https://www.zdnet.com/article/new-york-attorney-general-declares-top-isps-committed-net-neutrality-fraud/ * Edition: + Asia + Australia + Europe + India + United Kingdom + United States + ZDNet around the globe: + ZDNet France + ZDNet Germany + ZDNet Korea + ZDNet Japan Search What are you looking for? [ ] Go * Videos * Windows 10 * 5G * Best VPNs * Cloud * Security * AI * more + TR Premium + Working from Home + Innovation + Best Web Hosting + ZDNet Recommends + Tonya Hall Show + Executive Guides + ZDNet Academy + See All Topics + White Papers + Downloads + Reviews + Galleries + Videos + TechRepublic Forums * Newsletters * All Writers * + Preferences + Community + Newsletters + Log Out * * + What are you looking for? [ ] Go * Menu + Videos + Windows 10 + 5G + Best VPNs + Cloud + Security + AI + TR Premium + Working from Home + Innovation + Best Web Hosting + ZDNet Recommends + Tonya Hall Show + Executive Guides + ZDNet Academy + See All Topics + White Papers + Downloads + Reviews + Galleries + Videos + TechRepublic Forums * * + o Preferences o Community o Newsletters o Log Out * us + Asia + Australia + Europe + India + United Kingdom + United States + ZDNet around the globe: + ZDNet France + ZDNet Germany + ZDNet Korea + ZDNet Japan New York Attorney General declares top ISPs committed net neutrality fraud It turns out the FCC's request for comments on net neutrality had been totally spammed by Broadband for America, an ISP lobbying group. * * * * * * * * Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols By Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols for Networking | May 7, 2021 -- 20:42 GMT (13:42 PDT) | Topic: Networking When then-President Donald Trump's Federal Communications Commission (FCC) tried to destroy net neutrality in 2017, everyone knew that millions of comments in favor of breaking net neutrality were bogus. As then-New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman said at the time, two million net neutrality comments were fake. Schneiderman said: "Moving forward with this vote would make a mockery of our public comment process and reward those who perpetrated this fraud to advance their own hidden agenda." Schneiderman was wrong. His successor, Letitia James, found after a multi-year investigation that there had been "18 million fake comments with the FCC," including over 500,000 fake letters sent to Congress in support of the repeal. Featured * Quantum computers could be doing useful work more quickly than everyone thought * This old programming language is suddenly hot again. But its future is still far from certain * The best Peloton alternatives: Top indoor exercise bikes * The best VPN services: Safe and fast don't come free Behind this vast majority of this astroturfing campaign was Broadband for America, a marketing group funded by the country's top ISPs. In classic 1984 doublespeak, it claims to be in favor of net neutrality while, in reality, being a group of its greatest enemies. Its members include AT&T, CenturyLink, Charter, CTIA - The Wireless Association, Comcast, Cox, NCTA - The Internet & Television Association, Telecommunications Industry Association (TIA), and USTelecom-The Broadband Association. James reported: "After a multi-year investigation, we found the nation's largest broadband companies funded a secret campaign to influence the FCC's repeal of net neutrality rules -- resulting in millions of fake public comments impersonating Americans. These illegal schemes are unacceptable." Altogether, 80% of all public FCC comments filed on its net-neutrality proposal four years ago came from the scammers. There was never, as Ajit Pai, then-FCC chairman and a former Verizon attorney claimed at the time, any mass support for destroying net neutrality. Pai, after leaving office, was hired as a partner by private equity firm Searchlight Capital Partners, where he works on telecom and ISP acquisitions. James continued: "The broadband industry hired marketing companies that co-opted and created identities and filed nearly 18 million fake comments with the FCC and sent over half a million fake letters to Congress in support of the repeal. This practice was also used to influence other policies. Today, we stopped three of these marketing companies from continuing their illegal behavior and recommended reforms to stop this type of fraud in the future." MORE ON NET NEUTRALITY * Anti-net neutrality spammers are flooding FCC's pages with fake comments * FCC won't publish evidence of alleged DDoS attack, amid net neutrality battle * Internet and tech giants to stage global net neutrality protest * FCC chairman voted to sell your browsing history -- so we asked to see his * FCC blocks rules that stop internet providers from secretly selling your data These three companies are Fluent, React2Media and Opt-Intelligence. They all settled with the attorney general's office and agreed to pay fines. They did not, however, admit to any wrongdoing. They did agree to get permission from anyone they quote in the future in comments purporting to represent public opinion. These businesses and at least three other companies were paid $4.2 million by Broadband for America. The investigation into this hack of democracy is still ongoing. Where did the fake comments come from? The Office of the New York Attorney General (OAG) found that Broadband for America couldn't rely on real grassroots support since the public overwhelmingly supported robust net neutrality. So, it created them via co-registration lead generation. In coregistration, consumers are offered rewards, such as gift cards, sweepstakes entries, or an e-book, for providing personal information and responding to advertisements. These include everything from discounted children's movies to free trials of products. To conceal the comments' true source, Broadband for America's contractors also created web pages for the conservative-leaning advocacy groups. Few comments, however, were submitted via these web pages. But they gave the impression that comments the FCC received came from Trump supporters. In fairness, it wasn't just the anti-net neutrality forces that generated fake comments. A 19-year-old college student who supported net neutrality filed over 7.7 million pro-neutrality comments with the FCC. Unlike Broadband for America, he didn't use the names and addresses of real people without their consent. Instead, he automatically created comments using software-generated fake names and addresses. The FCC, in theory, should have been able to spot this activity. In practice, it was clueless and didn't detect that millions of submissions were coming from a single IP address. The OAG also identified another group of 1.6 million pro-neutrality comments that were submitted using fictitious identities but hasn't been able to find out where they came from. In the course of the investigation, the OAG found the FCC wasn't the only one being targeted by big business. The OAG found that fraudulent comment campaigns had also targeted policy decisions at the Environmental Protection Agency and the Bureau of Energy Management at the US Department of the Interior. Looking ahead, the OAG recommends several reforms to root out the deception and fraud that have infected public policy-making. These are * Advocacy groups to take steps to ensure they have obtained valid consent from an individual before submitting a comment or message to the government on their behalf * Agencies and legislatures that manage electronic systems that receive comments and messages to hold advocacy groups and their vendors more accountable for the comments they submit on behalf of individuals * Lawmakers to strengthen laws to deter the submission of deceptive and unauthorized comments to the government * Agencies to adopt technical safeguards to protect against unauthorized bulk submissions using automation. Hopefully, all these changes will happen sooner than later. Democracy has enough trouble as it without businesses pretending to be millions of citizens. Related Stories: * President Biden's FCC appointment is a big step toward net neutrality's return * Zero-rating: Another way of poisoning net neutrality * We need more broadband internet than ever with Covid keeping us at home * FCC chairman Ajit Pai out, net neutrality back in Related Topics: Government Cloud Internet of Things Security Data Centers * * * * * * * * Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols By Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols for Networking | May 7, 2021 -- 20:42 GMT (13:42 PDT) | Topic: Networking Show Comments LOG IN TO COMMENT * My Profile * Log Out | Community Guidelines Join Discussion Add Your Comment Add Your Comment More from Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols * [][istock-1167770131] Enterprise Software Linux's Technical Advisory Board reports on the UMN 'Hypocrite Commits' patches * [][image-8] Virtualization New Relic open sources Pixie, its Kubernetes-native in-cluster observability platform * [][richard-m-stallman] Enterprise Software The Free Software Foundation reveals how RMS was re-elected and its future * [][shutterstock-1272369802] E-Commerce Shopify joins the Open Invention Network Linux patent protection group Please review our terms of service to complete your newsletter subscription. [ ] By registering, you agree to the Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices outlined in the Privacy Policy. You will also receive a complimentary subscription to the ZDNet's Tech Update Today and ZDNet Announcement newsletters. You may unsubscribe from these newsletters at any time. [ ] You agree to receive updates, alerts, and promotions from the CBS family of companies - including ZDNet's Tech Update Today and ZDNet Announcement newsletters. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to receive the selected newsletter(s) which you may unsubscribe from at any time. You also agree to the Terms of Use and acknowledge the data collection and usage practices outlined in our Privacy Policy. Continue Newsletters See All See All Related Stories * 1 of 3 * * [][vocus-network-map] Vocus turning to sovereignty as its competitive advantage Australian carrier sees benefits in being onshore and selling itself to a local consortium. * [][2] Best security system in 2021: Secure your home or business ZDNet has brought together the best options on the market this year, from DIY kits to full smart home setups. * [][cloudflare] Cloudflare surges as Q1 revenue tops expectations, outlook higher as well Cloudlfare said it had more than 4 million customer's in Q1. * [][210505-service-mesh-005] Rolling the dice on network slicing: Kubernetes sparks a rethink of 5G edge The problem with distributed computing, as with distributed anything, is finding the appropriate system of governance. A management model for distributed computing may be emerging, ... * [][telco-5g-mobile-tower] TPG Telecom to invite customers onto 5G fixed wireless in June TPG CEO boasts the telco's network has been built for video as it prepares for invite-only 5G home service. * [][gettyimages-1176148198] Budget 2021: Regional Connectivity Program gets second round and extra AU$130m pot Prior to the national Budget due on Tuesday, the Commonwealth has announced it will plough an extra AU$130 million into the Regional Connectivity Program. ... * [][bushfire-gettyimages-11] Budget 2021: Bushfire-prone urban fringes to get AU$16.4m in mobile network grants The Commonwealth to boost mobile funding on urban fridges and will hand ACMA AU$4.2 million to oversee the News Bargaining Code. * [][tiktok-logo] Fastly plunges: Q1 results miss expectations, CFO stepping down Fastly said it will search for a replacement will CFO Adriel Lares stays on for a transitionary period. * [][istock-1204762248] Juniper's new security portal aims to ease the move to a SASE architecture The new Security Director Cloud is designed to help organizations transition to SASE without undercutting their existing security deployments. ZDNet Connect with us (c) 2021 ZDNET, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Privacy Policy | Cookie Settings | Advertise | Terms of Use * Topics * Galleries * Videos * Sponsored Narratives * Do Not Sell My Information * About ZDNet * Meet The Team * All Authors * RSS Feeds * Site Map * Reprint Policy * Manage | Log Out * Join | Log In * Membership * Newsletters * Site Assistance * ZDNet Academy * TechRepublic Forums