https://nautil.us/issue/25/water/five-things-we-still-dont-know-about-water * * [p] Nautilus [nautilus-l] * Issues * Topics * Coronavirus * Blog * Thanks for Joining the Newsletter * * * Login * Subscribe SELECT NEWSLETTERS AND SUBMIT CONTACT DETAILS... * [*]New chapters Thursdays Nautilus publishes a new chapter of feature stories on its monthly theme, every Thursday. Sign up to this list to stay up to date on [ ] the latest and greatest. [ ] [Submit] * [*]Editor's picks Sundays Read about the Nautilus stories and blogs we've been thinking about over the past week. [ ] * * * TheEdge_THUMB Special Issue The Edge Intelligent_Life_THUMB Special Issue Intelligent Life OceanBlues_THUMB Special Issue Whale Songs Harmony_THUMB Special Issue Harmony [18583_e4563f7b21ded1b4baf7494d1] Special Issue Healthy Communication HiddenTruths_THUMB Special Issue Hidden Truths Outsiders_THUMB Special Issue Outsiders Universal_THUMB Issue 099 Universality Mind_THUMB Issue 098 Mind Wonder_THUMB Issue 097 Wonder Rewired_THUMB Issue 096 Rewired Escape_THUMB Issue 095 Escape * Evolving_THUMB Issue 094 Evolving Forerunners_THUMB Issue 093 Forerunners Frontiers_THUMB Issue 092 Frontiers AmazeBrain_THUMB Issue 091 The Amazing Brain SomethingGreen_THUMB Issue 090 Something Green DarkSide_THUMB Issue 089 The Dark Side Love-Sex_THUMB Issue 088 Love & Sex Risk_THUMB Issue 087 Risk Energy_THUMB Issue 086 Energy Reopen_THUMB Issue 085 Reopening Outbreak_THUMB Issue 084 Outbreak Intelligence_THUMB Issue 083 Intelligence * Panpyschism_THUMB Issue 082 Panpsychism Maps_THUMB Issue 081 Maps Scharf_TH Issue 080 Aliens Catalysts_THUMB Issue 079 Catalysts Atmospheres_THUMB Issue 078 Atmospheres Underworlds_THUMB Issue 077 Underworlds Language_THUMB Issue 076 Language Story_THUMB Issue 075 Story Networks_THUMB Issue 074 Networks Play_THUMB Issue 073 Play Quandary_THUMB Issue 072 Quandary Flow_Curtain-THUMB Issue 071 Flow * Variables_THUMB Issue 070 Variables Patterns_THUMB Issue 069 Patterns Context_THUMB Issue 068 Context Reboot_THUMB Issue 067 Reboot Clockwork_THUMB Issue 066 Clockwork Curtain_THUMB Issue 065 In Plain Sight Unseen_THUMB-F Issue 064 The Unseen Horizons_THUMB Issue 063 Horizons Systems_THUMB Issue 062 Systems Coordinates_THUMB-2 Issue 061 Coordinates Searches_CURTAIN_THUMB Issue 060 Searches Connections_THUMB Issue 059 Connections * Self_Curtain_HERO Issue 058 Self Community-THUMB Issue 057 Communities Curtain_THUMB Issue 056 Perspective Trust_HERO Issue 055 Trust Unspoken_CURTAIN_THUMB Issue 054 The Unspoken Monsters_Curtain_THUMB Issue 053 Monsters Hive_Curtain_THUMB Issue 052 The Hive Limits_Curtain_THUMB-2 Issue 051 Limits Emergence_THUMB Issue 050 Emergence Absurd_THUMB-F Issue 049 The Absurd Chaos_THUMB Issue 048 Chaos 047_TH-2 Issue 047 Consciousness * Balance_CURTAIN-THUMB Issue 046 Balance Power_TH_2 Issue 045 Power Luck_TH-2 Issue 044 Luck Heroes_TH-1 Issue 043 Heroes Fakes_TH Issue 042 Fakes Selection-TH-1 Issue 041 Selection LEARNING_TH-2 Issue 040 Learning Sport_THUMB-2 Issue 039 Sport Noise_THUMB Issue 038 Noise Currents_TH-3 Issue 037 Currents Aging_THUMB Issue 036 Aging Boundaries_THUMB-preview Issue 035 Boundaries * Adaptation_CURTAIN_THUMB Issue 034 Adaptation Attraction_THUMB-F. Issue 033 Attraction Space_TH. Issue 032 Space Stress_THUMB Issue 031 Stress Identity_TH-1 Issue 030 Identity 029_Scaling_TH-2 Issue 029 Scaling 028_THUMB Issue 028 2050 027_THUMB_F1 Issue 027 Dark Matter 026_CURTAIN_THUMB Issue 026 Color 025-Water_THUMB Issue 025 Water 024_THUMB-F. Issue 024 Error 023-THUMB-1 Issue 023 Dominoes * 022_THUMB-2 Issue 022 Slow Information_THUMB-1 Issue 021 Information 020_Creativity_THUMB-v2 Issue 020 Creativity SP_Nature_THUMB Special Issue In Our Nature 019_THUMB Issue 019 Illusions 018_THUMB_1 Issue 018 Genius Cover_THUMB Issue 017 Big Bangs 16_THUMB. Issue 016 Nothingness 015_THUMB Issue 015 Turbulence 14_THUMB Issue 014 Mutation Issue13_THUMB Issue 013 Symmetry 012_THUMB Issue 012 Feedback * 011_THUMB Issue 011 Light Issue-010_COVER-THUMB Issue 010 Mergers & Acquisitions Time_COVER_THUMB Issue 009 Time SpaceNest_THUMB Issue 008 Home 007_THUMB Issue 007 Waste Issue6_THUMB Issue 006 Secret Codes Fame_THUMB Issue 005 Fame 004_THUMB Issue 004 The Unlikely 003_thumb Issue 003 In Transit Uncertainty_THUMB Issue 002 Uncertainty [87_c7e1249ffc03eb9ded908c236bd1] Issue 001 What Makes You So Special [51_2838023a778dfaecdc212708f721] PREVIEW ISSUE The Story of Nautilus See Issue Library Enter Search Below... [ ] Search TRENDING TOPIC Science Practice [14783_7a60] Does Theranos Mark the Peak of the Silicon Valley Bubble? Aerodynamics Aliens Animals Anthropology Archaeology Architecture Art Artificial Intelligence Astronomy Chemistry Climate Cognitive Science Computer Science Cryptography Earth Science Economics Education Environment Evolution Fiction Fine Art Food Genetics Health History Information Theory Insects Linguistics Literature Math Memoir Microbiology Mortality Music Neuroscience Oceanography Paleontology Philosophy Physics Physiology Psychology Reproduction Science Practice Sociology Technology The Web MOST POPULAR Does Theranos Mark the Peak of the Silicon Valley Bubble? The Smaller the Theater, the Faster the Music What Time Feels Like When You're Improvising A New View of Time She'll Text Me, She'll Text Me Not When Bad Things Happen in Slow Motion How I Taught My Computer to Write Its Own Music Is Artificial Intelligence Permanently Inscrutable? We Need to Save Ignorance From AI The Trouble with Theories of Everything The Strange Brain of the World's Greatest Solo Climber Why You Feel the Urge to Jump Resume Reading -- Five Things We Still Don't Know About Water Close Nautilus Matter Chemistry Five Things We Still Don't Know About Water From steam to ice, water continues to mystify. Richard Saykally By Richard Saykally Illustration by Jackie Ferrentino June 11, 2015 * Add a comment * Facebook * Twitter * Email * Sharing * Reddit * Stumbleupon * Tumblr * Pocket What could we not know about water? It's wet! It's clear. It comes from rain. It boils. It makes snow and it makes ice! Does our...By Richard Saykally What could we not know about water? It's wet! It's clear. It comes from rain. It boils. It makes snow and it makes ice! Does our government actually spend taxpayer money for you to study water?" This excerpt is from one of the last conversations I had with my dear late mother, who passed away some seven years ago, still remarkably frugal at age 99. Her words reflect a view seemingly held by half the world's population: Water is boring. The other half of the world, though, fanned by pseudoscience and new-age gurus, seems to buy into magical properties like homeopathy, structured water, polywater, and water memory. The truth lies somewhere in the middle. Yes, water is common--in fact, it is the third most common molecule in the universe. But, contrary to Mother's views, it is also deceptively complex. Here are just a few of the scientific problems related to water that remain open today: Sapolsky_TH-F1 Also in Chemistry Whiskey Can't Hide Its Age Either By Tasha Eichenseher In case you haven't heard, doomsday is coming--more droughts, floods, famine, class warfare, entitled children, and, brace yourself: a bourbon shortage! Yes, traditional Kentucky distillers didn't predict or prepare for this Mad Men-inspired mixology epoch. And if it continues on...READ MORE 1. How Many Kinds of Ice Are There? At latest count, there are 17 different crystalline forms of solid water. However, only one form--Ice I[h]--exists commonly on Earth outside of the laboratory. A second crystalline form called Ice I[c] is present in very minor amounts in the upper atmosphere, and another 15 forms occur only at very high pressures. (There is also a lot of water in interstellar space, but it is usually an amorphous, non-crystalline, glassy ice frozen onto dust grains.) The remarkable variety of crystalline ice forms results from the tetrahedral network of strong hydrogen bonds formed among neighboring water molecules. In the condensed phases of water, each molecule optimizes its hydrogen bonding capacity by forming four hydrogen bonds at near-tetrahedral angles. The hydrogen bonds inside Ice I[h] form an open, three-dimensional structure with a low density. [6380_2f635a9fe4a4d8d1ec9e3a111cc02f4b]Big Ice: Liquid water (left) is composed of hydrogen (white) and oxygen (red) atoms arranged in a nearly tetrahedral structure. Common ice, or Ice I[h] (right), shows a three-dimensional network that is less dense, explaining why ice floats on water.Wikimedia The application of pressure to tetrahedral substances, including crystalline ice, elemental carbon, silicon, and phosphorus, can collapse low-density solid forms into a variety of structures of sequentially higher density, presumably until the close-packed limit is reached. This produces the 17 forms of crystalline ice we have observed so far. Are there more to discover? 2. Are There Two Kinds of Liquid Water? Several decades ago, Japanese scientists claimed to have observed transitions between two phases of amorphous ice under high pressure. Since we believe that amorphous ice is essentially a frozen snapshot of the corresponding liquid, this observation implied that two types of liquid water must exist: normal, low-density water, and a compact high-density form analogous to high-pressure amorphous ice. Subsequent simulations have supported this claim. They investigated water whose temperature was below freezing, but above its "homogeneous nucleation temperature" (the temperature below which liquid water cannot exist). In this so-called "deeply supercooled" region, scientists saw evidence for a phase transition between two liquid forms of water. However, other scientists argue that these results are artifacts, and that such transitions are unlikely to occur, based on principles of statistical mechanics. The fact that they occur so far away from equilibrium makes them difficult to observe and model--in fact, behavior far away from equilibrium is a current frontier of condensed matter theory. 3. How Does Water Evaporate? The rate of evaporation of liquid water is one of the principal uncertainties in modern climate modeling. It determines the size distribution of water droplets in clouds, which, in turn, determines how clouds reflect, absorb, and scatter light. But the exact mechanism for how water evaporates isn't completely understood. The evaporation rate is traditionally represented in terms of a rate of collision between molecules, multiplied by a fudge factor called the evaporation coefficient, which varies between zero and one. Experimental determination of this coefficient, spanning several decades, has varied over three orders of magnitude. Theoretical calculations have been hampered by the fact that evaporation is an extremely rare event, requiring prohibitively long and large computer simulations. There is something remarkable about the mist surrounding Niagara Falls: The individual droplets move as if they are negatively charged. Together with his colleagues, David Chandler, of the University of California, Berkeley, used a theory capable of describing such rare events, called transition path sampling, to calculate the water evaporation coefficient. They arrived at a value near one. This corresponds fairly well to recent liquid microjet experiments that produce a value of 0.6 for both normal water and heavy water. However, there are a couple of wrinkles. For one thing, it remains unclear why experiments performed under more atmospherically relevant conditions yield much lower values. Also, the transition path sampling simulations suggest that evaporation relies on an anomalously large capillary wave running along the liquid's surface, which strains and weakens the hydrogen bonds holding on to an evaporating water molecule. The addition of salts to water raises the surface tension and suppresses the capillary wave amplitude, and so should reduce the evaporation rate. But experimental studies show little or no effect when salts are added. 4. Is the Surface of Liquid Water Acidic or Basic? [6361_38eb9] There is something remarkable about the mist surrounding Niagara Falls: The individual droplets move as if they are negatively charged. The same is true for most waterfalls. This has long been interpreted as evidence for the accumulation of negative hydroxide (OH-) ions at the droplet surfaces, which would mean that the surfaces are basic--with a pH value greater than the 7 of neutral water. In fact, this thinking has become dogma within the community of colloid scientists. The surface of liquid water contains a larger number of broken hydrogen bonds, which produce a rather different chemical environment than that found in the bulk. But recent experiments and calculations suggest that hydrated protons (H+) actually dominate the liquid water surface, producing an acidic (less than 7) pH and a positively charged surface, rather than a basic, negatively charged surface. Many important processes in chemistry and biology, like atmospheric aerosol-gas exchanges, enzyme catalysis, and transmembrane proton transport, involve proton exchanges at the water surface, and explicitly depend on the pH at the water's surface--a quantity which is currently unknown. 5. Is Nanoconfined Water Different? Water isn't always sloshing around in giant oceans. Both in nature and in man-made devices, water is often confined to unimaginably tiny spaces, like reverse micelles, carbon nanotubes, proton exchange membranes, and xerogels (which are highly porous glassy solids). Both experiment and calculation seem to indicate that water confined by solid walls to tiny regions of space, whose size is comparable to that of a few hundred molecules, begins to exhibit quantum mechanical effects, including delocalization and quantum coherence. These properties are strikingly different from those of bulk water, and could influence everything from biological cells to geological structures. It could be also be of considerable practical significance, for example in designing more efficient desalinization systems. Current results remain somewhat ambiguous, however, and more work in this area remains to be done in order to determine the nature of water under confinement. Richard Saykally is a professor of chemistry at the University of California, Berkeley. He has published over 400 publications that have been cited over 30,000 times. [6346_c16882e007c5c7a773acd7c5e8869ab7] Issue 025 Water Explore This Issue * Chapter two Murky Waters + Saykally_THUMB-1 Chemistry Five Things We Still Don't Know About Water + [6339_9b1c93a6864c39e48417ee] Chemistry Ingenious: Richard Saykally + Mackenzie_THUMB Physics To Predict Turbulence, Just Count the Puffs + Preston_THUMB-3 Environment The Deadly Plant Sneeze Related Article [6339_9b1c93a6864c39e48417ee48] Matter Ingenious: Richard Saykally By Brian Gallagher 2 Comments - Join the Discussion Next Article: [6339_9b1c93a6864c39e48417ee486b] Matter Ingenious: Richard Saykally By Brian Gallagher Related Articles: * Zeldovich_HERO Matter Seven Molecules' Claim to Fame By Patchen Barss * Weintraub_THUMB Matter The Executioner We Can't Live Without By Pamela Weintraub * Francis_THUMB-2 Matter How To Clock a Glacier By Matthew R. Francis [Prime_payw] Nautilus uses cookies to manage your digital subscription and show you your reading progress. It's just not the same without them. Please sign in to Nautilus Prime or turn your cookies on to continue reading. Thank you! * About * Awards and Press * Contact / Work with Us * Donate * FAQ * Media Kit * Prime * Privacy Policy * RSS * Subscribe * Terms of Services NAUTILUS: SCIENCE CONNECTED Nautilus is a different kind of science magazine. We deliver big-picture science by reporting on a single monthly topic from multiple perspectives. Read a new chapter in the story every Thursday. Get Nautilus Editor's Picks and new articles right to your inbox! [ ] [Subscribe] x (c) 2021 NautilusThink Inc, All rights reserved. Matter, Biology, Numbers, Ideas, Culture, Connected Site by Code and Theory * Quantcast