https://www.bbc.com/news/business-59341750 BBC Homepage * Skip to content * Accessibility Help * Your account * Home * News * Sport * Reel * Worklife * Travel * Future * Culture * MenuMore Search * Home * News * Sport * Reel * Worklife * Travel * Future * Culture * Music * TV * Weather * Sounds Close menu BBC News Menu * Home * Coronavirus * Climate * Video * World * US & Canada * UK * Business * Tech * Science * Stories More * Entertainment & Arts * Health * In Pictures * Reality Check * World News TV * Newsbeat * Long Reads * Business * Market Data * New Economy * New Tech Economy * Companies * Entrepreneurship * Technology of Business * Economy * CEO Secrets * Global Car Industry * Business of Sport Facebook tells LA police to stop spying on users with fake accounts By Mary-Ann Russon Business reporter, BBC News Published 1 day ago Share close Share page Copy link About sharing LA policemanImage source, Getty Images Facebook has written to the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD), demanding that it stop setting up fake profiles to conduct surveillance on users. This comes after the Guardian revealed that the US police department had been working with a tech firm, analysing user data to help solve crimes. Facebook expressly prohibits the creation and use of fake accounts. The intent, it said, was to "create a safe environment where people can trust and hold one another accountable". "Not only do LAPD instructional documents use Facebook as an explicit example in advising officers to set up fake social media accounts, but documents also indicate that LAPD policies simply allow officers to create fake accounts for 'online investigative activity'," wrote Facebook's vice president and deputy general counsel for civil rights Roy Austin in a letter outlining Facebook's policies. "While the legitimacy of such policies may be up to the LAPD, officers must abide by Facebook's policies when creating accounts on our services. The Police Department should cease all activities on Facebook that involve the use of fake accounts, impersonation of others, and collection of data for surveillance purposes." Documents obtained through public record requests made by non-profit organisation the Brennan Center of Justice showed that in 2019, the LAPD had been using Voyager Labs' social media surveillance software to collect data from suspects' social media networks, including their friends' accounts. Voyager Labs claims its software is able to analyse large amounts data to help solve crimes, including helping to discern users' motives and beliefs. The LAPD said in emails that the software had been particularly useful in investigating the activities of street gangs online and crucial in helping its robbery and homicide division collect evidence. Pot calling the kettle black? Facebook argues that spying on users and impersonating legitimate users goes against its purpose, which is to enable people to "connect and share with real people using their authentic identities". Facebook and Meta logoImage source, NurPhoto Image caption, In October, Facebook announced that its parent company would now be called Meta in a nod to Mark Zuckerberg's ambitions of creating a "metaverse" However, Robert Potter, an Australian security expert specialising in lawful surveillance, thinks fake names can be justified in situations where human rights activists or journalists are seeking to protect their privacy online, or for users in countries where there is internet censorship. And he is surprised at the social network's strong stance against the LAPD, when it has been slow to take action in the past on issues like misleading political ads, online scams and social media's negative effects on teenagers. "It's genuinely interesting to see that Facebook has become the nexus for so many problematic communications, from child trafficking and terrorism communications to Covid disinformation," he told the BBC. "Yet they seem to care more about the LAPD misusing their platform than sometimes they do about China or Russia." Despite its claims regarding authenticity and accountability, in August the social network banned the accounts of US academics researching political ads on its platform. Facebook said the researchers' data-scraping browser extension tool undermined its security, while the academics argued that their work was vital in maintaining democracy and keeping the social network's practices transparent. "If you're not cracking down across the board on malicious actors using your platform, you don't have strong grounds to crack down on legitimate use of the platform," said Mr Potter, who built the Washington Post's cyber-security operations centre and has advised the Australian government on cyber-security. "You're not special if you run a social media platform. If there's not a rule saying you can't have an undercover cop in a church, why should a social media platform be any different?" Related Topics * Social networks * Companies * Cyber-crime * Los Angeles * Mass surveillance * Undercover police * Facebook * Surveillance * United States More on this story * Facebook changes its name to Meta in major rebrand Published 28 October * Facebook earns $9bn despite whistleblower scandal Published 26 October * Facebook is making hate worse, whistleblower says Published 25 October Top Stories * Calls for calm as teen gunman acquittal divides US Published 7 hours ago * Why Kyle Rittenhouse case so divides the US Published 22 hours ago * WHO very worried about Covid rise in Europe Published 6 hours ago Features * Why Kyle Rittenhouse case so divides the US Two men argue outside court * Ros Atkins on... Rising tensions with Russia. VideoRos Atkins on... Rising tensions with Russia Putin * How China censored a tennis star Chinese tennis player Peng Shuai signing autographs * * School bus experiment brings hope to French estates Housing estate in Toulouse * Japan goes from vaccine hesitancy to success A Tokyo fire brigade staff member (R) administers a dose of the Covid-19 coronavirus vaccine at Aoyama University in Tokyo on August 2, 2021. * The extraordinary power of poo Toilet * Cumberbatch on the challenge of playing a misogynist Benedict Cumberbatch * What a lack of sunlight really does to your brain Woman sitting in mostly darkness * Striking pictures from around the world this week A lemur looking at a lens as a man takes photographs at Qingdao Forest Wildlife World in China's eastern Shandong province, on 18 November 2021 Elsewhere on the BBC * 'We said we'd never talk about it again' How a night out in Glasgow ended in disaster Michael Byrne * The story of an intense secret affair Are Marianne and Connell meant to be together? Normal People Most Read * 1Calls for calm as teen gunman acquittal divides US * 2Outage locks Tesla drivers out of their cars * 3New meat tray 'could save tonnes of plastic waste' * 4WHO very worried about Covid rise in Europe * 5US motorway frenzy after armoured van spills money * 6Why Kyle Rittenhouse case so divides the US * 7Theranos boss makes surprise testimony at trial * 8Cumberbatch on the challenge of playing a misogynist * 9All-electric plane 'sets records' in new tests * 10Who is US teen cleared of protest killings? BBC News Services * On your mobile * On smart speakers * Get news alerts * Contact BBC News * Home * News * Sport * Reel * Worklife * Travel * Future * Culture * Music * TV * Weather * Sounds * Terms of Use * About the BBC * Privacy Policy * Cookies * Accessibility Help * Parental Guidance * Contact the BBC * Get Personalised Newsletters * Why you can trust the BBC * Advertise with us * AdChoices / Do Not Sell My Info (c) 2021 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.