https://www.zdnet.com/article/sco-linux-fud-returns-from-the-dead/ * Edition: + Asia + Australia + Europe + India + United Kingdom + United States + ZDNet around the globe: + ZDNet France + ZDNet Germany + ZDNet Korea + ZDNet Japan Search What are you looking for? [ ] Go * Videos * Windows 10 * 5G * Best VPNs * Cloud * Security * AI * more + TR Premium + Working from Home + Innovation + Best Web Hosting + ZDNet Recommends + Tonya Hall Show + Executive Guides + ZDNet Academy + See All Topics + White Papers + Downloads + Reviews + Galleries + Videos + TechRepublic Forums * Newsletters * All Writers * + Preferences + Community + Newsletters + Log Out * * + What are you looking for? [ ] Go * Menu + Videos + Windows 10 + 5G + Best VPNs + Cloud + Security + AI + TR Premium + Working from Home + Innovation + Best Web Hosting + ZDNet Recommends + Tonya Hall Show + Executive Guides + ZDNet Academy + See All Topics + White Papers + Downloads + Reviews + Galleries + Videos + TechRepublic Forums * * + o Preferences o Community o Newsletters o Log Out * us + Asia + Australia + Europe + India + United Kingdom + United States + ZDNet around the globe: + ZDNet France + ZDNet Germany + ZDNet Korea + ZDNet Japan SCO Linux FUD returns from the dead UPDATED with IBM's response: Believe it or not, SCO's ancient and long disproved copyright claims that Linux was copied from Unix are returning in a new lawsuit by Xinuos vs IBM and Red Hat. * * * * * * * * Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols By Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols | April 1, 2021 -- 00:26 GMT (17:26 PDT) | Topic: Enterprise Software I have literally been covering SCO's legal attempts to prove that IBM illegally copied Unix's source code into Linux for over 17 years. I've written well over 500 stories on this lawsuit and its variants. I really thought it was dead, done, and buried. I was wrong. Xinuos, which bought SCO's Unix products and intellectual property (IP) in 2011, like a bad zombie movie, is now suing IBM and Red Hat "illegally Copying Xinuos' software code for its server operating systems." ZDNet Recommends The best Linux Foundation classes The best Linux Foundation classes Want a good tech job? Then you need to know Linux and open-source software. One of the best ways to pick them up is via a Linux Foundation course. Read More For those of you who haven't been around for this epic IP lawsuit, you can get the full story with "27 eight-by-ten color glossy photographs and circles and arrows and a paragraph on the back of each one" from Groklaw. If you'd rather not spend a couple of weeks going over the cases, here's my shortened version. Back in 2001, SCO, a Unix company, joined forces with Caldera, a Linux company, to form what should have been a major Red Hat rival. Instead, two years later, SCO sued IBM in an all-out legal attack against Linux. The fact that most of you don't know either company's name gives you an idea of how well that lawsuit went. SCO's Linux lawsuit made no sense and no one at the time gave it much of a chance of succeeding. Over time it was revealed that Microsoft had been using SCO as a sock puppet against Linux. Unfortunately for Microsoft and SCO, it soon became abundantly clear that SCO didn't have a real case against Linux and its allies. SCO lost battle after battle. The fatal blow came in 2007 when SCO was proven to have never owned the copyrights to Unix. So, by 2011, the only thing of value left in SCO, its Unix operating systems, was sold to UnXis. This acquisition, which puzzled most, actually made some sense. SCO's Unix products, OpenServer and Unixware, still had a small, but real market. At the time, UnXis now under the name, Xinuos, stated it had no interest in SCO's worthless lawsuits. In 2016, CEO Sean Snyder said, "We are not SCO. We are investors who bought the products. We did not buy the ability to pursue litigation against IBM, and we have absolutely no interest in that." So, what changed? The company appears to have fallen on hard times. As Snyder stated: "systems, like our FreeBSD-based OpenServer 10, have been pushed out of the market." Officially, in his statement, Snyder now says, "While this case is about Xinuos and the theft of our intellectual property, it is also about market manipulation that has harmed consumers, competitors, the open-source community, and innovation itself." In the complaint to the US District Court of the Virgin Islands, the company claims: First, IBM stole Xinuos' intellectual property and used that stolen property to build and sell a product to compete with Xinuos itself. Second, stolen property in IBM's hand, IBM and Red Hat illegally agreed to divide the relevant market and use their growing market powers to victimize consumers, innovative competitors, and innovation itself. Third, after IBM and Red Hat launched their conspiracy, IBM then acquired Red Hat to solidify and make permanent their scheme. The copyright claims are almost two decades old now and have been disapproved time after time. Xinuos has expanded these copyright claims to cover IBM's Unix operating system such as AIX, as well. Xinuo\s, however, also claims that its litigation is based on specific UnixWare and OpenServer operating systems and code that came into existence after September 19, 1995, and not the early Unix code. IBM spokesperson Doug Shelton responded, "Xinuos's copyright allegations merely rehash the stale claims of its predecessor, whose copyrights Xinuos purchased out of bankruptcy--and have no merit. Xinuos's antitrust allegations, brought against IBM and Red Hat, the world's largest open-source company, similarly defy logic. IBM and Red Hat will aggressively defend the integrity of the open-source development process and the inherent choice, and thus competition, that open source fosters." As for the other claims, that IBM and Red Hat split up the Unix/Linux market between them and that IBM bought Red Hat to consolidate its market share, Xinuos has offered no proof of its assertions. I'm so surprised. Related Stories: * SCO's legal war against IBM and Linux comes to an end * Mission Accomplished: SCO Loses, Groklaw Closes * Worst tech mergers and acquisitions: Caldera and SCO Related Topics: IBM Cloud Big Data Analytics Innovation Tech and Work Collaboration * * * * * * * * Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols By Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols | April 1, 2021 -- 00:26 GMT (17:26 PDT) | Topic: Enterprise Software Show Comments LOG IN TO COMMENT * My Profile * Log Out | Community Guidelines Join Discussion Add Your Comment Add Your Comment More from Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols * [][free-software-foundatio] Enterprise Software The Free Software Foundation's leadership crisis worsens * [][istock-1156760867] Digital Health and Wellness Linux Foundation and OpenTreatments Foundation team up to fight rare genetic diseases * [][subu] Enterprise Software CloudLinux Launches AlmaLinux, CentOS Linux clone * [][istock-1184465348] Enterprise Software Free Software Foundation leaders and supporters desert sinking ship Please review our terms of service to complete your newsletter subscription. [ ] By registering, you agree to the Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices outlined in the Privacy Policy. You will also receive a complimentary subscription to the ZDNet's Tech Update Today and ZDNet Announcement newsletters. You may unsubscribe from these newsletters at any time. [ ] You agree to receive updates, alerts, and promotions from the CBS family of companies - including ZDNet's Tech Update Today and ZDNet Announcement newsletters. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to receive the selected newsletter(s) which you may unsubscribe from at any time. You also agree to the Terms of Use and acknowledge the data collection and usage practices outlined in our Privacy Policy. Continue Newsletters See All See All Related Stories * 1 of 3 * * [][microsoft-building] Microsoft revealed the latest truths about working from home. One is truly disturbing As many drift from working from home to a more hybrid model, what has been lost? And who has really, really gained? Microsoft knows things aren't good. ... * [][screen-shot-2021-03-29-] Southwest Airlines announced a big change that may leave customers speechless When the pandemic and technology get together, they can completely alter the very concept of customer service. But is it a good thing? * [][istock-1160479733] Top cloud providers in 2021: AWS, Microsoft Azure, and Google Cloud, hybrid, SaaS players Cloud computing in 2021 has become the de facto choice of IT due to digital transformation shifts accelerated by remote work and the COVID-19 pandemic. Here's a look the cloud leaders ... * [][kazmaier] Google Cloud hires SAP alum Kazmaier, unifies database, data analytics, Looker units Kazmaier was President of SAP HANA & Analytics and led SAP's global product, solution and engineering teams for database, data warehousing and analytics. ... * [][free-software-foundatio] The Free Software Foundation's leadership crisis worsens RMS has been kicked off the GCC Steering Committee while FSF management team members are resigning * [][customer-engagement] Twilio Segment CEO: Why customer engagement depends on developers As businesses deal with more customer touchpoints than ever before, they'll need developers to make sense of it all, Twilio Segment CEO Peter Reinhardt says. ... * [][collaborationtools3fizk] Research: Majority of enterprises rely on digital collaboration tools Ninety-five percent of respondents said their companies use video conferencing tools such as Microsoft Teams or Zoom, according to a recent TechRepublic Premium poll. ... * [][customer-experience-emp] Cisco integrates IMImobile into Webex Contact Center Following the IMImobile acquisition, Cisco is aiming to deliver a more robust customer experience as a service (CXaaS) offering * [][istock-1169865744] HP South Pacific backflips on last year's loss for 2020 fiscal year HP South Pacific has reported a net profit of just over AU$13 million. ZDNet Connect with us (c) 2021 ZDNET, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Privacy Policy | Cookie Settings | Advertise | Terms of Use * Topics * Galleries * Videos * Sponsored Narratives * Do Not Sell My Information * About ZDNet * Meet The Team * All Authors * RSS Feeds * Site Map * Reprint Policy * Manage | Log Out * Join | Log In * Membership * Newsletters * Site Assistance * ZDNet Academy * TechRepublic Forums