson bobbobson said about 2 hours ago Just one more indicator that the end is nigh. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Forum User scout6900 scout6900 said about 2 hours ago Nice article. People absolutely love to complain about stupid things. See the uproar over Minnie Mouse in a pantsuit. Thanks for the information! --------------------------------------------------------------------- Read More on the forums... Please enable JavaScript to comment --------------------------------------------------------------------- Related Articles article thumbnail Apple Watch Wallet sync issues found following watchOS 8.4, iOS 15.3 update A small number of users are having problems with the Apple Wallet, with the Apple Watch version not properly syncing with their iPhone after the latest round of updates. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Universal Control, Apple's record Q1 earnings, and more on the AppleInsider podcast On this week's episode of the AppleInsider podcast, Apple sets new holiday quarter records, software updates address multiple bugs across Apple's lineup, and iPhone could one day process credit card payments. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Mandatory Olympics iOS and Android apps are spying on athletes for China A researcher has found that the mandatory Beijing 2022 Olympics app for iOS and Android is collecting and sending audio to Chinese servers. --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Apple Watch Series 7 in Red and Starlight Best Apple Watch deals Save on the new Series 7 New iPad discounts 2021 iPads are on sale now Save up to $147 Apple MacBook Air in Gold Every M1 MacBook Air is discounted Save up to $150 --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Latest comparisons article thumbnail Compared: Apple's 16-inch MacBook Pro versus MSI GE76 Raider Apple directly compared the graphical capabilities of the 16-inch MacBook Pro against the MSI GE76 Raider gaming notebook at its launch. Here's how it fares against the rest of the notebook's specifications. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Compared: 16-inch MacBook Pro vs Razer Blade 15 Advanced Apple used the Razer Blade 15 Advanced as a point of comparison for the performance of the M1 Max chip. Here's how the rest of the notebook compares against the 16-inch MacBook Pro. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Compared: iPad mini vs Kindle Paperwhite The iPad mini is an ideal companion for avid readers, but Amazon's Paperwhite ebook reader is still a good proposition for bookworms. It all depends on how much you read. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Compared: AirPods vs AirPods Pro vs Beats Fit Pro The new Beats Fit Pro offer Active Noise Cancellation in a package that's cheaper than the AirPods Pro. Here's how they fare against the AirPods Pro and its lower-priced stablemate, AirPods. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Compared: M1 Max 16-inch MacBook Pro versus Mac Pro Apple's new 16-inch MacBook Pro with the M1 Max processor is undeniably a powerhouse. Here's how it compares to Apple's Intel-based Mac Pro tower, and why folks that rely on that machine may need to consider the laptop as a viable upgrade. --------------------------------------------------------------------- * iPhone 13 * iPhone 13 Pro * iPhone 12 * MacBook Pro * AirPods * iPad mini * Mac mini * MacBook Air * More... Latest News article thumbnail author image Arculus review: A crypto cold storage wallet with promise 47 minutes ago Arculus review: A crypto cold storage wallet with promise The Arculus card is a new cryptocurrency cold wallet for your iPhone that secures your private keys. It does its job well but reeks of as-of-yet unfulfilled potential. By Andrew O'Hara | 47 minutes ago 0 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image Apple Watch Wallet sync issues found following watchOS 8.4, iOS 15.3 update 1 hour ago Apple Watch Wallet sync issues found following watchOS 8.4, iOS 15.3 update A small number of users are having problems with the Apple Wallet, with the Apple Watch version not properly syncing with their iPhone after the latest round of updates. By Malcolm Owen | 1 hour ago 0 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image How we ended up with the 'Pregnant Man' Emoji 2 hours ago How we ended up with the 'Pregnant Man' Emoji With the release of the iOS 15.4 beta comes the inclusion of the Unicode 14.0 standard with the controversial "Pregnant Man" emoji. Here's how Unicode U+1FAC3 came about. By Jason Snively | 2 hours ago 21 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image Apple warns macOS Monterey beta testers of FileVault issue 4 hours ago Apple warns macOS Monterey beta testers of FileVault issue Apple is warning developers beta testing macOS Monterey 12.3 that they could encounter a boot loop if they use it on a Mac with macOS Catalina and FileVault enabled. By Malcolm Owen | 4 hours ago 4 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image Examining Apple's record-shattering $123.9B first quarter by the numbers 5 hours ago Examining Apple's record-shattering $123.9B first quarter by the numbers Apple has once more reported high revenue in its first quarterly results of 2022. AppleInsider looks more closely at the figures to show how the record-breaking quarter compares to previous years. By Malcolm Owen | 5 hours ago 6 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image Best deals Jan. 29: Refurbished Intel 27-inch iMacs, $99 AirPods, $90 Linksys Wi-Fi Extender, more! 8 hours ago Best deals Jan. 29: Refurbished Intel 27-inch iMacs, $99 AirPods, $90 Linksys Wi-Fi Extender, more! Alongside refurbished Intel iMacs and $99 AirPods, Saturday's best deals include an Anova Sous Vide cooker for $159 and a Snow Joe Snow Thrower for $130. By AppleInsider Staff | 8 hours ago --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image FAA announces agreement with AT&T, Verizon on 5G expansion 1 day ago FAA announces agreement with AT&T, Verizon on 5G expansion The Federal Aviation Administration says it has reached an agreement with AT&T and Verizon to expand 5G service in a way that mitigates aircraft safety concerns. By Mike Peterson | 1 day ago 18 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image Apple launches support for unlisted App Store apps accessible via link 1 day ago Apple launches support for unlisted App Store apps accessible via link The App Store now supports unlisted apps that are only accessible with a link, Apple has announced in an update on its developer website. By Mike Peterson | 1 day ago 6 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Apple Watch Wallet sync issues found following watchOS 8.4, iOS 15.3 update A small number of users are having problems with the Apple Wallet, with the Apple Watch version not properly syncing with their iPhone after the latest round of updates. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Universal Control, Apple's record Q1 earnings, and more on the AppleInsider podcast On this week's episode of the AppleInsider podcast, Apple sets new holiday quarter records, software updates address multiple bugs across Apple's lineup, and iPhone could one day process credit card payments. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Mandatory Olympics iOS and Android apps are spying on athletes for China A researcher has found that the mandatory Beijing 2022 Olympics app for iOS and Android is collecting and sending audio to Chinese servers. --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Latest Videos article thumbnail Hands on with Universal Control and other new features in iOS 15.4 We go hands on with new features coming in iOS 15.4, as well as iPadOS 15.4 and macOS Monterey 12.3. New features include Universal Control, dozens of new emoji, and more. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Benchmarks show that Intel's Alder Lake chips aren't M1 Max killers New benchmark tests confirm that the Alder Lake Core i9 processor features significant performance gains compared to its predecessor, but the flagship Intel chip is still not going to unseat the M1 Max as an overall package. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Wemo Smart Video Doorbell review: The new HomeKit doorbell of choice This HomeKit Secure Video doorbell is the epitome of an Apple smart home device. Let's take a close look at the just-announced Belkin Wemo Smart Video Doorbell. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail How to tell the difference between real AirPods Pro and counterfeit ones Details are key in spotting a fake set of AirPods or AirPods Pro. We picked up a set of widely available clones and compared them to genuine AirPods Pro so you can better protect yourself from getting scammed by counterfeit Apple earbuds. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail How to master the camera app on iPhone 13 and iPhone 13 mini Take a deep dive into the ever-expanding default Camera app on iPhone 13 and iPhone 13 mini, to get the most out of it. --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Latest Reviews article thumbnail Arculus review: A crypto cold storage wallet with promise The Arculus card is a new cryptocurrency cold wallet for your iPhone that secures your private keys. It does its job well but reeks of as-of-yet unfulfilled potential. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Belkin BoostCharge Pro Portable Wireless Charger Pad for MagSafe review: A pricey, but better option With a price tag pushing $60, Belkin has a lot to prove with its inelegantly-named BoostCharge Pro Portable Wireless Charger Pad for MagSafe. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Woolnut Coated Sleeves review: New protective & waterproof iPad covers Woolnut's new line of water-resistant iPad Pro covers ditch the leather to help protect your Apple tablet while also looking great. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Ethos and Icon microphone review: Approachable, high-end audio perfect for podcast creators Earthworks Audio has built two quality products that compete with the most popular USB and broadcast microphones on the market. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail BentoStack review: Japanese-inspired accessory storage Carry all of your Apple essentials from your MacBook Pro charger to your AirPods with the novel BentoStack from Function101. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Click to Load More --------------------------------------------------------------------- AppleInsider Wordmark Donate with PayPal button AppleInsider is one of the few truly independent online publications left. If you love what we do, please consider a small donation to help us keep the lights on. If you love AppleInsider and want to support independent publications, please consider a small donation. Donate to AppleInsider Apple A-Z * Apple Silicon * iPhone 12 * iPhone 12 mini * iPhone 12 Pro * iPhone 12 Pro Max * HomePod mini * 14" MacBook Pro * Apple Watch 6 * iPad Air * More... Price Guides * All * New Macs * iPads * Apple Watch * iPhones * Apple TV & Accessories * AirPods & Homepods * iPhone & iPad Trade-in Prices More * How-Tos * Forums * Podcasts * Deals * Videos * Reviews * Contact Us * Advertise on AI Designed by Crafted Copyright (c) 2022, Quiller Media, Inc. Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use Quantcast article thumbnail author profile image {{ title }} {{ dateFormatted }} {{ title }} {{ summary }} {{{ reviewStars.html }}} By {{ author }} | {{ dateFormatted }} {{ commentCount }} ---------------------------------------------------------------------