https://www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/health-family/two-weeks-after-his-operation-david-bennett-is-alive-his-pig-s-heart-beating-soundly-1.4783776 Irish Times masthead Sign up for alerts from The Irish Times Not Now I am interested Notification wireframe Just click on "Allow Notifications" on the message appearing on your browser to activate them. bell-slash We will send you a quick reminder in the future, in case you change your mind. [p] * * Search * Newsletters * Crossword * Notices * Help Centre * My Account * Subscribe * Sign In The Irish Times Wed, Jan 26, 2022 ^ * The Irish Times * News * Sport * Business * Opinion * Life & Style * Culture * More * Video * Podcasts * Executive Jobs * Search * Subscribe * My Account * Sign In * Life & Style * Health & Family * Parenting * Fitness * Get Running * Summer of Family * The Health Centre All Life & Style * Food & Drink + Recipes + Restaurants + Drink * Homes & Property + New to the Market + Property Clinic + Design + Take 5 + Fine Art & Antiques + Gardens * Health & Family + Parenting + Fitness + Get Running + Summer of Family + The Health Centre * People + Obituaries + New to the Parish * Travel + Ireland + Europe + Long Haul + Walks * Motors + Car Reviews * Fashion + Beauty * Abroad + Join the network + Generation Emigration + Working Abroad + Returning to Ireland + Australia + Canada + Gulf States + New Zealand * Outdoors * Specials + Sustainable Ireland + Future of Fertility + It's Christmas * Podcasts + Women's Podcast + Back to Yours + Ross O'Carroll-Kelly * Partner Sites + MyHome.ie Two weeks after his operation David Bennett is alive, his pig's heart beating soundly Dr Muiris Houston: We must weigh the shortage of human organs against animal rights Mon, Jan 24, 2022, 06:01 Dr Muiris Houston Dr Bartley Griffith of University of Maryland Medical Centre and David Bennett. Photograph: David Bennett jnr/PA Wire Dr Bartley Griffith of University of Maryland Medical Centre and David Bennett. Photograph: David Bennett jnr/PA Wire Were you surprised to read about the first ever pig-to-human heart transplant that took place in the US earlier this month? I have to say I was - for a multiplicity of reasons. One of the first feature articles I wrote for The Irish Times, published in February 2000, looked at how xenotransplantation (animal-to-human organ transfer) would be "the next step forward in the ever-changing world of transplant surgery, and has come about because of a global shortage of human organs". Almost 22 years later the first ever xenotransplant has finally taken place. On January 7th, David Bennett (57) was transplanted with a genetically modified heart from a pig at the University of Maryland Medical Centre. Suffering from end-stage heart failure, he was deemed unsuitable for a standard human-to-human transplant. Doctors had also decided he was a poor candidate for a ventricular assist device (an implantable artificial mechanical pump) because he had an irregular heart beat. Some two weeks later Bennett is still alive, with his new heart beating soundly. So far, there are no reports of rejection of the pig's heart by his immune system. Some of the 10 genetic changes made to the pig heart prior to transplantation seem to have subdued the usual sequence of rejection. Why a pig and not a monkey or a baboon? * Rethinking Alzheimer's: what causes the disease and can it be cured? * Tired of dieting? The 10 principles of intuitive eating * I keep obsessing over people who are already in relationships While it is true that pigs are less compatible with humans than monkeys, they can be genetically manipulated to produce organs less likely to be rejected on transplantation. Pigs quickly grow to full size, produce larger litters and can be more easily reared by biotechnology companies. 'Better' choice You may also be surprised on ethical grounds. Animal rights activists may not be appeased by claims that pigs are already bred for human consumption and so represent a "better" choice than apes or monkeys. The significant genetic alterations necessary to prepare organs for transplant may be unacceptable to many. In Bennett's case, the biotech company that made the pig heart used in the transplant cut out three pig genes that trigger attacks from the human immune system, and added six human genes that help the body to accept the organ. A final genetic modification aims to prevent the heart from growing post transplantation. The University of Maryland Medical Centre of surgeons performing surgery on a pig as medics in the US made history last week when they transplanted a pig heart into a human patient with terminal heart disease. Photograph: University of Maryland Medical Centre/PA Wire The University of Maryland Medical Centre of surgeons performing surgery on a pig as medics in the US made history last week when they transplanted a pig heart into a human patient with terminal heart disease. Photograph: University of Maryland Medical Centre/PA Wire You may be taken aback to hear that Bennett's surgery took place without a clinical trial of the procedure. The researchers had applied to the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to do a clinical trial of pig hearts in people, but were turned down. On the basis that he otherwise faced certain death, the researchers got a one-off permission from the FDA to give Bennett a pig heart. Standard human-to-human heart transplantation is well established and highly successful: it has a one-year survival of about 90 per cent and a low one-year risk for rejection. Not knowing whether xenotransplantation has the potential to meet that standard in the absence of proper research puts a major question mark over the new procedure. Around the corner In favour of continuing to explore xenotransplants is the shortage of human donor organs. For example, about a third of donated hearts cannot be used in a transplant for a variety of reasons. And we must acknowledge the fact that heart valves from pigs have been used in humans for decades, and that insulins used prior to 1978 were derived from pigs and cattle. But another issue that cannot be ignored when it comes to xenotransplants is that, for some of us, the thought of accepting an animal organ as a replacement for our own may even be repugnant. Would you have concerns for your personal identity if you received a pig's heart? So will xenotransplantation ever become routine? According to one veteran transplant surgeon I spoke to 22 years ago: "Xenotransplantation is just around the corner - and always will be." mhouston@irishtimes.com * Topics: * David Bennett * Medical Humanities Tcd Mcrn * Fda * Food And Drug Administration ( Fda ) * University Of Maryland Medical Centre * Houston Medical * United States Read More * Dr Muiris Houston: Omicron may push Delta out for good * How a lab scientist's bad cold led to the 'marvel' mRNA vaccine * 'We'll never fully understand why Fintan decided life in his 30s was not worth living' * Covid-19 symptoms: How do I know if I have Omicron or Delta? * 'I'm struggling to connect with someone else after my girlfriend left me' * 'Flurona': Can you get the flu and coronavirus at the same time? Subscribe. More from The Irish Times * Health & Family 'When we are in a committed relationship we get into the thick of things with our partners and we take risks that may not happen in friendships.' Photograph: iStock 'I was deeply in love with my non-lesbian best friend for years' * Parenting The plague hit the house finally but it's a miracle really we got this far without anyone contracting it. Photograph: iStock Jen Hogan: Children overlooked again as unfair restrictions continue in schools * Fitness Our perception of freedom has been challenged and many of the runners I have spoken to feel more vulnerable than ever Running with Ashling on our minds: 'We feel more vulnerable than ever' * Health Younger GPs will not put up with the long hours that their older colleagues have been prepared to accept, the Oireachtas committee on health has been told. File photograph: Lynne Cameron/PA Wire Younger GPs will not put up with 'mad stuff' faced by older colleagues, committee hears Sponsored Many businesses are only now scratching the surface of digital transformation and how they can use data and tools to connect with customers or engage employees. Photograph: Getty Images 'Digitalisation makes things simpler and changes the way you do business' Andrew Brownlee, chief executive of Solas: The inclusion of apprenticeships and further education options on the CAO is a "game changer". Photograph: Getty Images More CAO options for students with inclusion of further education and training Ulster University has devised programmes to teach language to children and young people. Photograph: Getty Images How language research is changing lives in Northern Ireland ESB's solar PV offering addresses the difficulties which many organisations experience in achieving payback on such projects. Setting out a roadmap to zero carbon with solar The Irish Times Logo Commenting on The Irish Times has changed. To comment you must now be an Irish Times subscriber. SUBSCRIBE GO BACK Error Image The account details entered are not currently associated with an Irish Times subscription. Please subscribe to sign in to comment. Comment Sign In [ ] [ ] [ ]I agree to the Terms & Conditions, community standards and Privacy Policy SIGN IN Forgot password? The Irish Times Logo Thank you You should receive instructions for resetting your password. When you have reset your password, you can Sign In. The Irish Times Logo Please choose a screen name. This name will appear beside any comments you post. Your screen name should follow the standards set out in our community standards. Screen Name Selection Hello Please choose a screen name. This name will appear beside any comments you post. Your screen name should follow the standards set out in our community standards. [ ] Only letters, numbers, periods and hyphens are allowed in screen names. CONFIRM The Irish Times Logo Commenting on The Irish Times has changed. To comment you must now be an Irish Times subscriber. SUBSCRIBE Forgot Password Please enter your email address so we can send you a link to reset your password. [ ] SUBMIT Sign In Your Comments Sign In Sign Out We reserve the right to remove any content at any time from this Community, including without limitation if it violates the Community Standards. We ask that you report content that you in good faith believe violates the above rules by clicking the Flag link next to the offending comment or by filling out this form. New comments are only accepted for 3 days from the date of publication. Also in Health & Family Jen Hogan: Children overlooked again as unfair restrictions continue in schools Jen Hogan: Children overlooked again as unfair restrictions continue in schools We owe it to them to make sure they get to have a normal school experience 'I was deeply in love with my non-lesbian best friend for years' 'I was deeply in love with my non-lesbian best friend for years' Dear Trish: How do I know I'll love my new girlfriend as much as I loved that friend? Rosita Boland: I sincerely hope my terrifying panic attacks never return Rosita Boland: I sincerely hope my terrifying panic attacks never return For six months, I experienced severe and prolonged panic attacks, night and day Expert tips: How to deal with persistent panic attacks Expert tips: How to deal with persistent panic attacks Key to dealing with issue is to ride out incidents and challenge beliefs leading to them How to eat in your 50s: What you need to know about nutrition and health How to eat in your 50s: What you need to know about nutrition and health How to stave off weight gain, heart disease, osteoporosis, loss of muscle and cholesterol What are the factors behind a 73% drop in teenage pregnancies in Ireland? What are the factors behind a 73% drop in teenage pregnancies in Ireland? Dramatic statistic reflects many strands of societal change here in past two decades Running with Ashling on our minds: 'We feel more vulnerable than ever' Running with Ashling on our minds: 'We feel more vulnerable than ever' Mary Jennings: We must ensure we do our best to look after our outdoor community Two weeks after his operation David Bennett is alive, his pig's heart beating soundly Two weeks after his operation David Bennett is alive, his pig's heart beating soundly Dr Muiris Houston: We must weigh the shortage of human organs against animal rights Anxiety isn't necessarily bad and can be helpful. Here's why Anxiety isn't necessarily bad and can be helpful. Here's why 'A lot of the distress that we feel with anxiety comes from the resistance to it' Tired of dieting? The 10 principles of intuitive eating Tired of dieting? The 10 principles of intuitive eating Best bet is not to try all of them at once - take it in your stride and see which works for you [image] Most Read in Life & Style 1 [image] Terenure villa-style house with 'grannycore' aesthetic for EUR725k 2 'When we are in a committed relationship we get into the thick of things with our partners and we take risks that may not happen in friendships.' Photograph: iStock 'I was deeply in love with my non-lesbian best friend for years' 3 The plague hit the house finally but it's a miracle really we got this far without anyone contracting it. Photograph: iStock Jen Hogan: Children overlooked again as unfair restrictions continue in schools 4 Workplace bullying is often part of a wider organisational dynamic How to spot a workplace bully: It's the person with 'high unhealthy' self-esteem 5 Dr Bartley Griffith of University of Maryland Medical Centre and David Bennett. Photograph: David Bennett jnr/PA Wire Two weeks after his operation David Bennett is alive, his pig's heart beating soundly 6 Teenage births represented 5.7% of the 54,789 births in the Republic in 2000; in 2020, they accounted for just 1.5% of the 55,959 births that year. Photograph: iStock What are the factors behind a 73% drop in teenage pregnancies in Ireland? 7 A site visit from a surveyor will establish any limitations that apply to your proposed development I want to build another shed in my garden. Do I need planning permission? 8 Supriya Singh moved to Ireland with her family in 2016. 'Five years ago I felt very connected to the UK but now I'm more connected to Ireland,' she says. Photograph: Alan Betson 'Many people migrate to Ireland to build a new life. Some succeed, some struggle, some fail' 9 I wanted to mark the ending of the carry-on, and the beginning of whatever this next bit turns out to be. Photograph: iStock Roisin Ingle: Time to find ourselves again? I went looking for myself down the pub 10 Mini intends to preserve the history of each car by keeping the engine, gearbox and so on saved and logged, so that the process of electrification can be easily reversed if a future owner wants to restore their Mini Recharged to its original specification BMW brings electric power to classic Minis Real news has value SUBSCRIBE * Subscribe + Why Subscribe? + Subscription Bundles + Subscription Help Centre + Gift Subscriptions * Support + My Account + Help Centre + Contact Us * Irish Times products & services + Home Delivery + Page Sales + Photo Sales + Newsletters + Discount Codes + ePaper + Crosswords + Newspaper Archive + Article Archive + eBooks * About us + Advertise + Contact Us + The Irish Times Trust + Careers * Our partners + Rewarding Times + MyHome.ie + Top 1000 + The Gloss + Recruit Ireland + Irish Times Training Subscribe * Why Subscribe? * Subscription Bundles * Subscription Help Centre * Gift Subscriptions Support * My Account * Help Centre * Contact Us About Us * Advertise * Contact Us * The Irish Times Trust * Careers Irish Times Products & Services * ePaper * Crosswords * Newspaper Archive * Article Archive * eBooks * Home Delivery * Page Sales * Photo Sales * Newsletters * Discount Codes Follow us Download the app Download on the App Store Download on Google Play * Our Partners * Rewarding Times * MyHome.ie * Top 1000 * The Gloss * Recruit Ireland * Irish Times Training * Terms & Conditions * Privacy Policy * Cookie Information * Cookie Settings * Community Standards * Copyright (c) 2018 THE IRISH TIMES For the best site experience please enable JavaScript in your browser settings Sign In [ ] [ ] Sign In Forgot Password? Don't have an account? Subscribe Need some help ? * Digital Subscriptions FAQs * Subscriber Only Articles * The ePaper * Subscriber Rewards * Subscriber Tour * Breaking news app * My Account * eBooks * Email Newsletters * Crossword Club * Newspaper Archive * Sign Out SUBSCRIBE [ ] Wed 26/1/2022 * News + Climate + Coronavirus + Ireland + World + Politics + Crime & Law + Health + Education + Subscriber Only + ePaper + Brexit * Sport + Gaelic Games + Soccer + Rugby + Golf + Racing + Other Sports + Women in Sport + Comment * Business + The Economy + Your Money + Companies + Technology + Work + Commercial Property + Comment * Opinion + Editorials + Letters + Columnists + An Irishman's Diary + Opinion & Analysis + Martyn Turner * Life & Style + Food & Drink + Homes & Property + Health & Family + People + Travel + Motors + Fashion + Abroad * Culture + Books + Film + Music + Stage + Art & Design + TV, Radio, Web + Tuarascail + Heritage * More + You are what you read + eBooks + Offers + Jobs + Family Notices + Competitions * Video * Podcasts + Confronting Coronavirus + Inside Politics + The Women's Podcast + Inside Business + Added Time + World View + Back to Yours + The Irish Times Book Club * Executive Jobs * Crosswords * Notices * Help Centre * Newsletters [ ] [ ] [ ] Forgot Password? Sign In Invalid email or password. Not an Irish Times subscriber? Subscribe * Digital Subscriptions FAQs Frequently asked questions about your digital subscription * Subscriber Only Articles Specially selected and available only to our subscribers * Subscriber Rewards Exclusive offers, discounts and invitations * Subscriber Tour Explore the features of your subscription * Crossword Club Digital Simplex and Crosaire crosswords * Newspaper Archive 150 years of Irish Times journalism * My Account Manage your account * eBooks Carefully curated selections of Irish Times writing * Email Newsletters Sign up to get the stories you want delivered to your inbox * The ePaper An exact digital replica of the printed paper * Breaking news app Our Apple and Android apps to read on the go * Sign Out Update Payment Details --------------------------------------------------------------------- Unfortunately USERNAME we were unable to process your last payment. Please update your payment details to keep enjoying your Irish Times subscription. Update Payment Details Not Now