https://appleinsider.com/articles/21/08/17/germany-writes-to-tim-cook-to-reconsider-csam-plans AppleInsider logo * News * Reviews * How-Tos * Videos * Deals + Apple Deals + MacBook Air Deals + MacBook Pro Deals + Mac mini Deals + iPad Deals + AirPods deals + Apple Watch Deals + iMac Deals + iPhone Deals + Apple Authorized Resellers + Apple Student Discount + Macs for Students * Price Guides + Apple Prices + MacBook, iMac & Mac mini Prices + iPad Prices + Apple Watch Prices + iPhone Prices + Apple TV & AirTag Prices + AirPods, HomePod & Beats Prices + iPad & iPhone Trade-in Values * Apple A-Z + AirPods + Apple TV + Apple Watch + HomePod + iPad + iPhone + Mac + More... * More + Forums + Podcasts + Contact Us + Advertise * AAPL: 150.23 ( -0.89 ) [ ] Toggle navigation Close Nav AppleInsider Logo [ ] * News * How-Tos * Apple A-Z + AirPods + Apple TV + Apple Watch + HomePod + iPad + iPhone + Mac + More... * Reviews * Videos * Deals + Apple Deals + MacBook Air Deals + MacBook Pro Deals + Mac mini Deals + iPad Deals + AirPods deals + Apple Watch Deals + iMac Deals + iPhone Deals + Apple Authorized Resellers + Apple Student Discount + Macs for Students * Price Guides + Apple Prices + MacBook, iMac & Mac mini Prices + iPad Prices + Apple Watch Prices + iPhone Prices + Apple TV & AirTag Prices + AirPods, HomePod & Beats Prices + iPad & iPhone Trade-in Values * Podcasts * Forums * Contact Us * Advertise on AI AAPL: 150.23 ( -0.89 ) Copyright (c) 2021, Quiller Media, Inc. Contact Us | Privacy Policy German government wants Tim Cook to reconsider CSAM plans Malcolm Owen's Avatar By Malcolm Owen | Aug 17, 2021 Aug 17, 2021 article thumbnail 20 Comments FacebookFacebook Twitter Twitter Reddit Reddit The German parliament is wading into the Apple CSAM debate, with a Digital Agenda committee chief writing to Apple CEO Tim Cook to express concerns about mass surveillance. Apple's CSAM scanning system continues to draw criticism over its existence, largely at a misinterpretation as to what the system does and is capable of doing. The criticism has now reached the German Bundestag, the national parliament, which is now stepping into the affair. A letter sent by Digital Agenda committee chairman Manuel Hoferlin claims Apple is treading a "dangerous path" and is undermining "secure and confidential communication," according to Heise Online. The letter to Cook urges Apple to not implement the system, both to protect society's data, and to avoid "foreseeable problems" for the company itself. The CSAM tools are considered the "biggest breach of the dam for the confidentiality of communication that we have seen since the invention of the Internet," a translated extract from Hoferlin's letter reads. Without confidential communication, the internet would become "the greatest surveillance instrument in history." The proposed tools are actually for two separate tasks. The main tool is a scanner that checks hashes of images uploaded to iCloud Photos for matches against a database of known CSAM images, not the content of the files themselves. The second is in Messages, which will warn young users of harmful material they may see in messages, and will inform family account administrators of the incident. While the second system uses on-device machine learning to inspect the images, Apple is not fed back any data about the scans. Despite the narrow impact of the tools, and reassurances from Apple, the parliament member still insists a narrow backdoor is still a backdoor. Requests to open the backdoor to scan other types of content are inevitable, they add, and could have Apple risking access to major international markets if it rejects them. The Bundestag letter arrives one day after a German journalist union called for the European Commission to look into the matter, due to the perceived "violation of the freedom of the press." --------------------------------------------------------------------- AppleInsider has affiliate partnerships and may earn commission on products purchased through affiliate links. These partnerships do not influence our editorial content. 20 Comments Comments (20) Forum User bluefire1 bluefire1 said about 4 hours ago No matter how laudable Apple's motives may be, this is a slippery slope that should definitely be reconsidered. Privacy, which Apple consistently prides itself in and boasts about, shouldn't have any back door exceptions. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Forum User xyzzy-xxx xyzzy-xxx said about 4 hours ago bluefire1 said: No matter how laudable Apple's motives may be, this is an idea which should never have come to pass. Totally agree, if it's really about the cloud they would need to scan in the cloud and not putting spyware onto a billion if devices. Since scanning data on user's devices is prohibited in many countries, Apple is also in legal trouble (even when it officially is only in the USA), since a company plays the gatekeeper of this spyware and could change things at any time (even for specific users)! --------------------------------------------------------------------- Forum User ne1 ne1 said about 4 hours ago xyzzy-xxx said: bluefire1 said: No matter how laudable Apple's motives may be, this is an idea which should never have come to pass. Totally agree, if it's really about the cloud they would need to scan in the cloud and not putting spyware onto a billion if devices. Since scanning data on user's devices is prohibited in many countries, Apple is also in legal trouble (even when it officially is only in the USA), since a company plays the gatekeeper of this spyware and could change things at any time (even for specific users)! Agree with both these points. Apple needs to pull this "feature" from iOS15 in North America and everywhere else. It goes against everything Apple stands for. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Forum User genovelle genovelle said about 4 hours ago Since the images are not scanned but specific data from hash tag markers to identify know child pornography images from a data base. It is no different from a file that has a known virus being detected and handled. There is a reason this guy is coming out as many others. They have these files themselves and are fearful of being caught --------------------------------------------------------------------- Forum User dantheman827 dantheman827 said about 4 hours ago genovelle said: Since the images are not scanned but specific data from hash tag markers to identify know child pornography images from a data base. It is no different from a file that has a known virus being detected and handled. There is a reason this guy is coming out as many others. They have these files themselves and are fearful of being caught Sure... everyone that's against this has CSAM... that makes perfect sense... Or I don't know, maybe people actually value their privacy and Apple just messed up big time? It's not an objection to the scanning, it's an objection to the scanning being done on your device without you having the option to disable it. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Read More on the forums... Please enable JavaScript to comment --------------------------------------------------------------------- Related Articles article thumbnail AirTag helps find stolen motorcycle, may have acted as a deterrent A Renton, Washington resident was able to locate his motorcycle using AirTag after it had been stolen earlier Tuesday morning. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Hands On: Glass is an iOS app to bring photographers together Glass is an iOS app that aims to rekindle the feeling of an early Instagram by being a photo-sharing app designed for photographers. While it is early in its journey, the app seems to be starting strong. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Apple giving iOS 15 users choice between new and old Safari design The sixth developer beta for iOS 15 has added a toggle that reverses Apple's Safari address bar design to the iOS 14 top-bar style. --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Back to School Apple hardware Apple Student Discount Best back-to-school bargains New iPad discounts M1 iPads are on sale now Save up to $147 Apple M1 MacBook Air deals Every M1 MacBook Air is discounted Save up to $150 --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Latest comparisons article thumbnail Compared: Klipsch T5 II ANC versus AirPods Pro Klipsch refreshed its T5 II True Wireless earphones to include active noise cancellation, bringing it into the same market as Apple's AirPods Pro. Here's where the newcomer stands against Apple's personal audio offering. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Master & Dynamic MW08 versus AirPods Pro and Beats Studio Buds Apple may have market dominance with its AirPods Pro, but neither AirPods Pro nor the new Beats Studio Buds can match the luxurious build quality of Master & Dynamic's new MW08 Sport true wireless earbuds. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Compared: Beats Studio Buds vs AirPods, AirPods Pro, and Powerbeats Pro With the launch of the Beats Studio Buds, Apple now has a total of four wireless earbuds it sells to consumers. Here's how the newcomers face against AirPods, AirPods Pro, and Beats Powerbeats Pro. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Compared: AirPods Pro vs Sony WF-1000XM4 true wireless earbuds Sony launched the WF-1000XM4 wireless earbuds in June, its noise-cancelling rival to the Apple AirPods Pro. Here's how Sony's latest stacks up against Apple's heavy hitter. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Compared: Apple AirPods and AirPods Pro versus Echo Buds In April, Amazon upgraded its Echo Buds to make it a better value-oriented rival to Apple's AirPods. Here's how Amazon's offerings stack up to Apple's AirPods and AirPods Pro. --------------------------------------------------------------------- * New iPhone * AirPods Max * iPhone 12 * iPhone 13 * iPhone 12 Pro * iPhone 12 Pro Max * iPad Air * More... Latest News article thumbnail author image Apple to pursue copyright claims against Corellium in appellate court 40 minutes ago Apple to pursue copyright claims against Corellium in appellate court Apple on Tuesday filed a notice of appeal in its copyright infringement lawsuit against Corellium, a case that was partially settled last week. By Mikey Campbell | 40 minutes ago 3 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image Apple releases watchOS 8 beta 6 to developers 1 hour ago Apple releases watchOS 8 beta 6 to developers Apple's sixth developer beta for watchOS 8 is now available for testing hours after beta versions of iOS 15, iPadOS 15 and tvOS 15 were released on Tuesday. By Wesley Hilliard | 1 hour ago 0 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image Apple Watch Activity Challenge celebrates national parks on Aug. 28 1 hour ago Apple Watch Activity Challenge celebrates national parks on Aug. 28 Apple's next Apple Watch Activity Challenge is scheduled to kick off on Aug. 28 and will urge users to work out in celebration of national parks. By AppleInsider Staff | 1 hour ago 0 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image Apple's new Siri Remote for Apple TV gets firmware update 2 hours ago Apple's new Siri Remote for Apple TV gets firmware update Apple on Tuesday released a firmware update for its new Siri Remote for Apple TV 4K and Apple TV HD, likely delivering bug fixes and performance improvements to the device. By AppleInsider Staff | 2 hours ago 3 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image Polish opposition lawyer thanks Apple for strong encryption amid corruption case 2 hours ago Polish opposition lawyer thanks Apple for strong encryption amid corruption case A Polish lawyer and frequent critic of the country's government thanked Apple for its strong encryption after local prosecutors failed to break into his iPhone. By Mike Peterson | 2 hours ago 2 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image Zendure SuperBase Pro review: This is the power station you want 2 hours ago Zendure SuperBase Pro review: This is the power station you want Zendure's new SuperBase Pro is unlike any other power station. With constant 4G connectivity, multiple 100W USB-C ports, and six AC outputs, the station's utility can make it an indispensable tool for users. By Andrew O'Hara | 2 hours ago --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image Functioning Apple-1 computer with rare Koa wood case to hit auction block 3 hours ago Functioning Apple-1 computer with rare Koa wood case to hit auction block A functioning Apple-1 computer that's in "mint condition" and sporting a Koa wooden case is set to hit the auction block in November. By Mike Peterson | 3 hours ago 1 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail author image AirTag helps find stolen motorcycle, may have acted as a deterrent 3 hours ago AirTag helps find stolen motorcycle, may have acted as a deterrent A Renton, Washington resident was able to locate his motorcycle using AirTag after it had been stolen earlier Tuesday morning. By Wesley Hilliard | 3 hours ago 7 --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail AirTag helps find stolen motorcycle, may have acted as a deterrent A Renton, Washington resident was able to locate his motorcycle using AirTag after it had been stolen earlier Tuesday morning. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Hands On: Glass is an iOS app to bring photographers together Glass is an iOS app that aims to rekindle the feeling of an early Instagram by being a photo-sharing app designed for photographers. While it is early in its journey, the app seems to be starting strong. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Apple giving iOS 15 users choice between new and old Safari design The sixth developer beta for iOS 15 has added a toggle that reverses Apple's Safari address bar design to the iOS 14 top-bar style. --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Latest Videos article thumbnail How to play on your PlayStation 5 or Xbox Series X with an iPad Pro While you could play console games on your TV, you could just as easily play them on an M1 iPad Pro. Here's what you need to know to use the Xbox and Playstation game streaming features on Apple's tablet. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Will iPhone 13 get a bigger battery? That and more on This Week in Apple The latest "This Week in Apple" breaks down the new rumors on iPhone 13 including the notion that it may include a larger battery. We also talk about the new MacBook Pros and Apple's latest betas. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail How to master multitasking on iPad and iPad Pro in iPadOS 15 Here's how you can master Apple's iPad or iPad Pro running iPadOS 15 including running apps in Split View, using the Shortcuts app, and more. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Compared: Klipsch T5 II ANC versus AirPods Pro Klipsch refreshed its T5 II True Wireless earphones to include active noise cancellation, bringing it into the same market as Apple's AirPods Pro. Here's where the newcomer stands against Apple's personal audio offering. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail iPad revenue is up, but are sales down because of the M1? Apple reported Q3 2021 iPad revenue at $7.4 billion, an increase of 12% in dollar-value. Did the M1 supercharge iPad sales volumes, or is something else going on? --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Latest Reviews article thumbnail Zendure SuperBase Pro review: This is the power station you want Zendure's new SuperBase Pro is unlike any other power station. With constant 4G connectivity, multiple 100W USB-C ports, and six AC outputs, the station's utility can make it an indispensable tool for users. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Harber Slim Laptop Backpack Review: lightweight, protective, and gorgeous You'll want to carry your MacBook Pro in Harber's Slim Laptop Backpack, and it's big enough to take cables, an iPad, and more. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Zens Magnetic + Watch Wireless Charger Review: MagSafe-like mount and power for four devices The new Zens Magnetic + Watch Wireless Charger has a MagSafe-like magnetic wireless charger alongside a second Qi charging pad, a USB output, and an Apple Watch puck for an incredibly compact desktop charging station. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail Nomad Leather Keychain review: A better AirTag keyring There are several AirTag keychain holders, including a few from Apple itself. Nomad's entrant is one of the most well-rounded yet, keeping things simple and stylish. --------------------------------------------------------------------- article thumbnail PlugBug Slim review: Easily pocketable power The new PlugBug Slim aims to provide 20W of power in an ultra-compact design perfect for travel or areas too cramped for traditional wall-warts. It's an excellent product on its own, but we set out to see if it was worth it in an increasingly crowded market. --------------------------------------------------------------------- LOAD MORE AppleInsider Wordmark Apple A-Z * Apple Silicon * iPhone 12 * iPhone 12 mini * iPhone 12 Pro * iPhone 12 Pro Max * HomePod mini * 14" MacBook Pro * Apple Watch 6 * iPad Air * More... Price Guides * All * New Macs * iPads * Apple Watch * iPhones * Apple TV & Accessories * AirPods & Homepods * iPhone & iPad Trade-in Prices More * How-Tos * Forums * Podcasts * Deals * Videos * Reviews * Contact Us * Advertise on AI Designed by Crafted Copyright (c) 2021, Quiller Media, Inc. Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use Quantcast article thumbnail author profile image {{ title }} {{ dateFormatted }} {{ title }} {{ summary }} {{{ reviewStars.html }}} By {{ author }} | {{ dateFormatted }} {{ commentCount }} ---------------------------------------------------------------------