https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-09-23/sheriff-alex-villanueva-secret-police * Business * California * Climate & Environment * Entertainment & Arts * En Espanol * Food * Housing & Homelessness * Image * Lifestyle * Obituaries * Opinion * Politics * Science * Sports * Travel * World & Nation * All Sections * _________________ * Newsletters * Photography * Podcasts * Video * _________________ * About Us + About Us + Archives + Company News + eNewspaper + For the Record + Got a Tip? + L.A. Times Careers + L.A. Times Store + L.A. Times Studios + News App: Apple IOS + News App: Google Play + Newsroom Directory + Public Affairs + Reprints, Rights & Permissions + About Us + Archives + Company News + eNewspaper + For the Record + Got a Tip? + L.A. Times Careers + L.A. Times Store + L.A. Times Studios + News App: Apple IOS + News App: Google Play + Newsroom Directory + Public Affairs + Reprints, Rights & Permissions * Advertising + Place an Ad + Classifieds + Coupons + People on the Move + Find/Post Jobs + Local Ads Marketplace + Media Kit: Why the L.A. Times? + Hot Property Sections + Place an Open House + Sotheby's International Realty + Place an Ad + Classifieds + Coupons + People on the Move + Find/Post Jobs + Local Ads Marketplace + Media Kit: Why the L.A. Times? + Hot Property Sections + Place an Open House + Sotheby's International Realty * Bestcovery * B2B Publishing * Business Visionaries * Hot Property * Crossword & Games * L.A. Times Events * L.A. Times Store * Subscriptions + Manage Subscription + EZPAY + Delivery Issue + eNewspaper + Students & Educators + Subscribe + Subscriber Terms + Manage Subscription + EZPAY + Delivery Issue + eNewspaper + Students & Educators + Subscribe + Subscriber Terms Copyright (c) 2021, Los Angeles Times | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | CA Notice of Collection | Do Not Sell My Personal Information Sections * California * Entertainment * Sports * Food * Climate * Opinion * | * Place an Ad * Coupons * Crossword * eNewspaper Show Search [ ]Search Query Submit Search Advertisement * Facebook * Twitter * Show more sharing options Share Close extra sharing options * Facebook * Twitter * LinkedIn * Email * Copy Link URLCopied! * Print California L.A. County sheriff's unit accused of targeting political enemies, vocal critics Sheriff Alex Villanueva responds to a recent RAND report saying gang-like cliques still exist within the sheriff's dept. Sheriff Alex Villanueva at a news conference. (Al Seib/Los Angeles Times) By Alene TchekmedyianStaff Writer Sept. 23, 2021 Updated 6:20 AM PT * Facebook * Twitter * Show more sharing options Share Close extra sharing options * Facebook * Twitter * LinkedIn * Email * Copy Link URLCopied! * Print On paper, the deputies are scattered around the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department in various assignments. One is supposed to be working patrol in Lancaster, another in West Hollywood. A third is assigned to a gang crime unit. In reality, though, the group of nine men and women make up a little-known team of investigators formed by Sheriff Alex Villanueva and other top sheriff's officials. Much of what they do, by design, is a mystery to the public and even to most within the department. But as some of the investigations handled by the team have come to light, a common thread has emerged: Their targets are outspoken critics of Villanueva or the department. The unit, named the Civil Rights and Public Integrity Detail, has pursued a long-running investigation into one of Villanueva's most vocal critics, L.A. County Inspector General Max Huntsman, and others despite sheriff's officials being told by the FBI and state law enforcement officials that it appeared no crimes had been committed, a senior sheriff's official said. Advertisement The team also has an open criminal inquiry into a nonprofit that is run by a member of a county board that oversees the sheriff and is associated with county Supervisor Sheila Kuehl, both of whom have clashed fiercely with Villanueva and called for his resignation. Concern over the team has caused consternation both inside and outside the department. Even the union representing rank-and-file deputies put out a warning that a member of the detail was using "unconventional tactics" to question deputies. Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva briefs the media about the latest safety precautions the department is taking regarding COVID-19 at the Hall of Justice in Los Angeles on Monday, March 16, 2020. ( Photo by Nick Agro / For The Times) California Watchdog panel wants review of L.A. Sheriff's unit for possible crimes, intimidation A watchdog panel that oversees the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department voted Thursday to ask county attorneys to determine whether Sheriff Alex Villanueva or his agency broke the law in their handling of a special unit that has been accused of targeting some of his most outspoken critics. George Gascon, the county's district attorney, decided he wanted nothing to do with the unit after sheriff's officials proposed the two agencies create a task force to collaborate on public corruption investigations. "He's only targeting political enemies," Gascon told The Times about Villanueva. "It was obvious that was not the kind of work I wanted to engage in, so we declined." Shortly after Gascon refused to partner with the Sheriff's Department, Villanueva came out as a strong supporter of a recall campaign to kick the district attorney out of office. The unit has spurred a bitter confrontation between Villanueva and the Civilian Oversight Commission, which oversees the sheriff and his agency. Commission members say they fear the sheriff is using it to intimidate people who challenge him and to score points in personal vendettas, not conduct legitimate inquiries into possible crimes. LOS ANGELES, CA NOVEMBER 15, 2018 --- Inspector General County of Los Angeles Max Huntsman speaks at the Los Angeles County Sheriff Civilian Oversight Commission. Oversight committee met Thursday morning November 15, 2018 to discuss investigation into tattooed deputy cliques and allegations of racial profiling by deputies during enforcement activities along the Interstate 5 freeway. (Irfan Khan / Los Angeles Times) California L.A. County sheriff's top watchdog is under investigation -- by the L.A. County sheriff The Sheriff's Department says allegations against the watchdog include conspiracy and theft. "Smells a little bogus," says Supervisor Sheila Kuehl. Advertisement The slow pace of the unit's investigations and its apparent lack of results have only deepened suspicions. "These highly publicized criminal investigations have never resulted in charges being filed, suggesting an ulterior motive," Sean Kennedy, a Loyola Law School professor who sits on the commission, said in a 10-page memo calling for an investigation into whether Villanueva is abusing his power. The commission subpoenaed Villanueva to appear before them Thursday to answer questions about the team. The sheriff has indicated that he will not show up, saying he is too busy. In a July letter to the commission's executive director, Undersheriff Tim Murakami said Kennedy's memo was filled with "wild accusations" and accused the commission of collaborating with the inspector general's office and media organizations, including The Times, to spread false information about Villanueva and the Sheriff's Department. Advertisement Murakami answered initial questions about the unit during a brief interview with The Times in April, but has not responded to repeated follow up questions. A spokesman for the department told The Times earlier this month that Murakami and other sheriff's officials would not discuss the detail with the Times reporter who was investigating it because the spokesman claimed the reporter had a conflict of interest. The spokesman repeatedly refused to provide any details of the alleged conflict to a Times editor. The department suggested it would answer questions from "any other" Times reporter. The Times declined to assign a new reporter to the story. On Wednesday evening, the sheriff released a public statement defending the unit as a tool for fighting corruption and denying it was being used to go after his political opponents. "The sole responsibility of the Sheriff's Department is to investigate allegations of criminal conduct as they are discovered, regardless of how inconvenient it may be to the subject of the investigation," the statement said. "The unit is supervised by the Undersheriff, and I have recused myself from all decision making to avoid any potential conflict of interest." Advertisement Within the department, however, multiple sources said they have heard the team referred to as the sheriff's "secret police." The idea for the team was rooted in Villanueva's upstart campaign for sheriff in 2018. While trying to persuade liberal voters he would be a progressive reformer, he also vowed to address what he said was widespread corruption among the department's senior ranks that led to deputies being unfairly disciplined. LOS ANGELES, CA - JUNE 07: Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva talks with media, homeless advocates and local residents as he walked the Venice Boardwalk. He railed about the failures of local elected officials "to properly regulate public spaces" and said he'd like to see the boardwalk cleared of tents by the Fourth of July. Venice Boardwalk on Monday, June 7, 2021 in Los Angeles, CA. (Al Seib / Los Angeles Times). California 'Running against the woke left': Can Sheriff Villanueva's shift to the right work in L.A.? After convincing liberal voters he would represent their interests, Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva has shifted decisively to the right as a reelection bid looms. After taking office, Villanueva took steps to make good on his campaign promise, including hiring back deputies who he said had been wrongly fired. He also formed a team to investigate current and former high-ranking Sheriff's officials over allegations of criminal wrongdoing in cases against deputies, said multiple law enforcement sources who requested their names not be used. There is no indication any of those cases resulted in charges. Advertisement A central member of the team, several law enforcement sources said, was Mark Lillienfeld, a longtime homicide investigator who had retired in 2016. Aides had cautioned Villanueva during his first week in office against bringing Lillienfeld onboard, said Joseph Dempsey, a now-retired sheriff's chief who attended a meeting with other aides to brief Villanueva about Lillienfeld. The aides told Villanueva that a few months earlier Lillienfeld, who at the time was investigating a murder for the district attorney's office, had dressed in a sheriff's uniform to pose as a deputy to sneak a McDonald's Egg McMuffin and a cup of coffee in to an inmate at Men's Central Jail -- a violation of jail rules. x Retired L.A. County sheriff's homicide Det. Mark Lillienfeld enters Men's Central Jail in a deputy's uniform and leaves a plastic bag and cup in the inmate chapel. Advertisement Sheriff's officials banned him from county jails and posted notices with Lillienfeld's photo at jail entrances, directing employees to alert a supervisor if he showed up. [gif] California Sheriff rehires corruption investigator accused of posing as deputy in bizarre jail incident After he allegedly brought contraband into the Men's Central Jail, officials posted Mark Lillienfeld's photograph and directed employees to alert a supervisor if he showed up. Dempsey said Villanueva shrugged off the warnings and downplayed the jail incident, telling the group that Lillienfeld was "way too important" to his future plans. Villanueva, he said, didn't elaborate. Bob Olmsted, an assistant sheriff at the time who was also in the meeting, corroborated Dempsey's account. Dempsey's account contradicts what Murakami, Villanueva's undersheriff, said in an interview two years ago, which was that Villanueva was not aware of the Egg McMuffin incident until The Times began asking questions about it a year after it occurred. Advertisement In a brief interview after he was rehired in 2019, Lillienfeld said he was reporting to Murakami and assigned to investigate public corruption. Murakami identified Lillienfeld as a member of the unit to The Times. In August 2019, Murakami made the unusual move of announcing that the department was investigating Huntsman, its top watchdog. In a letter to the Board of Supervisors and a statement at the time, he said Huntsman, members of his staff and sheriff's officials were under investigation for allegedly stealing confidential files the department keeps on high-ranking officials. He urged the board to sideline Huntsman until the investigation was complete. The announcement came after Villanueva told Huntsman that if the inspector general went ahead with plans to release a report about the sheriff's rehiring of a deputy who had been fired over domestic violence and stalking allegations, "there would be consequences," Huntsman has said. [gif] California L.A. County sheriff reinstates deputy fired over domestic abuse and stalking allegations Caren Carl Mandoyan played a special role last month at the swearing-in of Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva, standing on stage and holding the box of gold pins that would adorn the collars of the top cop and his senior executives. Advertisement Cmdr. Eli Vera, who is running against Villanueva for sheriff in next year's election, said he and others advised the sheriff at the time against pursuing the investigation. "The investigation will be discredited when it's perceived that you have a personal interest," Vera said. "It casts a shadow on the legitimacy of the investigation." Villanueva agreed to bring the case to the FBI and the state attorney general's office, said Vera, who was present in April 2019 when the two agencies were briefed. But when the federal and state officials concluded no crimes had been committed and told sheriff's officials they wouldn't take the case, Villanueva decided to press ahead with an investigation, Vera said. Villanueva, Vera said, "hand selected" the team that would investigate the allegedly stolen files and conduct other probes. He added that while the sheriff recused himself from that investigation and others, he often "let it be known what outcome he was looking for." Advertisement LOS ANGELES, CA - MAY 26: Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva discusses organizational change, transparency, accountability and how they relate to the issue of deputy cliques during a press conference at the Hall of Justice Wednesday May 26, 2021. The Sheriff also addressed a damages claim filed by the city of Compton against Los Angeles County today, alleging the sheriff's department has bilked the city out of millions of dollars by falsely reporting the amount of time deputies spend patrolling the city. Sheriff Alex Villanueva dismissed the allegations. "We have about 45 contracts and we measure the minutes, and there's a rate -- we have to get close to 100%, either slightly above or slightly below,'' Villanueva said. "If we're missing that target, I don't think it's going to be the grand conspiracy that the outgoing mayor of Compton wants it to be. "But we'll definitely take the allegation seriously, and we are already doing a thorough audit on it, and we'll take action based on the results of that. Nothing unusual there. But to call it a fraud, that might be a little bit of a stretch.'' Hall of Justice on Wednesday, May 26, 2021 in Los Angeles, CA. (Al Seib / Los Angeles Times). California L.A. County sheriff has legal power to ban gang-like groups of deputies, county lawyers say L.A. County Sheriff Alex Villanueva has broad legal authority to crack down on entrenched, gang-like groups of deputies, according to attorneys for the county. More than two years into the investigation, no charges have been filed. In April, Murakami said the case remained open. "There's been progress on it," Murakami said. "Just gathering more information. ... When they move forward with anything, we want to make sure our facts are right." When asked in April for an account of the team's work, Murakami said his investigators were taking cases brought by outside municipalities and the district attorney's office, and also made reference to the unit having cleared one sheriff's official of wrongdoing, but declined to provide specifics. Advertisement The unit's investigation into Peace Over Violence, a nonprofit that offers crisis intervention and other services to victims of domestic violence, has also unfolded in a controversial fashion. LOS ANGELES CA SEPTEMBER 7, 2021 - Los Angeles County Sheriff's commander Eli Vera held a press conference in front of the Hall of Justice in downtown Los Angeles Tuesday morning, Sept. 7, 2021. Vera, who is running against L.A. County Sheriff Alex Villanueva, was recently demoted from a chief to a commander. California Sheriff Villanueva demotes high-ranking official who is trying to unseat him Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva has demoted a top advisor who is challenging him in next year's election. Early this year, Sgt. Max Fernandez, a member of the unit, showed up to the organization's offices and introduced himself as a sex crimes investigator, said the group's executive director Patti Giggans, who is also a member of the oversight commission and has been critical of Villanueva's leadership, including his resistance to complying with information requests and his handling of the Kobe Bryant helicopter photo sharing scandal. Fernandez did not respond to a request for comment. Fernandez was given a tour of the office and left his business card, Giggans said. Advertisement A week or so later, Fernandez showed up again, Giggans said. This time, he had a warrant. Fernandez was looking for records about contracts the group has with public agencies, including one with the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority to operate a hotline for reporting sexual harassment on public transit, Giggans said. The warrant also demanded records on communications the organization's staff had with various county officials, including Supervisor Kuehl, a close friend of Giggans who also has been sharply critical of what she's described as Villanueva's resistance to accountability and failure to crack down on gang-like groups of deputies with matching tattoos. Giggans and Kuehl have each called on the sheriff to resign. The Sheriff's Department served similar warrants on Metro officials and on Metro's inspector general. At the time, a Metro spokesman told The Times that "given the limited information contained in the warrant, we cannot determine the nature of LASD's investigation." A Compton deputy's tattoo photographed as part of an excessive force lawsuit. California Rep. Waters seeks federal probe of L.A. County deputies' alleged Executioners gang Rep. Maxine Waters asks U.S. Justice Department to investigate allegations a violent gang of deputies runs the L.A. County sheriff's Compton station. Advertisement What evidence Fernandez and the team used to convince a judge to grant the warrants has not been made public. Peace Over Violence turned over the records, while attorneys for Metro and Metro's inspector general objected and asked a judge to block the effort. In motions to quash the warrants and other court documents, lawyers for Metro's inspector general and the judge who issued the warrants raised questions about the sheriff's probe. After Harvinder Anand, a lawyer for Metro's inspector general, reported that Fernandez had claimed Judge Ronald S. Coen gave the Sheriff's Department the green light to "forcibly take computers if the search warrant is not complied with," Coen responded in a sworn statement that he never told Fernandez that. Advertisement Anand said in a sworn declaration that Fernandez told him he "does not think Peace Over Violence did anything" illegal and that he "personally does not see it," referring to allegations of misconduct by the nonprofit. Anand also said in the declaration that Fernandez had admitted the investigation into Peace Over Violence stemmed largely from information provided by Jennifer Loew, a Metro employee who is embroiled in a retaliation lawsuit against her employer. Loew has alleged the nonprofit was improperly awarded a series of contracts pushed by Kuehl's office to run the hotline. Kuehl's office said they were not involved in awarding the contracts. LOS ANGELES, CA - MAY 26: Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva discusses organizational change, transparency, accountability and how they relate to the issue of deputy cliques during a press conference at the Hall of Justice Wednesday May 26, 2021. The Sheriff also addressed a damages claim filed by the city of Compton against Los Angeles County today, alleging the sheriff's department has bilked the city out of millions of dollars by falsely reporting the amount of time deputies spend patrolling the city. Sheriff Alex Villanueva dismissed the allegations. "We have about 45 contracts and we measure the minutes, and there's a rate -- we have to get close to 100%, either slightly above or slightly below,'' Villanueva said. "If we're missing that target, I don't think it's going to be the grand conspiracy that the outgoing mayor of Compton wants it to be. "But we'll definitely take the allegation seriously, and we are already doing a thorough audit on it, and we'll take action based on the results of that. Nothing unusual there. But to call it a fraud, that might be a little bit of a stretch.'' Hall of Justice on Wednesday, May 26, 2021 in Los Angeles, CA. (Al Seib / Los Angeles Times). California Sheriff's Department ordered to release misconduct, use-of-force records in response to Times lawsuit The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department must turn over thousands of pages of records related to deputy misconduct and instances in which deadly force was used, a judge ruled Friday. Jennifer Loew's husband, Adam, told The Times that he's an acquaintance of Villanueva. Villanueva has posted photos on social media with Loew's daughter. Advertisement Adam Loew told The Times he has never discussed the Metro investigation with the sheriff. He said, however, that he did email Murakami to complain about what he saw as the slow pace of the investigation into the hotline. He said Lillienfeld showed up to his home days later. Loew made a recording of the more than hourlong conversation, which The Times listened to. Lillienfeld told Loew he was "poking the wrong f--ing bear." "That's what I'm telling you, dumb f--, is that clear?" Lillienfeld said. "I can't make it any clearer than that." Lillienfeld did not respond to a request for comment. Advertisement During the recorded conversation, Lillienfeld also said that he does not talk with Villanueva about the investigation, even though the sheriff asks for updates. And he suggested to Loew that he believes it would be inappropriate for a sheriff to use a criminal inquiry for political benefit. Giggans defended her organization's work and told The Times she believes the sheriff seized the opportunity to harass her and Kuehl by latching onto a campaign against Peace Over Violence that was instigated by a disgruntled Metro employee. "It couldn't be more obvious, the retaliatory behavior," Giggans said. Murakami told The Times in April that the claims of retaliation are untrue. Advertisement One Sheriff's Department source said: "If they didn't investigate it, we would be accused of a cover up." The unit has also caused tensions within the department. In February last year, Lillienfeld and another member of the unit, Steve Nemeth, showed up to the sheriff's station in Compton to interview Deputy Austreberto Gonzalez, according to the deputy's attorney. Gonzalez had anonymously reported to the department's Internal Affairs Bureau that a deputy had been assaulted by an alleged member of the Compton Executioners, a gang-like group of deputies who have been accused of violent behavior and running roughshod over the station. Advertisement Word of Gonzalez's call to Internal Affairs had somehow leaked, and deputies at the station suspected he was ratting out a fellow deputy, his attorney Alan Romero said. Typically, detectives from one of the department's internal affairs units would have discreetly contacted Gonzalez to gather more information. Instead, Lillienfeld and his partner announced to the employee working at the station's front desk that they were on a special assignment and asked to speak with Gonzalez, Romero said. When Gonzalez told the investigators he was worried about them questioning him so publicly, Lillienfeld was dismissive, Romero said. "It's OK, buddy," Lillienfeld said, according to Romero. "They're not going to know." Romero said the investigators acted "to retaliate against the whistleblower, to put the whistleblower in danger." Lillienfeld and Nemeth did not respond to a request for comment. Advertisement Gonzalez is suing the department for retaliation and has testified about the Executioners in an unrelated excessive force lawsuit. Since then, Villanueva has repeatedly called into question Gonzalez's credibility, saying the deputy has no evidence to back up his claims. Romero said another one of his clients was followed by Lillienfeld after suing the county. The allegation echoed one made by Huntsman, who said Lillienfeld intimidated members of his staff. On at least two occasions, Huntsman said, Lillienfeld showed up at commission meetings and appeared to follow around members of Huntsman's team, including one staffer who Lillienfeld trailed into a parking lot. Around the time Lillienfeld and Nemeth showed up at the Compton station, the Assn. of Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs sent an email warning its membership about Lillienfeld. "The department is using some unconventional tactics to conduct internal investigations," the union said, referring to the agency's use of retirees hired back on a part time basis. "One such person is retired Deputy Mark Lillienfeld." Advertisement Ron Hernandez, the union's president at the time who has since retired, said he wanted to remind deputies they could insist on having a union representative with them during an interview. "The fact that he was out there talking to people was concerning to me," Hernandez said. "I had no idea what he was doing or how he was doing it other than the fact that it might be a little confusing to the deputies because they don't know his role either." --------------------------------------------------------------------- California Newsletter The view from Sacramento For reporting and exclusive analysis from bureau chief John Myers, get our California Politics newsletter. Enter email address [ ] Sign Me Up You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times. [gif] Alene Tchekmedyian Follow Us * twitter * instagram * email * facebook Alene Tchekmedyian covers the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department. She previously wrote about the county's criminal courts and breaking news throughout California. Before joining The Times in 2016, she reported on crime and policing for the Glendale News-Press and Burbank Leader. She grew up in Huntington Beach and graduated from UCLA. Show Comments Subscribers Are Reading * The Fall California List lettering illustration with animation of fall leaves Travel For Subscribers The 40 best California experiences: Fall edition * [gif] Business For Subscribers How the pandemic helped scatter $1-million homes across L.A. * Trona, CA - July 29: Community activist Regina Troglin stands between two rust spotted water pipes, owned by Searles Valley Minerals, traveling through Poison Canyon that supplies water to Trona. Photographed on Thursday, July 29, 2021 in Trona, CA. (Irfan Khan / Los Angeles Times) California For Subscribers A 7.1 earthquake couldn't kill this Mojave Desert town. But a water war just might * A fisherman casts his line near the idle paddleboats of Echo Park Lake. Business For Subscribers These are L.A.'s new million-dollar neighborhoods Subscribers Are Reading * Travel For Subscribers The 40 best California experiences: Fall edition * Business For Subscribers How the pandemic helped scatter $1-million homes across L.A. * California For Subscribers A 7.1 earthquake couldn't kill this Mojave Desert town. But a water war just might * Business For Subscribers These are L.A.'s new million-dollar neighborhoods * Housing & Homelessness Appeals court strikes down sweeping order to house L.A.'s skid row homeless population Advertisement Latest California * California Palo Alto woman charged with arson in Fawn fire in Shasta County * California A champion of COVID-19 vaccines, Newsom fights plan to mandate them for prison guards * California California to offer COVID booster shots for teachers, healthcare workers, seniors * California L.A. County escapes post-Labor Day COVID surge, but more vaccinations are needed * California PG&E charged with manslaughter in Shasta County fire that killed 4 Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Los Angeles Times A California Times publication Subscribe for unlimited access Follow Us * twitter * instagram * youtube * facebook * + eNewspaper + Coupons + Find/Post Jobs + Place an Ad + Media Kit: Why the L. A. Times? + Bestcovery * + Crossword + Sudoku + Obituaries + Recipes + L.A. Times Store + Wine Club * + About/Contact + For the Record + L.A. Times Careers + Manage Subscription + Reprints and Permissions + Site Map Copyright (c) 2021, Los Angeles Times | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | CA Notice of Collection | Do Not Sell My Personal Information