https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/03/after-more-2-decades-searching-scientists-finger-cause-mass-eagle-deaths Skip to main content ScienceMag.org Search X [ ] Advanced Search * Contents * News * Careers * Journals Read our COVID-19 research and news. Share [ca_0326NID] Eagles may get exposed to a neurotoxin through their prey. MIKE MARTIN After more than 2 decades of searching, scientists finger cause of mass eagle deaths By Erik StokstadMar. 25, 2021 , 2:00 PM More than 25 years ago, biologists in Arkansas began to report dozens of bald eagles paralyzed, convulsing, or dead. Their brains were pocked with lesions never seen before in eagles. The disease was soon found in other birds across the southeastern United States. Eventually, researchers linked the deaths to a new species of cyanobacteria growing on an invasive aquatic weed that is spreading across the country. The problem persists, with the disease detected regularly in a few birds, yet the culprit's chemical weapon has remained unknown. Today in Science, a team identifies a novel neurotoxin produced by the cyanobacteria and shows that it harms not just birds, but fish and invertebrates, too. "This research is a very, very impressive piece of scientific detective work," says microbiologist Susanna Wood of the Cawthron Institute. An unusual feature of the toxic molecule is the presence of bromine, which is scarce in lakes and rarely found in cyanobacteria. One possible explanation: the cyanobacteria produce the toxin from a bromide-containing herbicide that lake managers use to control the weed. The discovery highlights the threat of toxic cyanobacteria that grow in sediment and on plants, Wood says, where routine water quality monitoring might miss them. The finding also equips researchers to survey lakes, wildlife, and other cyanobacteria for the new toxin. "It will be very useful," says Judy Westrick, a chemist who studies cyanobacterial toxins at Wayne State University and was not involved in the new research. "I started jumping because I got so excited." Wildlife biologists with U.S. Geological Survey and local institutions first detected the eagles' brain disease, now called vacuolar myelinopathy, at DeGray Lake in Arkansas in late 1994. They soon learned that coots and owls at the lake were dying with similar brain lesions. The researchers ruled out industrial pollutants and infectious disease, and they couldn't find any algal toxins in the water. Then funding ran out, and the scientists turned to other projects. But Susan Wilde, an aquatic ecologist at the University of Georgia, Athens, persisted, with intermittent funding. "I just had a lot of colleagues and graduate students that were self-propelled to work on this." Birds were dying at lakes and reservoirs throughout the southeast, and at every lake her team visited, they found Hydrilla verticillata, a tough and fast-growing invasive plant. In 2001, Wilde noticed dark spots on the underside of the leaves. Back in the lab, she put a sample under a microscope and shone light that makes cyanobacteria glow red. The whole leaf lit up. "I was running around the hallways," Wilde recalls. "It was kind of a eureka moment." The cyanobacterium was a new species, which Wilde named Aetokthonos hydrillicola in 2014. She suspected it was producing a neurotoxin. To confirm that hunch, Wilde and colleagues fed hydrilla to mallards in the lab. Only those that ate leaves harboring the cyanobacteria developed brain lesions. Next, a group led by Timo Niedermeyer, a natural products chemist at Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg, figured out how to culture the cyanobacterium and initially found that the lab-grown strain did not cause lesions in chickens. "Huge disappointment," he recalls. But when they added bromide salts to the culture medium, the cyanobacteria began to produce the neurotoxin. In further tests, Wilde and colleagues found that the toxin also kills fish, insects, and worms. "This is a really potent neurotoxin, even at fairly low levels," she says. Wilde suspects mammals are also vulnerable; her colleagues hope to test the compound on mice. Niedermeyer's lab discovered the neurotoxin was fat-soluble, which is unusual for cyanobacterial toxins and suggests it can accumulate in tissues. Fish and birds are exposed when they eat hydrilla coated with the new species of cyanobacteria, and then the toxin may move through the food web as eagles and owls consume afflicted prey. "If verified, bioaccumulation has important consequences to the whole ecosystem and human health" if people consume toxin-contaminated fish or waterfowl, says Kaarina Sivonen, a microbiologist at the University of Helsinki. The cyanobacterium appears to get the bromide it needs to make the toxin from hydrilla, which can concentrate bromide from lake sediment in its leaves. Bromides are rare in freshwater, but they could be eroding from rocks, or they might originate from coal-fired power plants. Other sources could include brominated flame retardants, fracking fluids, and road salt. Wilde suspects one local source might be an herbicide, diquat dibromide, that is used to kill hydrilla. Wilde points to recent success managing the weed without chemicals, by stocking lakes with fish that eat hydrilla. Although grass carp are not desirable for fishing, using sterile carp would ensure the population would die out once its work was done. The Army Corps of Engineers has already released the fish into a reservoir on the border of Georgia and South Carolina, where they removed the hydrilla. Since then, no more sick eagles have been found. Saving the birds from the neurotoxin will be a long fight, however, because both hydrilla and the cyanobacteria are exceptionally hardy. The invasive plant is likely to continue to be spread by boats, researchers say, and perhaps also migrating birds. "We should expect the cyanobacterium to follow," says George Bullerjahn, a microbiologist at Bowling Green State University, "and the threat of toxicity to become a broader issue." Posted in: * Environment * Plants & Animals doi:10.1126/science.abi7119 [Stokstad_0] Erik Stokstad Erik is a reporter at Science, covering environmental issues. * Email Erik * Twitter More from News * A leafcutter ant queen surrounded by worker ants, which are about one-sixth of the queen's size. What can ants, bees, and other social insects teach us about aging? * jumper rabbit with play button overlay This rabbit walks on its 'hands.' Scientists think they've found the genetic reason why * Two wren-sized birds side by side with playbutton Tiny differences in plumage and song have split two nearly identical birds into different species Got a tip? How to contact the news team ScienceInsider * A man pushes an elderly woman in a wheel chair down a crowded hallway COVID-19 is soaring again in India. Can vaccines stop it? By Vaishnavi ChandrashekharMar. 26, 2021 * An American flag flies in front of the United States Capitol Dome House panel offers its plan to double NSF budget and create technology directorate By Jeffrey MervisMar. 26, 2021 * Syringes containing the new COVID-19 vaccine sit on a tray Syringe size and supply issues continue to waste COVID-19 vaccine doses in United States By Sofia MoutinhoMar. 26, 2021 * Sunset with clouds in Aachen on February 26, 2021 U.S. needs solar geoengineering research program, National Academies says By Paul VoosenMar. 25, 2021 * virus illustration AstraZeneca lowers efficacy claim for COVID-19 vaccine, a bit, after board's rebuke By Jon CohenMar. 25, 2021 More ScienceInsider Sifter * Adult silverleaf whitefl First case of gene transfer between plants and animals: insect swipes protective DNA By Sofia MoutinhoMar. 26, 2021 * Jason Robinson of Sale lies on the ground after suffering a concussion during the Guinness Premiership match between Worcester Warriors and Sale Sharks at Sixways on February 11, 2006 in Worcester, England Your spit could reveal whether you've had a concussion By Adrian ChoMar. 24, 2021 * tornado over a field Scientists have been underestimating the power of tornadoes By Sofia MoutinhoMar. 23, 2021 * different stages of a letter being unfolded Scientists use 'x-ray vision' to read a letter sealed in 1697 By Sofia MoutinhoMar. 2, 2021 * Sahar Saleem placing a mummy in a CT scanner This ancient Egyptian pharaoh met a gruesome end, scans reveal By Sofia MoutinhoFeb. 23, 2021 More Sifter Read the Latest Issue of Science 26 March 2021 Vol 371, Issue 6536 Magazine Cover Table of Contents * Ecology Long live the queen * Astronomy Lens array captures dim objects missed by giant telescopes * Carbon capture marches toward practical use * Anthropology Great Lakes people among first coppersmiths * Ecology Mysterious eagle killer identified * European News Deadly viral outbreak ravages European horses * About Us + Journals + News from Science + Leadership + Team Members + Work at AAAS * For Advertisers + Advertising Kits + Awards and Prizes + Custom Publishing + Webinars * For Authors + Submit + Information for Authors + Editorial Policies * For Librarians + Manage Your Institutional Subscription + Information for Librarians + Request a Quote + FAQs * Related Sites + AAAS.org + EurekAlert! + Science in the Classroom + Science Magazine Japanese * Help + Access and Subscriptions + Order a Single Issue + Reprints and Permissions + Contact Us + Accessibility * Stay Connected o o o o o o AAAS (c) 2021 American Association for the Advancement of Science. All rights Reserved. AAAS is a partner of HINARI, AGORA, OARE, CHORUS, CLOCKSS, CrossRef and COUNTER. * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * Contact AAAS