https://newatlas.com/space/emdrive-dead-thrust-refuted/ * SUBSCRIBE AD-FREE * LOG IN * HOME * LIFESTYLE + Health & Wellbeing + Outdoors + Tiny Houses + Architecture + Around the Home + Good Thinking + Holiday Destinations + View all LIFESTYLE categories + Health & Wellbeing + Outdoors + Tiny Houses + Architecture + Around the Home + Good Thinking + Holiday Destinations + View all LIFESTYLE categories * SCIENCE + Energy + Medical + Space + Materials + Biology + Environment + Physics + View all SCIENCE categories + Energy + Medical + Space + Materials + Biology + Environment + Physics + View all SCIENCE categories * TECHNOLOGY + Photography + Military + Mobile Technology + Games + Drones + Home Entertainment + Deals + View all TECHNOLOGY categories + Photography + Military + Mobile Technology + Games + Drones + Home Entertainment + Deals + View all TECHNOLOGY categories * TRANSPORT + Automotive + Aircraft + Bicycles + Motorcycles + Marine + Urban Transport + View all TRANSPORT categories + Automotive + Aircraft + Bicycles + Motorcycles + Marine + Urban Transport + View all TRANSPORT categories (c) 2021 New Atlas New Atlas Logo [] Menu * HOME * LIFESTYLE + Health & Wellbeing + Outdoors + Tiny Houses + Architecture + Around the Home + Good Thinking + Holiday Destinations + View all LIFESTYLE categories * SCIENCE + Energy + Medical + Space + Materials + Biology + Environment + Physics + View all SCIENCE categories * TECHNOLOGY + Photography + Military + Mobile Technology + Games + Drones + Home Entertainment + Deals + View all TECHNOLOGY categories * TRANSPORT + Automotive + Aircraft + Bicycles + Motorcycles + Marine + Urban Transport + View all TRANSPORT categories * SUBSCRIBE AD-FREE * LOG IN Show Search [ ]Search Query Submit Search Physics Scientists pinpoint source of "impossible" EmDrive's thrust By Loz Blain April 05, 2021 * Facebook * Twitter * Flipboard * LinkedIn [] / # Scientists pinpoint source of ... According to one peer-reviewed paper, the EmDrive thruster was able to produce 720 mN of thrust from an electricity input of 2.5 kW According to one peer-reviewed paper, the EmDrive thruster was able to produce 720 mN of thrust from an electricity input of 2.5 kW Photo: EmDrive View 1 Image According to one peer-reviewed paper, the EmDrive thruster was able to produce 720 mN of thrust from an electricity input of 2.5 kW 1/1 According to one peer-reviewed paper, the EmDrive thruster was able to produce 720 mN of thrust from an electricity input of 2.5 kW Photo: EmDrive In 2014, no less an authority than NASA proclaimed in peer-reviewed papers that it was getting mysterious thrust from the EmDrive, a strange, brassy trumpet of a thing that its creators claimed could produce thrust with no propellant. NASA's findings replicated 2009 experiments in China. A zero-propellant thruster? The world sat up and listened. The ability to generate thrust without having to carry the parasitic mass of fuel would be a game-changer in space, and even if the EmDrive's experimental thrust figures were small (720 millinewtons per 2.5 kW of input power in the 2009 Chinese experiment), they'd be several times more effective per weight and per watt of input than current ion propulsion systems, which need to carry fuel. The trouble is, where ion drives are easily explained (a propellant is ionized, then electromagnetically thrown out the back of the thruster to push the vehicle forward), nobody could figure out how the EmDrive was producing Newtons while apparently disagreeing with Newton on the whole conservation of energy thing. The inventor had a theory, but so did German scientists Martin Tajmar, Oliver Neunzig and Marcel Weikert, and the three have spent the last four years fine-tuning their experiments to prove it. In 2018, the team showed some weird results suggesting that the EmDrive's thrust didn't seem to be coming from the EmDrive itself, and they hypothesized that the results were possibly something to do with electromagnetic interference from the prototype's power cables interacting with the Earth's magnetic field. So they set out to eliminate those effects, using an on-board battery and relocating other components to stop any electromagnetic effects, and redesigning the experiment to address some hypotheses raised by other teams trying to get a handle on the EmDrive as well. Now, the team says it's found exactly where the thrust is coming from - and it's bad news for EmDrive enthusiasts. "We found out that the cause of the 'thrust' was a thermal effect," Tajmar told Grenzwissenschaft-Aktuell.de. "For our tests, we used NASA's EmDrive configuration from White et al. (which was used at the Eagleworks laboratories, because it is best documented and the results were published in the 'Journal of Propulsion and Power'. With the aid of a new measuring scale structure and different suspension points of the same engine, we were able to reproduce apparent thrust forces similar to those measured by the NASA-team, but also to make them disappear by means of a point suspension." "When power flows into the EmDrive," he continued, "the engine warms up. This also causes the fastening elements on the scale to warp, causing the scale to move to a new zero point. We were able to prevent that in an improved structure. Our measurements refute all EmDrive claims by at least three orders of magnitude." The team presented its results at this year's Space Propulsion 2020+1 conference, which was held online due to the pandemic. The entire EmDrive kerfuffle, then, comes down to this: it's really, really hard to precisely measure tiny amounts of thrust, and the standard design everyone's been using to figure out how hard the EmDrive's pushing has been susceptible to an almost imperceptible thermal expansion that made it look like there was thrust, where there was actually none. Newton stands undefeated. In a double victory lap, Tajmar and the team also killed two other EmDrive variants, the LemDrive, and the Mach-Effect Thruster, saying that while it was disappointing that the team couldn't verify the claimed capabilities of these "impossible" engines, at least it had done some great work pushing measuring technology forward. So hopefully the next impossible drive can be proven impossible a lot sooner and with less effort. The German team's paper is freely accessible at ResearchGate, and enjoy EmDrive's explanation of how the thing was supposed to work in the video below. EmDrive Fundamentals Source: Grenzwissenschaft-Aktuell via Popular Mechanics Tags PhysicsSatelliteSpace TravelNASASpacecraftmicrowaveNew Atlas Audio * Facebook * Twitter * Flipboard * LinkedIn Loz Blain Loz Blain Loz has been one of our most versatile contributors since 2007, and has since proven himself as a photographer, videographer, presenter, producer and podcast engineer, as well as a senior features writer. Joining the team as a motorcycle specialist, he's covered just about everything for New Atlas, concentrating lately on eVTOLs, hydrogen, energy, aviation, audiovisual, weird stuff and things that go fast. 11 comments Sign in to post a comment. Please keep comments to less than 150 words. No abusive material or spam will be published. toni24 April 6, 2021 12:21 AM I always thought that the best way to test an impossible space drive, would be to place the test engine in the vacuum of space and turn it on. If it works then it works. We can figure out why it works later. Juanjo April 6, 2021 02:41 AM The problem is to test anything complex in space. It is at least 1000 times the cost compared to the surface of Earth. And, if you need an specialized item to test a different variable, you need to carry it from Earth to the Space Station, for example. David April 6, 2021 06:44 AM If thrust is produced from heat generated by the impossible device itself, imagine what a nice hot cup of tea at Milliways would do. ;-) FB36 April 6, 2021 08:10 AM IMHO, EmDrive could easily really work & w/o requiring any new/exotic physics! All photons (including MW) carryaway momentum (just like atom/ molecules of any rocket fuel)! What EmDrive really needs, to actually produce thrust, is just someone open a hole in the back, to let MW photons escape & so carryaway momentum!!! akarp April 6, 2021 09:43 AM @toni24: Yes! There is a lot in life that 'works'...where understanding why may not be found out in my life time. Aaron MacTurpen April 6, 2021 10:05 AM I suspect Big Space had something to do with quashing this revolutionary propulsion system. Who funds these "scientists?" :P David Knowles April 6, 2021 10:16 AM Isn't anyone else sadden by the tone of this article. We need to keep testing because one day a so called impossible drive may work. fasteddie2020 April 6, 2021 11:42 AM Duh.....Is anyone else on this string old enough to remember the Dean Space Drive System and gravitational-intertial radiation? EmDrive falls into the same category. Past concepts of this type have caused politicians to insist that government organizations study the effect, resulting in the dump of taxpayer dollars. Make it stop! EJ222 April 6, 2021 11:47 AM @FB36 Photon rockets are a solid idea, one that pops up frequently in sci fi. While technically not a reactionless drive, their ISP is literally the theoretical maximum for a rocket. Problem is, you need A LOT of photons to produce any thrust. That kind of power output would make nuclear fusion look like a toy, and then one has to send all those photons out the back without annihilating the spaceship. The kind of exotic matter needed for such a design is barely even theorized yet. Solar sails operate on a similar theory, but sunlight is so weak that an impossibly large and lightweight sail is needed to really get anywhere. Chuck April 6, 2021 12:22 PM I spent 25 years working with electron beams. The Von Ardenne type gun produced a considerable amount of pressure exerted on the target material and relies on a high level of vacuum to operate. I would think a space based use would be ideal. It also needs DC current that might be supplied by a solar array. It produces a high energy stream of electrons that may provide thrust Load More Saving comment... [ ] Post Related Stories * The ALPHA experiment at CERN Physics CERN scientists cool antimatter with lasers for the first time * A diagram of an unusual particle decay that may hint at unknown physics Physics CERN anomaly hints at new particle physics Standard Model can't explain * Analysis of background gravitational waves suggest dark-matter-like particles or a phase transition in the early universe could be behind them Physics Dark matter or cooling "primordial soup" could create gravitational waves * Researchers have measured the smallest gravitational pull yet - equivalent to about the mass of a ladybug Physics Physicists measure the gravitational pull of a ladybug Load More Most Viewed * The Lexus LF-Z Electrified concept has a 90-kWh liquid-cooled, lithium-based battery pack New Atlas Weekly Newscast * The Super Kayak is presently on Kickstarter Outdoors Inflatable Super Kayak catamaran packs into a bag for transport * Researchers have created a synthetic single-celled organism (not pictured) that can divide properly Biology Synthetic organism undergoes cell division in breakthrough study * The prototype solar concentrator, inside its protective dome Good Thinking Sunlight-concentrating ball illuminates dark places Load More [] Over 280,000 people receive our email newsletter. See the stories that matter in your inbox every morning. Join * HOME + FEATURES + REVIEWS + ABOUT + ADVERTISE + TERMS + PRIVACY + CONTACT + RSS + FAQ * LIFESTYLE + Architecture + Around the Home + Children + Collectibles + Good Thinking + Health & Wellbeing + Holiday Destinations + Outdoors + Pets + Remarkable People + Tiny Houses * SCIENCE + Biology + Electronics + Energy + Environment + Materials + Medical + Physics + Quantum Computing + Space * TECHNOLOGY + 3D Printing + Computers + Deals + Photography + Drones + Games + Home Entertainment + Laptops + Military + Mobile Technology + Music + Robotics + Smartwatches + Telecommunications + Wearable Electronics + Virtual Reality * TRANSPORT + Aircraft + Automotive + Bicycles + Marine + Motorcycles + Urban Transport Follow Us * twitter * instagram * flipboard * facebook * linkedin (c) 2021 New Atlas