https://news.uchicago.edu/story/why-cant-we-identify-music-notes-well-colors-perfect-pitch-study-offers-clues [ ] * Home * Latest stories * Find faculty experts * Confronting COVID-19 website * Podcasts * Virtual events Media Resources Covering a story? Visit our page for journalists or call (773) 702-8360. * * * * Odyssey students at Rockefeller Odyssey Scholarship Program UChicago Board of Trustees' gift launches new $200 million commitment to undergraduate financial aid and educational access Top Stories 1. Collaborating with Kenyan government on development innovations is key to fighting poverty, says Nobel laureate 2. Aloof neutrons may actually 'talk' to one another briefly in new kind of symmetry 3. Do 911 calls ensure public safety? Experts reimagine crisis responses in UChicago event Newsletter Get more with UChicago News delivered to your inbox. Why can't we identify music notes as well as colors? A perfect pitch study offers clues By Max Witynski Aug 30, 2021 Neuroscientists explore how people with absolute pitch process sounds Both light and sound travel as waves, with characteristics that allow people with typical vision and hearing to perceive and categorize them when they reach their eyes and ears: "That's a small red dog barking," someone might say. But while people can easily name most colors in different groups--distinguishing the specific frequencies and wavelengths of light--few can do the same for musical notes, which represent sounds with distinct, unchanging pitches. Hearing a musical note and naming it is beyond the listening expertise of most people. In fact, this ability is rare enough that society celebrates people who can label musical notes heard spontaneously: They are said to have "perfect pitch," or "absolute pitch" as scientists who study the science of auditory perception call the ability. More common among musicians is "relative pitch," the ability to name musical notes in relation to one another on a scale ("do, re, mi") but not without a reference note. For psychologists and neuroscientists at the University of Chicago who have studied perfect pitch for years, this raised an interesting question about the relationship between sensory processing and cognition: What makes some musicians so good at identifying musical sounds? Is it the way their brains process sounds, their musical training, or both? To help answer this question, doctoral student Katherine Reis and Prof. Howard Nusbaum worked with other UChicago researchers to design a study comparing people with perfect pitch and people without perfect pitch on a series of tasks. "The presumed rarity of absolute pitch should be striking, as it is comparable to only being able to classify colors by their relationship to other colors and not with consistent labels such as 'blue,'" the authors wrote in a journal article describing their findings, which was published in July in Nature: Scientific Reports. The task the researchers tested participants on required naming piano notes and naming "pure" sine tones generated by a computer (these represent exact frequencies without an instrument's timbre). Thirty-one people participated in the study: 16 with perfect pitch and 15 who were accomplished musicians without perfect pitch. In each trial, the scientists used electrodes attached non-invasively to people's heads to monitor the way their brains and nervous systems reacted to sounds--a measure called the "frequency following response" (FFR)--and recorded their accuracy along with details about the participants' backgrounds in music, including prior training. They found that in both groups, the FFR--which provides a snapshot of the integrity of a person's ability to process sounds--predicted people's performance on pitch identification better than any metric previously used in studies of perfect pitch, including musical training. Participants also tended to be better at naming notes played on a piano as compared to the computer-generated sine tones: Those with perfect pitch averaged 98% accuracy on piano and 77% for sine tones, while those without averaged 29% accuracy on piano and 25% for sine tones. According to UChicago doctoral student John Veillette, who was also a co-author on the paper, this suggests that timbres--which are conferred by upper harmonics in sound frequencies and give instruments their unique, familiar rings--play an important role in pitch recognition. Reis said that implies that experience is probably involved in pitch recognition, since even people with self-reported perfect pitch weren't "perfect" when the notes were produced in an unfamiliar way. "As a result of our study, we now know that features of the FFR predict absolute pitch ability even better than the developmental factors that people usually associate with absolute pitch, like the age you first learned an instrument," Reis said. "This suggests there's a really low-level difference (in terms of the nervous system's response) in how absolute pitch possessors encode sounds in the brain." But despite the differences between the brains of people with and without perfect pitch, FFR itself is not a "fixed" trait--in other words, people may be able to improve their FFR, and their ability to name notes, over time, according to the scientists. So, the study demonstrates that FFR is a very strong predictor of a person's accuracy when labeling notes, and perhaps a good metric for understanding a person's facility with sound recognition. But while it suggests that people who have fast, accurate FFR may be better at such tasks, it doesn't mean that FFR is immutable. "As many fields in the behavioral sciences are now discovering, it may not be possible to fully understand cognition or perception without considering their dynamic interaction," the authors wrote. For Nusbaum, this was not surprising. The Stella M. Rowley Professor of Psychology has spent years studying perfect pitch alongside other scientists--including study co-authors Shannon Heald, an assistant instructional professor in the Department of Psychology, and Stephen Van Hedger, AB'09, PhD'15, now an assistant professor of psychology at Huron University College in Ontario. They have argued consistently that perfect pitch is not a dichotomous ability that people either have or do not have: Instead, it may be better thought of as a continuous spectrum. "Perfect pitch was long thought to be a rare ability that only some children could acquire if they had the right musical training in early childhood," Nusbaum said. "However, this study provides further evidence that while the differences in people's ability to categorize notes are real--and related to cognitive processing--our brains develop in tandem with the skills we practice over our entire lives. So, when it comes to pitch learning, practice, in a sense, really does make 'perfect.'" Citation: "Individual differences in human frequency-following response predict pitch labeling ability" Reis et al. Nature: Scientific Reports, July 12, 2021. Newsletter Get more with UChicago News delivered to your inbox. Top Stories 1. Collaborating with Kenyan government on development innovations is key to fighting poverty, says Nobel laureate 2. Aloof neutrons may actually 'talk' to one another briefly in new kind of symmetry 3. Do 911 calls ensure public safety? Experts reimagine crisis responses in UChicago event Related Topics Perfect Pitch , Howard Nusbaum Latest News A 'we' project: In city-wide exhibition, MacArthur Fellows invoke art as a tool for change Top row, left to right: Brent Staples, Katherine Freese, Zhenan Bao, Kim Ng, Jonathan Rapping; bottom row, left to right: Alida Miranda-Wolff, Efe Ukala, Julie Brennan, Albert Chang, Sofia Gross Awards UChicago alumni awarded for professional achievements, service to University Illustration symbolizing SARS-CoV-2 variants, with a red spiked ball surrounded by blue spiked balls on a yellow background COVID-19 What do we know about the Delta variant of SARS-CoV-2? Students sit together inside a glass-walled meeting room inside UChicago's Crerar Library Computer science New College data science major: From foundations to insight to impact Illustration depecting Behavioral economics Core knowledge Behavioral economics, explained Liza Merenzon Meet a UChicagoan UChicago student and gymnast fulfills Olympic dreams in Tokyo Emergency response team Harris Public Policy Do 911 calls ensure public safety? Experts reimagine crisis responses in UChicago event View latest news Around UChicago University of Chicago campus aerial Awards Profs. Mark Siegler and Geoffrey Stone to receive Norman Maclean Faculty Award Reading list Books you should read this summer, according to UChicago faculty AP-NORC Most Americans support vaccine mandates in certain public spaces, survey finds Pritzker School of Molecular Engineering Researchers discover new strategy for developing human-integrated electronics Odyssey students at Rockefeller Odyssey Scholarship Program UChicago Board of Trustees' gift launches new $200 million commitment to undergraduate financial aid and educational access Ayodele Drum and Dance Chicago Black Dance Legacy Project 'We're not in it alone': Building community for Black dance President Robert J. Zimmer Reflecting on 15 years of impact President Robert J. Zimmer Interior of Harper Library College Admissions Unique UChicago essay questions spark students' creativity University of Chicago Office of Communications 5801 S. Ellis Ave., Suite 120, Chicago, IL 60637 (773) 702-8360 news@uchicago.edu * Office of Communications Staff Directory * For Journalists * Feedback * Brand & Identity Guidelines * * * *