https://nautil.us/issue/99/universality/the-vast-viral-world-what-we-know-and-dont-know * * [p] Nautilus [nautilus-l] * Issues * Topics * Coronavirus * Blog * Thanks for Joining the Newsletter * * * Login * Subscribe SELECT NEWSLETTERS AND SUBMIT CONTACT DETAILS... * [*]New chapters Thursdays Nautilus publishes a new chapter of feature stories on its monthly theme, every Thursday. Sign up to this list to stay up to date on [ ] the latest and greatest. [ ] [Submit] * [*]Editor's picks Sundays Read about the Nautilus stories and blogs we've been thinking about over the past week. [ ] * * * Universal_THUMB Issue 099 Universality Mind_THUMB Issue 098 Mind Wonder_THUMB Issue 097 Wonder Rewired_THUMB Issue 096 Rewired Escape_THUMB Issue 095 Escape Evolving_THUMB Issue 094 Evolving Forerunners_THUMB Issue 093 Forerunners Frontiers_THUMB Issue 092 Frontiers AmazeBrain_THUMB Issue 091 The Amazing Brain SomethingGreen_THUMB Issue 090 Something Green DarkSide_THUMB Issue 089 The Dark Side Love-Sex_THUMB Issue 088 Love & Sex * Risk_THUMB Issue 087 Risk Energy_THUMB Issue 086 Energy Reopen_THUMB Issue 085 Reopening Outbreak_THUMB Issue 084 Outbreak Intelligence_THUMB Issue 083 Intelligence Panpyschism_THUMB Issue 082 Panpsychism Maps_THUMB Issue 081 Maps Scharf_TH Issue 080 Aliens Catalysts_THUMB Issue 079 Catalysts Atmospheres_THUMB Issue 078 Atmospheres Underworlds_THUMB Issue 077 Underworlds Language_THUMB Issue 076 Language * Story_THUMB Issue 075 Story Networks_THUMB Issue 074 Networks Play_THUMB Issue 073 Play Quandary_THUMB Issue 072 Quandary Flow_Curtain-THUMB Issue 071 Flow Variables_THUMB Issue 070 Variables Patterns_THUMB Issue 069 Patterns Context_THUMB Issue 068 Context Reboot_THUMB Issue 067 Reboot Clockwork_THUMB Issue 066 Clockwork Curtain_THUMB Issue 065 In Plain Sight Unseen_THUMB-F Issue 064 The Unseen * Horizons_THUMB Issue 063 Horizons Systems_THUMB Issue 062 Systems Coordinates_THUMB-2 Issue 061 Coordinates Searches_CURTAIN_THUMB Issue 060 Searches Connections_THUMB Issue 059 Connections Self_Curtain_HERO Issue 058 Self Community-THUMB Issue 057 Communities Curtain_THUMB Issue 056 Perspective Trust_HERO Issue 055 Trust Unspoken_CURTAIN_THUMB Issue 054 The Unspoken Monsters_Curtain_THUMB Issue 053 Monsters Hive_Curtain_THUMB Issue 052 The Hive * Limits_Curtain_THUMB-2 Issue 051 Limits Emergence_THUMB Issue 050 Emergence Absurd_THUMB-F Issue 049 The Absurd Chaos_THUMB Issue 048 Chaos 047_TH-2 Issue 047 Consciousness Balance_CURTAIN-THUMB Issue 046 Balance Power_TH_2 Issue 045 Power Luck_TH-2 Issue 044 Luck Heroes_TH-1 Issue 043 Heroes Fakes_TH Issue 042 Fakes Selection-TH-1 Issue 041 Selection LEARNING_TH-2 Issue 040 Learning * Sport_THUMB-2 Issue 039 Sport Noise_THUMB Issue 038 Noise Currents_TH-3 Issue 037 Currents Aging_THUMB Issue 036 Aging Boundaries_THUMB-preview Issue 035 Boundaries Adaptation_CURTAIN_THUMB Issue 034 Adaptation Attraction_THUMB-F. Issue 033 Attraction Space_TH. Issue 032 Space Stress_THUMB Issue 031 Stress Identity_TH-1 Issue 030 Identity 029_Scaling_TH-2 Issue 029 Scaling 028_THUMB Issue 028 2050 * 027_THUMB_F1 Issue 027 Dark Matter 026_CURTAIN_THUMB Issue 026 Color 025-Water_THUMB Issue 025 Water 024_THUMB-F. Issue 024 Error 023-THUMB-1 Issue 023 Dominoes 022_THUMB-2 Issue 022 Slow Information_THUMB-1 Issue 021 Information 020_Creativity_THUMB-v2 Issue 020 Creativity SP_Nature_THUMB Special Issue In Our Nature 019_THUMB Issue 019 Illusions 018_THUMB_1 Issue 018 Genius Cover_THUMB Issue 017 Big Bangs * 16_THUMB. Issue 016 Nothingness 015_THUMB Issue 015 Turbulence 14_THUMB Issue 014 Mutation Issue13_THUMB Issue 013 Symmetry 012_THUMB Issue 012 Feedback 011_THUMB Issue 011 Light See Issue Library Enter Search Below... [ ] Search TRENDING TOPIC Science Practice [14783_7a60] Does Theranos Mark the Peak of the Silicon Valley Bubble? Aerodynamics Aliens Animals Anthropology Archaeology Architecture Art Artificial Intelligence Astronomy Chemistry Climate Cognitive Science Computer Science Cryptography Earth Science Economics Education Environment Evolution Fiction Fine Art Food Genetics Health History Information Theory Insects Linguistics Literature Math Memoir Microbiology Mortality Music Neuroscience Oceanography Paleontology Philosophy Physics Physiology Psychology Reproduction Science Practice Sociology Technology The Web MOST POPULAR Does Theranos Mark the Peak of the Silicon Valley Bubble? The Smaller the Theater, the Faster the Music What Time Feels Like When You're Improvising A New View of Time She'll Text Me, She'll Text Me Not When Bad Things Happen in Slow Motion How I Taught My Computer to Write Its Own Music Is Artificial Intelligence Permanently Inscrutable? We Need to Save Ignorance From AI The Trouble with Theories of Everything The Strange Brain of the World's Greatest Solo Climber Why You Feel the Urge to Jump Resume Reading -- The Vast Viral World: What We Know (and Don't Know) Close Nautilus Biology Microbiology The Vast Viral World: What We Know (and Don't Know) Exploring the minuscule and mysterious world of viruses. Lauren E. Oakes By Lauren E. Oakes Illustration by Bryce Gladfelter April 7, 2021 * Add a comment * Facebook * Twitter * Email * Sharing * Reddit * Stumbleupon * Tumblr * Pocket Slightly ovoid in shape and somewhat blurred at the edges, the black splotches were scattered across a mottled gray background, looking...By Lauren E. Oakes Slightly ovoid in shape and somewhat blurred at the edges, the black splotches were scattered across a mottled gray background, looking much like a postmodern painting. At a meeting of the Medical Society of Berlin in 1938, Helmut Ruska, a German physician and biologist, was presenting the first images ever seen of virus particles. The splotches were members of the poxvirus family, specifically ectromelia, visualized directly in the lymph fluids of infected mice. Thanks to the invention of the electron microscope, then known as the Ubermikroscop, scientists could finally observe--actually see--what was already known to exist: the minuscule and mysterious world of viruses. Ruska's brother, Ernst, a physicist, had built the first prototype of the instrument while completing his Ph.D., but Helmut saw the device's potential application to the field of biology. Helmut and his colleagues went on to gather nearly 2,000 black-and-white images by the end of 1939. Their collection included a variety of pathogens known to infect humans and plants, including the variola virus (which causes smallpox) and tobacco mosaic virus ( the first virus ever discovered). Simple in structure but advanced in function, viruses exist in a category that lies between the inert and the living. Just over 80 years later, scientists published the first images of SARS-CoV-2, the novel virus that causes COVID-19. To reveal its iconic spike protein, they used an instrument similar to Ruska's. The black-and-white images visually confirmed that this was a member of the coronavirus family, enabling scientists around the world to begin drawing upon existing knowledge of such viruses from years of prior research. Scientists were able to directly observe this new virus soon after a cluster of patients in China was diagnosed in late December 2019 with a pneumonia of unknown cause. By March 2020, COVID-19 had been declared a pandemic by the World Health Organization. Events moved far more slowly in previous pandemics. The Black Death pandemic in the mid 1300s killed more than one-third of Europe's population in four years, without anyone knowing what caused it. By the time of the 1918 flu pandemic, scientists understood the disease's cause but couldn't see the virus or test for it. When SARS-CoV-2 emerged, the value of basic science research conducted many decades earlier became quickly evident in the form of innovative tools for virus detection. Researchers can now sequence novel viruses and study their genomes, but even so the electron microscope continues to offer a unique "open" view of such pathogens. "You can't really argue with a picture," says Cynthia Goldsmith, who uses electron microscopy to identify pathogens for the U.S. Centers for Disease Control. "This technology allows us to see not only how the virus looks but also how it grows in the cell." Although Goldsmith has identified so many viruses over the years that she can't even guess the number, the viruses she's examined are limited to those already known to cause disease--and those that primarily infect people. But scientists estimate that 1.67 million yet-to-be discovered viral species exist in mammal and bird hosts. Bats, for example, teem with new strains of coronaviruses. There may be more viruses than there are stars in the universe. Basic science research being conducted today will play a critical role in helping us to understand their past, present, and future--and better prepare us for the emergence of still more novel viruses. Sapolsky_TH-F1 Also in Microbiology Infected Monkeys and Other Cautionary Tales From the Biolab By Yvonne Bang On May 27th, the Pentagon admitted that it had shipped live anthrax to facilities in multiple U.S. states, and to a U.S. airbase in South Korea--by accident. Anthrax is usually kept in highly secure biolabs with multiply redundant safeguards. But...READ MORE "Scientists and public health officials have spent a lot of time thinking about when and where the next pandemic will emerge," says Laura Bloomfield of Stanford University. "But what we've learned is that the likelihood of predicting that precisely is very low. We need to put the structures in place to prepare and respond but also to prevent future outbreaks in the first place." That will mean engaging in more basic science research. It will mean not only discovering and sequencing more viruses, but also investing in research that will improve our ability to understand the structures of viruses, how they interact with their hosts, and how they have evolved through history. In addition, preparing for the next pandemic will also mean focusing more on human behavior and repairing our relationship with nature. Activities such as clearing native forests for industrial forestry or agriculture, expanding human settlement or land use into intact ecosystems, and trading wildlife greatly increase the chances of another catastrophic outbreak. The discovery of viruses In Ruska's day, researchers used the term "filterable infectious agents" to describe viruses. Experimentation had revealed that these tiny entities, invisible to the naked eye, were capable of passing through filters that caught and retained bacteria and other microorganisms. Coined from a Latin word meaning "slimy liquid," "potent juice," or "poison," the term "virus" was applied to agents both tiny enough to pass through filters and unable to reproduce without the aid of a living host--plant or animal. Martinus Beijerinck, a Dutch microbiologist and botanist, demonstrated that viruses cause disease by experimenting with sap from sickly tobacco-plant leaves during the 19th century. He was one of the first scientists to show that an entity too small to be detected by a light microscope is capable of infecting plants. Beijerinck's application of freshly extracted sap from sick plants produced spots on the leaves of healthy plants; the more sap he applied, the worse the symptoms--including malformed leaves. He called the sap from the sick plants contagium vivum fluidum (contagious living fluid). He noted it was "drawn into the growth of dividing cells," meaning it required other life (plant cells, in this case) to reproduce. Beijerinck's discovery of this liquid poison capable of infecting other plants laid the foundation for our ability, today, to identify new viruses, decipher their morphology (their structure), and use this information to develop treatments against the diseases they cause. But it also biased our popular perception of viruses as solely pathogenic--that is, capable of causing illness. In most cases, viruses don't cause disease, and many are beneficial. They shape our life, for better or worse, with some viruses posing health threats but many others serving helpful functions. [18333_aea93b39fbf6af64f5785c9514c1ef39] How viruses shape life Simple in structure but advanced in function, viruses exist in a category that lies between the inert and the living. Some biologists think of them as quasi-alive, while others refer to them as inanimate tiny particles or arrangements of matter. But experts agree they are like vines wrapping around the tree of life; their existence involves symbiosis, an intimate association between two forms of life. Viruses can reproduce only inside living cells. Even at our healthiest, our bodies are home to trillions of viruses, maybe more. There, they are most "alive," as their genetic material penetrates into their host's cells and turns them into virus-making factories. "Think of a virus and a cell together as a microscopic copy machine," explains Sarah Olson, a disease ecologist with the Wildlife Conservation Society's Health Program. "The virus uses existing entry points to get into the cell--and when it enters, it's carrying instructions to take over the cell's machinery and make copies of itself. Then off it goes to the next." "Giruses" may be the descendants of cells from deep time, but others suggest that they may constitute a fourth dimension of life. A virus replicates through a series of steps, first attaching to a host cell and injecting its genetic material, then incorporating itself into the cell's genetic material as the cell churns out more viruses. Once the viral information becomes integrated into a host's genome, that information becomes part of the host and can be passed across generations. Indeed, approximately 8 percent of the human genome comes from viral genes, which means we've evolved along with viruses and will continue doing so. In fact, without viruses, humans and other mammals might still be laying eggs. At some point during evolution, the protein syncytin, which is essential for the formation of the placenta, came from a retrovirus infection. We also know that viruses can keep bacteria from invading our gut and causing infections. Like other living creatures, viruses also carry out a Darwinian mission: They aim to increase in number as much as possible, to extend their geographic boundaries, and to survive across time. That is exactly what SARS-CoV-2 is doing now, even as vaccines roll out and new variants are identified. But the past is still important. As Michael Emerman, a biologist at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in Seattle, says, the motivation for studying ancient events in the evolutionary history of viruses is to better understand pressing modern challenges. The origins of viruses and why their history matters Patterns that have emerged from basic research on the origins of viruses and their evolution may help inform our preparedness for future pandemics. "You'd like to have a single explanation for the origins of all current viruses," says Julia Durzynska, a biologist at Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznan, Poland, who has written about viral evolution. "Instead, there are three dominant models that seem to complete each other." The so-called "virus-first" model suggests that at the dawn of life, very simple forms of viruses existed before cells. The ancient ancestors of modern viruses may have provided raw material for the development of cellular life. If this model were true for all viruses in the world today, it would mean that they all evolved from a few viral ancestors. In some ways, that would make identifying new viruses and developing vaccines or treatments easier--scientists could take what they know about one virus and use it as a starting point to understand its relatives. The second so-called "escape" or progressive model of viral origins suggests that viruses arise from genetic elements that escape from the genes of larger organisms. Bacteriophages (viruses that infect bacteria), for example, would come from bits of bacterial genetic material. So according to this model, not all viruses come from deep time--that is, early in the immense arc of the earth's history, before any multicellular life existed. The third model, known as the "reduction" model, is based on a hypothesis that viruses were once larger, free-living organisms. Over time, it is believed that they lost their genetic information and ended up smaller and unable to reproduce alone. But they managed to sustain their existence by replicating in the cells of other organisms. The discovery most commonly interpreted as evidence for this model is that of the mimivirus--the first "giant virus," which was initially isolated in 2003. How giant viruses expanded our view of the viral world Twenty-five years ago, David Wessner, now a biologist at Davidson College, was a postdoctoral scholar on a research team that was studying coronaviruses. His work involved examining their spike proteins--prongs protruding from the viruses' exterior--and determining how they interacted with cells. "A lot of that basic research set the stage for the response when COVID-19 emerged," says Wessner, "and the same could end up being true for basic research on giant viruses. We haven't yet identified any giant viruses that affect human health dramatically, but that could change." What would later be named a mimivirus was first observed during an investigation of a 1992 pneumonia outbreak in England. Bernard La Scola, a microbiologist at Aix-Marseille Universite in France, led a multiyear effort to isolate the unknown entity and examine its structure. He had a friend who at the time was working with electron microscopy. "I gave him a sample," says La Scola. "I asked him if he could look at this curious matter and told him that I had no idea what it was.'" La Scola says that when he first saw the resulting image, he wasn't thinking about a giant virus. "It was only after I looked at the scale that I realized it was too big to be a virus. And so we began our study with that." La Scola and his colleagues knew they had isolated something new. Viruses aim to increase in number as much as possible, to extend their geographic boundaries, and to survive across time. Ultimately, the discovery of the mimivirus (Acanthamoeba polyphaga) --and later the mamavirus and then the even larger pandoravirus --stretched the human perception of what it means to be a virus, given their relative size and genetic complexity. Some scientists think these "giruses" may be the descendants of cells from deep time, while others suggest that they may constitute a fourth dimension of life, distinct from the archaea, bacteria, and eukaryote domains that make up the tree of life model. La Scola doesn't engage much in the debates regarding the origins of viruses in deep time; he focuses instead on isolating and identifying new viruses. Over the years, he and his students have received funding from various sources, including his university, the Mediterranee Infection Foundation, and the French Ministry of Health, but La Scola says most of his work on giant viruses has been unfunded. It has benefited from the funding he's received for other, more applied projects--and from his and others' keen interest and persistence. Today, though giant viruses aren't known to affect human health dramatically, La Scola points warily to Asfivirus, the African swine fever virus. It transmits from ticks to pigs and between pigs. It causes hemorrhagic fever and is closely related to a giant virus that La Scola and his team isolated in Marseille from sewage. "It's an example of genome reduction, because it lost about two-thirds of its genome," he says. "And now this giant virus is probably the agent of hemorrhagic fever in vertebrates--the pigs." The virus may have come from a larger organism and evolved to cause illness. It happened once, so it could happen again--perhaps in people. In 2020, La Scola and his colleagues published a paper on the puzzling origins of another novel virus--the Yaravirus. When they sequenced the virus to decipher its genetic information, they realized that some of the genes looked similar to those found in giant viruses, but they couldn't figure out how or whether the Yaravirus was related to them. None of its genes matched any sequences of known organisms. It was completely new--a virus of dark matter, characterized by unique genetic information. Such dark matter, a vast abyss, is evidence of a viral world we must come to understand better. The role of human behavior In intact ecosystems like healthy forests, viruses and their wild hosts have long interacted in a delicate balance with each other. When humans intrude on what scientists call an "existing disease ecology network," they often expose themselves to unfamiliar viruses. Similarly, taking wild animals out of a forest and transporting them to commercial markets also exposes humans to novel viruses. Looking ahead, humans' entanglement with the viral world will be shaped in part by "the edge"--that is, the degraded habitats where people and wildlife interact and exchange pathogens. "There's a related metric: edge density," says Bloomfield. Edge density refers to the shape and extent of fragmentation in a landscape where humans carry out their daily activities. Cutting trees, building roads, and expanding urban settlements are all activities that can cause such fragmentation. Environmental degradation creates more "edges" between humans and animal habitats and thus more possibilities that people may come into contact with viruses to which they previously haven't been exposed. Bloomfield studies how modifying landscapes encourages interactions between people and wildlife and affects infectious disease emergence. Infectious disease doctors often focus on specific diseases, while public health experts commonly pursue the details of spillover events--when a virus moves from one species to another, such as from a bat or monkey to a human. But Bloomfield is interested in much larger patterns: how human behavior drives both connectivity and environmental degradation, increasing edge density and therefore the risk of disease transmission. The fishbone pattern of roads cut into the Amazon forest is a common example. In 2000 and 2001, researchers in Peru documented a 278-fold higher biting rate by mosquitos in deforested areas, compared with relatively pristine sites. Cases of malaria rose as mosquitos reproduced quickly in newly sunlit pools and people encroached into the forest. In Uganda, Bloomfield's research revealed greater edge density around households and activities such as collecting materials for house construction. Foraging in forested habitats also increases the likelihood of contact between people and other primates. Researchers have found that forest degradation has been associated with outbreaks of many viruses that originated in wildlife, such as Nipah, Hendra, and Ebola. "Areas with higher biodiversity and human encroachment on that biodiversity are definitely areas of concern," says Bloomfield. "The more interactions between species you have, the higher likelihood you have for rare transmission events," she notes. Science journalist David Quammen, who wrote a prescient book about the emergence of novel diseases, explains that the phenomenon is similar to the chance of rolling a pair of dice and getting snake eyes. The odds on one roll are low, but roll the dice often enough and eventually you'll end up with a pair of ones. Spillovers and outbreaks can occur when the right virus transmits to people under the right circumstances. Modern travel and our current level of human connectivity around the globe means that an outbreak can quickly become a pandemic when an infected person travels from one location to another. Perhaps we may find the right balance only by developing a better understanding of the viral world and the many ways that viruses continue to shape our lives--by attacking us, by becoming part of us, and by helping us, too. Halting degradation and wildlife trade will also help us keep people apart from novel--and potentially harmful--viruses. Prior to 2015, data on emerging infectious diseases was not even tracked by G-FINDER, a project that monitors and reports on global funding for research and development on neglected diseases--under the auspices of the global think tank Policy Cures Research and with support from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. A combination of the Ebola epidemic; pandemics like SARS, MERS, and H1N1; and mounting concern regarding global health security raised the issue in the collective consciousness even prior to the emergence of SARS-CoV-2. Yet funding for basic science research on viruses and emerging infectious diseases still lags where many experts feel it should be. Increasing recognition of the interconnections among people, animals, plants, and their shared environment--and the effects of these interconnections on human health--will also require a paradigm shift to more interdisciplinary research and collaboration. Because the health of people, animals, and the environment are deeply intertwined, research efforts and problem-solving require bridges between the efforts of medical and environmental scientists. So far, there aren't a lot of mechanisms fostering such interdisciplinary research. "I think foundations are probably where we'll find a lot of this support," says Bloomfield. Scientists around the world made history this year by developing an effective vaccine against COVID-19 less than a year after those first images of the novel coronavirus were available. It was basic science research that laid the foundation for such an unprecedented response; in the past, vaccines have often taken 10 to 15 years to develop. Shaped in part by our continued interactions with nature and each other, our future demands a continuation of that approach: putting existing knowledge into action and supporting basic research aimed at deciphering a viral world that we still do not wholly know. Lauren E. Oakes is conservation scientist at the Wildlife Conservation Society, an adjunct professor in the Department of Earth System Science at Stanford University, and a science writer. She is the author of In Search of the Canary Tree (Basic Books, 2018). This article was originally published on our Science Philosophy Alliance Channel in April 2021. Issue 099 Universality Explore This Issue * Chapter one Unity + Jahren_THUMB Science Practice Gaia, the Scientist + Oakes_THUMB Microbiology The Vast Viral World: What We Know (and Don't Know) + Topol_THUMB Health How to Conquer COVID-19 Amid a Confederacy of Dunces Join the Discussion Next Article: Topol_THUMB Biology How to Conquer COVID-19 Amid a Confederacy of Dunces By Eric Topol & Abraham Verghese Related Articles: * Walter_THUMB Biology Will Viruses Save Us From Superbugs? By Katharine Walter * Geib_THUMB Biology We Didn't Evolve for This By Claudia Geib * Upton_THUMB Biology When Pigs Fly By John Upton [Prime_payw] Nautilus uses cookies to manage your digital subscription and show you your reading progress. It's just not the same without them. Please sign in to Nautilus Prime or turn your cookies on to continue reading. Thank you! * About * Awards and Press * Contact / Work with Us * Donate * FAQ * Media Kit * Prime * Privacy Policy * RSS * Subscribe * Terms of Services NAUTILUS: SCIENCE CONNECTED Nautilus is a different kind of science magazine. We deliver big-picture science by reporting on a single monthly topic from multiple perspectives. Read a new chapter in the story every Thursday. Get Nautilus Editor's Picks and new articles right to your inbox! [ ] [Subscribe] x (c) 2021 NautilusThink Inc, All rights reserved. Matter, Biology, Numbers, Ideas, Culture, Connected Site by Code and Theory * Quantcast