https://casdinteret.com/2022/01/rebuilding-notre-dame-painstaking-battle-between-new-and-old/ Skip to content cas d'interet cas d'interet Reflections of a Francophile Skip to content * Home * Contact * Disclaimer Home French Culture Rebuilding Notre Dame, Painstaking Battle Between New and Old Rebuilding Notre Dame, Painstaking Battle Between New and Old Carol A. Seidl January 21, 2022 January 21, 2022French Culture, General This spring will mark the 3-year anniversary of the devastating fire that destroyed the roof of the Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris. A day after the inferno, President Emmanuel Macron announced to the world that within 5 years France would "rebuild Notre Dame Cathedral, more beautiful than ever". Since then, the ambitious project has run into a series of setbacks and unforeseen sidetracks. In addition to raising the money needed to rebuild, organizers have employed hundreds of scientists, historical experts, and tradesmen to secure the site and put a restoration plan in place. In December, France's National Heritage and Architecture Commission gave the green light for most of the proposed renovations. Now the process of recreating a new Notre Dame, which imitates the old, is in full swing, with a goal of opening to the public on April 16, 2024. Working in winterWorking in winterRennovation work in full swing, December 2021. Witnessing a Cultural Disaster On the evening of April 15, 2019, hundreds of thousands of people around the globe began streaming live footage of smoke billowing above the roof of Notre Dame. Shortly before sunset, flames could be seen breaching the rooftop's surface. Within an hour, they had engulfed the cathedral's ornate spire and brought it crashing down, provoking a collective worldwide gasp of horror. Unbeknownst to onlookers, the seemingly delicate steeple was covered with 250 tons of lead. When it collapsed, it left a gaping hole in Notre Dame's roof, through which tumbled hundreds more tons of stone, lead, and metal scaffolding. Notre Dame on FireNotre Dame on FireSmoke and flames shoot skyward above Notre Dame de Paris, April 15, 2019. Photo: AP Securing a Hazardous Work Site In the days following the collapse, inspectors began the months-long process of determining how best to prepare the site for the extensive renovations to come. Complicating their task were two extenuating factors. First, the remaining structure was tremendously weakened and in need of immediate reinforcement. Second, most of the lead had been vaporized by the heat of the flames. Experts estimate that fire temperatures reached 800-900 degrees C (1500-1650 degrees F), lifting tons of lead particles into the atmosphere. Much of the airborne lead drifted away from the cathedral, eventually settling on the streets of Paris and beyond. But there were also high levels of toxic lead dust covering all parts of the cathedral and debris. Debris inside Notre DameDebris inside Notre DameDebris inside the Notre Dame Cathedral after the fire. Photo: Christopher Petit Tesson Notre Dame's massive pillars of stone give it the appearance of strength but the structure is actually quite fragile. Engineers and architects have never fully understood how masons of the 12th and 13th centuries managed to build an edifice that's height well-exceeds those of its contemporaries. The vaults of Notre Dame's ceiling are relatively thin, ranging from 20 to 30 centimeters thick. The extreme heat of the fire removed an additional 1-2 cm, warped many of the stones, and re-opened cracks that had been repaired in the 19th century. With its roof in tatters, the structural integrity of Notre Dame's walls was imperiled--much of the building in danger of collapse. Before any significant work could begin, engineers needed to construct massive wooden supports to secure the flying buttresses. These graceful arches on the exterior of the building prevent the walls from collapsing outward by counterbalancing the weight of the heavy vaulted ceiling. With the ceiling in ruins, however, the weight of the buttresses threatened to push the walls inward. While the buttresses may have a uniform appearance to the naked eye, they had warped in varied and inconsistent ways over the centuries. Hence, each flying buttress had to be closely studied to account for myriad eccentricities before building the wooden brace that would prevent its collapse. Wooden braces under buttressesWooden braces under buttressesWooden braces support Notre Dame's flying buttresses. Glass removed from nearby windows. Photo: PBS Another extremely precarious job was installing a tarpaulin over the roof to protect the interior from the elements. Thankfully, none of the stained glass in the building was damaged. However, certain windows were completely dismantled and will be reconstructed at a later date. If left in place, their weight and location could complicate or endanger ongoing work. Ironically, one of the hardest tasks was disassembling the steel scaffolding which had been installed to restore the spire prior to the fire. Some pieces lay in a heap within the cathedral. However, the portions that remained standing were twisted, unstable, and fused together. As such, the scaffolding was no longer simple to dismantle. Motion sensors were installed throughout the tangled lattice. These triggered regular false alarms, forcing evacuations of the building until safe conditions were re-established and workers could resume. Twisted scaffoldingTwisted scaffoldingTwisted and collapsed scaffolding, erected prior to the fire to renovate the spire. Scientific Inquiries After months of stabilizing the basic structure of the cathedral, clean up crews began working inside. A massive triage was underway. Archeological remains were carefully excavated from the rubble, catalogued, and shelved beneath large tents for further study. As a result, scientists and engineers are learning more about building techniques used by their 12th and 13th-century predessors. These discoveries not only inform history, but also influence the methods that will be employed for Notre Dame's reconstruction. Sorting of debrisSorting of debrisFractured statuary, stones, and timber are stored beneath tents on Notre Dame's parvis. One unexpected finding was the use of massive iron staples. Concealed behind the stonework's facade, these staples connected stones in the vault of the cathedral, reinforcing and strengthening the roof. Longer bands of iron were discovered at the tops of the cathedral's walls and elsewhere. This revelation provoked a detailed scan of other structures. Using sophisticated metal detectors, scientists gradually identified an elaborate skeleton of iron buried within the walls and columns of Notre Dame. Iron stapleIron stapleIron staple used to connect stones in Notre Dame's vault. Another area under intense scrutiny has been the composition of various mortars used throughout the building. Scientists have lifted samples from different types of joints, different types of connected surfaces, and different centuries. The composition of each mortar sample provides clues about the origins of the materials that went into mixing it. Architectural historians are interested in determining whether different mortars were intentionally chosen to fulfill specific roles. The recipes, once revealed, are recreated in a lab and studied for strength, drying, and hardening properties. When portions of the vault (to name one example) are rebuilt, masons will use mortars that closely resemble the original mixes. Where possible, archeologists have tried to puzzle various blocks of rubble back into their original positions relative to each other. They study never-before-seen surfaces in an effort to gather clues about the tools and techniques used by 12th and 13th-century craftsmen to cut and position each block. Such research will aid the restoration team in rebuilding the cathedral while following the original construction techniques as closely as feasible. Reconstructing and archReconstructing and archPositioning fallen blocks that once formed and arch over the nave of the cathedral. All Systems Go Fortunately, France has received more than adequate funding to support this precarious and painstaking work. After the fire, donations flooded in from around the world, raising roughly 850 million euros--1 million euros for each year that the cathedral has been around. This sum is more than double the annual budget of the French Ministry of Culture. Less than one year after the project got underway, however, work ground to a halt as the coronavirus led France into a lockdown. Despite the setbacks, Macron has held fast to his original goal of reopening in 5 years. Recognizing international interest in the project, the French president has called upon skilled tradesmen and technicians from around the world to help with Notre Dame's reconstruction. The response has been positive, from professional mountain climbers that now swing from ropes to clean soot-covered stonework, to the American company Autodesk, selected to provide 3D modeling for the exterior landscape. Until recently, the work has focused on securing the site, installing new supports and scaffolding, and clearing away debris. Now, however, with the approval of France's National Heritage and Architecture Commission, renovations can proceed at full speed. Mass has been scheduled for April 16, 2024. Yet, experts and onlookers alike predict that restoration work will continue well beyond that date. One thing is clear, a small army of scientists, architects, archeologists, historians, technicians, tradesmen, artists, clergy, and others are committed to rebuilding Notre Dame in all of its former glory. Cathedral of Notre Dame 2009Cathedral of Notre Dame 2009Cathedral of Notre Dame Paris, by Zuffe, 2009 Other Posts Featuring the Cathedral of Notre Dame de Paris Notre Dame Cathedral Paris in New Online Exposition Fanciful Visions of Notre Dame's Reconstruction How Victor Hugo Saved Notre Dame de Paris Whodunit? The Deadly Bullets that Narrowly Missed General de Gaulle Other Resources * Le Monde, Les materiaux de Notre-Dame de Paris livrent leurs secrets * Le Monde, Les travaux de securisation de Notre-Dame de Paris acheves, la phase de restauration peut commencer * France24, Inside Notre-Dame: The challenges of restoring iconic cathedral * Science, Saving Grace * PBS Nova, Saving Notre Dame * Friends of Notre Dame, NOTRE-DAME CATHEDRAL'S INTERIOR RENOVATIONS * Smithsonian, France Approves Controversial Plan to Renovate Notre-Dame Cathedral * BIM+, Paris turns to Autodesk for Notre-Dame design competition Thank you for sharing! * Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) * Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window) * Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) * Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window) * Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) * More * * Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) * Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) * * Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window) * Click to print (Opens in new window) * * Like this: Like Loading... Plus de cas d'interet [c8f59de571][c8f59de571] About Carol A. Seidl Serial software entrepreneur, writer, translator, and mother of 3. Avid follower of French media, culture, history, and language. Lover of books, travel, history, art, cooking, fitness, and nature. Cultivating connections with francophiles and francophones. View all posts by Carol A. Seidl - Archeology, architecture, History, Notre Dame de Paris, reconstruction, science. Bookmark. Tactless or Tactical? French President Macron Threatens Anti-Vaxers 17 Comments 1. [7fe3c8b][7fe3c8b] masercot January 21, 2022 at 3:07 pm That fire was heartbreaking. Loading... Reply + [c8f59de][c8f59de] Carol A. Seidl January 21, 2022 at 3:54 pm Yes it was, but like many catastrophes, there seem to be upsides. Scientists and historians are discovering many hidden secrets and the current reconstruction budget will allow for a brilliant restoration. Loading... Reply 2. [9041967][9041967] pedmar10 January 21, 2022 at 3:48 pm Yes will held Mass April 24 2024,have severalupdates on it, the last is here fyi https://paris1972-versailles2003.com/2021/12/10/ notre-dame-cathedral-update-dec2021/ Loading... Reply + [c8f59de][c8f59de] Carol A. Seidl January 21, 2022 at 3:58 pm Thanks for the link! Loading... Reply o [9041967][9041967] pedmar10 January 21, 2022 at 4:06 pm You are welcome. Loading... Reply 3. [76f936b][76f936b] WordsAndPeace January 21, 2022 at 5:36 pm Thanks for all the fascinating details, I didn't know about the discoveries related to building techniques Loading... Reply + [c8f59de][c8f59de] Carol A. Seidl January 21, 2022 at 7:07 pm Yes. I found that very surprising. The skill of the ancient craftsmen is hard to overestimate. Absolutely astounding considering the weights involved and the precision with which the block was laid. Loading... Reply 4. [452fa59][452fa59] Lory January 22, 2022 at 2:09 am Thank you, this was fascinating indeed. I was especially struck that sometimes there has to be a certain amount of destruction / dismantling to enable us to learn how something was constructed, and to activate those constructive forces. Lessons for life! Loading... Reply + [c8f59de][c8f59de] Carol A. Seidl January 22, 2022 at 8:12 am You're right Lory, there often is a silver lining to most setbacks. Before the fire, the budget to restore the cathedral was negligible and the church was having difficulty raising money even to restore the spire. Now they have the funds to do so much. I hope I can see Notre Dame when the restoration is done. Loading... Reply 5. [3292c45][3292c45] Smitha V January 22, 2022 at 10:24 am Had visited it in 2016 and was in complete awe of the architecture. I remembered feeling shocked when I heard of the fire. Thank you for explaining it in so much detail here. Its important for us to remember and understand the complexity of this architectural marvel. Loading... Reply + [c8f59de][c8f59de] Carol A. Seidl January 22, 2022 at 10:52 pm I agree Smitha. It will be interesting to see how well they can recreate the original. Loading... Reply 6. [5178635][5178635] annieasksyou January 23, 2022 at 4:16 pm This was a fascinating look at the past and present Notre Dame. Reading about the 12th and 13th Century building methods, I was reminded of Arthur Koestler's "The Anatomy of Snobbery." Those in the present sometimes assume we've progressed far beyond the intelligence and knowledge of humans centuries ago. Giant iron staples seem a metaphoric puncturing of that conviction. Loading... Reply + [c8f59de][c8f59de] Carol A. Seidl January 24, 2022 at 1:06 pm Koestler's book sounds intriguing. When was it written? I often feel as though social media is making us even dumber. If the power ever goes out, we're doomed. Loading... Reply o [ba5c842][ba5c842] equinoxio21 January 25, 2022 at 12:55 pm Dumber indeed. And power will be the first thing to go out in case of war... (I have petrol lamps in the house... just in case.) Loading... Reply # [c8f59de][c8f59de] Carol A. Seidl January 25, 2022 at 2:05 pm As I sit inside, looking at the frigid white landscape outside my window, I can't say I feel the same level of security. Loading... Reply 7. [ba5c842][ba5c842] equinoxio21 January 25, 2022 at 12:53 pm Very well documented Carol. A friend form California whatsaspped me that day. I was south of Mexico city. Shocking. Then saw Notre-Dame a few months later. They seem to be doing a good job, at a good pace for France. We seem to have avoided the "conteporary gesture" to replace the spire... Thank God! Loading... Reply + [c8f59de][c8f59de] Carol A. Seidl January 25, 2022 at 2:03 pm I agree Brieuc. I'm glad they're not messing with the original design. By all accounts it seems like things are progressing in excellent fashion-especially given the hurdles they've had to overcome. Loading... Reply Leave a Reply Cancel reply This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed. * [Close and accept] Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use. To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy * Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Mail RSS * Subscribe via Email Never miss a post and stay connected. Email Address [ ] Subscribe * Search for: [ ] Search * Recent Posts + Rebuilding Notre Dame, Painstaking Battle Between New and Old + Tactless or Tactical? French President Macron Threatens Anti-Vaxers + Winter Reflections, Assessing a Year of Reading and Writing + Year-End Humor from France, Ring Out 2021 with a Laugh + The Miser's Ghost, A Winter's Cautionary Tale from Quebec * Of Interest My Tweets * Follow on BloglovinFollow on Bloglovin Copyright (c) 2017-2021 Carol A. Seidl. All Rights Reserved. Powered by Nirvana & WordPress. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Mail RSS Loading Comments... Write a Comment...[ ] Email [ ] Name [ ] Website [ ] [Post Comment] Send to Email Address [ ] Your Name [ ]Your Email Address [ ] [ ] loading [Send Email] Cancel Post was not sent - check your email addresses! Email check failed, please try again Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. %d bloggers like this: