https://oldschool-mtg.blogspot.com/2021/06/the-typesetting-troubles-in-alpha.html Fortsatt till huvudinnehall Leta i den har bloggen [ ] [Sok] Old School Mtg The blag Pages * Blog * Rules * Popular posts * Deck Techs * Decks to Beat * Scryings * About 93/94 Mer... Typesetting Troubles in Alpha * Hamta lank * Facebook * Twitter * Pinterest * E-post * Andra appar juni 04, 2021 [20210603_2] Card templating demand precision and accuracy. If we look back at the history of Magic typesetting, we'll find examples of cards with the wrong text (like Time Elemental in Spanish 4th Edition), cards with text omitted (like Vampire Bats in Chinese 4th Edition), or cards with their text offset incorrectly. [20210603_200244] The right Gaea's Touch has incorrect offset on text and symbols; a fairly common error on this particular card. Another possible typesetting error is accidental printing with the wrong font. The most famous font error in Magic is probably AErathi Berserker from Legends. While it didn't exactly get printed with the wrong font, the letter 'AE' didn't exist in the standard Magic font at the time so it was printed with the first letter of its name omitted. [aerathiber] Reasonably fun fact is that 'AE' exists in the italicized flavor text font. Additional reasonably fun fact is that WotC created a plane called 'Rath' a couple of years later inspired by this error. Notes are typically given to the typesetter on how the card should be set up. But occasionally these notes are missed and the notes themselves end up on the card rather than the symbols they represented. For Magic, this was a particular problem in the Alpha run of Limited Edition. And I can kinda see how it could happen. Before Alpha there was no Magic and the typesetters would have no idea of the rules of the game. The text box would read as gibberish to most, so one might think that "GGGG" is some sort of rules concept rather than a typographical note. [20210603_200202] The reason Force of Nature in Alpha is seventy times cooler than in Beta. [20210603_200044] Unlimited Edition with correct symbols to the left, Alpha with typographical error to the right. We should note that typesetting errors are not the same as basic misspellings or errors in capitalization. Sloppy editing was not that uncommon back in the days, but these things had little to do with the typesetting. [20210603_200527] Black Vise in Alpha, Beta, and Unlimited. All have identical ("correct") typesetting, but a formatting error on capitalization in the rules text. [20210603_200624] Phantasmal Forces in Alpha, Beta, and Unlimited. Here the typesetter failed to replace the 'U' in the text box with a blue mana symbol. This was immediately corrected in the following printings. Having incorrectly mana symbols in text boxes was a thing for all three creatures requiring upkeep mana in Alpha. Here's the last one of those: [20210603_200742] Rad. On many non-land cards colored mana was simply typed out. "Add 3 black mana", "Add 1 white mana", and so on. Text boxes on cards like Mox Ruby, Dark Ritual, and Llanowar Elves might just have added to the confusion for a printing professional looking at the "BBB" note on Demonic Hordes. [20210604_154640] Now one might assume that they missed the notes for all mana symbol in creature text boxes, but they actually got most of them right. All activated ability were written correctly, and on cards like Dragon Whelp they also got it right in the rules text following the ability. [20210603_201312] Yeah, I know the right one is a Beta and not an Alpha. Text box is identical on the two printings though, and I ain't spending no extra effort on an Alpha Whelp unless I get some sweet typographical error action. And while I guess missing a line break and starting the flavor text at the same line as the rules text is kinda blameworthy, that strangeness stayed with the card all the way until 4th Edition. There is however one more creature that failed the typesetting of mana symbols pretty spectacularly. And this is possibly the most Alpha textbox of any creature in the set. I don't own this card in Alpha myself, so please enjoy these stock images. [rockhydra-a] Alpha to the left, Beta to the right. Let's all agree that this text box is pure metal regardless of typesetting shenanigans. "New heads may be grown for RRR apiece". Wizard. The last card where they messed up the mana symbols in the text box was Drain Life. Alpha Drain Life is hence about seventeen times more oldschool than Beta Drain Life. [20210603_201052] The Beta version has identical typesetting to Unlimited (all Beta cards do). If we decide to go rather deep here, we find that most any card that mention colored mana in other contexts than activation costs or adding mana to the mana pool failed to set the symbols correctly. Which leads me to - for the first time in my 27-year Magic history - raising my glass in respect to the rules text on Farmstead. [farmstead] How on Earth did they get this one right? Full disclosure, they also got the notes correct on Stasis and Conversion, but I still think Farmstead is due for some credit here. Apart from mana symbols, there were a couple other typesetting issues in that first batch of cardboard crack. One of them I'm not really sure how it occurred, as the best explanation I've found is that it was "a typographical error ... caused by a global replacement error". What kind of global replacement error leads to this outcome I don't know, but the end result is rad. [20210603_200847] "[E]nchantments on creature are CARD ed." Take that, English language. Our last card today might well be my favorite of the bunch. At least if we go purely on typesetting errors and not how likely I am to sleeve it up. It looks so strange, yet so very readable. This is another card I don't own in Alpha, so here goes stock images: [birdsofparadise] Fun thing is, "//" is a common way in typography to represent a line break. I can see how one might not catch that "GGGG" should be replaced by four green circles with trees, but "//" isn't that cryptic. Not many people can claim to have a playset of Alpha Birds of Paradise, but a good number of the people I know who do view that playset as the crown of their collection, eking out both Juzams and Power on their personal scale of iconic. I've seen people take such a radical pride and joy in their Alpha Birds that it is hard to find comparisons with other cards. The typesetting error help tell a story of a card rushed, a mostly un-tested card made to find use for art that was rejected for a dual land, and that somehow became one of the most recognized and defining creatures in Magic. ... So that's my rant on text-box typesetting errors in Alpha. These are not the only happy little accidents that made it to the set of course; we could easily spend another blogpost on print errors outside the textbox, a third on ambiguous wordings, and a fourth on art miscommunications. But I guess my point is that typesetting is also hard, and that there are a few cards that appear objectively more oldschool in Alpha than in any other set. And that I'm supremely happy with my new Force of Nature. Can't wait to Spirit Link it up and smash face. * Hamta lank * Facebook * Twitter * Pinterest * E-post * Andra appar Kommentarer Skicka en kommentar Anvander Blogger Pages * Blag * About 93/94 * Rules * Scryings * Decks to Beat * Deck Techs * Popular posts Hot hyperlinks * 52-Week Beta * All Tings Considered * Alpha/Beta Oldschool * Argivian Restoration * Baltimore Old School Mtg * Beasts of the Bay * Brothers of Fire UK blog * Deep Spawners * End of turn, draw a card * Eternal Central Old School * Fishliver Oil Cup * French Boars * Geocities of Brass * Gunnarson's Bag * Liga Madrid * Lords of the Pit * Mtg Underground * Music City Old School Mtg * n00bcon homepage * Old School at Gencon * Quantitatively Old School * Ready to Role * Sisters of the Flame * Stockholm in a Bottle * Strictly Average Mtg * The Sentinel * Toronto 93/94 * Understanding Ancestral Recall * Unlimited Adventures * Urborg Buffet * Vintage Magic * Wak-Wak * Wizard's tower Archive * 2021 12 + jun 2021 1 o Typesetting Troubles in Alpha + maj 2021 2 + apr 2021 2 + mar 2021 3 + feb 2021 2 + jan 2021 2 * 2020 28 + dec 2020 3 + nov 2020 2 + okt 2020 3 + sep 2020 3 + aug 2020 2 + jul 2020 3 + jun 2020 2 + maj 2020 2 + apr 2020 2 + mar 2020 3 + feb 2020 1 + jan 2020 2 * 2019 24 + dec 2019 2 + nov 2019 3 + okt 2019 2 + sep 2019 2 + aug 2019 2 + jul 2019 3 + jun 2019 1 + maj 2019 2 + apr 2019 1 + mar 2019 2 + feb 2019 2 + jan 2019 2 * 2018 43 + dec 2018 5 + nov 2018 3 + okt 2018 5 + sep 2018 4 + aug 2018 4 + jul 2018 4 + jun 2018 2 + maj 2018 3 + apr 2018 3 + mar 2018 3 + feb 2018 4 + jan 2018 3 * 2017 29 + dec 2017 3 + nov 2017 3 + okt 2017 3 + sep 2017 2 + aug 2017 1 + jul 2017 2 + jun 2017 2 + maj 2017 4 + apr 2017 2 + mar 2017 3 + feb 2017 3 + jan 2017 1 * 2016 53 + dec 2016 5 + nov 2016 4 + okt 2016 4 + sep 2016 5 + aug 2016 2 + jul 2016 4 + jun 2016 6 + maj 2016 4 + apr 2016 5 + mar 2016 5 + feb 2016 4 + jan 2016 5 * 2015 63 + dec 2015 5 + nov 2015 6 + okt 2015 9 + sep 2015 5 + aug 2015 5 + jul 2015 4 + jun 2015 5 + maj 2015 5 + apr 2015 5 + mar 2015 5 + feb 2015 4 + jan 2015 5 * 2014 58 + dec 2014 5 + nov 2014 6 + okt 2014 4 + sep 2014 5 + aug 2014 5 + jul 2014 4 + jun 2014 6 + maj 2014 6 + apr 2014 7 + mar 2014 4 + feb 2014 3 + jan 2014 3 * 2013 56 + dec 2013 3 + nov 2013 6 + okt 2013 5 + sep 2013 5 + aug 2013 6 + jul 2013 5 + jun 2013 5 + maj 2013 3 + apr 2013 8 + mar 2013 3 + feb 2013 3 + jan 2013 4 * 2012 44 + dec 2012 8 + nov 2012 2 + okt 2012 2 + sep 2012 1 + aug 2012 5 + jun 2012 3 + maj 2012 1 + apr 2012 1 + mar 2012 6 + feb 2012 4 + jan 2012 11 * 2011 7 + dec 2011 7 Visa mer Visa mindre