https://www.macrumors.com/2021/04/08/epic-games-apple-conclusions-of-law/ Mac RumorsMac RumorsSkip to Content Got a tip for us?Let us know * a. Send us an email * b. Anonymous form * close This icon serves as a link to download the eSSENTIAL Accessibility assistive technology app for individuals with physical disabilities. It is featured as part of our commitment to diversity and inclusion. Skip to Content MacRumors * Front Page * Roundups + AirPods[1x1] + AirPods Max[1x1] + AirPods Pro[1x1] + Apple Car[1x1] + Apple Deals[1x1] + Apple Glasses[1x1] + Apple Pay[1x1] + Apple Pro Display XDR[1x1] + Apple Stores[1x1] + Apple TV[1x1] + Apple Watch SE[1x1] + Apple Watch Series 6[1x1] + CarPlay[1x1] + HomePod[1x1] + HomePod mini[1x1] + iMac[1x1] + iMac Pro[1x1] + iOS 14[1x1] + iOS 15[1x1] + iPad[1x1] + iPad Air [1x1] + iPad mini 5[1x1] + iPad Pro[1x1] + iPadOS 14[1x1] + iPhone 11[1x1] + iPhone 12[1x1] + iPhone 12 Pro[1x1] + iPhone 13[1x1] + iPhone SE 2020[1x1] + iPhone XR[1x1] + iPod touch[1x1] + Mac mini[1x1] + Mac Pro[1x1] + MacBook Air[1x1] + MacBook Pro 13"[1x1] + MacBook Pro 16"[1x1] + macOS 12[1x1] + macOS Big Sur[1x1] + tvOS 14[1x1] + watchOS 7[1x1] + WWDC 2021[1x1] * Guides * How Tos * Reviews * Buyer's Guide * Forums This icon serves as a link to download the eSSENTIAL Accessibility assistive technology app for individuals with physical disabilities. It is featured as part of our commitment to diversity and inclusion. [ ][Submit] * AirPods Max * MacBook Air * MacBook Pro 13" * macOS Big Sur * WWDC 2021 * iOS 15 * iPhone 12 * iPhone 12 Pro * iPhone 13 * iPad * AirPods Pro * Apple Glasses * Apple Watch Series 6 * HomePod * HomePod mini * iMac * Apple Pro Display XDR * Mac Pro * AirPods * Apple Deals * Apple Watch SE * iOS 14 * iPad Air * iPad mini 5 * iPhone 11 * iPhone SE 2020 * iPhone XR * iPod touch * Mac mini * Apple TV * MacBook Pro 16" * macOS 12 * Apple Car * Apple Stores * iMac Pro * iPad Pro * CarPlay * iPadOS 14 * tvOS 14 * watchOS 7 * Apple Pay All > * Front Page * Roundups * Guides * How Tos * Reviews * Buyer's Guide * Upcoming Products * Forums * Archives * Tips / Contact Us * This icon serves as a link to download the eSSENTIAL Accessibility assistive technology app for individuals with physical disabilities. It is featured as part of our commitment to diversity and inclusion. Epic Games Began Planning Antitrust Lawsuit Against Apple Two Years Ago With 'Project Liberty' Thursday April 8, 2021 12:01 am PDT by Juli Clover Ahead of its upcoming bench trial against Epic Games, Apple today filed 500 pages of documents covering findings of fact and conclusions of law, which basically summarizes the information exchanged between Apple and Epic, presents the relevant facts to the judge, and argues for the logical conclusions that should be drawn when law is applied to the case. fortnite apple logo 2fortnite apple logo 2 Apple sticks to many of the talking points that it has argued since the beginning of its dispute with Epic Games. The App Store has remained unchanged in terms of general fee structure since it first debuted in 2008, and while policies have been updated, the development principles have remained the same. Apple sees Epic's challenge as an attack on its fundamental App Store business model of 13 years. Apple maintains that its rigorous review guidelines for apps provide consumers with security, privacy, and reliability, something that its devices are also known for, leading to significant benefits for end users and developers. The 30 percent fee that Apple charges is in line with the fees charged by other app marketplaces and software providers as demonstrated in a study that Apple had commissioned earlier this year, and Apple recently introduced the Small Business Program to drop fees to 15 percent for developers making under $1 million annually. Apple entered a market where 30 percent commissions were already accepted -- it did not set that rate when the App Store launched. In response to claims that the App Store is anticompetitive because there are no alternate app stores allowed on the iPhone, Apple points to competition in the device and game transaction markets. There are other platforms that people can choose, along with other gaming options, and web apps are supported on iPhone and iPad as gaming alternatives that Microsoft and Google have already taken advantage of. Apple uses Epic's main title, Fortnite, to illustrate its point. Epic's flagship game, Fortnite, illustrates the competitive landscape. Apple supports "cross-plat- form" play and cross-platform transactions. The same consumer can make in-app purchases of V-Bucks on her iPhone (through the browser) during a lunch break, and on a console at home in the evening. Apple (unlike some of its competitors) allows "cross-wallet" play, so that in-game purchases--called V-Bucks in Fortnite--can be made on one device and used on another. In other words, an iOS user can purchase V-Bucks on a PC and then (prior to Fortnite's removal) use them in Fortnite on their iPhone or iPad--with Epic owing not even a penny's commission to Apple. Epic internal documents related to "Project Liberty" suggest that Epic has been plotting against Apple and Google since 2018. Epic began Project Liberty when it saw a decline in its average monthly active users and revenue, devising a strategy to pay less commission while still taking advantage of the benefits of the App Store and the money that Apple has invested into the ecosystem. Epic Games hired lawyers and a PR firm as part of its plan to launch a lawsuit against Apple, ultimately shelling out hundreds of thousands of dollars. Epic outlined its plan to get Fortnite approved with hidden alternate payment options, which was then activated by a hotfix, leading to the current dispute. Epic internal documents described the legal battle against Apple and Google as "fun!" and contemplated how to get Apple and Google to reconsider their fees without Epic Games looking like "the baddies." This was all part of a pre-planned media strategy called "Project Liberty." Epic retained Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP and a public relations firm in 2019, and this lawsuit is the culmination of that effort. Epic seeks to portray Apple as the bad guy so that it can revive flagging interest in Fortnite. Yet, ironically, when Epic got kicked off the iOS platform, it told players that they could continue playing on consoles, PCs, and other devices--demonstrating the existence of competition and the absence of monopoly. Tim Sweeney, the CEO of Epic Games, has confirmed Project Liberty in prior interviews and has said that Epic spent months preparing the lawsuit against Apple, though Apple's court filings provide new insight into the lengths that Epic went to in order to rope Apple and Google into an antitrust lawsuit. Apple argues that an expansion of antitrust law is unwarranted and that Epic's product market descriptions are inaccurate because of the other platforms the App Store is competing with. Apple claims that Epic overstates the App Store's profitability, and that arguments that the review process is ineffective are inaccurate. Last year, Apple rejected 150,000 apps, and malware on iOS devices is almost unheard of compared to the high number of malicious apps found on PCs and Android devices. Apple says that Epic's claim that the market is only iOS apps will fail, and that the relief that Epic seeks would be harmful for consumers and developers as it would weaken the App Store. Apple also sees the App Store as an integrated feature of the iPhone and in-app purchase as an integrated feature of the App Store that does not allow for third-party payment options, which is what Epic is aiming for. At bottom, Epic is asking this Court to force alternative terms on Apple so that Epic can make more money. But Epic's request would harm other developers and consumers, in addition to imposing unprecedented obligations on Apple to open its proprietary systems and engineering to third parties. The Epic v. Apple bench trial is set to start on May 3, and it will conclude the week of May 24. Both Epic and Apple will call high-profile witnesses, including Apple CEO Tim Cook, Apple Fellow Phil Schiller, Apple engineering chief Craig Federighi, and former iOS software chief Scott Forstall, who will be testifying on behalf of Apple. Apple's Proposed Findin... by MacRumors Tags: Epic Games, Epic Games vs. Apple Guide [ 115 comments ] Top Rated Comments ian87w Avatar ian87w 16 hours ago at 12:07 am Wait, so Epic's decision when their revenue is declining is to hire lawyers and PR firms to bite Apple and Google? And they literally planned to break the ToS through a hot fix? Do people still want to side with Epic? Score: 50 Votes (Like | Disagree) farewelwilliams Avatar farewelwilliams 15 hours ago at 12:37 am App Store has been more than fair. 30% pays for plenty of essential developer resources that indie developers rely on. Epic wants to stop funding these resources and keep the money to themselves. Epic isn't doing it to help developers, they're stealing from developers. Score: 33 Votes (Like | Disagree) m4mario Avatar m4mario 15 hours ago at 12:51 am The App store is still the only way to get apps on iOS Thats not true. You can absolutely use HTML 5, Javascript and all the web technologies and develop a web app. Any user can add an app like that to Home Screen and use it like a regular app (Only catch is it will need an internet connection). HTML 5 is completely open and based on common standards. If HTML 5 standards specify Camera access, then iOS provides it. What you cant do is use Apple in-house built technologies like Xcode, Swift, Apple's iOS API's and other Apple developed technologies for free and develop an app and distribute it without paying Apple a cut. That I think is fair. Sure Apple's technologies is far superior to HTML 5(which is an industry standard), that's what Apple worked hard for. Asking for these technologies without paying Apple anything is unfair. Score: 29 Votes (Like | Disagree) Krizoitz Avatar Krizoitz 15 hours ago at 01:15 am The App store is still the only way to get apps on iOS And? There's nothing unprecedented or illegal about that. iOS isn't a market, smartphones and devices are. The only way to get digital games on the Xbox is through Microsoft's store. The only way to get them on PlayStation is through Sony's store. Want to sell your game for Nintendo, Microsoft or Sony's platform? You have to get their approval and follow their rules. Since none of them have a monopoly the consumer can choose which platform or platforms they want to engage with. Same with smartphones. Apple offers one approach, Google a different one. Consumers can choose which one they like. If you don't like Apple walled garden model it's really really easy to not buy an iPhone. Score: 22 Votes (Like | Disagree) BvizioN Avatar BvizioN 15 hours ago at 12:59 am I want them to fail in an epic way. Score: 18 Votes (Like | Disagree) Anson_431 Avatar Anson_431 14 hours ago at 01:39 am Wait, so Epic's decision when their revenue is declining is to hire lawyers and PR firms to bite Apple and Google? And they literally planned to break the ToS through a hot fix? Do people still want to side with Epic? I actually wonder how the court would perceive this deliberately planned and executed breach of contract when Epic is trying to play the victim here. It wasn't even 2 months. It's TWO YEARS for crying out loud......... Score: 9 Votes (Like | Disagree) Read All Comments Top Stories iPhone trade iniPhone trade in Apple Adjusts Trade-In Value of iPad Pro, iPhone 11, and Select Mac Models Monday April 5, 2021 1:54 am PDT by Sami Fathi Apple has adjusted the trade-in values of a number of its products, including the majority of the iPad and Mac lineup, while also making some changes to iPhone. Apple's trade-in program allows customers to trade-in older devices, and receive a certain amount of value for them, to use towards a purchase of a new device. The exact trade-in value a device has is measured by its condition, when ... Read Full Article * 41 comments new m1 chipnew m1 chip M1 Mac RAM and SSD Upgrades Found to Be Possible After Purchase Tuesday April 6, 2021 5:34 am PDT by Hartley Charlton Technicians in China have reportedly succeeded in upgrading the memory and storage of the M1 chip, suggesting that Apple's integrated custom silicon for the Mac may be more flexible than previously thought. Reports of maintenance technicians being able to expand the memory and storage of M1 Macs began circulating on Chinese social media over the weekend, but now international reports have... Read Full Article * 160 comments apple music for artists new iconapple music for artists new icon Apple's Revamped Apple Music for Artists Icon Leads to Speculation About iOS 15 Design Plans Tuesday April 6, 2021 1:03 pm PDT by Juli Clover Apple yesterday updated its Apple Music for Artists app with some minor bug fixes and improvements, but also one other notable change -- a new icon. New icon on the right The Apple Music for Artists app now features a simpler, streamlined icon with a pinkish red music logo rather than the multicolored logo that was used before. The icon also has an embossed look that makes it stand out from... Read Full Article * 139 comments iphone 13 pro macotakaraiphone 13 pro macotakara Alleged iPhone 13 Pro Mockup Shows Smaller Notch, Repositioned Earpiece and Front Camera Sunday April 4, 2021 1:12 pm PDT by Sami Fathi Images shared by Japanese site Mac Otakara claim to show a 3D-printed mockup of the upcoming 6.1-inch iPhone 13 Pro with a smaller notch, and repositioned earpiece and front camera, but with minimal changes otherwise. According to the images, Apple plans to move the earpiece to the top of the notch within the screen bezel, lining up with a previous photo shared by MacRumors that shows the... Read Full Article * 111 comments maxresdefaultmaxresdefault Microsoft Pits Surface Pro 7 Against iPad Pro, Says Surface is 'Still the Better Choice' Monday April 5, 2021 10:07 am PDT by Juli Clover Microsoft today shared an ad that pits the Surface Pro 7 against Apple's iPad Pro, in a continuation of a Surface Pro 7 vs. MacBook ad campaign that kicked off in January. The ad highlights the Surface Pro 7's kickstand, pointing out that the iPad does not have a built-in kickstand option, and it calls the iPad Pro's keyboard "a lot heavier" than the Surface option. Microsoft also goes... Read Full Article * 380 comments tim cook apple parktim cook apple park Sideloading Apps Would 'Break' the Security and Privacy of iPhone, Says Tim Cook Monday April 5, 2021 4:32 am PDT by Sami Fathi In a wide-ranging interview with The New York Times' Kara Swisher, on her podcast "Sway," Apple CEO Tim Cook talks about Apple's feud with Facebook, its stance on privacy, Apple's legal battle with Epic Games, and possible future Apple innovations such as Apple Glasses. Apple is in the midst of a heated public spat with Facebook over privacy, particularly over an upcoming feature on iOS that ... Read Full Article * 336 comments Top Stories 55 FeatureTop Stories 55 Feature Top Stories: WWDC 2021 Announced, iPhone SE Rumors, 'Cheese Grater' iPhone Design? Saturday April 3, 2021 6:00 am PDT by MacRumors Staff While we're still waiting on word of a potential Apple event in April, we did get confirmation about another upcoming Apple event this week, WWDC 2021, which will return to its usual early June timeframe but remain in an all-virtual format similar to last year's edition. Other Apple news and rumors this week included a report about future iPhone SE models, a crazy Apple patent filing that... Read Full Article * 22 comments Whatsapp FeatureWhatsapp Feature WhatsApp Testing Ability to Transfer Chats Between iOS and Android Tuesday April 6, 2021 12:37 am PDT by Sami Fathi WhatsApp is testing a new feature that will allow users to transfer their chat history, logs, and transcripts between iOS and Android devices, making it easier for WhatsApp users to switch between the two platforms. The new future, in the early stages of development, was brought to light by WABetaInfo, who often shares unreleased and hidden features behind the chatting service. According to ... Read Full Article * 68 comments iPhone 13 Notch FeatureiPhone 13 Notch Feature Mass Production of A15 Chip for iPhone 13 Set to Begin Ahead of Schedule in Late May Tuesday April 6, 2021 7:29 am PDT by Sami Fathi Longtime Apple supplier TSMC is set to begin mass shipments of Apple's upcoming A15 chip for the iPhone 13 ahead of schedule at the end of May, according to a snippet of a full report set to be published tomorrow by DigiTimes. The new chip will be based on an enhanced version of the 5nm process, which first debuted in the A14 Bionic with the 2020 iPad Air and iPhone 12 lineup. While the full ... Read Full Article * 101 comments fortnite apple featuredfortnite apple featured Facebook Doesn't Want to Give Apple Requested Documents in Epic v. Apple Fight [Updated] Monday April 5, 2021 11:34 am PDT by Juli Clover Facebook and Apple are squabbling over document requests in the ongoing Epic v. Apple legal battle, according to a new discovery letter filed with the court today. Facebook is involved because Facebook executive Vivek Sharma is set to testify on behalf of Epic. Apple wants a "limited set of documents" that are needed for a fair cross examination of Sharma, who plans to testify about Apple's... Read Full Article * 84 comments Next Article tmobile 5g modem T-Mobile Launches Unlimited 5G Home Internet for $60/Month Guides 14 iOS 14.4 Features iOS 14.4 is out now! Read about everything new in this release. apple fitness plus guide tiny Apple Fitness+ Apple Fitness+ is out! Read all about it. macbook air m1 unboxing feature2 Apple Silicon M1 Guide Everything to know about the Apple Silicon M1 Chip fitness plus weekly series Apple Fitness+ vs. Peloton Apple Fitness+ and Peloton offer polished workout routines delivered by enthusiastic instructors and accompanied by motivating music playlists. See more guides Upcoming AirPods Gen 3 Feature AirPods 3 1st Half of 2021 Rumored design changes include shorter stems like current AirPods Pro, but without advanced features like active noise cancellation. AirPods Pro Gen 2 Feature2 AirPods Pro 2 Spring 2021 Updated AirPods Pro could see some design changes like elimination of the stem. imac 2017 roundup menu iMac Early 2021? iPad Pro-like design? New screen sizes? airtags mockup 4 blue AirTags Early 2021? Tile-like Bluetooth tracking device designed to be attached to items like keys and wallets, letting you find them right in the Find My app. * WWDC 2021 * MacBook Pro * iPhone 13 * Apple Glasses See full product calendar [macrumors-simple-logo-light][macrumors-simple-logo-dark] MacRumors attracts a broad audience of both consumers and professionals interested in the latest technologies and products. We also boast an active community focused on purchasing decisions and technical aspects of the iPhone, iPod, iPad, and Mac platforms. Advertise on MacRumors Our Staff Arnold Kim Editorial Director Email * Twitter Eric Slivka Editor in Chief Email * Twitter Juli Clover Senior Editor Email * Twitter * Google+ Joe Rossignol Editor Email * Twitter Mitchel Broussard Editor Email * Twitter Tim Hardwick Editor Email * Twitter Marianne Schultz Editor Email * Twitter Dan Barbera Video Content Producer Email * Twitter Ryan Barrieau Graphic Designer Email *Twitter Chris Jenkins Contributing Writer Email * Twitter Steve Moser Contributing Writer Email * Twitter Frank McShan Contributing Writer Email * Twitter Hartley Charlton Contributing Writer Email * Twitter Sami Fathi Contributing Writer Email * Twitter Related Links Touch Arcade 'Chaser Tracer' is an '80s-Inspired Arcade Game with a Killer Synthwave Soundtrack that's Launching Next Week SwitchArcade Round-Up: 'Astro Aqua Kitty', 'Super Fowlst 2', 'Island', and Today's Other New Releases and Sales 'Disgaea RPG' Finally Launches Next Week in the West on iOS and Android with Pre-Orders Now Live on the App Store 'SaGa Frontier Remastered' from Square Enix Gets a New Trailer Showcasing the New Features and Content Included in the Upcoming Remaster Out Now: 'A Game of Thrones: Board Game', 'Crash Dive 2', 'NBA Ball Stars', 'Heroic Expedition', 'DemonCrawl', 'The Wake', 'Anagraphs', 'End Matter', 'Hannya Bullet Hell' and More SwitchArcade Round-Up: 'Pac-Man 99' Launches Today, Mini-Views Featuring 'Rip Them Off', Plus Today's New Releases and Sales New Karakin Map Now Available in 'PUBG Mobile' Mario Kart Tour's 41st Tour Is Now Live in the Form of the Ninja Tour Featuring the New Ninja Hideaway Track YouTube [1x1] No iPad Mini Pro at Rumored April Apple Event? [1x1] New Apple TV with 120Hz Support and New Remote Coming Soon? [1x1] Sonos Roam Review: Tiny AirPlay 2 Speaker with Incredible Sound? [1x1] The Oppo Find X3 Pro Has A Crazy Cool Feature! [1x1] NEW Siri Voices in iOS 14.5! (No Longer Defaults to Female) Copyright (c) 2000-2021 MacRumors.com, LLC. Privacy / DMCA contact / Affiliate and FTC Disclosure Accessibility Statement [ Featured On/Off ] [ Full Articles On/Off ] [ Fluid | Fluid HD ] [ Auto | Light | Dark ] Quantcast