https://www.science.org/content/article/why-do-placebos-work-scientists-identify-key-brain-pathway Advertisement * * news * careers * commentary * Journals * Covid-19 Science Science * * * Log in * Become A Member [science] science [sciadv] science advances [sciimmunol] science immunology [scirobotic] science robotics [signaling] science signaling [stm] science translational medicine [spj-cover] science partner journals Quick Search anywhere Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Quick Search in Journals Enter Search Term[ ] Searching: Anywhere AnywhereScienceScience AdvancesScience ImmunologyScience Robotics Science SignalingScience Translational Medicine Advanced Search Search Trending Terms: * covid-19 * climate * science policy * genome editing * batteries Log In Become A Member Quick Search anywhere Enter Search Term[ ] science.org * Custom publishing * collections * videos * podcasts * blogs * visualizations * prizes and awards * authors & reviewers * librarians * advertisers * about * help * * * * * * AAAS Logo * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * Accessibility * News Home * All News * ScienceInsider * News Features GET OUR E-ALERTS HomeNewsAll NewsWhy do placebos work? Scientists identify key brain pathway Back To All News * News * Brain & Behavior Why do placebos work? Scientists identify key brain pathway Study finds opposite impacts on brainstem of placebo and "nocebo" effects * 27 Oct 2021 * 2:30 PM * ByDaryl Austin open pill capsule Peter Dazeley/Getty Images Share: * Twitter * Linked In * Facebook * Reddit * Wechat * Email The placebo effect can bring powerful relief--but what does that look like in your brain? A new study finds fake therapies and fake side effects have a real impact on your brainstem, a hub of pain processing, affecting it in opposite ways. The work could help scientists develop better treatments for chronic pain. It's "a major rigorous contribution to the field," says Ted Kaptchuk, a biomedical scientist at Harvard Medical School who was not involved with the study. Still, he cautions that more work is needed to see whether this laboratory-based study translates to the real world. Scientists have known about the placebo effect for more than 400 years. In 1572, a French philosopher wrote that "there are men on whom the mere sight of medicine is operative." Yet researchers have struggled to understand why patients given a nonactive therapy such as a sugar pill still feel relief. They've also been confounded by the opposite phenomenon: When patients are told a placebo has harmful side effects, they often feel bad afterward--the so-called "nocebo" effect. To find the signature of these two effects in brain, researchers brought 27 participants--13 men and 14 women with an average age of 23--into their laboratory at the University of Melbourne. The scientists strapped a device called a thermode to their arm, which heated up to a moderately painful temperature. Afterward, the researchers told the participants they were applying one of three creams to the affected area: a pain reliever, a pain inducer (which would make the heat feel worse), and a control cream with no effect. In reality, all three substances were petroleum jelly. All the while, the team scanned the volunteers with a high-resolution functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) machine to detect which parts of their brain were most active. Most participants in the study experienced either the placebo or nocebo effect. About one-third reported lower levels of pain when the "pain reliever" was applied, whereas slightly more than half reported more pain when the "pain inducer" was applied. The fMRI results reflected these responses. Both the placebo and nocebo effects influenced activity in the brainstem, the researchers report this week in The Journal of Neuroscience. The placebo effect increased activity in an area called the rostral ventromedial medulla, which relays pain information, and decreased activity in the periaqueductal gray, which helps the body suppress pain. The nocebo effect induced the opposite change. (The findings may seem counterintuitive, but multiple areas of the brainstem act in complex ways when it comes to creating the sensation of pain, the authors say.) The approach is excellent, says Tor Wager, a neuroscientist who studies the placebo effect at Dartmouth College. "It was done at ultra-high resolution, which makes it much better for identifying [parts of] the brainstem that play key roles in pain control." Though other studies have shown brain activity in response to both the placebo and nocebo effects, he and other experts say the new work offers the most detailed view yet of how the brain responds to these phenomena. The results may offer a route for future treatments of chronic pain, says Lewis Crawford, a neuroscientist at the University of Sydney School of Medical Sciences and the study's lead author. Doctors have applied electrical impulses to the brainstem--an approach known as deep brain stimulation--to treat burning "neuropathic" pain, which can be caused by nerve damage, as well as carpal tunnel syndrome, and cancer-related pain (such as that resulting from nervous system tumor invasion or radiation-induced nerve damage) with only mixed success for decades, he notes. Part of the problem was an inability to identify exactly which parts of the brainstem are responsible for controlling the modulation of pain, Crawford says. By localizing placebo- and nocebo-induced sensations to more precise brain areas, the new study could help narrow down targets for stimulation, he says. Placebo or not, that's a valuable dose of good news. --------------------------------------------------------------------- doi: 10.1126/science.acx9483 Relevant tags: Brain & Behavior About the author Daryl Austin Daryl Austin Author Daryl Austin is a journalist based in Utah who covers science, health, and history, and the areas where they converge. He has written for National Geographic, Smithsonian Magazine, Kaiser Health News, Discover Magazine, LiveScience, and The Washington Post. --------------------------------------------------------------------- More from news A Black woman in bed with her hands covering her face. 28 Oct 2021 Poor sleep takes a heavy toll on communities of color. Can scientists help? By * Rodrigo Perez Ortega Artist and volunteers carry polar bear sculpture 28 Oct 2021 News at a glance: Climate promises, a predatory 'Hydra' publisher, and tracking the birth of elements By * Science News Staff An upside-down jellyfish. 28 Oct 2021 'If it's alive, it sleeps.' Brainless creatures shed light on why we slumber By * Elizabeth Pennisi View more Got a tip for Science's news department? Connect Advertisement ScienceInsider Nicole Boivin 28 Oct 2021By * Andrew Curry Max Planck Institute demotes noted archaeologist Trees in the boreal forest at dawn 28 Oct 2021By * Charles Piller DNA barcoding paper retracted after its first author flags serious problems The Copernicus Carbon Dioxide Monitoring mission satellite 28 Oct 2021By * Warren Cornwall On eve of climate summit, researchers sharpen emissions tracking Masked nurse caring for patient in bed 28 Oct 2021By * Meredith Wadman OCD drug shows promise against COVID-19 View more Advertisement Sifter a man brushing his teeth in front of a mirror 27 Oct 2021By * Jocelyn Kaiser Unusual Alzheimer's treatment may have helped patients who have gingivitis A surgical team examines a porcine kidney for any signs of hyperacute rejection 20 Oct 2021By * Jennifer Couzin-Frankel Doctors successfully attach a pig kidney to a human body lunar capsule 8 Oct 2021By * Rachel Fritts The Moon was volcanically active 2 billion years ago, new space rocks reveal GW Orionis, a triple star system with a peculiar inner region 29 Sep 2021By * Rachel Fritts Scientists may have found the first known planet to orbit three stars View more Advertisement RecommendedClose 7 May 2004By * Jean Marx Locating a Key Step in Pain's Pathway [200582321] 23 Aug 2005By * Susan Brown Placebos' Effects Pinpointed in Brain April 2021 Drugs and Placebos Look Alike in the Brain February 2002 Placebo and Opioid Analgesia-- Imaging a Shared Neuronal Network Skip slideshow Follow Us * * * * * * * NEWS * All News * ScienceInsider * News Features * Subscribe to News from Science * News from Science FAQ * CAREERS * Careers Articles * Find Jobs * Employer Profiles * COMMENTARY * Opinion * Analysis * Blogs * JOURNALS * Science * Science Advances * Science Immunology * Science Robotics * Science Signaling * Science Translational Medicine * Science Partner Journals * AUTHORS & REVIEWERS * Information for Authors * Information for Reviewers * LIBRARIANS * Manage Your Institutional Subscription * Library Admin Portal * Request a Quote * Librarian FAQs * ADVERTISERS * Advertising Kits * Custom Publishing Info * Post a Job * RELATED SITES * AAAS.org * AAAS Communities * EurekAlert! * Science in the Classroom * ABOUT US * Leadership * Work at AAAS * Prizes and Awards * HELP * FAQs * Access and Subscriptions * Order a Single Issue * Reprints and Permissions * Contact Us Follow Us * * * * * * AAAS logo (c) 2021 American Association for the Advancement of Science. All rights reserved. AAAS is a partner of HINARI, AGORA, OARE, CHORUS, CLOCKSS, CrossRef and COUNTER. back to top * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * Accessibility Thank you for reading News fromScience. You have reached your limit of 5 free news stories this month. To gain unlimited access to News fromScience, pleaseLog inor subscribe to News from Science. AAAS Members canLog infor unlimited access. $2.99/Month$25/YearFrequently Asked Questions