https://www.latimes.com/opinion/la-xpm-2012-jul-13-la-ol-blowback-pscyhology-science-20120713-story.html * Business * California * Climate & Environment * Entertainment & Arts * En Espanol * Food * Housing & Homelessness * Image * Lifestyle * Obituaries * Opinion * Politics * Science * Sports * Travel * World & Nation * All Sections * _________________ * Newsletters * Photography * Podcasts * Video * _________________ * About Us + About Us + Archives + Company News + eNewspaper + For the Record + Got a Tip? + L.A. Times Careers + L.A. Times Store + L.A. Times Studios + News App: Apple IOS + News App: Google Play + Newsroom Directory + Reprints, Rights & Permissions + About Us + Archives + Company News + eNewspaper + For the Record + Got a Tip? + L.A. Times Careers + L.A. Times Store + L.A. Times Studios + News App: Apple IOS + News App: Google Play + Newsroom Directory + Reprints, Rights & Permissions * Advertising + Place an Ad + Classifieds + Coupons + People on the Move + Find/Post Jobs + Local Ads Marketplace + Media Kit: Why the L.A. Times? + Hot Property Sections + Place an Open House + Sotheby's International Realty + Place an Ad + Classifieds + Coupons + People on the Move + Find/Post Jobs + Local Ads Marketplace + Media Kit: Why the L.A. Times? + Hot Property Sections + Place an Open House + Sotheby's International Realty * Bestcovery * B2B Publishing * Business Visionaries * Hot Property * Crossword & Games * L.A. Times Events * L.A. Times Store * Subscriptions + Manage Subscription + EZPAY + Delivery Issue + eNewspaper + Students & Educators + Subscribe + Subscriber Terms + Manage Subscription + EZPAY + Delivery Issue + eNewspaper + Students & Educators + Subscribe + Subscriber Terms Copyright (c) 2021, Los Angeles Times | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | CA Notice of Collection | Do Not Sell My Personal Information Sections * California * Entertainment * Sports * Food * Climate * Opinion * | * Place an Ad * Coupons * Crossword * eNewspaper Show Search [ ]Search Query Submit Search Advertisement * Facebook * Twitter * Show more sharing options Share Close extra sharing options * Facebook * Twitter * LinkedIn * Email * Copy Link URLCopied! * Print Opinion Why psychology isn't science By Alex B. Berezow July 13, 2012 12 AM PT * Facebook * Twitter * Show more sharing options Share Close extra sharing options * Facebook * Twitter * LinkedIn * Email * Copy Link URLCopied! * Print Psychologist Timothy D. Wilson, a professor at the University of Virginia, expressed resentment in his Times Op-Ed article on Thursday over the fact that most scientists don't consider his field a real science. He casts scientists as condescending bullies: "Once, during a meeting at my university, a biologist mentioned that he was the only faculty member present from a science department. When I corrected him, noting that I was from the Department of Psychology, he waved his hand dismissively, as if I were a Little Leaguer telling a member of the New York Yankees that I too played baseball. "There has long been snobbery in the sciences, with the 'hard' ones (physics, chemistry, biology) considering themselves to be more legitimate than the 'soft' ones (psychology, sociology)." The dismissive attitude scientists have toward psychologists isn't rooted in snobbery; it's rooted in intellectual frustration. It's rooted in the failure of psychologists to acknowledge that they don't have the same claim on secular truth that the hard sciences do. It's rooted in the tired exasperation that scientists feel when non-scientists try to pretend they are scientists. Advertisement That's right. Psychology isn't science. Why can we definitively say that? Because psychology often does not meet the five basic requirements for a field to be considered scientifically rigorous: clearly defined terminology, quantifiability, highly controlled experimental conditions, reproducibility and, finally, predictability and testability. Happiness research is a great example of why psychology isn't science. How exactly should "happiness" be defined? The meaning of that word differs from person to person and especially between cultures. What makes Americans happy doesn't necessarily make Chinese people happy. How does one measure happiness? Psychologists can't use a ruler or a microscope, so they invent an arbitrary scale. Today, personally, I'm feeling about a 3.7 out of 5. How about you? The failure to meet the first two requirements of scientific rigor (clear terminology and quantifiability) makes it almost impossible for happiness research to meet the other three. How can an experiment be consistently reproducible or provide any useful predictions if the basic terms are vague and unquantifiable? And when exactly has there ever been a reliable prediction made about human behavior? Making useful predictions is a vital part of the scientific process, but psychology has a dismal record in this regard. Just ask a foreign policy or intelligence analyst. To be fair, not all psychology research is equally wishy-washy. Some research is far more scientifically rigorous. And the field often yields interesting and important insights. But to claim it is "science" is inaccurate. Actually, it's worse than that. It's an attempt to redefine science. Science, redefined, is no longer the empirical analysis of the natural world; instead, it is any topic that sprinkles a few numbers around. This is dangerous because, under such a loose definition, anything can qualify as science. And when anything qualifies as science, science can no longer claim to have a unique grasp on secular truth. That's why scientists dismiss psychologists. They're rightfully defending their intellectual turf. ALSO: Advertisement Vernon's bad choices Daum: The GOP's Palin hangover Secure Communities: The Trust Act fix Alex B. Berezow is the editor of RealClearScience.com, where this piece originally appeared. He has a doctorate in microbiology. Advertisement --------------------------------------------------------------------- Opinion Newsletter A cure for the common opinion Get thought-provoking perspectives with our weekly newsletter. Enter email address [ ] Sign Me Up You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times. More From the Los Angeles Times * Opinion Second Opinion: How to change an American medical system that harms Black maternal health photo illustration of a pregnant woman silhouette Opinion Second Opinion: How to change an American medical system that harms Black maternal health We need to end a culture of obstetric racism that has resulted in a maternal mortality rate for Black women that is around three times that of white women. More Coverage Video: Saving the lives of Black mothers * Opinion Op-Ed: As a 12-year-old, I defied the KKK to comfort Freedom Riders injured in a firebombing Freedom Riders on a Greyhound bus sponsored by the Congress Of Racial Equality (CORE) in 1961. Opinion Op-Ed: As a 12-year-old, I defied the KKK to comfort Freedom Riders injured in a firebombing Sixty years ago, a preteen white girl in Alabama tended to Freedom Riders after their bus was firebombed. Her life would never be the same. * Opinion Letters to the Editor: My district is pulling its weight on homelessness, says Councilman John Lee John Lee, a Republican who worked for the last councilman to hold the seat, campaigned on his long history in the district and billed himself as a fiscal conservative who would be a " different voice " on a City Council dominated by Democrats. Opinion Letters to the Editor: My district is pulling its weight on homelessness, says Councilman John Lee City Councilman John Lee responds to a Times editorial on his motion to withdraw city funding from a homeless housing project. * Opinion Letters to the Editor: Biden deserves to be heralded as another FDR if he succeeds President Joe Biden speaks with the Interstate 10 Calcasieu River Bridge behind him, Thursday, May 6, 2021, in Lake Charles, La. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon) Opinion Letters to the Editor: Biden deserves to be heralded as another FDR if he succeeds President Biden's massive spending proposals have the support of most Americans, even though GOP lawmakers oppose them. Subscribers Are Reading * USC Sports USC's Song Girls project a glamorous ideal; 10 women describe a different, toxic reality USC song girls Josie Bullen (far right) and Adrianna Robakowski (second from right). USC Sports USC's Song Girls project a glamorous ideal; 10 women describe a different, toxic reality Ten former USC Song Girls described to The Times a toxic culture within the famed collegiate dance team that included longtime former coach Lori Nelson rebuking women publicly for their eating habits, personal appearance and sex lives. More Coverage Pictures: USC Song Girls through the years * California Column One: The pandemic shaped my family for generations. Not COVID -- the 1918 flu Sarah and Max Landsburg wedding, Dec. 1912. California Column One: The pandemic shaped my family for generations. Not COVID -- the 1918 flu "My father died in the 1918 flu," my dad told me. Only later did we learn how the pandemic created enduring family secrets and mysteries. * California Drones show California's great white sharks are closer -- and more common -- than you think [gif] California Drones show California's great white sharks are closer -- and more common -- than you think This Malibu photographer captures images of great white sharks along the Southern California coast, many just feet from unknowing swimmers and surfers. * Company Town Top Hollywood talent agency accused of tolerating sexual harassment, misconduct Illustration of talent agent wearing superhero cape with female silhouette Company Town Top Hollywood talent agency accused of tolerating sexual harassment, misconduct Current and former employees of ICM Partners allege that the talent agency tolerated harassment and misconduct toward women and people of color. * Music A homeless L.A. musician helped create a Daft Punk classic. So why hasn't he seen a dime? LOS ANGELES, CA - MARCH 01: Eddie Johns, the '70s soul and funk bandleader sits for a portrait at his home on Monday, March 1, 2021 in Los Angeles, CA. (Brian van der Brug / Los Angeles Times) Music A homeless L.A. musician helped create a Daft Punk classic. So why hasn't he seen a dime? Daft Punk sampled Eddie Johns' "More Spell on You" on their hit "One More Time." Johns, who has struggled with homelessness, was never paid or credited. Advertisement Latest Opinion * Opinion Letters to the Editor: California, stop divvying up water like it's the Little Ice Age OROVILLE, CALIFORNIA - APRIL 27: Trees burned by the recent Bear Fire line the steep banks of Lake Oroville where water levels are low on April 27, 2021 in Oroville, California. Four years after then California Gov. Jerry Brown signed an executive order to lift the California's drought emergency, the state has re-entered a drought emergency with water levels dropping in the state's reservoirs. Water levels at Lake Oroville have dropped to 42 percent of its 3,537,577 acre-foot capacity. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images) Opinion Letters to the Editor: California, stop divvying up water like it's the Little Ice Age California's water policies were instituted at a time we now know was unusually wet for the area. It's time to stop using water as if we were not in a new, drier era. * Opinion Column: The war is on for control of Congress -- but California tied its hands behind its back FILE - In this March 5, 2021, file photo The Capitol is seen just before sunrise in Washington. The state across the South are the center of the upcoming once-a-decade redistricting battle. The region is the fastest-growing in the country and as a result will be adding an estimated half-a-dozen House seats. (AP Photo/ Carolyn Kaster, File) Opinion Column: The war is on for control of Congress -- but California tied its hands behind its back The state took the high road reforming its redistricting process. But now it will have one fewer tool in the battle to keep Democrats in power. * Opinion Op-Ed: After Eli Broad, how will we remake Los Angeles? Schaben, Allen J. -- B58972168Z.1 LOS ANGELES, CA JAN. 6, 2011: Philanthropist Eli Broad unveils the architectural designs for The Broad Art Foundation's new contemporary art museum called "The Broad" on Grand Avenue in downtown Los Angeles. Designed by architects Diller Scofidio & Renfro, the three-story museum features a porous honeycomb "veil" that wraps the building and is visible through an expansive, top floor sky-lit gallery that will be hoe to works of contemporary art drawn from the 2,000-piece Broad Collections. ( Allen J. Schaben / Los Angeles Times Opinion Op-Ed: After Eli Broad, how will we remake Los Angeles? Eli Broad envisioned Grand Avenue as DTLA's Champs-Elysees. Instead it may be a memorial to an urbanism of big gestures that is passing into history. * Opinion Op-Ed: NFTs are digital tulip fever: Would you pay thousands for a bar code? ONE-TIME USE - OP-ED - MAY 2021 Beeple (b. 1981), EVERYDAYS: THE FIRST 5000 DAYS 21,069 x 21,069 pixels (319,168,313 bytes) Minted on 16 February 2021. This work is unique. Image obtained by Susan Brenneman from Christie's with permission to publish in the specific op-ed piece on May 9, 2021. Per Christie's: "BEEPLE'S FIRST 5000 DAYS THE FIRST PURELY DIGITAL NFT-BASED WORK OF ART OFFERED BY A MAJOR AUCTION HOUSE ACHIEVES $69,346,250 IN A CHRISTIE'S ONLINE ONLY SALE BECOMES THE THIRD MOST VALUABLE WORK BY A LIVING ARTIST SOLD AT AUCTION. 22 MILLION VISITORS TUNED INTO CHRISTIES.COM FOR THE FINAL MINUTES OF BIDDING BIDDERS FROM 11 COUNTRIES" Opinion Op-Ed: NFTs are digital tulip fever: Would you pay thousands for a bar code? Nonfungible tokens are a dressed-up species of bookkeeping. But what art needs is less auditing and more ecstasy. * Opinion Op-Ed: How anti-democratic politics make India's COVID calamity worse Multiple funeral pyres of victims of COVID-19 burn at a ground that has been converted into a crematorium for mass cremation in New Delhi, India, Saturday, April 24, 2021. Indian authorities are scrambling to get medical oxygen to hospitals where COVID-19 patients are suffocating from low supplies. The effort Saturday comes as the country with the world's worst coronavirus surge set a new global daily record of infections for the third straight day. The 346,786 infections over the past day brought India's total past 16 million. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri) Opinion Op-Ed: How anti-democratic politics make India's COVID calamity worse Narendra Modi's suppression of dissent has brought India to its knees and tens of thousands of Indians to their deathbeds. Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Los Angeles Times A California Times publication Subscribe for unlimited access Follow Us * twitter * instagram * youtube * facebook * + eNewspaper + Coupons + Find/Post Jobs + Place an Ad + Media Kit: Why the L. A. Times? + Bestcovery * + Crossword + Sudoku + Obituaries + Recipes + Smart Speakers + Wine Club * + About/Contact + For the Record + L.A. Times Careers + Manage Subscription + Reprints and Permissions + Site Map Copyright (c) 2021, Los Angeles Times | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | CA Notice of Collection | Do Not Sell My Personal Information