https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2021/08/22/sweden-experiment-no-lockdowns-led-better-mental-health-healthier/ Jump to content * News * Business * Sport * Opinion * Politics * World * Money * Life * Style * Travel * Culture Subscribe now Free for one month Log in See all World * USA * Europe * Middle East * Asia * Australasia * Africa * Latin America The Sweden experiment: how no lockdowns led to better mental health, a healthier economy and happier schoolchildren While Sweden's decision to stay open throughout the pandemic generated international debate, the controversy passed most people in Sweden by By Richard Orange Malmo 22 August 2021 * 8:00am Sweden's coronavirus policy seems to have paid off Sweden's coronavirus policy seems to have paid off It's the start of the new school year in Sweden, and the highly infectious delta variant is starting to hit the country hard, with cases having doubled since the end of July. In a lot of countries that would mean one thing: lockdown. But not in Sweden. Instead, at Sorgenfri school in central Malmo, the only visible anti-Covid measure is a ban on parents entering the school building. "I'm not worried at all," says Elin Brusewitz, 35, as her son played with his skateboard beside her. "We were fine during the last outbreaks. I guess I'm a typical Swede: not worried unless the authorities tell me to be worried.". Sweden's decision to eschew lockdown and leave pubs, restaurants, shopping centres and primary schools open throughout the pandemic generated furious discussion internationally. Millions of people across the world have been confined to their homes, watched businesses go under, and struggled to stay on top of their studies amid wave after wave of restrictions to prevent the spread of coronavirus. But for some 10 million Swedes, the eighteen months since the first local Covid-19 case was registered last February have been largely unremarkable. Two-thirds of people are not worried about the consequences of the pandemic for them and their family, according to the most recent opinion survey for the Civil Contingencies Agency, carried out in mid-June. State epidemiologist Anders Tegnell, Public Health Agency of Sweden, enjoying a beer while working on his laptop at an outdoor restaurant in Stockholm, Sweden Anders Tegnell was the architect of Sweden's strategy Credit: TT News Agency And there is broad support for the government's choices. Just a quarter felt the authorities should have given public health greater priority over the economy. Anders Tegnell, the state epidemiologist who was the architect of Sweden's strategy, was last week voted "most important Swede of the year" by the readers of Sweden's leading supermarket magazine. That is not to say the virus has not taken its toll - nearly 15,000 people have died in total, around 1,450 per million. But that death rate is lower than the average for the European Union as a whole (1,684), and well below those of France, Spain, Italy and the UK. Some now concede Sweden has not become the cautionary tale many predicted. "Many times I would have thought that the situation would have gone a different way, but it worked for Sweden," said Samir Bhatt, professor of Public Health at the University of Copenhagen, and one of the team at Imperial College who pushed the UK's lockdown strategy. "They achieved infection control; they managed to keep infections relatively low and they didn't have any health care collapse." The real benefits of Sweden's radical policy, however, can be seen in the economy, the psychological impact, and in schools. Sweden GDP forecast At the end of the first wave last year, the IMF predicted that Sweden's economy would contract by 7 per cent in 2020. In the end, GDP shrank by just 2.8 per cent, significantly lower than the EU average of 6 per cent and the UK - a staggering 9.8 per cent. Sweden's economy has also bounced back faster than any other country in Europe. By June, GDP had overtaken where it was before the pandemic struck and the economy is estimated to grow by 4.6 per cent this year. The government avoided splashing out on costly financial-support packages, spending just $22bn (PS16bn) - 4.2 per cent of its GDP - on wage subsidies and other measures. As a result, in 2020, the country recorded the second-smallest budget deficit in the European Union after Denmark, and its national debt has come through the crisis almost unscathed. "The public finances have been hit relatively lightly compared to most countries, probably due to the fact that we have used less draconian measures," Urban Hansson Brusewitz, Director General of Sweden's National Institute of Economic Research [and no relation to Elin], told the Telegraph. The psychological toll of the pandemic also appears to have been less dramatic in Sweden. Covid mental health The National Board of Health and Welfare reported a continuation in the decline in the number of people seeking treatment for anxiety and depression, particularly among children and young adults. A large part of this is likely down to the decision to keep primary and lower secondary schools open throughout. Even in upper secondary schools, only children who test positive or have been formally contact-traced are asked to stay home. Entire schools and classes were quarantined very rarely and only in exceptional circumstances if advised by a local infectious disease doctor. That's a marked contrast to the UK, where as many as a million children were sent home from school during the "pingdemic". "We are very happy that we kept our schools open. I think that that is very important," explained Sara Byfors, unit chief at the Public Health Agency. An analysis of national grades published by the Swedish National Agency for Education last month found no evidence that the pandemic had negatively affected children's educational attainment. "The fact that grades have stayed stable suggests that both teachers and pupils have handled this tough pandemic year well," said the agency's general director Peter Fredriksson in a statement. "No group of pupils seems to have been affected more negatively than any other." Students run out of their school celebrating their high school graduation at Nacka Gymnasium in Stockholm, Sweden It is the start of the new school year in Sweden Credit: AFP Ms Byfors said the worst impact of the pandemic appeared to have been on the few people who did have to quarantine. "We know that it had a big effect on the elderly that were isolated, and we also know that a lot of children were affected if they were in the higher grades that had to have distance learning," she said. "How big it is and what the long-term effects will be [is] still to be determined." However, Dr Bhatt, the University of Copenhagen professor, is keen to point out that for all of its successes, Sweden saw more Covid fatalities than its Nordic neighbours who took a more interventionist approach. The death rate was between three and four times that of Denmark, and nearly 10 times those of Finland and Norway - suggesting Swedes died that didn't need to. And Dr Bhatt does not think another, non-Nordic country such as Britain could have copied Sweden's policies and got the same results. With about 23 people per square kilometre, Sweden has about a tenth of the population density of the UK, while about half of Swedish households comprise just one person - a major factor in local transmission. Sweden Covid deaths In a paper published last week in science journal Nature, Dr Bhatt, together with the UK's former government advisor Neil Ferguson and other researchers, estimated that if the UK had adopted Sweden's policies, its death rate would have been between two and four times higher. "What Sweden did was a pandemic response that involved large numbers of interventions, a considerable amount of reliance on population behaviour and population adherence, and a reliance on the intricacies of what makes Swedish culture Swedish culture," Dr Bhatt said. "If the UK had adopted what Sweden did, I have no doubt in my mind that it would have had an absolute disaster. For residents of Malmo, the gamble has paid off. Zaina Vujcics is a podiatrist who runs a small business close to Sorgenfri school that was able to stay open throughout the pandemic. She is adamant: "Sweden has had the best coronavirus policy." "In Denmark, in Norway, in France, Belgium, everywhere else, I would have had to close," she said. "I am so happy to be living in Sweden." Have you been based in Sweden during the pandemic? Share your experiences in the comment section below. Related Topics * Europe, * Coronavirus, * Sweden * * * * The Telegraph values your comments but kindly requests all posts are on topic, constructive and respectful. Please review our commenting policy. You need to be a subscriber to join the conversation. Find out more here. Log In Subscribe Show comments Advertisement More stories Related Topics * Europe, * Coronavirus, * Sweden * * * * More from World News * Donald Trump's Doha agreement was a retreat dressed as a peace deal Kate Clark 22 Aug 2021, 9:18pm US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo meets Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar, head of the Taliban's peace negotiation team, during talks in Doha * France praised for 'anticipatory planning' and evacuating 600 Afghans in May, months before the UK and US By Rebecca Rosman 22 Aug 2021, 7:22pm People flying out of Kabul on French plane * Covid-fearing Australian council shoots rescue dogs to stop volunteers travelling to pick them up By Giovanni Torre 22 Aug 2021, 7:07pm A woman walks her dog in New South Wales * 'Playing football can now get them killed': Afghan women's football captain appeals for help By Davide Zanelli 22 Aug 2021, 6:56pm Afghan female football players from Isteghlal (in purple) and Afghan (red) compete during the women's football tournament final match in Kabul * Human sewage 'dumped from Chinese ships' is destroying reefs in disputed South China Sea By Nicola Smith 22 Aug 2021, 6:36pm Colorful fish and a sea turtle with soft and hard corals on a tropical coral reef. Hawksbill Turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata), a Yellow-mask Angelfish (Pomacanthus xanthometopon), Foxface Rabbitfish (Siganus vulpinus), a Regal Angelfish (Pygoplites diacanthus), an Ornate Butterflyfish (Chaetodon ornatissimus), a Blacklip Butterflyfish (Chaetodon kleinii), and a Longnose Butterflyfish (Forcipiger Flavissimus). Tubbataha Reef Natural Park, Sulu Sea, The Philippines, South Pacific Ocean region. * Taliban sends 'hundreds' of fighters to crush resistance By James Rothwell 22 Aug 2021, 6:30pm Taliban stands guard at the green zone where most of the embassies are situated in Kabul, Afghanistan More from The Telegraph Back to top Follow us on: * * * * * * * Contact us * About us * Rewards * Reader Prints * Branded Content * Syndication and Commissioning * Guidelines * Privacy * Terms and Conditions * Advertising Terms * Fantasy Sport * UK Voucher Codes * Betting Offers * Modern Slavery (c) Telegraph Media Group Limited 2021 Please support us by disabling your adblocker We've noticed you're adblocking. We rely on advertising to help fund our award-winning journalism. We urge you to turn off your ad blocker for The Telegraph website so that you can continue to access our quality content in the future. Thank you for your support. Need help? Visit our adblocking instructions page. Close