https://www.seevenice.it/en/who-founded-venice-the-controversial-origins-of-a-city-built-in-a-lagoon/ SeeVenice * About me * Experiences * Tours * Virtual Tours * Blog * Tips * EN + IT + DE [ ] [] Guida turistica a Venezia - A tour guide in Venice Guida turistica a Venezia - A tour guide in Venice * About me * Experiences * Tours * Virtual Tours * Blog * Tips * EN + IT + DE [ ] [] Who founded Venice? The controversial origins of a city built in a lagoon Home >> Who founded Venice? The controversial origins of a city built in a lagoon Who founded Venice? The controversial origins of a city built in a lagoon By Luisella Romeo, blogseevenice Posted May 30, 2021 In Venetian history Who founded Venice? The controversial origins of a city built in a lagoon2021-05-302021-05-31http://www.seevenice.it/wp-content/uploads/ 2016/01/logosmall.jpgSeeVenicehttps://www.seevenice.it/wp-content/ uploads/2021/05/img_6657.jpg200px200px 8 Who founded Venice is a challenging question. You will need patience, some scepticism and, believe it or not, some sense of humour, too. The foundation of Venice in the year 421 The legendary foundation date of March 25th in the year 421 has revealed to be medieval fake news. Such date has no historical proof. And yet, legends matter. The City Council of Venice for instance has decided to celebrate it with a series of events under the # Venezia1600 for the whole year. The important issue would be not to forget it is a legend. April Fool Day in Venice in the year 2021 That is why, in order to emphasise the need to be rigorous in historical research, the world-wide acclaimed institutions of the State Archive of Venice and the Marciana National Library have arranged a great April Fool. Pretending to have discovered two documents supporting the theory of the year 421, they even announced a breaking-news conference on the implications of this extraordinary discovery. Forgotten documents, covered in the dust. It sounded so exciting, so Indiana Jones' style! And they went further, announcing they "discovered" a poem in Provencal language mentioning the legendary date, especially in the following lines: Fonda Vineghia nel quatrozent vinti (...) Who composed the poem? A certain Aloysius de Bhrukny... The ones familiar with the current political life of Venice will have already recognised how the poet's name terribly echoes the name of the current Mayor of Venice, Luigi Brugnaro, who strongly supports the # Venezia1600 events. Who founded Venice according to history books Most of the Venetian history books quote ancient chronicles written in the 10th and the 15th century that postpone the date. Some mention the end of the 5th century, some the 7th century. But they all agree that it was after the fall of the Western Roman Empire under the pressure of the barbaric invasions, that the inhabitants of the Roman city of Altino abandoned their homes to move to the lagoon. There, they founded a new city on the island of Torcello, feeling protected by the shallow water of the lagoon. The first inhabitants of the Venetian lagoon were therefore refugees. [img_6358] The Basilica Santa Maria Assunta in Torcello There is an apparent inconsistency regarding the date and which barbaric invasions ancient chronicles talk about -the Huns or the Lombards? The main problem however is that in the last twenty years archeological investigations have proved that life in the lagoon was present long before the barbaric invasions and even before the legendary date of 421. The obsession regarding the origins of Venice There is a sort of an obsession when it comes to the origins of any city. As if defining the origins of a city, you could tell who you are. Personally I abhor any use of the word "identity". Nationalism, ethnic purity, shaping historical memory are far from historians' goal. Let's be honest: if you read Venice was founded by refugees, it is not necessarily true, but it's very true that someone for centuries has repeatedly told so, because they wanted you to believe this. In the legends Venice appears as a city originated from the sea. A free city. Freedom which is self determined, neither under the Pope's jurisdiction, nor the Emperor's. A city of refugees is a city with no pure origins, which would sound promising and helpful for an international trading capital. Moreover, those refugees were heroic Romans escaping from Barbarians, isn't that a nice story? Venice is therefore the heir of the Roman empire, strongly connected to the Byzantine world. Is there anything else we can do, but being skeptical and taking with a grain of salt whatever ancient documents say? Do not feel frustrated. The answer lies in that interesting link between history and archeology. Who founded Venice: an archeological answer Actually, you would never guess where some archeological remains are stored in Venice that could explain a lot about the first Doges that moved to Venice. Not just, they seem to reveal a part of the history that has been concealed and forgotten as it was not the story you would like to hear. [img_6645] A courtyard at the National Archeological Museum in Venice In the courtyards of the Procuratie Nuove, in St. Mark's square, by the premises of the Archeological museum, there is a collection of ancient remains, quite heterogeneous, no labels, no chronological display. There, I spent some great time with Diego Calaon, associate professor of Ancient Topography at the University of Venice Ca' Foscari. Prof. Calaon is continuing with passion and contagious enthusiasm the archeological research started by Ernesto Canal in the late 1960s in the lagoon, which prof. Wladimiro Dorigo strongly supported and contributed to with more insightful studies. Sant'Ilario monastery at Dogaletto di Mira The several remains look forgotten and lie covered in the dust. Some are really interesting for our research of the origins of Venice. Some come from an archeological site on the mainland facing the lagoon called Dogaletto di Mira and regard Sant'Ilario Benedictine monastery. This extraordinary collection features some elements presenting the history of Venice in those early years in a different light. The first Doges of Venice Prof. Calaon explained the monastery was founded in the year 819 and the church of this monastery was chosen by the Doges Agnello and Giustiniano Participazio as their burial place. Just to understand better who we talk about, these are the doges that moved the Doge's residence in the year 810 to St. Mark's square and founded St. Mark's Basilica in the year 829. Shall we call them the founders of Venice? [img_6642] A sarcophagus at the National Archeological Museum in Venice from Sant'Ilario monastery [img_6696] A sarcophagus at the National Archeological Museum in Venice from Sant'Ilario monastery Malamocco and its port It was through this monastery that the Participazio in the 9th century, with the help of a major fleet, controlled a major trading centre, called Metamauco, or Malamocco, placed by the point where the Brenta river (once called Medoacus) emptied out in the lagoon. Goods travelled through this port. They came from the Mediterranean Sea and Constantinople and found their way to Europe, across the Alps. Viceversa, goods from Europe reached this port and were shipped all over the Mediterranean Sea. In Dogaletto di Mira very little is left of this powerful monastic presence as ploughing was constant throughout the years. You can spot the foundations of some religious buildings, a graveyard and presumably a fortification. All that was discovered there lies now in the courtyards of the National Archeological Museum in St. Mark's square and dates back to the 6th up to the 11th century. Who founded Venice? What about if they were "Barbarians"? After the Aachen treaty in 812 sealed the peace between Franks and Byzantines for the control of the Adriatic Sea, the first Venetians would certainly intermediate between the two. The fun part however is that Venice has always been described as a city politically lying under the Eastern Roman Empire's influence. When we look at these remains though, it is clear that the situation was much more dynamic and fluid. The first Venetians followed Western political habits that can be assimilated to the Carolingian world. [img_6686] A well-head at the National Archeological Museum in Venice [img_6679] A well-head at the National Archeological Museum in Venice Carolingian and Byzantine heritage Fragments in this collection reveal that their art was Carolingian, too. From the well-heads to the funerary inscriptions mentioning "Lantfrid" or "Constantia". [img_6643] The funeral inscription mentioning Lantfrid, a Carolingian name, National Archeological Museum in Venice [img_6692] Remain of a sarcophagus at the National Archeological Museum in Venice from Sant'Ilario monastery mentioning Costantia At the same time, the Participazios chose a mosaic floor decoration of their church on the mainland featuring elements which reveal a cultural contamination with islamic and byzantine civilisations, such as the presence of the mythical "senmurv", a winged figure with a head like a dog, the legs like a lion and the tail as a peacock. [img_0773] The "senmurv" on the mosaic floor of Sant'Ilario, National Archeological Museum in Venice The sarcofagi instead bear Western Carolingian if not Lombard motifs. What about if they were the tombs of the Participazios? If so, then we should start thinking the first Venetians were not the heirs of the Roman Empire, but "Barbarians" who felt the fascination of the Byzantine culture and eventually absorbed it. You will agree, prof. Calaon adds, this was a story which could not fit with the fake news spreading in the centuries later that wanted to represent the origins of Venice connected to the Roman heritage and to the classical world. A museum of the history of Venice While research goes on to find out who founded Venice (and why), my hope is that some energy will also be spent to arrange a museum that narrates the history of Venice. Preserving and promoting this collection is a duty after all this time it's been instead neglected. Nothing like ancient remains can question myths and certainties and highlight the true fascination of historical research. by Luisella Romeo registered tourist guide in Venice, Italy www.seevenice.it Bibliography Diego Calaon, Margherita Ferri, Il monastero dei Dogi Santi Ilario e Benedetto ai margini della laguna veneziana, 2007 Stefano Riccioni, I mosaici altomedievali di Venezia e il monastero di S. Ilario. Orditi 'venetico-carolingi' di una koine alto Adriatica, 2017 Aachen, Agnello Participazio, Barbarians, Brenta, Byzantines, Carolingian, Constantinople, Correr Museum, Diego Calaon, Dogaletto di Mira, Doge, Doge's palace, Ernesto Canal, founders of Venice, Franks, Giustiniano Participazio, Guided tours, Langobards, Lombards, Malamocco, mosaic floor, mosaics, National Archeological Museum, origins of Venice, Procuratie Nuove, Sant'Ilario, senmurv, St Mark's basilica, Torcello, tours, Venetian lagoon, Venezia, Venezia1600, Venice, Venice's origins, well-heads, Wladimiro Dorigo, www.seevenice.it Recommended Posts * Stars and constellations or zodiac signs in Venetian Art Stars and constellations or zodiac signs in Venetian Art * The first airport in Venice on sand, grass and lagoon water: the Giovanni Nicelli The first airport in Venice on sand, grass and lagoon water: the Giovanni Nicelli * Equestrian statues in Venice: horses with or without a man Equestrian statues in Venice: horses with or without a man Showing 8 comments * [79540] Domenico Cardone May 31, 2021 Reply Ottimo articolo. Brava! + [cdf81] Luisella Romeo, blogseevenice June 1, 2021 Reply Caro Domenico, grazie! Le tue parole mi fanno grande piacere! * [4426e] Mary Jane June 15, 2021 Reply This presents the problems of "foundation myths" in an interesting light. I'm quite curious to learn about the archaeological evidence for previous occupation of the islands of the lagoon (prior to the 5th century). What sorts of discoveries have been made? Is it possible that the mediaeval "barbarians" in fact displaced or simply blended in with the earlier inhabitants of the lagoon? + [cdf81] Luisella Romeo, blogseevenice June 16, 2021 Reply Dear Mary Jane, thank you! You can find a lot of articles on the subject. Check for Diego Calaon and I believe there are articles in English, too. You can also subscribe to the FB group called "Torcello abitata" to follow the work each year a group of archeologists lead in Torcello. There are coins, pipes, amphorae, remains of port buildings, ceramics, glassware, fireplaces, cisterns to collect and filter rainwater... As for other remains, I found the frescoes of the villa in Lio Piccolo extremely fascinating. o [4426e] Mary Jane June 16, 2021 Reply Grazie Luisella! I just found Calaon and Ferri's article online, and I'll look around for others as well. I feel almost embarrassed that I knew nothing about this before, but mostly it is quite exciting to discover something totally new to explore. Now for a tour of the very earliest remains of Venice... # [cdf81] Luisella Romeo, blogseevenice June 16, 2021 Reply Very true! And the fun part is that we still don't know much about who founded Venice ... vs who founded Torcello * [b1121] Jane Parker November 10, 2021 Reply Fascinating research and purpose. + [cdf81] Luisella Romeo, blogseevenice November 10, 2021 Reply Grazie, Jane! It's indeed a great research! And more is being discovered in these days!!! Stay tuned Leave a Comment Cancel reply [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ]Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. CAPTCHA Refresh [ ] CAPTCHA Code * [POST COMMENT] Tags Accademia Gallery Andrea Palladio art arts and crafts Biennale Ca' Pesaro Ca' Rezzonico Carlo Scarpa carnival Correr Museum Doge's palace Faro convention Gabriel Bella Ghetto Giudecca glass gondola Grand Canal Guided tours hidden Venice Jewish history Lido Murano music palace Paolo Veronese Peggy Guggenheim photography Pietro Longhi Querini Stampalia Museum Renaissance rowing Scuola Grande San Rocco St Mark's basilica St Mark's church St Mark's square Tintoretto Titian tours Venetian lagoon Venezia Venice Vittore Carpaccio water www.seevenice.it Popular Posts * Bridges in Venice and what makes them unique Bridges in Venice and what makes them unique October 28, 2020 * The birds of the lagoon of Venice The birds of the lagoon of Venice July 31, 2017 * Confettis for all parties! Confettis for all parties! February 25, 2015 * Who founded Venice? The controversial origins of a city built in a lagoon Who founded Venice? The controversial origins of a city built in a lagoon May 30, 2021 * When swimming in Venice was not a crime When swimming in Venice was not a crime September 30, 2018 * Dogs in Venetian art museums Dogs in Venetian art museums June 29, 2016 * Silk velvet weaving and weavers in Venice Silk velvet weaving and weavers in Venice June 26, 2017 * Venetian glass beads and jewels today! Venetian glass beads and jewels today! July 12, 2015 HOW YOU CAN CONTACT ME For more information on the itineraries and to book with me, please contact me at l.romeo@seevenice.it FOLLOW ME Recent Posts * Stars and constellations or zodiac signs in Venetian Art Stars and constellations or zodiac signs in Venetian Art January 22, 2022 * The first airport in Venice on sand, grass and lagoon water: the Giovanni Nicelli The first airport in Venice on sand, grass and lagoon water: the Giovanni Nicelli December 22, 2021 * Equestrian statues in Venice: horses with or without a man Equestrian statues in Venice: horses with or without a man November 28, 2021 Recent Comments * Luisella Romeo, blogseevenice on Stars and constellations or zodiac signs in Venetian Art * Jill Kerby on Stars and constellations or zodiac signs in Venetian Art * Luisella Romeo, blogseevenice on Bridges in Venice and what makes them unique * Anonymous on Bridges in Venice and what makes them unique * Luisella Romeo, blogseevenice on Who founded Venice? The controversial origins of a city built in a lagoon SEEVENICE Luisella Romeo SeeVenice / Venezia Cell. +39 349 0848 303 e-mail l.romeo@seevenice.it P. IVA 03220940278 (c) Luisella Romeo -- credits Nashi -- Privacy Policy [img_6495small-150x15] The Pink Lioness team and the tradition of women rowing in Venice Venetian traditions [img_0984small-1-150x] Venetian floors in terrazzo, marble and glass mosaics: what makes them specialVenetian architecture Questo sito utilizza dei cookies di terze parti. Continuando la navigazione stai dando il consenso ad utilizzare questi cookies. Leggi l'informativa estesa per saperne di piu.OkCookie policy