https://www.wsj.com/articles/robinhoods-debut-is-clouded-by-sec-scrutiny-of-payment-for-order-flow-11625655600 Skip to Main ContentSkip to Search Dow Jones, a News Corp companyAbout WSJ * News Corp is a global, diversified media and information services company focused on creating and distributing authoritative and engaging content and other products and services. * Dow Jones + Barron's + BigCharts + Dow Jones Businesses + Dow Jones Newswires + Factiva + Financial News + Mansion Global + MarketWatch + Newsmart + NewsPlus + Risk & Compliance + WSJ Live + WSJ Pro + WSJ Video + WSJ.com * News Corp + Avail + Business Spectator + HarperCollins Publishers + Housing + Knewz.com + Makaan + New York Post + PropTiger + REA + realtor.com + Storyful + The Australian + The Sun + The Times * The Wall Street Journal SubscribeSign In English Edition * English * Zhong Wen (Chinese) * Ri Ben Yu (Japanese) Print Edition Video Podcasts Latest Headlines SubscribeSign In * Home * World + Regions + Africa + Asia + Canada + China + Europe + Latin America + Middle East + Sections + Economy + More + World Video * U.S. + Sections + Economy + Law + New York + Politics + More + WSJ Noted. + U.S. Video + What's News Podcast * Politics + Sections + Capital Journal + More + Politics Video + Columns + Gerald Seib + Washington Wire * Economy + WSJ Pro + Bankruptcy + Central Banking + Private Equity + Strategic Intelligence + Venture Capital + More + Economic Forecasting Survey + Economy Video + Sections + Capital Account * Business + Sections + Management + The Future of Everything + Obituaries + Tech/WSJ.D + Industries + Aerospace & Defense + Autos & Transportation + Commercial Real Estate + Consumer Products + Energy + Entrepreneurship + Financial Services + Food & Services + Health Care + + Hospitality + Law + Manufacturing + Media & Marketing + Natural Resources + Retail + C-Suite + CFO Journal + CIO Journal + CMO Today + Logistics Report + Risk & Compliance + The Experience Report + Columns + Heard on the Street + WSJ Pro + Artificial Intelligence + Bankruptcy + Central Banking + Cybersecurity + Private Equity + Strategic Intelligence + Sustainable Business + Venture Capital + More + Business Video + Journal Report + Business Podcast * Tech + Sections + CIO Journal + The Future of Everything + Columns + Christopher Mims + Joanna Stern + Julie Jargon + Nicole Nguyen + More + Tech Video + Tech Podcast * Markets + Sections + Bonds + Commercial Real Estate + Commodities & Futures + Stocks + Personal Finance + WSJ Money + Streetwise + Intelligent Investor + Columns + Heard on the Street + Greg Ip + Jason Zweig + Laura Saunders + James Mackintosh + Market Data + Market Data Home + U.S. Stocks + Currencies + Companies + Commodities + Bonds & Rates + Mutual Funds & ETFs + More + CFO Journal + Markets Video + Your Money Briefing Podcast + Secrets of Wealthy Women Podcast + Search Quotes and Companies * Opinion + Columnists + Gerard Baker + Sadanand Dhume + James Freeman + William A. Galston + Daniel Henninger + Holman W. Jenkins + Andy Kessler + William McGurn + Walter Russell Mead + Peggy Noonan + Mary Anastasia O'Grady + Jason Riley + Joseph Sternberg + Kimberley A. Strassel + Reviews + Books + Film + Television + Theater + Art + Masterpiece Series + Music + Dance + Opera + Exhibition + Cultural Commentary + More + Editorials + Commentary + Future View + Letters to the Editor + The Weekend Interview + Potomac Watch Podcast + Foreign Edition Podcast + Opinion Video + Notable & Quotable * Life & Arts + Sections + Arts + Books + Cars + Food & Drink + Health + Ideas + Science + Style & Fashion + Travel + More + WSJ. Magazine + WSJ Recipes + WSJ Puzzles + The Future of Everything + Life Video + Arts Video * Real Estate + Sections + Commercial Real Estate + House of the Day + More + Real Estate Video * WSJ. Magazine + Sections + Fashion + Art & Design + Travel + Food + Culture * Sports + Columns + Jason Gay + Sections + MLB + NBA + NFL + Golf + Tennis + Soccer Search * Home * World + Regions + Africa + Asia + Canada + China + Europe + Latin America + Middle East + Sections + Economy + More + World Video * U.S. + Sections + Economy + Law + New York + Politics + More + WSJ Noted. + U.S. Video + What's News Podcast * Politics + Sections + Capital Journal + More + Politics Video + Columns + Gerald Seib + Washington Wire * Economy + WSJ Pro + Bankruptcy + Central Banking + Private Equity + Strategic Intelligence + Venture Capital + More + Economic Forecasting Survey + Economy Video + Sections + Capital Account * Business + Sections + Management + The Future of Everything + Obituaries + Tech/WSJ.D + Industries + Aerospace & Defense + Autos & Transportation + Commercial Real Estate + Consumer Products + Energy + Entrepreneurship + Financial Services + Food & Services + Health Care + + Hospitality + Law + Manufacturing + Media & Marketing + Natural Resources + Retail + C-Suite + CFO Journal + CIO Journal + CMO Today + Logistics Report + Risk & Compliance + The Experience Report + Columns + Heard on the Street + WSJ Pro + Artificial Intelligence + Bankruptcy + Central Banking + Cybersecurity + Private Equity + Strategic Intelligence + Sustainable Business + Venture Capital + More + Business Video + Journal Report + Business Podcast * Tech + Sections + CIO Journal + The Future of Everything + Columns + Christopher Mims + Joanna Stern + Julie Jargon + Nicole Nguyen + More + Tech Video + Tech Podcast * Markets + Sections + Bonds + Commercial Real Estate + Commodities & Futures + Stocks + Personal Finance + WSJ Money + Streetwise + Intelligent Investor + Columns + Heard on the Street + Greg Ip + Jason Zweig + Laura Saunders + James Mackintosh + Market Data + Market Data Home + U.S. Stocks + Currencies + Companies + Commodities + Bonds & Rates + Mutual Funds & ETFs + More + CFO Journal + Markets Video + Your Money Briefing Podcast + Secrets of Wealthy Women Podcast + Search Quotes and Companies * Opinion + Columnists + Gerard Baker + Sadanand Dhume + James Freeman + William A. Galston + Daniel Henninger + Holman W. Jenkins + Andy Kessler + William McGurn + Walter Russell Mead + Peggy Noonan + Mary Anastasia O'Grady + Jason Riley + Joseph Sternberg + Kimberley A. Strassel + Reviews + Books + Film + Television + Theater + Art + Masterpiece Series + Music + Dance + Opera + Exhibition + Cultural Commentary + More + Editorials + Commentary + Future View + Letters to the Editor + The Weekend Interview + Potomac Watch Podcast + Foreign Edition Podcast + Opinion Video + Notable & Quotable * Life & Arts + Sections + Arts + Books + Cars + Food & Drink + Health + Ideas + Science + Style & Fashion + Travel + More + WSJ. Magazine + WSJ Recipes + WSJ Puzzles + The Future of Everything + Life Video + Arts Video * Real Estate + Sections + Commercial Real Estate + House of the Day + More + Real Estate Video * WSJ. Magazine + Sections + Fashion + Art & Design + Travel + Food + Culture * Sports + Columns + Jason Gay + Sections + MLB + NBA + NFL + Golf + Tennis + Soccer Search [ ][Search] Share * Facebook * Twitter * LinkedIn * Copy Link * Markets * Finance Robinhood's Debut Is Clouded by SEC Scrutiny of Payment for Order Flow The practice provided 81% of the online brokerage's first-quarter revenue Following the GameStop trading frenzy, the SEC is expected to take a fresh look at payment for order flow, a decades-old practice that is at the heart of how commission-free trading works. WSJ explains what it is, and why critics say it's bad for investors. Illustration: Jacob Reynolds/WSJ By Alexander Osipovich Close Alexander Osipovich * Biography * @aosipovich * alexander.osipovich@wsj.com July 7, 2021 7:00 am ET Robinhood Markets Inc. is on a collision course with regulators over a controversial practice that generates most of its revenue, as the online brokerage gears up for a highly anticipated initial public offering. In its IPO filing, released Thursday, Robinhood disclosed that 81% of its first-quarter revenue came from sending its customers' stock, options and cryptocurrency orders to high-speed trading firms--a practice known as payment for order flow. Payment for order flow, or PFOF, makes it possible for Robinhood to let customers place trades with no upfront commission payment. Zero-commission stock trades helped the company win over millions of younger, less affluent customers and are now standard practice at many of Robinhood's competitors. Payment for order flow critics--including the country's top market regulator, Securities and Exchange Commission Chairman Gary Gensler--are wary of the practice. They argue that it poses a conflict of interest for brokerages, because the brokers can either collect more money for selling their customers' order flow or pass that money on to customers in the form of price savings on their trades. Last month, Mr. Gensler said the SEC was reviewing payment for order flow, fueling speculation among some market observers that PFOF could be banned. "The entire business model of some brokers is in the crosshairs," said Tyler Gellasch, executive director of Healthy Markets Association, an investor trade group. To Read the Full Story Subscribe Sign In [wsj-logo-b] Continue reading your article with a WSJ membership View Membership Options Resume Subscription We are delighted that you'd like to resume your subscription. You will be charged $ + tax (if applicable) for The Wall Street Journal. You may change your billing preferences at any time in the Customer Center or call Customer Service. You will be notified in advance of any changes in rate or terms. You may cancel your subscription at anytime by calling Customer Service. Please click confirm to resume now. Confirm Sponsored Offers * Wayfair: 10% off your 1st order with Wayfair Professional * Target: 20% off sitewide - Target Promo Code 2021 * Macy's: Macy's coupon - Sign up to get 25% off next order * Kohl's: 30% off Kohl's coupon for Rewards members * Saks Fifth Avenue: 20% off first order - Saks Fifth Avenue promo code * PrettyLittleThing: Use this PrettyLittleThing promo code to get 50% off Most Popular News * Haitian President Assassinated at Home, Official Says Haitian President Assassinated at Home, Official Says * Sha'Carri Richardson Is Left Off the U.S. Olympic Team Sha'Carri Richardson Is Left Off the U.S. Olympic Team * Pfizer Vaccine Less Effective Against Delta, Data Show Pfizer Vaccine Less Effective Against Delta, Data Show * Wall Street Split on Forcing Bankers to Return to Office Wall Street Split on Forcing Bankers to Return to Office * Air Force Found Largely Responsible for Texas Church Shooting Air Force Found Largely Responsible for Texas Church Shooting Most Popular Opinion * The Culture War Must Go On Opinion: The Culture War Must Go On * OPEC, Biden and Gas Prices Opinion: OPEC, Biden and Gas Prices * Nixon Warned About U.S. Decline Opinion: Nixon Warned About U.S. Decline * The DNC's Dishonest Voting Case Against Arizona Opinion: The DNC's Dishonest Voting Case Against Arizona * The IRS Is ProPublica's Accessory Opinion: The IRS Is ProPublica's Accessory Most Popular Videos * [https://m.wsj.net/video/20210706/070721-seib-scotustakeaways/ 070721-seib-scotustakeaways_167x94.jpg] Impact of Supreme Court's Conservative Majority Begins to Emerge * [https://m.wsj.net/video/20210707/070721elsa2/ 070721elsa2_167x94.jpg] Hurricane Elsa Hurtles Toward Florida After Destruction in Caribbean * [https://m.wsj.net/video/20210706/070621afghanistanborder/ 070621afghanistanborder_167x94.jpg] Taliban Gains Ground in Afghanistan Amid U.S. Troop Withdrawal * [https://m.wsj.net/video/20210701/evchargesplash/ evchargesplash_167x94.jpg] How the EV Industry Is Trying to Fix Its Charging Bottleneck * [https://m.wsj.net/video/20210706/070721jobincentives/ 070721jobincentives_167x94.jpg] Employers Competing for Workers Turn to Signing Bonuses and Freebies * The Wall Street Journal * English Edition + English + Zhong Wen (Chinese) + Ri Ben Yu (Japanese) * + Subscribe Now + Sign In * Back to Top << WSJ Membership * WSJ+ Membership Benefits * Subscription Options * Why Subscribe? * Corporate Subscriptions * Professor Journal * Student Journal * WSJ High School Program * WSJ Amenity Program * Public Library Program * WSJ Live Customer Service * Customer Center * Contact Us Tools & Features * Emails & Alerts * Guides * Topics * My News * RSS Feeds * Video Center * Watchlist * Podcasts Ads * Advertise * Commercial Real Estate Ads * Place a Classified Ad * Sell Your Business * Sell Your Home * Recruitment & Career Ads * Coupons More * About Us * Commercial Partnerships * Content Partnerships * Corrections * Jobs at WSJ * News Archive * Register for Free * Reprints * Buy Issues * Facebook * Twitter * Instagram * YouTube * Podcasts * Snapchat * Google Play * App Store Dow Jones Products * Barron's * BigCharts * Dow Jones Newswires * Factiva * Financial News * Mansion Global * MarketWatch * Private Markets * Risk & Compliance * WSJ Pro * WSJ Video * WSJ Wine * Privacy Notice * Cookie Notice * Do Not Sell My Personal Information * Copyright Policy * Data Policy * Subscriber Agreement & Terms of Use * Your Ad Choices * Copyright (c)2021 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved.