https://astronomy.com/news/2019/03/its-even-harder-to-destroy-asteroids-than-we-thought * Astronomy Magazine 00012 * SUBSCRIBE * RENEW * DIGITAL EDITIONS * GIVE A GIFT Login or Register | Customer Service Tonight's Sky -- Search By Name Enter coordinates Use current location [SUBMIT] [-- ] [SUBMIT] SUN & MOON MERCURY & VENUS MARS, JUPITER & SATURN Sun RISE-- SET-- Sun Moon -- -- Moon PHASE-- DISK-- Mercury RISE-- SET-- Mercury -- Venus -- -- Venus -- Mars RISE-- SET-- Mars -- Jupiter -- -- Jupiter -- Saturn -- -- Saturn -- Tonight's Sky -- Change location City/place name [ ] US state, Canadian province, or country [] OR US ZIP code [ ] [Search] [Cancel] Searching... Tonight's Sky -- Select location [] [Search Again] [Select] [Cancel] Tonight's Sky -- Enter coordinates Latitude: [ ]deg [ ]' [N] Longitude: [ ]deg [ ]' [W] UTC Offset: [ ] [OK] [Cancel] * Home * The Magazine * News * Observing * Photos * Videos * Blogs * Community * Shop * Magazine * News * Observing * Photos * Videos * Blogs * Community * Shop [menu_icon]MENU [Search Astronomy.com] Search Astronomy.com 00012 ABOUT THE MAGAZINE About Us Back Issues Email Newsletter Renew Digital Editions Advertiser Links Trips & Tours Contact Us Current Issue Special Issues Subscribe Give a Gift Advertise with Us Contests Press Room Subscriber Extras SUBSCRIBER EXTRAS IN EVERY ISSUE Sky this Month Ask Astro Web Extras COLUMNISTS Bob Berman Glenn Chaple Stephen James O'Meara Erika Rix Tony Hallas Adam Block Jeff Hester Phil Harrington FEATURES 50 Greatest Mysteries 50 Weirdest Objects Superstars Podcast StarDome Star Atlas Product Reviews 5 Questions with David Eicher ASYAR0821_07 The rise and fall of Arecibo Observatory - an oral history RECENT HEADLINES * Why haven't humans reached Mars? * Video: How much does Earth weigh? * Snapshot: Centaurus A shows off its dusty tendrils * The Sky This Week: Early risers enjoy the Orion Nebula * How astronauts go to the bathroom in outer space * Ask Astro: Why are so many stars named Gliese? * Sky This Month: September 2021 TOPICS * solar system * galaxies * stars * cosmology * black holes * space flight * exoplanets * space physics * milky way The Orion Nebula and Running Man The Sky This Week: Early risers enjoy the Orion Nebula RECENT HEADLINES * The Sky This Week: The Moon meets Uranus * The Sky This Week: View the Blue Sturgeon Moon * The Sky This Week: Jupiter reaches opposition * The Sky This Week: The Perseids peak * The Sky This Week: Saturn reaches opposition * The Sky This Week: Enjoy July's Buck Moon * The Sky This Week: Pluto reaches opposition TOPICS * Sky this Week * Observing Podcasts * Observe the Solar System * Astronomy for Kids * Product Reviews * Star Atlas * Tonight's Sky * Sky Events * Get to Know the Night Sky * Tour the Deep Sky * Sky Guide * Observing Tools * StarDome PICTURE OF THE DAY The first one The first one RECENT GALLERIES TOPICS * Imaging Basics * Reader Photo Gallery * Calendar * Picture of the Day * Image Galleries IBE21thumbweb Infinity & Beyond -- Episode 21: The Voyager Missions RECENT HEADLINES * Infinity & Beyond -- Episode 20: What are quasars? * Infinity & Beyond -- Episode 19: The Science of Star Wars * Infinity & Beyond -- Episode 18: The Cosmic Microwave Background * Infinity & Beyond -- Episode 17: What are Pulsars? * Infinity & Beyond -- Episode 16: Pluto's icy heart * Infinity & Beyond -- Episode 15: What is Dark Matter? * Watch: Mining the Moon for rocket fuel TOPICS * Cosmic Adventures * Astronomy 101 * Dave's Universe * Seasonal Observing * Tour the Solar System * Observing Basics * The Real Reality Show * Issue Previews [3833] Queen guitarist Brian May and David Eicher launch new astronomy book RECENT POSTS * Astronomy welcomes Caitlyn Buongiorno * Enter the Space & Beyond Box Photo Contest! * Last chance to join our 2020 Costa Rica Star Party! * Join Us in Tucson for Our Annual Public Star Party! * Learn about the Moon in a great new book * New book chronicles the space program TOPICS * Local Group * From the Industry * Dave's Universe * Year of Pluto READER GALLERIES TOPICS * Events * Astronomy Foundation * Reader Galleries * Groups * Why Join? * Astronomy Day NEW PRODUCTS 15374 Astronomy Magazine Collection 2016-2020 DVD-ROM 81372W800 The Complete Star Atlas AS052007W800 Cosmos: Origin and Fate of the Universe IN OUR STORE * Subscribe * Back Issues * Special Issues * Books & DVDS * Digital Downloads * Space & Beyond Box * Globes & Maps * Posters * Calendar * STEM Toys * Gifts & Toys CURRENT ISSUE 00012 * The Magazine * Tonight's Sky * News * Observing * Photos * Videos * Blogs * Community * Shop * * Home * / * News * / * It's even harder to destroy asteroids than we thought It's even harder to destroy asteroids than we thought New research shows smacking an asteroid may fracture but not shatter it. By Alison Klesman | Published: Thursday, March 7, 2019 AsteroidBreakup Smacking an asteroid with a bomb or a smaller asteroid should shatter it into manageable pieces, right? Wrong, a new study shows - this picture isn't likely after a minor collision. NASA/JPL-Caltech You've likely heard by now that the movie Armageddon got it all wrong -- it's just not feasible to blow up an asteroid heading toward Earth with a bomb or few. But how unfeasible is it, really? New research set for publication March 15 in the planetary science journal Icarus is sending any hope humanity might have had to nuke an incoming asteroid threat even further into the realm of impossibility. Breaking up asteroids, it turns out, is really, really hard to do. The new study, led by recent Ph.D. graduate Charles El Mir from the Johns Hopkins University's Department of Mechanical Engineering, makes use of both recent advancements in understanding about the way rock fractures, as well as improved computer code to model what happens when you smack an asteroid with something big. "Our question was, how much energy does it take to actually destroy an asteroid and break it into pieces?" El Mir said in a press release. The answer to that question, it turns out, is "that asteroids are stronger than we used to think and require more energy to be completely shattered," he said. A two-step process The simulations run by El Mir and his colleagues allowed them to study the aftermath of an asteroid collision via a "hybrid" approach that focuses on two different stages of a hit using two different types of computer code. They modeled an asteroid 15 miles (25 kilometers) across undergoing a head-on impact from a 0.75-mile-diameter (1.21 km) impactor made of basalt and traveling at 3 miles (5 km) per second. During the fictitious collision, a material model first showed the short-term fragmentation that took place within the asteroid just after it is struck, a process that occurs within just a fraction of a second. Then, their code handed the calculations over to a different type of model called an N-body model, which showed what happened over the longer term -- hours after impact -- as the asteroid's gravity influenced any small pieces that might have flown off during the collision. Would an asteroid shatter on impact? And what would happen to those pieces over time? Would they fly apart, or would they come back together to re-form the asteroid, nullifying the effects of the impact? In answer, the team found that no -- the asteroid didn't shatter on impact. Instead, the initial impact causes millions of internal cracks to develop, and the areas nearest the hit actually flowed like sand, allowing a crater to form. But those cracks didn't destroy the asteroid; instead, they left behind a damaged but intact body that was large enough to pull any smaller pieces that may have flown off back onto itself, essentially completely reassembling the parent body. This video shows the first phase of the simulated asteroid collision, during which a crater forms and cracks move through the interior of the target. Johns Hopkins University During the second phase of the collision, all the fragments that flew off are brought back down to the parent body via gravity, essentially reassembling it, albeit into a different shape and surface composition. Johns Hopkins University The results differ significantly from previous studies in the early 2000s, whose code simulated a collision between an identical pair. In that study, the larger body was completely destroyed. But the older code, the researchers say, was not able to take into account the smaller-scale processes occurring on the asteroid during the initial collision. Because cracks propagate through an asteroid with limited speed, the authors say, they aren't able to shatter an asteroid as easily as previously thought. More than just movie magic That's not the large-scale destruction moviegoers are going for, but it does tell researchers a lot about how collisions between asteroids might have shaped their evolution into the objects they are today. The work also has applications, the researchers say, for future missions to mine material from asteroids. That's because material thrown off during the collision ended up scattered back over the asteroid's surface -- potentially exposing internal riches for easier access. But it's still hard to forget the picture of an asteroid hurtling toward our planet. While this new study indicates a Hollywood-style explosion wouldn't save Earth from an incoming impactor, it still holds keys to answering the question of what we would do if Armageddon's storyline became a reality. (And just in case you're starting to feel nervous, NASA's already on this -- the Planetary Defense Coordination Office is tasked with monitoring and learning more about any large objects with orbits that bring them within 0.05 AU [about 4.6 million miles, or 7 million km].) "If there's an asteroid coming at Earth, are we better off breaking it into small pieces, or nudging it to go a different direction? And if the latter, how much force should we hit it with to move it away without causing it to break? These are actual questions under consideration," said El Mir. "It is only a matter of time before these questions go from being academic to defining our response to a major threat," added study co-author K.T. Ramesh of the Hopkins Extreme Materials Institute. "We need to have a good idea of what we should do when that time comes - and scientific efforts like this one are critical to help us make those decisions." 0 JOIN THE DISCUSSION Read and share your comments on this article RELATED ARTICLES [2DA388362E] The rise and fall of Arecibo Observatory - an oral history [DD1C94CBE2] Why haven't humans reached Mars? [53C3D5C095] Video: How much does Earth weigh? [548EE0F0FA] Snapshot: Centaurus A shows off its dusty tendrils [0EBA7752FB] The Sky This Week: Early risers enjoy the Orion Nebula [6D4E162CF4] How astronauts go to the bathroom in outer space [F10CC95920] Ask Astro: Why are so many stars named Gliese? [8E317AFC3C] Sky This Month: September 2021 [55EB3994F3] Astronomers identify a new class of habitable planet [arrow-left] [arrow-righ] YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE 15374 Astronomy Magazine Collection 2016-2020 DVD-ROM 81372W800 The Complete Star Atlas AS052007W800 Cosmos: Origin and Fate of the Universe 81457_Moon_Globesmall Astronomy's Moon Globe 814043dsmall Galaxies by David Eicher 81297temporary Astronomy Puzzles 81276 Jon Lomberg Milky Way Posters 81403small Cosmic Clouds 3-D AS04CV0319_HIRES Astronomy for Kids [arrow-left] [arrow-righ] Comment on this article Want to leave a comment? Only registered members of Astronomy.com are allowed to comment on this article. Registration is FREE and only takes a couple minutes. Login or Register now. 0 comments Most recent | Oldest to newest [spinner_la] No one has commented yet. LATEST NEWS ASYAR0821_07 The rise and fall of Arecibo Observatory - an oral history shutterstock_1049625074 Why haven't humans reached Mars? pexelspixabay87651 Video: How much does Earth weigh? POPULAR 48534978061_8f7012faaa_c Did solar eclipses help kick-start human curiosity? ASYBS0521_02 Breakthrough Starshot: Voyage to the stars solareclipsecowboy First look at the 2024 total solar eclipse TRIPS & TOURS startrails2234343_1280 Coming Soon: More travel opportunities with Astronomy ADVERTISEMENT FREE EMAIL NEWSLETTER Receive news, sky-event information, observing tips, and more from Astronomy's weekly email newsletter. View our Privacy Policy. Email Address: [Email address ] Sign up * Follow us: * Find us on Facebook Facebook * Follow us on Twitter Twitter * Google+ Google+ THE MAGAZINE 00012 Table of Contents Subscribe Digital Editons ADVERTISEMENT ADVERTISEMENT Apollo_RightRail A chronicle of the first steps on the Moon, and what it took to get there. Find us on Facebook Astronomy Magazine Astronomy Magazine * The Magazine * News * Observing * Photos * Videos * Blogs * Community * Shop * About Us * Advertising * Contact Us * Terms of Use * Privacy Policy * Copyright Policy * Website Accessibility FREE EMAIL NEWSLETTER [Email address ] Sign up! By signing up you may also receive reader surveys and occasional special offers. We do not sell, rent or trade our email lists. View our Privacy Policy. * Follow us: * Find us on Facebook Facebook * Follow us on Twitter Twitter 00012 SUBSCRIBE RENEW DIGITAL EDITIONS GIVE A GIFT CUSTOMER SERVICE Kalmbach Media More great sites from Kalmbach Media: Astronomy | Bead&Button | Bead&Button Show | Classic Toy Trains | Classic Trains | Discover | Facet | Finescale Modeler | Garden Railways | Jewelry and Beading Store | Kalmbach Hobby Store | Model Railroader | Model Railroader Video Plus | My Science Shop | Scale Auto | Trains | Trains.com Quantcast