https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/cold-war-surgical-arms-race * * Trips + Upcoming Trips + All Trips Trips Blog [second-edi] Get the Atlas Obscura book Shop Now >> Upcoming Trips View All Trips >> [blank-11b9] City of Secrets: Underground in Los Angeles [blank-11b9] Afloat the Erie Canal: A Self-Led Houseboat Adventure [blank-11b9] Tunisia Through the Sands of Time [blank-11b9] Science in the Field: Tracking Wild Bumblebees in the Redwoods * Experiences Quick Links + Online Courses + Online Experiences Experiences by City + Chicago + Denver + Los Angeles + New York + Philadelphia + Seattle + Washington, D.C. Upcoming Experiences View All Experiences >> [blank-11b9] Online New York Adventures In Digital Archives [blank-11b9] Online New York Cartooning Folklore & Family History With Zawadi Noel [blank-11b9] Online New York A Bat's Life w/ Dr. Laura Kloepper: Cave Life [blank-11b9] Online New York City Tales From the Museum w/ Kylie & Zak: The International Museum of Surgical Science * Places + Top Destinations + Newly Added Places + Most Popular Places + Random Place + Lists + Itineraries + ------------------------------------------------------------- Add a Place + ------------------------------------------------------------- Visit Our Forums Newly Added Places View All Places >> [blank-11b9] Zagreb, Croatia Gric Tunnel 45.8149, 15.9710 [blank-11b9] Bridgewater, Massachusetts Bridgewater Seal Statue 41.9860, -70.9760 Velasca Tower Milano, Italy Torre Velasca (Velasca Tower) 45.4599, 9.1906 Castle Amphitheater Provo, Utah Castle Amphitheater 40.2341, -111.6317 Top Destinations View All Destinations >> Countries + Australia + Canada + China + France + Germany + India + Italy + Japan Cities + Amsterdam + Barcelona + Beijing + Berlin + Boston + Budapest + Chicago + London + Los Angeles + Mexico City + Montreal + Moscow + New Orleans + New York City + Paris + Philadelphia + Rome + San Francisco + Seattle + Stockholm + Tokyo + Toronto + Vienna + Washington, D.C. * Foods Newly Added Places to Eat & Drink View All Places to Eat >> The "Bakauke Inari" shrine. Niigata Rice Cracker Museum & Bakauke Inari [blank-11b9] The Champion [blank-11b9] The Lillipad Cafe Tolbooth Tavern Tolbooth Tavern [blank-11b9] Tapi Tapi Ice Cream * Stories Most Recent Stories View All Stories >> Zainab Muhammad, Grimaldi Baez, and Tania Maria Rios Marrero harvest zinnias for Truelove Seeds. Keep Your Quarantine Garden Growing With These 8 Unique Seed Companies The partial skull found in Marcel Loubens Cave is more than 5,000 years old Solved: The Mystery of a Lonely Human Skull in an Italian Cave Dracula's Castle, on an amusement pier in Wildwood, New Jersey. When the Jersey Shore Was the Epicenter for Haunted Attractions Berenice's history as a port may partially explain why so many cats were buried there. Is This Egyptian Site the World's Oldest Pet Cemetery? Vladimir Demikhov demonstrates, for an audience of experts, the implantation of an artificial heart-like device in a dog at the 18th International Congress of Surgery in Munich, on September 18, 1959. How the United States and Soviet Union Embarked on a Macabre Surgical Arms Race * Videos Most Recent Videos View All Videos >> [blank-11b9] Meet the Experimental Violinist Forging Her Own Path Sponsored by Nissan [blank-11b9] A Parachutist's Wise Philosophy Sponsored by Nissan [blank-11b9] The Stilt Houses of Pasco County Sponsored by Florida's Sports Coast [blank-11b9] How a Blacksmith in Jordan Created His Own Sign Language 9:02 [blank-11b9] In Naples, Praying With Skulls Is an Ancient Tradition 7:28 * Sign In Join * Sign In ----------------------------------------------------------------- Join * What's near me? Brought to you by [delta_logo] [GettyImage] How the United States and Soviet Union Embarked on a Macabre Surgical Arms Race Cold War animal experimentation and the roots of transplantation medicine. by Brandy Schillace March 4, 2021 How the United States and Soviet Union Embarked on a Macabre Surgical Arms Race Copy Link Facebook Twitter Reddit Flipboard Pocket Vladimir Demikhov demonstrates, for an audience of experts, the implantation of an artificial heart-like device in a dog at the 18th International Congress of Surgery in Munich, on September 18, 1959. Keystone-France/Gamma-Rapho via Getty Images In This Story [blank-11b9] Destination Guide Russia This story is excerpted and adapted from Brandy Schillace's Mr. Humble and Dr. Butcher: A Monkey's Head, the Pope's Neuroscientist, and the Quest to Transplant the Soul, published in March 2021 by Simon & Schuster. --------------------------------------------------------------------- A grainy black-and-white film shuddered across television screens in the last days of May 1958. A man in a long white lab coat gestures to a corner, where a figure waits, shadowy and indistinct. He leads the creature into the light of a courtyard, revealing a strange composite body: a large mastiff dog with a strange and cockeyed mini-body projecting from his back. The second head lolls to one side, tongue panting, legs hanging askew over the shoulders of his larger mate. Offered a saucer of milk, both heads drink for an applauding group of onlookers; close-cut angles reveal the bandages and stiches. Cerberus, named after the mythical three-headed hound of Hades, parades before the camera, a surgically remastered two-headed dog. No one speaks in the footage; if they had, most of the wider world wouldn't have been able to understand. The film and the physiologist behind it, Vladimir Demikhov, emerged from behind the Iron Curtain, inexplicable, macabre, and without much context. And yet the flickering images sent a tremor round the surgical world. The footage reached as far as Cape Town, where Christiaan Barnard (already working on the first human heart transplant) felt compelled to try and repeat Demikhov's experiments. (He succeeded but the dog died, and he had an effigy stuffed and paraded about campus.) News also reached the surgeons at Boston's Peter Bent Brigham, though Joseph Murray, the young doctor on the cutting edge of early transplantation efforts, wasn't convinced of its veracity. Might it not be a hoax? Vladimir Demikhov, pictured here in 1970, believed that his surgical experimentation on dogs could be translated to humans. Vladimir Demikhov, pictured here in 1970, believed that his surgical experimentation on dogs could be translated to humans. Keystone-France/Gamma-Keystone via Getty Images Some dozen years before, Russia had released another film, its first ever produced for Western audiences, called Experiments in the Revival of Organisms. The film presented medical centers with whole departments dedicated to isolated organs: hearts beating on their own, lungs breathing by use of a bellows, the head of a dog supposedly kept alive by machines. This motley circus belonged to Sergei Bryukhonenko, a man both hailed for his groundbreaking research into blood transfusion and later reviled (outside Russia) as a surgical charlatan. His experiments had been half-real chimeras. While he had successfully isolated certain organs, many of his other claims served only as propaganda, suggesting that Russian science would lead to human immortality. That didn't keep his footage from sparking fears of reanimated bodies, of life artificially extended beyond the grave--and the Cerberus film wasn't as easily dismissed. In May 1958, Demikhov gave a public lecture in Leipzig, East Germany, and even performed several heart transplant surgeries (on dogs) in Leipzig by that December. In 1959, he would take part in the XVIII Congress of the International Society of Surgery in Munich. In these presentations and papers, Demikhov revealed that he had been performing these kinds of transplant operations for four years, the first taking place in February 1954--before Murray ever transplanted a kidney (the world's first successful one, between twins, later that year), before the West knew it was possible to transplant anything more than skin. "What else," Western medicine asked, "might the Soviets have done?" "What else," Western medicine asked, "might the Soviets have done?" Many Stalinist laboratories operated quietly outside Moscow. The work remained shrouded in mystery, and unwarranted disclosure could mean imprisonment (or worse); scientists in the same lab limited conversation to the weather and the state of roads, making progress on shared projects difficult and discouraging. That anything so gripping as film footage could escape from Russia unnoticed beggared belief. No--this was surely intentional. But what did it mean? The "leak" (if so it was) followed hard upon the famous words of Soviet premier Nikita Khrushchev, who told Western ambassadors gathered at Moscow's Polish Embassy in 1956: "Whether you like it or not, history is on our side [...] We will bury you!" He meant to impress the assembly of the ultimate victory of socialism over capitalism. Soviet supremacy, he insisted, was "the logic of historical development." Demikhov's work sent the same kind of message, a warning to the West about the superiority of Soviet science. It shocked and dismayed, but it also begged for an answer. How would the United States meet such an unusual challenge? With only a spare few minutes of film, Cerberus and its surgical creator would inaugurate one of the strangest contests of the Cold War. --------------------------------------------------------------------- We have, all of us, grown up in a world of nuclear possibility. As late as the 1980s, students still performed air-raid drills, hiding beneath flimsy desks while pop icons such as Sting released singles hoping "the Russians love their children too." The military-industrial complex so completely anchors our understanding of the last century that it's only with difficulty that we imagine a world before it. Yet little of that extraordinary military apparatus existed before Enola Gay dropped the first atomic bomb over Hiroshima on August 6, 1945. The publicly given reason for doing so was to end the war, though firebombing campaigns had already ravaged Japanese cities, and Japan's hamstrung navy could no longer perform major maneuvers. Historians continue to debate whether unleashing radioactive warfare had been a necessary step, but one thing remains certain: The atom bomb's sheer destructive force, mysteriously expanding from the tell-tale mushroom cloud, made it the most powerful weapon of psychological intimidation yet invented. It sent a fearful message to the world about the United States' combined military might and technical superiority. That was, after all, the point. The pyrocumulus, or firestorm-cloud, following the U.S. bombing of Hiroshima in August 1945. The pyrocumulus, or firestorm-cloud, following the U.S. bombing of Hiroshima in August 1945. Roger Viollet via Getty Images The awesome, annihilating power of the bomb did more than end a war: It changed the role of science, which became, writes Cold War historian Audra Wolfe, a tool not only of war but of foreign relations, too. A climate of optimism developed among the American public, built on the belief that science had won the war for us, fostering a relaxed attitude toward our enemies and competitors. The United States, after all, controlled the brain trust of scientists, as well as the raw materials (stockpiles of uranium). Some researchers and government officials held less rosy views about either American superiority or the safety of its exclusive control. The most conservative estimates suggested at least a five-year monopoly on atomic ability. They were wrong. Soviets began testing the atom bomb by 1949, and the gap closed faster as time went on. How could a war-torn country, still deep in debt, produce results so quickly? The question haunted American officials. Mark Popovskii, a Russian journalist forced to flee to the United States for his reports about the Soviet government, described military laboratories "springing out of the ground like mushrooms," while Higher Examination Boards turned out up to 5,000 doctoral degrees per year. This wasn't mere saber rattling. If Russians could prove superiority in science and technology, they could control the temperature of the Cold War. If my science wins, went the argument, then that means my ideology's won, too--and both sides believed only one system could prevail. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Across America, surgeons' changing rooms, the medical equivalent of the water-cooler, buzzed with rumors about Russian medicine. Both Joseph Murray and Robert White, a neurosurgeon also deeply interested in transplantation, had witnessed firsthand how military science could influence and catalyze medical science, reallocating resources toward plastic surgery to heal wounds and the study of pathogens that might make troops sick. Ever since the war, Russia's military tech "had come so far so fast... we wondered if there was some spill over in medicine," White would later explain, remembering the wild speculation of those days. "Maybe behind the curtain there were research centers that had cured cancer or found ways to replace the blood with artificial solutions." American doctors were afraid the Russians were winning. And through the occasional films, publications, and propaganda speeches that reached the West, Russia certainly tried to give that impression. Fearful rumors suggested the Russians had mastered psychokinesis for guided missiles, or that they dabbled in the occult. After the war, experiments in medicine redoubled. The Soviet Institute for Brain Research at Leningrad State University researched telepathy, or "biological communication," and attempted training programs to boost military personnel's precognitive abilities. Fearful rumors suggested the Russians had even mastered psychokinesis for guided missiles, or that they dabbled in the occult. It might seem remarkable--even ridiculous--but the United States took these paranormal possibilities seriously. American scientists couldn't afford to be skeptical; no one really knew for sure that the Soviets hadn't made such breakthroughs. After all, a few decades earlier, splitting the atom had seemed just as magical, mysterious, and practically impossible. The postwar era operated on two guiding principles. On one hand, incredible hope for scientific (even pseudo-scientific) possibility; on the other, an increasing dread that the Soviets would get there first--the science fiction trope that the "enemy" would somehow beat the "good guys" through mastery of technology. And so, when the Demikhov footage appeared, it acted almost like the mushroom clouds off distant islands. Whatever else occurred behind the Curtain, the Russians were making monsters. --------------------------------------------------------------------- In 1959, journalist Edmund Stevens of LIFE Magazine received an unusual invitation: He and American photojournalist Howard Sochurek would be welcomed to document a surgery conducted by Demikhov, a physiologist without an MD who had been engaged in ambitious, even reckless surgical experiments. Stevens, who lived in Russia, had won a Pulitzer in 1950 for a series of articles for The Christian Science Monitor titled "Russia Uncensored," about life under Stalin. Despite being an American by birth, Stevens sympathized with the country he'd called home since 1934. American journalist Edmund Stevens, pictured here in 1940, spent more than five decades as a foreign correspondent in the Soviet Union. American journalist Edmund Stevens, pictured here in 1940, spent more than five decades as a foreign correspondent in the Soviet Union. Carl Mydans/The LIFE Picture Collection via Getty Images Stevens described Demikhov as "vigorously decisive," a man in utter command. The morning of the surgery, he presented his assistants and surgical nurse in turn, but the journalists could not help but concentrate on the "patients," one of whom was barking incessantly. Shavka, a "perky little mongrel" yipped excitedly, floppy ears and pointed nose actively twitching and alert. Her normally shaggy hair had been shorn away about her middle; she was soon to lose her torso and lower extremities, including all capacity for digestion, respiration, and heartbeat. Already anesthetized, Brodyaga, or "Tramp," lay upon the table next to her. He'd lost his freedom to dogcatchers, and would now serve as Shavka's "recipient." While the journalists marveled, Demikhov called over another dog. Named Palma, she had a series of serious scars upon her chest from an operation six days previous; Demikhov had given her a second heart and altered her lungs to accommodate it. She happily nuzzled him, wagging her tail. "You see, she bears me no ill will," he said, as if answering Stevens' misgivings. Demikhov scrubbed up for surgery on Shavka and Brodyaga. "You know the saying," he remarked in Russian. "Two heads are better than one." Shavka, who had continued to bark all the while, was at last put under a heavy narcotic. To the world, this was Demikhov's second two-headed canine surgery. In fact, it marked his 24th--two dozen surgeries (on 44 dogs) in five years. The entire procedure took less than four hours. His first, in 1954, had taken 12. Finished with the grisly work, Demikhov removed his gloves. The idea for a two-headed dog, he explained calmly, came to him 10 years earlier. Now, working on dogs seemed almost passe. "I have news for you," he announced. "We are moving our entire project to a wing of the Sklifosovsky Institute," Moscow's largest emergency hospital. They had outgrown the "experimental" stage, he claimed, and it was time to move on to human transplants. An operation, on September 24, 1958, at the Moscow Medical Institute involved grafting the head of a puppy onto a full grown dog. It was one of Vladimir Demikhov many experimental surgeries on dogs. An operation, on September 24, 1958, at the Moscow Medical Institute involved grafting the head of a puppy onto a full grown dog. It was one of Vladimir Demikhov many experimental surgeries on dogs. Bettmann/Getty Images Did Demikhov truly plan to operate on people, even though science had yet to find a reliable way to make non-twin transplants work? "Moscow is a huge city where hundreds die daily," he added. Why shouldn't the dead serve the living? Demikhov gave Stevens a rare smile, and revealed he had a test subject already, a woman of 35 who had lost her leg in a streetcar accident. He planned to provide her with a new one. "The main problem will be joining the nerves so that the woman can control her movements," he added. "But I am sure we can lick that too." Shavka and Brogyaga would perish only four days later. Demikhov didn't think of this as a failure, however. Far from it. Back at Brigham, Joseph Murray, reading Stevens's piece in LIFE, balked; the tissues Demikhov planned to transplant could never function properly, he grumbled. The dogs, after all, would have eventually perished from the rejection of the foreign tissue. Murray was now working hard on anti-rejection drugs, though he wouldn't have much success until the following decade. Demikhov couldn't expect favorable results "unless," he added derisively, "the Russians have made some breakthrough we don't know about." But as with the launch of Sputnik, no one could be certain they hadn't. Enormous streams of funding poured into research and development. Since Russia put up the first satellite, the United States would launch a better one. Since Russia put a dog in space (Laika, on Sputnik II), the United States would launch a chimp (named Ham). Stevens's article proved Demikhov's proficiency with head transplants, and in the same spirit of creative one-upmanship, the National Institute of Health in America began funding experimental laboratories. What the Soviets could do with dogs, went the logic, we could do with primates. And what could be done with primates could be done with humans. The United States and Soviet Union had embarked upon an inner space race--decades of surgical brinksmanship. Atlas Obscura Trips Searching for Russia's Northern Lights View This Trip medical experimentssurgerythe soviet imprintcold warmedicinesoviet historyhistory Using an ad blocker? We depend on ad revenue to craft and curate stories about the world's hidden wonders. Consider supporting our work by becoming a member for as little as $5 a month. Continue Using Ad-Block Support Us Keep Exploring [blank-11b9] dictators How Stalin and the Soviet Union Created a Champagne for the Working Class In 1936, the Party suddenly switched from denouncing bubbly to mass producing it. Jessica Gingrich November 5, 2019 [blank-11b9] space exploration How Soviet Science Magazines Fantasized About Life in Outer Space The Iron Curtain went to infinity and beyond. Winnie Lee March 13, 2020 [blank-11b9] soviet architecture On Vacation in Soviet-Era Sanatoriums The treatments are no longer mandatory, but they're still available. Anika Burgess August 19, 2019 [blank-11b9] plague Medieval Pilgrims Apparently Tried to Ward Off the Plague With Bawdy Badges Metal phalluses and vulvas were thought to protect against disease. Olivia Campbell January 29, 2021 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * Object of Intrigue The Most Influential Medical Book of the 16th Century 2:41 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * Object of Intrigue Mysterious and Intricate 17th-Century Anatomical Manikins 2:13 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * AO Docs Inside the World of an Obsessive Collector of Old Tech 4:05 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * PinDrop Step Inside a Surreal, Dizzying Italian Fortress 1:54 [W1siZiIsIj] Video A Glimpse Inside a Synthetic Cadaver Factory 3:48 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * Wonder From Home Show & Tell: The Radio Guy's Collection of Scary-Looking Headgear 11:59 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * Wonder From Home Show & Tell: See a Collection of Dissected Skulls and Medical Marvels 14:07 [W1siZiIsIj] Video See the Ruins of an Estonian Ghost Town 5:25 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * AO Docs Hawai`i's Native-Language Newspaper Archive 3:35 Sponsored by Olukai [W1siZiIsIj] Video * AO Docs 'Discovering' Mexico's Monarch Butterfly Migration 6:46 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * Object of Intrigue The Real Story Behind George Washington's Dentures 3:30 [W1siZiIsIj] Video * Object of Intrigue Behold, the Vampire-Killing Kit 4:19 [W1siZiIsIj] Video See the Mysterious Horned Helmet of Henry VIII 4:00 Want to see fewer ads? Become a Member. Related How Santa Survived the Soviet Era Of all the variations on the beloved character, Russia's Ded Moroz might have the strangest history. Read more [blank-11b9] [] We Need Your Help Support Atlas Obscura today so we can share wonder tomorrow. Become a Member Get Our Email Newsletter [ ] [Subscribe] Thanks for subscribing! View all newsletters >> Follow Us * * * * * Places * Recently Added * Most Popular * Random * Nearby * Add a Place Foods * Latest * Food & Drink * Stories * Places * Add a Food Trips * All Trips * Trips Blog * Art & Culture Trips * Food Trips * Hidden City Trips * History Trips * Photography Trips * Wildlife & Nature Trips * FAQ Experiences * All Experiences * Online Experiences * Online Courses * FAQ Community * Membership * Travel Forum * Latest Posts * Top Posts Company * About * Contact Us * FAQ * Work With Us * Advertising * Unique Gifts * Privacy Policy * Cookie Policy * Terms of Use [] (c) 2021 Atlas Obscura. All rights reserved. Questions or Feedback? Contact Us Thanks for sharing! Follow us on Twitter to get the latest on the world's hidden wonders. Like us on Facebook to get the latest on the world's hidden wonders. Follow us on Twitter Like us on Facebook Want a Free Book? Sign up for our newsletter and enter to win the second edition of our book, Atlas Obscura: An Explorer's Guide to the World's Hidden Wonders. [ ] Subscribe No Thanks Visit AtlasObscura.com Atlas Obscura: An Explorer's Guide to the World's Hidden Wonders Stay in Touch! Follow us on social media to add even more wonder to your day. Follow us on Twitter Like us on Facebook Follow Us on Instagram No Thanks Visit AtlasObscura.com No purchase necessary. Winner will be selected at random on 04/01/ 2021. Offer available only in the U.S. (including Puerto Rico). Offer subject to change without notice. See contest rules for full details. Add Some Wonder to Your Inbox Every weekday we compile our most wondrous stories and deliver them straight to you. [ ] Subscribe No Thanks We'd Like You to Like Us Like Atlas Obscura and get our latest and greatest stories in your Facebook feed. No Thanks This website uses cookies Atlas Obscura and our trusted partners use technology such as cookies on our website to personalise ads, support social media features, and analyse our traffic. Please click below to consent to the use of this technology while browsing our site. To learn more or withdraw consent, please visit our cookie policy. I Accept [p] Quantcast