https://www.science.org/content/article/covid-19-may-have-killed-nearly-3-million-india-far-more-official-counts-show Advertisement * * news * careers * commentary * Journals * Covid-19 Science Science * * * Log in * Become A Member [science] science [sciadv] science advances [sciimmunol] science immunology [scirobotic] science robotics [signaling] science signaling [stm] science translational medicine [spj-cover] science partner journals Quick Search anywhere Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Searching: Anywhere AnywhereScienceScience AdvancesScience ImmunologyScience Robotics Science SignalingScience Translational Medicine Advanced Search Search Trending Terms: * covid-19 * climate * science policy * genome editing * batteries Log In Become A Member Quick Search anywhere Enter Search Term[ ] science.org * Custom publishing * collections * videos * podcasts * blogs * visualizations * prizes and awards * authors & reviewers * librarians * advertisers * about * help * * * * * * AAAS Logo * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * Accessibility * News Home * All News * ScienceInsider * News Features GET OUR E-ALERTS HomeNewsScienceInsiderCOVID-19 may have killed nearly 3 million in India, far more than official counts show Back To ScienceInsider * ScienceInsider * Asia/Pacific COVID-19 may have killed nearly 3 million in India, far more than official counts show New analysis bolsters idea that country's seemingly low death rate was misleading * 6 Jan 2022 * 2:05 PM * ByJon Cohen A person wearing personal protective equipment walks past funeral pyres at a mass crematorium ground in East Delhi, India Images of fields filled with funeral pyres, like these in Delhi in April 2021, highlighted the massive toll of the pandemic in India.Atul Loke/Panos Pictures/Panos Pictures/Redux Share: * Twitter * Linked In * Facebook * Reddit * Wechat * Email India, from the earliest days of the pandemic, has reported far fewer COVID-19 deaths than expected given the toll elsewhere--an apparent death "paradox" that some believed was real and others thought would prove illusory. Now, a prominent epidemiologist who contended the country really had been spared the worst of COVID-19 has led a rigorous new analysis of available mortality data and concluded he "got it wrong." India has "substantially greater" COVID-19 deaths than official reports suggest, says Prabhat Jha of the University of Toronto-- close to 3 million, which is more than six times higher than the government has acknowledged and the largest number of any country. If true, the finding could prompt scrutiny of other countries with anomalously low death rates and push up the current worldwide pandemic total, estimated by the World Health Organization (WHO) at some 5.45 million people. "I think it does call for a recalibration of the global numbers plus saying, 'What the heck is going on in India?'" says Jha, whose team published the new India analysis today in Science. And India's suffering could be far from over--the Omicron variant of the coronavirus has begun to surge there. At the end of 2021, India reported about 480,000 deaths from SARS-CoV-2 infections. That's 340 COVID-19 deaths per million--about one-seventh the per capita COVID-19 mortality tallied in the United States. Jha's own early analysis supported the assertion that India had an unusually low mortality rate from COVID-19, but he and his colleagues have now probed more deeply. They tapped data from an independent polling agency that surveyed nearly 140,000 people across the vast country by telephone, asking whether anyone in each household had died from COVID-19. They also analyzed government reports from hospitals and similar facilities and looked at officially registered deaths. The result: a much higher estimate--between 2300 and 2500 deaths per million by September 2021, comparable to the rate in the United States, which has one-third as many people. Jha says his early, low estimate was based on the first wave of infections in the fall of 2020, which may have been less deadly than the Delta variant that drove India's massive surge in spring of 2021. He also focused on the large cities, where death rates may have been lower than in the countryside. And death registration in the country had been spotty even before the pandemic. But those factors can't be the whole story, he says. "There must be other things that we still don't understand." One, he says, is politics: He thinks the administration of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi has clouded the true picture of the pandemic. "The Indian government very much is trying to suppress the numbers in the way that they coded the COVID deaths," Jha says. He and others also fault the government for not releasing data from what's known as the Sample Registration System (SRS), which routinely surveys 1% of India's population to track births and deaths. "I think the political pressures were such that they said, 'Anything that's going to come out is going to be embarrassing.'" Ramanan Laxminarayan, a Princeton University epidemiologist and economist, doesn't see the undercount as entirely deliberate. He notes SRS data haven't been released since 2018, before the pandemic, so that suspension may just reflect a disorganized system. He adds that almost every country undercounts COVID-19 mortality. "I think all governments want to downplay the degree of deaths," he adds. (Three Indian government sources that Science contacted did not immediately reply to requests for comments on the new study.) The new estimates for India come as little surprise to Laxminarayan. "My starting point is that unless you can tell me why India is different, I'm going to assume that India is the same as any other country," he says. "I don't believe in exceptionalism of any kind unless it's well justified." His team last month published a study in The Lancet that focused on the Indian district of Chennai and concluded that reported deaths "greatly underestimated pandemic-associated mortality." Virologist Shahid Jameel of Ashoka University says the countrywide estimates by Jha's team are also "in broad agreement" with two other independent studies that examined a similar time frame. "India paid a heavy price for not having good real-time data on deaths, especially during the first wave. That led to complacency and a terrible toll in the second wave," Jameel says. The work nicely triangulates data from different sources, each of which has its own limitations, says Samira Asma, a WHO assistant director general who works on data and analysis. "The study design is robust," Asma says. "Countries can learn from this approach to ... produce country-specific estimates." WHO is now updating its estimates of excess deaths caused by COVID-19 and plans to release them soon, she says. A worldwide comparison of all-cause mortality before and during the pandemic, published in eLife 6 months ago, suggests undercounting is widespread. Russia had 4.5 times more deaths than normal, far beyond its official COVID-19 tally, and the trend has continued, the researchers recently tweeted. Tajikistan, Nicaragua, Uzbekistan, Belarus, and Egypt also had profound disconnects. Omicron has begun to run riot in India, and Jha warns the country should not count on it causing milder disease than earlier variants, as data from other countries suggest it might. "I would be really careful about those assumptions because they're based on selected populations that you can't take from South Africa or the U.K. or Canada to India," he says. And he's wary of "wishful thinking" that the prior high levels of infections in India and wide-scale vaccination will create population level immunity against the variant causing severe disease. "We just don't know enough about how these different variants behave in immunized populations," he says. Spoken like a researcher who doesn't want to get it wrong again. --------------------------------------------------------------------- doi: 10.1126/science.acz9960 Relevant tags: Asia/PacificHealth Coronavirus About the author Jon Cohen Jon Cohen mailTwitter Author Jon is a staff writer for Science. --------------------------------------------------------------------- More from news Eric Lander 10 Jan 2022 White House calls for consistent rules for disclosing foreign research funding By * Jeffrey Mervis A deer tick on a human finger 7 Jan 2022 Lyme-carrying ticks live longer--and could spread farther--thanks to warmer winters By * Elizabeth Pennisi SICB 2022 meeting attendees 6 Jan 2022 Omicron leads to fresh wave of scientific meeting cancellations By * Daniel Clery, Elizabeth Pennisi View more Got a tip for Science's news department? Connect Advertisement ScienceInsider Eric Lander 10 Jan 2022By * Jeffrey Mervis White House calls for consistent rules for disclosing foreign research funding SICB 2022 meeting attendees 6 Jan 2022By * Daniel Clery, Elizabeth Pennisi Omicron leads to fresh wave of scientific meeting cancellations A person wearing personal protective equipment walks past funeral pyres at a mass crematorium ground in East Delhi, India 6 Jan 2022By * Jon Cohen COVID-19 may have killed nearly 3 million in India, far more than official counts show Temporary field hospital is constructed in London 4 Jan 2022By * Kai Kupferschmidt, Gretchen Vogel Omicron cases are exploding. Scientists still don't know how bad the wave will be View more Advertisement Sifter Bat flying out of cave 6 Dec 2021By * Rachel Fritts Baby bats learn to navigate by hitching a ride on mom davemaoite 12 Nov 2021By * Paul Voosen This diamond contains a mineral never before seen in nature Homo naledi skull bones 5 Nov 2021By * Ann Gibbons First child's skull of Homo naledi unveiled Deer in a field 4 Nov 2021By * Rachel Fritts Pandemic coronavirus is widespread in Iowa deer View more RecommendedClose Migrants wearing protective face masks wait for transportation 27 May 2020By * Vaishnavi Chandrashekhar As India's lockdown ends, exodus from cities risks spreading COVID-19 far and wide In DepthNovember 2020 India's COVID-19 teacher a health care worker wearing a mask swabs a patient's nose in front of poster of a woman wearing a long dress 29 Oct 2020By * Vaishnavi Chandrashekhar India's COVID-19 cases have declined rapidly--but herd immunity is still far away, scientists say EditorialMay 2020 COVID-19 amidst Ebola's retreat Advertisement Support nonprofit science journalism Help News from Science publish trustworthy, high-impact stories about research and the people who shape it. Please make a tax-deductible gift today. Donate [logo-dark] x ( ) $25 (*) $50 ( ) $100 ( ) Other $ [ ] Please enter a valid email (*) Single ( ) Monthly Email: [ ] Please enter a valid email Country: [Country * ] [ ] I also wish to receive emails from AAAS/Science and Science advertisers, including information on products, services and special offers which may include but are not limited to news, careers information & upcoming events. Donate now Support nonprofit science journalism If we've learned anything from the COVID-19 pandemic, it's that we cannot wait for a crisis to respond. Science and AAAS are working tirelessly to provide credible, evidence-based information on the latest scientific research and policy, with extensive free coverage of the pandemic. Your tax-deductible contribution plays a critical role in sustaining this effort. Charitable Disclosures Loading... Skip slideshow Follow Us * * * * * * * NEWS * All News * ScienceInsider * News Features * Subscribe to News from Science * News from Science FAQ * About News from Science * CAREERS * Careers Articles * Find Jobs * Employer Profiles * COMMENTARY * Opinion * Analysis * Blogs * JOURNALS * Science * Science Advances * Science Immunology * Science Robotics * Science Signaling * Science Translational Medicine * Science Partner Journals * AUTHORS & REVIEWERS * Information for Authors * Information for Reviewers * LIBRARIANS * Manage Your Institutional Subscription * Library Admin Portal * Request a Quote * Librarian FAQs * ADVERTISERS * Advertising Kits * Custom Publishing Info * Post a Job * RELATED SITES * AAAS.org * AAAS Communities * EurekAlert! * Science in the Classroom * ABOUT US * Leadership * Work at AAAS * Prizes and Awards * HELP * FAQs * Access and Subscriptions * Order a Single Issue * Reprints and Permissions * Contact Us Follow Us * * * * * * AAAS logo (c) 2022 American Association for the Advancement of Science. All rights reserved. AAAS is a partner of HINARI, AGORA, OARE, CHORUS, CLOCKSS, CrossRef and COUNTER. back to top * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * Accessibility