https://www.geekwire.com/2021/washington-lawmakers-approve-capital-gains-tax-first-time-state-history/ * Toggle search box Toggle navigation GeekWire * Home * News + Amazon + Microsoft + Startups presented by Madrona Venture Group + Space + Cloud Tech + Geek Life presented by First Tech Federal Credit Union + Podcasts presented by Alexa Startups + Impact Series + Civic presented by Microsoft + Health/Life Sciences + Health Tech Podcast presented by Premera + Geek of the Week + Junior Geek of the Month presented by Northern Trust + Working Geek + Startup Spotlight + Tech Moves presented by Talentreach + Geek Real Estate by Realogics Sotheby's + Echo Geek - sponsored by Amazon + 2025 Podcast - sponsored by Northern Trust + TRANSFORM - sponsored by Intel * Jobs * Events + GeekWire Events + Community Calendar * Resources + Memberships + Health Benefits + GeekWire Startup Resources + GeekWire Startup List + GeekWire 200 + Seattle Engineering Outposts + Recent Fundings + GeekWire Startup Spaces + Community Calendar + Amazon Office Buildings + Venture Capital Directory + Northwest Women VC & Angel Investor List * About + About GeekWire + Email Newsletters + Contact Us + Advertise + Sponsors + Reprints & Permissions * * * * * Search for: [ ] * LATEST NEWS * [cy-scott-colo] Marijuana data platform Headset raises $1.8M to expand into recently legalized markets * Apple Cycling Map Seattle Apple Maps finally adds cycling-specific routing for Seattle bicyclists * * [zulily-co-fou] Zulily co-founder's SPAC raises $300 million * [prime-truck-g] Optimal Prime: Amazon's big quarter reveals its post-pandemic potential * [Junior-Geek-N] Junior Geek of the Month: Nigel Barnett will pursue engineering at MIT, and later, his astronaut dream * [Among-Us-on-P] Viral sensation 'Among Us' is coming to PlayStation 4 & 5 later this year * [elephantamzn1] Amazon plans to install smaller Elephant Car Wash sign outdoors on its campus 'for everyone to enjoy' * [amzn-employme] Amazon sheds 27k employees in Q1 in return to traditional post-holiday jobs pattern * Stratolaunch flight 'We are airborne!' Stratolaunch sends the world's biggest plane on second test flight * [Screen-Shot-2] Digital health startup Engage Technologies Group raises $15M for patient education tools * [1920x1080-100] Microsoft ups the ante against Valve by offering more money to PC game developers * [Screen-Shot-2] GeekWire Awards 2021: Meet the remarkable STEM educators who are inspiring next-gen geeks * [spheresmay201] Amazon crushes earnings estimates with $108.5B in Q1 revenue, up 44%, profits of $8.1B, up 224% * [kevin-hoffman] Remote cardiac monitoring startup Vector Remote Care raises $12.5M * [Baba-Yaga-lab] Washington winery with tech connections hopes to uncork some of the hype around NFTs * [Screen-Shot-2] Microsoft acquires Kinvolk, the Berlin-based cloud startup behind Flatcar Container Linux * [bigstock-1637] Excise or income? Washington state capital gains tax already faces a lawsuit -- here's what to know * [boriginscreen] Jeff Bezos and Blue Origin promise details coming next week for how to buy first seat on spaceflight * [20190920_Brad] Microsoft's Brad Smith goes after Google again over web content and digital advertising revenue * [Shah-Mokdad-1] CDC's new mask rules: Health experts differ on implications of updated guidelines Trending: 'We are airborne!' Stratolaunch sends the world's biggest plane on second test flight Washington lawmakers approve capital gains tax for the first time in state history by Mike Lewis on April 25, 2021 at 6:42 pmApril 30, 2021 at 2:54 pm Share 145 Tweet Share Reddit Email Become a GeekWire member [frame-225x300]Rep. Noel Frame, lead sponsor of the 2021 capital gains tax. (Noel Frame Photo) With time running out on the legislative session, Washington state lawmakers approved a $59 billion state budget including a tax on capital gains that has divided the region's tech community. The Sunday vote on the capital gains bill, mostly along party lines, primarily targets stock and business ownership sales with a 7% tax for the first time in state history. Rep. Noel Frame, a Seattle Democrat who was a key advocate of the measure, said she was thrilled the bill finally moved through the legislature. "I've been working on this for a decade," she said Sunday afternoon shortly after the bill's narrow 25-24 vote in the state Senate. "This is a really important step toward progressive tax reform." It's also going to be a target by groups who see a capital gains tax as an income tax by another name. Income taxes are unconstitutional in Washington state. "It's unquestionably an income tax," said Jason Mercier, an attorney with the conservative Washington Policy Center. "The IRS considers capital gains an income tax. So do we. "This will be challenged in court," he added. Frame said she expects nothing less than a full legal attack by the measure's opponents. But she remains confident the tax will stay on the books because she sees it as an excise tax similar to a sales tax and not an income tax. "I would be deeply surprised if they don't bring a lawsuit," she said. Proponents see the tax as more comparable to the state's existing Business and Occupation Tax which is assessed similarly to an excise tax but based on a business's gross receipts. And that net revenue essentially is its owners' income. "Based on (precedent), we feel there is good case law to interpret this as an excise tax," Frame said. Broadly, statehouse Democrats see the tax as a way to modify the state's regressive tax code that relies heavily on fees such as sales taxes which disproportionately affect low-income residents. Republicans view the tax as illegal and unnecessary based on the state's unexpected economic recovery. The tax is estimated to raise about $550 million annually starting in fiscal year 2023. The majority of the funds would go toward early education and childcare. And as for those federal capital gains taxes you might already be paying? Those, too, might be going up under a new Biden administration proposal. Based on (precedent), we feel there is good case law to interpret this as an excise tax. The $59 billion budget is actually higher than the prior two-year budget because it is buoyed by a stronger-than-expected economic recovery. Moreover, it's far from all of the money the state will be spending next year. Lawmakers are counting on an additional $10 billion in federal pandemic relief funding for families, businesses, and schools. In all, the budget earmarks money for a tax exemption for low-income families, child care programs, and forest and wildfire management, among other programs. The additional federal money will include more than half a billion dollars in rental assistance and another $500 million in funds to help businesses offset soaring unemployment insurance costs related to the massive layoffs of one year ago. But it is the capital gains tax that drew the consistent attention of the tech, business, and legal communities during the legislative session. Under the tax, the first $250,000 of capital gains would be exempt from the tax, as would specific asset sales. For example, stock sales higher than $250,000 would be taxed at 7%. Real estate would not be. From the legislative staff analysis: "Excluded (from the proposed capital gains tax): all real estate land and structures; assets held in a retirement account; assets transferred as part of a condemnation proceeding; livestock related to farming or ranching; certain types of property used in a trade or business such as machinery and equipment that have been immediately expensed; timber and timberlands; and goodwill received from the sale of a franchised auto." A letter published by the Washington Technology Industry Association, which represents more than 1,000 tech startups and larger companies, warned the tax will "remove a meaningful attraction and retention mechanism" for startups and "harm our competitiveness." Venture capitalist Nick Hanauer was dismissive of the WTIA's claim. "The WTIA letter's central claim is that adopting a tax on extraordinary capital gains will make Washington inhospitable to startups and lead them to locate elsewhere, but this is demonstrably false," Hanauer's Civic Ventures wrote in response. "Virtually every state that is a leader in high-tech startups -- like California, Massachusetts, New York, and Virginia -- also has a state tax on capital gains." Rahul Sood, CEO of Seattle-area startup Unikrn, called the passing of the bill a "dumb decision." Good to see Seattle wants to shut down as a startup hub. What a dumb decision. Instead they should focus on cutting fraud in healthcare and other areas. Cut spending waste in all areas of government. Honestly. https://t.co/7oYgOwemdc via @GeekWire -- Rahul Sood ???????? (@rahulsood) April 26, 2021 The bill also briefly became bogged down over language that prevents opponents of the tax to file a state voter referendum to challenge the measure. That language remained in the final bill, so any challenge of the tax will have come in the form of a lawsuit or the state initiative process. Gov. Jay Inslee is expected to sign the legislative package in the coming three weeks. Only after he signs the capital gains tax can it be challenged in court. "Once that happens, someone will file a lawsuit," Mercier said. [ghwai5_T_400x400-150] Mike Lewis is a longtime Seattle-area reporter who covers the intersection of policy and tech at GeekWire. He previously worked for KIRO 97.3 FM, Patch.com, the Seattle P-I, and McClatchy Newspapers. Follow Mike on Twitter or reach him at mike@geekwire.com. Share 145 Tweet Share Reddit Email * Previous Story New COVID-19 dashboard shares data on how well diagnostic tests perform against variants * Next Story Amazon wins two Oscars for 'Sound of Metal;' Netflix leads all studios with seven wins Filed Under: Civic Tagged With: capital gains tax * Nick Hanauer * Olympia * Washington Policy Center * WTIA GeekWire Newsletters Subscribe to GeekWire's free newsletters to catch every headline [ ] Email address Subscribe [*] GeekWire Daily - Top headlines daily [*] GeekWire Weekly - Most-read stories of the week, delivered Sunday [*] Breaking News Alerts - Important news as it happens [ ] GeekWire Startups - News, analysis, insights from the Pacific Northwest startup ecosystem, delivered Friday [ ] GeekWire Podcasts -- Weekly update with our latest audio episodes [ ] GeekWire Mid-week Update -- Most-read stories so far this week, delivered Wednesday [ ] GeekWire Local Deals -- Special offers for Pacific Northwest area readers [ ] Send Us a Tip Have a scoop that you'd like GeekWire to cover? Let us know. Send Us a Tip See MoreGeekWire Events GeekWire Awards Related Stories Washington state capital gains tax marches on: What the new law would do, and who is affected Washington state capital gains tax marches on: What the new law would do, and who is affected Washington state lawmakers target Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos, and other billionaires with wealth tax Washington state lawmakers target Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos, and other billionaires with wealth tax Washington state tech community spars over proposed capital gains tax Washington state tech community spars over proposed capital gains tax Will Bezos bounce? Amazon CEO's departure plan sharpens debate over 'billionaire tax' in Wash. state Will Bezos bounce? Amazon CEO's departure plan sharpens debate over 'billionaire tax' in Wash. state * Previous Story New COVID-19 dashboard shares data on how well diagnostic tests perform against variants * Next Story Amazon wins two Oscars for 'Sound of Metal;' Netflix leads all studios with seven wins Like what you're reading? Subscribe to GeekWire's free newsletters to catch every headline [ ] Email address Subscribe [*] GeekWire Daily - Top headlines daily [*] GeekWire Weekly - Most-read stories of the week, delivered Sunday [*] Breaking News Alerts - Important news as it happens [ ] GeekWire Startups - News, analysis, insights from the Pacific Northwest startup ecosystem, delivered Friday [ ] GeekWire Podcasts -- Weekly update with our latest audio episodes [ ] GeekWire Mid-week Update -- Most-read stories so far this week, delivered Wednesday [ ] GeekWire Local Deals -- Special offers for Pacific Northwest area readers [ ] Most Popular on GeekWire * JEDI news: Judge won't dismiss Amazon's claim that Trump interfered with $10B cloud contract JEDI news: Judge won't dismiss Amazon's claim that Trump interfered with $10B cloud contract * Stratolaunch flight 'We are airborne!' Stratolaunch sends the world's biggest plane on second test flight * Washington lawmakers approve capital gains tax for the first time in state history Washington lawmakers approve capital gains tax for the first time in state history * Bill Gates predicts 'very small numbers' of COVID by end of 2022, takes heat for vaccine patent defense Bill Gates predicts 'very small numbers' of COVID by end of 2022, takes heat for vaccine patent defense Job Listings on GeekWork Account Executive Account ExecutiveWave Broadband Enterprise Account Executive Enterprise Account ExecutiveWave Broadband Senior Software Engineer Senior Software EngineerINRIX Full-Stack Software Engineer (Python, Vue.js) Full-Stack Software Engineer (Python, Vue.js)INRIX Staff Software Engineer Staff Software EngineerChewy, Inc. Associate Director Product Manager (VOC) Associate Director Product Manager (VOC)Chewy, Inc. Find more jobs on GeekWork. Employers, post a job here. A Word From Our Sponsors [Qumulo_GW_featuredimage-200] The Art of Simplicity - Driving Customer Success with Simplified File Data Solutions Read More [SP-Graphic-Crosscut-Festiva] Catch the upcoming Crosscut Festival featured session, May 7th at 3PM. Register today! [Intel-SP-Graphic-225x225-Ho] Welcome to How Wonderful Gets Done 2021, by Intel Learn more today! [225-x-225-2021-GW-Awards-No] The GeekWire Awards return: Finalists announced, voting opens across 13 categories Vote here! [MEM_HA-200x225-SP-MN] Become a member, support independent journalism! Join today! Galactic Sponsors Bank of America Platinum Sponsors Wave Business EY Silver Sponsors Wells Fargo First Tech WSGR Seattle University About * About GeekWire * Contact Us * Ask About Advertising * Send Us a Tip * Apply for Startup Spotlight * Apply for Geek of the Week * Become a GeekWire Member * Join Our Startup List * Reprints and Permissions Follow * * * * * * * GeekWire Newsletters Catch every headline in your inbox [ ] Email address Subscribe [*] GeekWire Daily - Top headlines daily [*] GeekWire Weekly - Most-read stories of the week, delivered Sunday [*] Breaking News Alerts - Important news as it happens [ ] GeekWire Startups - News, analysis, insights from the Pacific Northwest startup ecosystem, delivered Friday [ ] GeekWire Podcasts -- Weekly update with our latest audio episodes [ ] GeekWire Mid-week Update -- Most-read stories so far this week, delivered Wednesday [ ] GeekWire Local Deals -- Special offers for Pacific Northwest area readers [ ] GeekWire Apps * iOS * Android * Apple News * Google Play Newsstand GeekWire Developer Blog Return to Top of Page Privacy Policy | Terms of Use (c) 2011-2021 GeekWire, LLC x Get smart with GeekWire. Sign up for our new daily newsletter. [ ] Sign Up Do not show again. [p] Quantcast *