https://www.eff.org/press/releases/eff-sues-proctorio-behalf-student-it-falsely-accused-copyright-infringement-get Skip to main content * About + Contact + Press + People + Opportunities + EFF 30th Anniversary * Issues + Free Speech + Privacy + Creativity and Innovation + Transparency + International + Security * Our Work + Deeplinks Blog + Press Releases + Events + Legal Cases + Whitepapers * Take Action + Action Center + Electronic Frontier Alliance + Volunteer * Tools + Privacy Badger + HTTPS Everywhere + Surveillance Self-Defense + Certbot + Atlas of Surveillance + Cover Your Tracks + Crocodile Hunter * Donate + Donate to EFF + Shop + Other Ways to Give + Membership FAQ * Donate + Donate to EFF + Shop + Other Ways to Give * Search form Search [ ] --------------------------------------------------------------------- Email updates on news, actions, and events in your area. Join EFF Lists * Copyright (CC BY) * Trademark * Privacy Policy * Thanks Electronic Frontier Foundation Donate EFF TURNS 30! LEARN MORE ABOUT US, AND HOW YOU CAN HELP. EFF TURNS 30! LEARN MORE. Electronic Frontier Foundation * About + Contact + Press + People + Opportunities + EFF 30th Anniversary * Issues + Free Speech + Privacy + Creativity and Innovation + Transparency + International + Security * Our Work + Deeplinks Blog + Press Releases + Events + Legal Cases + Whitepapers * Take Action + Action Center + Electronic Frontier Alliance + Volunteer * Tools + Privacy Badger + HTTPS Everywhere + Surveillance Self-Defense + Certbot + Atlas of Surveillance + Cover Your Tracks + Crocodile Hunter * Donate + Donate to EFF + Shop + Other Ways to Give + Membership FAQ * Donate + Donate to EFF + Shop + Other Ways to Give * Search form Search [ ] EFF Sues Proctorio on Behalf of Student It Falsely Accused of Copyright Infringement to Get Critical Tweets Taken Down Links to Software Code Excerpts in Tweets Are Fair Use PRESS RELEASE Press Release April 21, 2021 EFF Sues Proctorio on Behalf of Student It Falsely Accused of Copyright Infringement to Get Critical Tweets Taken Down Share It Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Copy link Phoenix, Arizona--The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) filed a lawsuit today against Proctorio Inc. on behalf of college student Erik Johnson, seeking a judgment that he didn't infringe the company's copyrights when he linked to excerpts of its software code in tweets criticizing the software maker. Proctorio, a developer of exam administration and surveillance software, misused the copyright takedown provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) to have Twitter remove posts by Johnson, a Miami University computer engineering undergraduate and security researcher. EFF and co-counsel Osborn Maledon said in a complaint filed today in U.S. District Court, District of Arizona, that Johnson made fair use of excerpts of Proctorio's software code, and the company's false claims of infringement interfered with Johnson's First Amendment right to criticize the company. "Software companies don't get to abuse copyright law to undermine their critics," said EFF Staff Attorney Cara Gagliano. "Using pieces of code to explain your research or support critical commentary is no different from quoting a book in a book review." Proctoring apps like Proctorio's are privacy-invasive software that "watches" students through eye-tracking and face detection for supposed signs of cheating as they take tests or complete schoolwork. The use of these "disciplinary technology" programs has skyrocketed amid the pandemic, raising questions about the extent to which they threaten student privacy and disadvantage students without access to high-speed internet and quiet spaces. Proctorio has responded to public criticism by attacking people who speak out. The company's CEO released on Reddit contents of a student's chat log captured by Proctorio after the student posted complaints about the software on the social network. The company has also sued a remote learning specialist in Canada for posting links to Proctorio's publicly available YouTube videos in a series of tweets showing the software tracks "abnormal" eye and head movements it deems suspicious. Concerned about how much private information Proctorio collects from students' computers, Johnson, whose instructors have given tests using Proctorio, examined the company's software, including the files that are downloaded to any computer where the software is installed. He published a series of tweets in September critiquing Proctorio, linking in three of those tweets to short software code excerpts that demonstrate the extent of the software's tracking and access to users' computers. In another tweet, Johnson included a screenshot of a video illustrating how the software is able to create a 360-degree image of students' rooms that is accessible to teachers and seemingly Proctorio's agents. "Copyright holders should be held liable when they falsely accuse their critics of copyright infringement, especially when the goal is plainly to intimidate and undermine them," said Gagliano. "We're asking the court for a declaratory judgment that there is no infringement to prevent further legal threats and takedown attempts against Johnson for using code excerpts and screenshots to support his comments." For the complaint: https://www.eff.org/document/johnson-v-proctorio-complaint For more on proctoring surveillance: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/08/ proctoring-apps-subject-students-unnecessary-surveillance Contact: Cara Gagliano Related Issues Fair Use Free Speech Student Privacy Face Surveillance Share It Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Copy link Join EFF Lists Join Our Newsletter! Email updates on news, actions, events in your area, and more. Email Address [ ] Postal Code (optional) [ ] Anti-spam question: Enter the three-letter abbreviation for Electronic Frontier Foundation: [ ] Don't fill out this field (required) [ ] [Submit] Thanks, you're awesome! Please check your email for a confirmation link. Oops something is broken right now, please try again later. Related Updates [eff-pr-og] Press Release | April 19, 2021 Video Hearings Tuesday and Wednesday: EFF Will Tell Copyright Office That Consumers Should Have the Freedom to Fix, Modify Digital Devices They Own San Francisco--On Tuesday, April 20, and Wednesday, April 21, experts from the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) fighting copyright abuse will testify at virtual hearings held by the Copyright Office in favor of exemptions to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) so people who have purchased digital devices--from cameras and... You Wouldn't Reimplement an API Deeplinks Blog by Michael Barclay | April 5, 2021 Victory for Fair Use: The Supreme Court Reverses the Federal Circuit in Oracle v. Google In a win for innovation, the U.S. Supreme Court has held that Google's use of certain Java Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) is a lawful fair use. In doing so, the Court reversed the previous rulings by the Federal Circuit and recognized that copyright only promotes innovation and creativity when... [dmca-copyright-1] Deeplinks Blog by Mitch Stoltz | March 25, 2021 Free as in Climbing: Rock Climber's Open Data Project Threatened by Bogus Copyright Claims Rock climbers have a tradition of sharing "beta"--helpful information about a route--with other climbers. Giving beta is both useful and a form of community-building within this popular sport. Given that strong tradition of sharing, we were disappointed to learn that the owners of an important community website, MountainProject.com, were... [COPYRIGHT-DIGITAL] Deeplinks Blog by Katharine Trendacosta | March 15, 2021 Thank You for Speaking Against a Terrible Copyright Proposal Last week was the deadline for comments on the draft of the so-called "Digital Copyright Act," a proposal which would fundamentally change how creativity functions online. We asked for creators to add their voices to the many groups opposing this draft, and you did it. Ultimately, over 900 of you... [og-copyrightbot-alt2] Deeplinks Blog by Christoph Schmon | February 26, 2021 From Creativity to Exclusivity: The German Government's Bad Deal for Article 17 The implementation process of Article 17 (formerly Article 13) of the controversial Copyright Directive into national laws is in full swing, and it does not look good for users' rights and freedoms. Several EU states have failed to present balanced copyright implementation proposals, ignoring the concerns off EFF,... Music & Copyright Deeplinks Blog by Katharine Trendacosta | February 19, 2021 Cops Using Music to Try to Stop Being Filmed Is Just the Tip of the Iceberg Someone tries to livestream their encounters with the police, only to find that the police started playing music. In the case of a February 5 meeting between an activist and the Beverly Hills Police Department, the song of choice was Sublime's "Santeria." The police may not got no crystal... Copyright Question Mark Deeplinks Blog by Katharine Trendacosta, Cara Gagliano | February 5, 2021 Some Answers to Questions About the State of Copyright in 2021 In all the madness that made up the last month of 2020, a number of copyright bills and proposals popped up--some even became law before most people had any chance to review them. So now that the dust has settled a little and we have some better idea what the... The number 2020 in a glitchy screen Deeplinks Blog by Cara Gagliano, Katharine Trendacosta | January 3, 2021 A Smorgasbord of Bad Takedowns: 2020 Year in Review Here at EFF, we take particular notice of the way that intellectual property law leads to expression being removed from the Internet. We document the worst examples in our Takedown Hall of Shame. Some, we use to explain more complex ideas. And in other cases, we offer our help.In terms... [dmca-copyright-1] Deeplinks Blog by Jason Kelley | December 22, 2020 The CASE Act Is Just the Beginning of the Next Copyright Battle As we feared, the "Copyright Alternative in Small-Claims Enforcement Act"--the CASE Act--that we've been fighting in various forms for two years has been included in a "must-pass" spending bill. This new legislation means Internet users could face up to $30,000 in penalties for sharing a meme or... [og-copyrightbot-hd_0_3] Deeplinks Blog by Katharine Trendacosta | December 22, 2020 This Disastrous Copyright Proposal Goes Straight to Our Naughty List Just yesterday we saw two wretched copyright bills-the CASE Act and a felony streaming bill -- slipped into law via a must-pass spending bill. But it seems some people in Congress were just getting started. Today, Senator Thom Tillis launched a "discussion draft" of the so-called Digital... Back to top EFF Home Follow EFF: * twitter * facebook * instagram * youtube * flicker * rss Contact * General * Legal * Security * Membership * Press About * Calendar * Volunteer * Victories * History * Internships * Jobs * Staff * Diversity & Inclusion Issues * Free Speech * Privacy * Creativity & Innovation * Transparency * International * Security Updates * Blog * Press Releases * Events * Legal Cases * Whitepapers * EFFector Newsletter Press * Press Contact Donate * Join or Renew Membership Online * One-Time Donation Online * Shop * Other Ways to Give * Copyright (CC BY) * Trademark * Privacy Policy * Thanks JavaScript license information *