https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/muscaria-hallucinogenic-mushroom-fresco * Want to see fewer ads? Become a Member. * Trips + Upcoming Trips + All Trips Trips Blog [second-edi] Get the Atlas Obscura book Shop Now >> Upcoming Trips View All Trips >> [blank-11b9] Only in Queens: Tasting Our Way Through New York's Most Diverse Borough [blank-11b9] Forage & Fiddle in Asheville [blank-11b9] Romania: Castles, Ruins, and Medieval Villages [blank-11b9] Solo Only: Chernobyl by Day, Kyiv by Night * Experiences Quick Links + Online Courses + Online Experiences Upcoming Experiences View All Experiences >> [blank-11b9] Online Playing With Sound: Experimental Music With Jamie Stewart [blank-11b9] Online Special Access: The Entomology Collection at The Academy of Natural Sciences [blank-11b9] Online Global Moves: Learn Indian Kuchipudi w/ Yamini Kalluri [blank-11b9] Online Making Scents: Experimental Perfumery With Saskia Wilson-Brown * Courses Upcoming Courses View All Courses >> [blank-11b9] Online Playing With Sound: Experimental Music With Jamie Stewart [blank-11b9] Online Making Scents: Experimental Perfumery With Saskia Wilson-Brown [blank-11b9] Online Historical Nonfiction: Research-Based Writing With Hadley Meares [blank-11b9] Online Fall Feasts: Foraging & Folklore With Felicity Roberts [blank-11b9] Online Stories in the Stones: How to Read a Gravestone With Dr. Elise M. Ciregna * Places + Top Destinations + Newly Added Places + Most Popular Places + Random Place + Lists + Itineraries + ------------------------------------------------------------- Add a Place + ------------------------------------------------------------- Visit Our Forums Newly Added Places View All Places >> Loshitsa Manor Front View Minsk, Belarus Loshitsa Manor and Park 53.8510, 27.5787 [blank-11b9] Kilmacolm, Scotland 'The Lost XVII' 55.8728, -4.6138 Curious visitor in the bamboo forest. Atlanta, Georgia Alpaca Treehouse 33.7227, -84.3278 Infield at the Zoo Omaha, Nebraska Infield at the Zoo 41.2255, -95.9316 Top Destinations View All Destinations >> Countries + Australia + Canada + China + France + Germany + India + Italy + Japan Cities + Amsterdam + Barcelona + Beijing + Berlin + Boston + Budapest + Chicago + London + Los Angeles + Mexico City + Montreal + Moscow + New Orleans + New York City + Paris + Philadelphia + Rome + San Francisco + Seattle + Stockholm + Tokyo + Toronto + Vienna + Washington, D.C. * Foods Newly Added Places to Eat & Drink View All Places to Eat >> Late afternoon coffee and cake. Cafe Strauss It's really very large! World's Largest Cheese Slicer [blank-11b9] Original Taco Bell Sign Naegelin's Bakery Naegelin's Bakery [blank-11b9] Preserved Victorian Wedding Cake * Stories Most Recent Stories View All Stories >> World War I impact craters, Verdun, 2005. Plants, Heavy Metals, and the Lingering Scars of World War I [blank-11b9] Podcast: The World's Oldest Living Things Green chile everything is the calling card of Albuquerque. That also occasionally extends to their minor league baseball team. How Minor League Baseball Teams Hype Hyper-Local Food In 2010, through a narrow hole in Antarctica's Ross Ice Shelf, researchers found thousands sea anemones clinging to the underside of the ice--a mysterious species, new to science. Exploring Antarctica's Upside-Down World This could be the last thing a plankter saw before being forced up to be consumed. See an Ordinary Jellyfish From an Extraordinary Perspective * Sign In Join * Sign In ----------------------------------------------------------------- Join * What's near me? Brought to you by [delta_logo] Does This Medieval Fresco Show A Hallucinogenic Mushroom in the Garden of Eden? Controversy over what's depicted in the image, and what it may say about early Christians, has raged for decades. by Emma Betuel August 5, 2021 Does This Medieval Fresco Show A Hallucinogenic Mushroom in the Garden of Eden? Copy Link Facebook Twitter Reddit Flipboard Pocket In France, Plaincourault Chapel features a peculiar depiction of the Garden of Eden's Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. In France, Plaincourault Chapel features a peculiar depiction of the Garden of Eden's Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. Alamy Stock Photo In This Story [blank-11b9] Destination Guide France Adam and Eve stand in the Garden of Eden, both of them faceless. Eve's ribs are bold slash marks, as if the artist wanted her to appear almost skeletal. But that is not the strangest thing about this faded 13th-century fresco inside France's medieval Plaincourault Chapel. Between Adam and Eve stands a large red tree, crowned with a dotted, umbrella-like cap. The tree's branches end in smaller caps, each with their own pattern of tiny white spots. It's this tree that has attracted visitors from around the world to the sleepy village of Merigny, some 200 miles south of Paris. Tourists, scholars, and influencers come to see the tree that, according to some enthusiasts, depicts the hallucinogenic mushroom Amanita muscaria. Not everyone agrees, however, and controversy over the fresco has polarized researchers, helped ruin at least one career, and inspired an idea--unproven but wildly popular, in some circles--that early Christians used hallucinogenic mushrooms. The question of what was painted on the back wall of Plaincourault goes back at least to 1911, when a member of the French Mycological Society suggested the thing sprouting between Adam and Eve was a "bizarre" and "arborescent" mushroom. The idea that the Tree of Life was actually A. muscaria pops up in the 1925 book The Romance of the Fungus World, which presents a "curious myth" about the Plaincourault fresco depicting the hallucinogenic mushroom, though there is no suggestion of its use by early Christians. Plaincourault Chapel in Merigny, France, was built in the 12th century, though its controversial fresco dates to the late 13th century.Plaincourault Chapel in Merigny, France, was built in the 12th century, though its controversial fresco dates to the late 13th century. Ed Buziak/Alamy Stock Photo A quarter-century later, the earlier mentions lured R. Gordon Wasson to see the fresco for himself. Wasson was a PR exec in banking, and also an amateur mycologist. Although he had no formal training in the field, he's known today for his prolific writing on mushrooms, particularly of the hallucinogenic variety, and fungi-focused travels, some of which were secretly funded by the CIA, which had its own interests in the topic. In 1952, when Wasson saw Plaincourault for himself, he wasn't convinced, and sought the opinion of Princeton art historian Erwin Panofsky. The scholar was blunt. "The plant in this fresco has nothing whatever to do with mushrooms," Panofsky wrote. The idea persisted, however, and was loudly revived in 1970 by John Marco Allegro, a scholar of ancient languages at the University of Manchester. In his book The Sacred Mushroom and the Cross, Allegro argued that Christianity itself had derived from a fertility cult whose members ingested hallucinogens. He called the Garden of Eden story "mushroom-based mythology." His visual evidence was the fresco at Plaincourault, in which "Amanita muscaria is gloriously portrayed," he wrote. Allegro was already a controversial figure: He had been publicly criticized by colleagues on a team translating the Dead Sea Scrolls for his overly imaginative interpretations. But The Sacred Mushroom was the final nail in the coffin of Allegro's career. Speaking to Time Magazine, one scholar called the book "a Semitic philologist's erotic nightmare." Other critics included Wasson, who wrote, "One could expect mycologists, in their isolation, to make this blunder. Mr. Allegro is not a mycologist but, if anything, a cultural historian." Despite the broad and negative reaction to the book, Allegro's interpretation of the Plaincourault fresco lives on, attracting new believers. Allegro's interpretation of the Plaincourault fresco lives on, attracting new believers. Two of the fresco's current champions are Julie and Jerry Brown, neither of whom are mycologists or art historians. Jerry is an anthropologist at Florida International University, where he teaches a course on psychedelics and culture. Julie is an integrative psychotherapist. The Browns believe that Allegro got a few things right, namely, the idea that early Christianity could have incorporated the use of psychoactive plants, and that mushrooms depicted in Christian art are proof of that use. Jerry Brown calls the fresco at Plaincourault "seminal" to this argument. "If Allegro were right, and Plaincourault did represent a stunning example of a psychoactive mushroom in a late 13th-century fresco, then entheogens [psychoactive substances] could be seen as integral to the origins of Judeo-Christianity with a usage persisting at least into medieval times as evidenced by this fresco," says Brown. While many religions past and present incorporate some form of psychoactive plant, "as yet, there is no convincing biomolecular archaeological evidence of the use of hallucinogens by early Christians," says Patrick McGovern, the scientific director of the Biomolecular Archaeology Project at the University of Pennsylvania. Art historians are also skeptical that the medieval fresco is secretly showcasing Christianity's psychedelic roots. "I can assure you that the arboreal form at Plaincourault, or elsewhere for that matter, in no way references a particular species of mushroom," says Marcia Kupfer, an independent scholar of medieval art and author of Romanesque Wall Painting in Central France. Medieval artists experimented with stylized flora and fauna; this detail from a church in Norway dates to the late 13th century, about the same time as the Plaincourault fresco.Medieval artists experimented with stylized flora and fauna; this detail from a church in Norway dates to the late 13th century, about the same time as the Plaincourault fresco. DeAgostini/Getty Images Elina Gertsman, an art historian at Case Western Reserve University, says she's not one to shy away from well-placed speculation, but even she can't get behind the idea that the tree is a hallucinogenic mushroom. Instead, she says, medieval artists may have been experimenting with new ways to stylize trees. There are countless examples of medieval images where artists did this, including lions that appear to be wearing glasses, or elephants with mitten-like feet . "I think you will be hard-pressed to find a specialist in medieval art who disagrees with me and subscribes, instead, to the psychedelic Christianity idea," Gertsman says. Jerry Brown has heard the art historians' assessments and remains unswayed. "As Louis Pasteur said, chance favors the prepared mind," says Brown. "My mind, having taught psychedelics for decades, recognized it." There is no shortage of prepared minds out there: The idea that the Plaincourault fresco depicts A. muscaria as the Tree of Life thrives on social media posts, blogs, and in digital image collections. Some of the sites alter the image of the tree to enhance its resemblance to the mushroom, boosting the red color or employing other "pretty blatant manipulation," says Gertsman. The idea of Plaincourault depicting a mushroom tree got another boost recently from comedian Joe Rogan, whose podcast, The Joe Rogan Experience, was the top podcast on Spotify in 2020. "That is an original fresco from France, 13th-century fresco depicting Adam and Eve and the Tree of Knowledge," Rogan told his millions of listeners. "That mushroom is a mushroom called the Amanita muscaria." A stylized Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil in a mid-12th century mosaic from in an Italian collection, origin unknown.A stylized Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil in a mid-12th century mosaic from in an Italian collection, origin unknown. Fine Art Images /Heritage Images/Getty Images If the idea of the Plaincourault fresco depicting a hallucinogenic mushroom has been debunked, repeatedly, by scholars in the best position to interpret it, why does it persist? The reason may be a combination of shifting societal attitudes and the very human tendency to see what we want to see. Americans, for example, are becoming more open to the idea of psychedelics, says Ido Hartogsohn, the author of American Trip: Set, Setting and the Psychedelic Experience in the 20th Century. In 2017, 53 percent of a nationally representative sample of 1,145 Americans said they supported medical research into psychedelics. In 2020, Oregon decriminalized psilocybin, a hallucinogenic compound found in several types of mushroom, and legalized it in therapeutic contexts-- the first state to do so. A growing acceptance of hallucinogens in the mainstream now may make many of us more willing to believe that they were used in the past, even in cultures and periods where hard evidence is lacking. "In some cases, advocacy of psychedelics can lead some to find clues for their existence everywhere, even when the supporting evidence is quite speculative in nature," say Hartogsohn. For the last 100 years, people have been seeing mushrooms when they look into the image at Plaincourault. Today, it may be easier than ever to see them, even if they're not really there. Read next The Mysterious Street Snack That Has Baffled Botanists for Decades Even DNA tests have yet to confirm its identity. [blank-11b9] hallucinogenbotanydrugschristianityreligionsciencehistory Want to see fewer ads? Become a Member. Want to see fewer ads? Become a Member. Using an ad blocker? We depend on ad revenue to craft and curate stories about the world's hidden wonders. Consider supporting our work by becoming a member for as little as $5 a month. Continue Using Ad-Block Support Us Keep Exploring [blank-11b9] churches Found: A Massive Medieval Cathedral From a 'Forgotten' Nubian Kingdom The discovery adds to our knowledge of Makuria, which ruled a vast region of Africa for six centuries. Matthew Taub July 8, 2021 [blank-11b9] science Grapefruit Is One of the Weirdest Fruits on the Planet From its name, to its hazy origins, to its drug interactions, there's a lot going on beneath that thick rind. Dan Nosowitz October 6, 2020 [blank-11b9] sacred spaces How Santa Survived the Soviet Era Of all the variations on the beloved character, Russia's Ded Moroz might have the strangest history. Dan Nosowitz December 19, 2019 [blank-11b9] sacred spaces An Island's Spiritual History, Documented in Haunting Photographs Walking the trails to prayer on Japan's Nozaki Island, once home to persecuted Christians. Anika Burgess June 11, 2018 [W1siZiIsIj] Video The Mystery of Hawai'i's Doctor's Pit 4:46 [W1siZiIsIj] Video The Reopening of Turkey's Controversial Greek Orthodox Monastery 3:50 [W1siZiIsIj] Video Step Inside Indonesia's Chicken Church 5:28 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * AO Docs The Muslims Preserving Kolkata's Last Jewish Synagogues 4:08 [W1siZiIsIj] Video Inside a Domed Pyramid With Astounding Acoustics and a History of Miracles 4:16 [W1siZiIsIj] Video In Naples, Praying With Skulls Is an Ancient Tradition 7:28 [W1siZiIsIj] Video Atlas Obscura Tries: Magnet Fishing 6:00 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * PinDrop A 30-Acre Garden Inspired by the Principles of Modern Physics 1:32 [W1siZiIsIj] Video The Flesh-Eating Beetles of Chicago's Field Museum 3:58 [W1siZiIsIj] Video Inside Ohio's Experimental Archaeology Lab 7:29 [W1siZiIsIj] Video A Visit to Buffalo's Lava Lab 4:51 [W1siZiIsIj] Video Where Scientists Play With Fire 7:22 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * Object of Intrigue A Colossal Squid Is Hiding in New Zealand 3:07 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * AO Docs Hawai`i's Native-Language Newspaper Archive 3:35 Sponsored by Olukai [W1siZiIsIj] Video * AO Docs 'Discovering' Mexico's Monarch Butterfly Migration 6:46 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * Object of Intrigue The Real Story Behind George Washington's Dentures 3:30 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * Object of Intrigue Behold, the Vampire-Killing Kit 4:19 [W1siZiIsIj] Video See the Mysterious Horned Helmet of Henry VIII 4:00 Want to see fewer ads? Become a Member. From Around the Web Atlas Obscura Trips City of Blooms: Floriculture in Paris View This Trip [] See Fewer Ads Become an Atlas Obscura member and experience far fewer ads and no pop-ups. Learn More Get Our Email Newsletter [ ] [Subscribe] Thanks for subscribing! View all newsletters >> Follow Us * * * * * Places * Recently Added * Most Popular * Random * Nearby * Add a Place Foods * Latest * Food & Drink * Stories * Places * Add a Food Trips * All Trips * Trips Blog * Art & Culture Trips * Food Trips * Hidden City Trips * History Trips * Photography Trips * Wildlife & Nature Trips * FAQ Experiences * All Experiences * Online Experiences * Online Courses * Online Experience FAQ * Online Course FAQ Community * Membership * Travel Forum * Latest Posts * Top Posts Company * About * Contact Us * FAQ * Work With Us * Advertising * Press * Unique Gifts * Privacy Policy * Cookie Policy * Terms of Use [] (c) 2021 Atlas Obscura. All rights reserved. Questions or Feedback? Contact Us Thanks for sharing! Follow us on Twitter to get the latest on the world's hidden wonders. Like us on Facebook to get the latest on the world's hidden wonders. Follow us on Twitter Like us on Facebook Want a Free Book? Sign up for our newsletter and enter to win the second edition of our book, Atlas Obscura: An Explorer's Guide to the World's Hidden Wonders. [ ] Subscribe No Thanks Visit AtlasObscura.com Atlas Obscura: An Explorer's Guide to the World's Hidden Wonders Stay in Touch! Follow us on social media to add even more wonder to your day. Follow us on Twitter Like us on Facebook Follow Us on Instagram No Thanks Visit AtlasObscura.com No purchase necessary. Winner will be selected at random on 09/01/ 2021. Offer available only in the U.S. (including Puerto Rico). Offer subject to change without notice. See contest rules for full details. Add Some Wonder to Your Inbox Every weekday we compile our most wondrous stories and deliver them straight to you. [ ] Subscribe No Thanks We'd Like You to Like Us Like Atlas Obscura and get our latest and greatest stories in your Facebook feed. No Thanks This website uses cookies Atlas Obscura and our trusted partners use technology such as cookies on our website to personalise ads, support social media features, and analyse our traffic. Please click below to consent to the use of this technology while browsing our site. To learn more or withdraw consent, please visit our cookie policy. I Accept [p] Quantcast