https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/we-havent-seen-quarter-of-known-bee-species-since-1990s National Geographic Logo - Home Skip to content * * * Renew * Subscribe * Menu a bee on a purple flower The 4.5-millimeter-long Smeathman's burrow bee belongs to the Halictidae family, also called sweat bees. Observations of halictid bees in the wild have dropped dramatically in recent decades. Photograph by Phil Savoie, Nature Picture Library Please be respectful of copyright. Unauthorized use is prohibited. * Animals * News We haven't seen a quarter of known bee species since the 1990s A sweeping analysis shows an overall downward trend in bee diversity worldwide, raising concerns about these crucial pollinators. ByLiz Langley Published January 22, 2021 * 6 min read ShareTweetEmail Bees feed us. Many of the 20,000 species pollinate 85 percent of food crops and fruits around the world--everything from garlic and grapefruits to coffee and kale. But, it seems, these crucial insects aren't doing very well. A study published today in the journal One Earth reveals that in recent decades, the number of bee species reported in the wild has declined globally. The sharpest decrease occurred between 2006 and 2015, with roughly 25 percent fewer species spotted--even as sightings by citizen scientists were increasing rapidly. Halictid bees--also called sweat bees for their attraction to our perspiration--pollinate important crops such as alfalfa, sunflowers, and cherries. Observations of these tiny metallic fliers have fallen by 17 percent since the 1990s, the study found. Bees in the rare Melittidae family, which provide us with blueberries, cranberries, and orchids, have plummeted by as much as 41 percent. (The world's bees are divided among seven families.) Though lesser known, such wild bees supplement the work of honeybees in managed hives. "Even if honeybees can be efficient pollinators of many crops, heavy reliance on a single species is very risky," says study leader Eduardo Zattara, a biologist at the Institute for Research on Biodiversity and the Environment, in Bariloche, Argentina. For instance, during a disease outbreak in 2006, the U.S. lost about half its honeybees. Had only domesticated bees been present, "the yield loss would have been enormous," Zattara says. (Read how dying bees spell trouble for U.S. agriculture.) The study drew on an open-access website called the Global Biodiversity Information Facility, which contains bee-observation records sourced from museums, universities, and private citizens going back to the 1700s. Most studies on bee diversity focus on a specific area or species, which is what inspired this broad analysis. "There's no long-term, very accurate, precise sampling of bees all over the world," Zattara says. "We wanted to see if we could use this kind of data to get a more global answer, and the answer we got is, yes." Nevertheless, he cautions, the records that underpin the study don't give us enough information to determine if certain species have gone extinct. "What we can say is that wild bees are not exactly thriving." Threats to bees The analysis shows a decline in species sightings on all continents except Australia, where there's a comparative dearth of data, Zattara says. Bees don't inhabit Antarctica. During the second half of the past century, a global agricultural boom led to habitat loss, while widespread use of pesticides killed off many plants bees rely on for food. Meanwhile, warming temperatures have forced bee species out of their native ranges or killed them outright. (Related: Bumblebees are going extinct in a time of "climate chaos.") Another cause of declines: When countries introduce non-native bees to pollinate particular agricultural crops, pathogens may come with them, "creating insect-style pandemics," Zattara says. He points to two European bumblebees brought into Chile and Argentina that have driven the Patagonian bumblebee--nicknamed the "flying mouse" on account of its size--to endangered status because of competition for its food and susceptibility to novel diseases. three bumblebees on a flowering plant Buff-tailed bumblebees, originally from Europe, forage on blackbeerry flowers in Puerto Blest, Argentina. The invasive species have wreaked havoc on native bees in Patagonia. Photograph by Eduardo E. Zattara Please be respectful of copyright. Unauthorized use is prohibited. Crunching bee data To derive order from a staggering amount of data--there could be as many as 100,000 bee records per year--Zattara and his colleague, biologist Marcelo Aizen, of Argentina's National University of Comahue, first divided the information by year. Then every species reported that year was counted. Zattara says what mattered wasn't how many individual bees were sighted in a year, but the frequencies of the species themselves. This approach helped reduce inconsistencies among countries--a much larger fraction of data comes from North America than, say, in Africa, so tallying up raw numbers of sightings could skew the results. Saving Bumblebees Became This Photographer's Mission 6:54 Saving Bumblebees Became This Photographer's Mission "Species that were more common would be almost always reported, while species that were harder to find would be more likely to be missing from a given year," he says. Then too with such a plethora of information going back hundreds of years, there's the likelihood of errors and personal biases creeping in, such as when an observer who is looking for a specific bee may ignore other species, says Rachael Bonoan, an ecologist at Providence College, in Rhode Island. Bonoan specializes in insect pollinators and wasn't involved in the research. (Read nine ways people can help pollinators at home.) Even so, "the authors really did a good job dealing with possible biases," Bonoan says. Zattara acknowledges that, when wrangling information on 20,000 bee species, mistakes and errors can occur. The rise of the citizen scientist Given the overall picture of declines, he hopes scientists will make more research and collection data public, including contributions by citizen scientists to help fill knowledge gaps. Indeed, during the coronavirus pandemic, many citizen science websites in the U.S. have shown more activity, particularly ones that track insects. "It's really useful to have many eyes watching out for change," Zattara says. "We've definitely hit this point in time where people are starting to care about insects, which is fantastic," Bonoan adds. Sounding the call to "care about these really charismatic, useful insects," she says, "can do nothing but good for the environment and other insect pollinators as well." ShareTweetEmail --------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Read This Next [yH5BAEAAAA] * Science * Interactive Graphic Visualizing 500,000 deaths from COVID-19 in the U.S. The United States has reached a grim milestone--the moment when half a million Americans have lost their lives to the coronavirus. Why kids need their own COVID-19 vaccine trials [yH5BAEAAAA] * Science * Coronavirus Coverage Why kids need their own COVID-19 vaccine trials Adolescents are being tested now. Younger children will be next. Why did vaccine manufacturers wait to study them? A black-footed ferret has been cloned, a first for a U.S. endangered species [yH5BAEAAAA] * Animals A black-footed ferret has been cloned, a first for a U.S. endangered species A black-footed ferret that died more than 30 years ago has been cloned using preserved cells, which could help inject diversity into the inbred, endangered population. 3-ton parts of Stonehenge may have been carried from earlier monuments [yH5BAEAAAA] * History & Culture 3-ton parts of Stonehenge may have been carried from earlier monuments Years of archaeological research now suggest that Neolithic Britons lugged massive elements of the iconic monument from far-flung reaches of the island. Go Further Animals * Yellow penguin spotted in Antarctica--here's why it's so rare + Animals Yellow penguin spotted in Antarctica--here's why it's so rare * A lemur died from tuberculosis--a likely victim of the illegal pet trade + Animals + Wildlife Watch A lemur died from tuberculosis--a likely victim of the illegal pet trade * Nearly 5,000 sea turtles rescued from freezing waters on Texas island + Animals Nearly 5,000 sea turtles rescued from freezing waters on Texas island * Selfie-taking tourists risk giving wild gorillas COVID-19, other diseases + Animals Selfie-taking tourists risk giving wild gorillas COVID-19, other diseases * Monkeys still forced to pick coconuts in Thailand despite controversy + Animals + Wildlife Watch Monkeys still forced to pick coconuts in Thailand despite controversy * A black-footed ferret has been cloned, a first for a U.S. endangered species + Animals A black-footed ferret has been cloned, a first for a U.S. endangered species * Grizzlies are coming back. But can we make room for them? + Animals Grizzlies are coming back. But can we make room for them? * More than 130 years after its discovery, this moth was finally photographed alive + Animals + Photo Ark More than 130 years after its discovery, this moth was finally photographed alive * The world's biggest owl is endangered--but it's not too late to save it + Animals + Last of the Last The world's biggest owl is endangered--but it's not too late to save it * Lasers, cannons, effigies: The surprising science of shooing vultures away + Animals Lasers, cannons, effigies: The surprising science of shooing vultures away * Echolocation is nature's built-in sonar. Here's how it works. + Animals Echolocation is nature's built-in sonar. Here's how it works. * How the world's largest rhino population dropped by 70 percent--in a decade + Animals + Wildlife Watch How the world's largest rhino population dropped by 70 percent--in a decade Environment * The unintended environmental benefit of Cuba's isolation + Environment The unintended environmental benefit of Cuba's isolation * Same force behind Texas deep freeze could drive prolonged heat waves + Environment Same force behind Texas deep freeze could drive prolonged heat waves * After you get a COVID-19 vaccine, what can you do safely? + Coronavirus Coverage After you get a COVID-19 vaccine, what can you do safely? * The Keystone XL pipeline is dead. Now what? + Environment The Keystone XL pipeline is dead. Now what? * This in-demand plant is evolving to hide from its predator--humans + Environment This in-demand plant is evolving to hide from its predator--humans * These widely used insecticides may be a threat to mammals too + Environment These widely used insecticides may be a threat to mammals too * Oil drilling on sensitive New Mexico public lands puts drinking water, rare caves at risk + Environment Oil drilling on sensitive New Mexico public lands puts drinking water, rare caves at risk * The world's wetlands are slipping away. This vibrant sanctuary underscores the stakes. + Environment The world's wetlands are slipping away. This vibrant sanctuary underscores the stakes. * This single number could reshape our climate future + Environment This single number could reshape our climate future * The U.S. commits to tripling its protected lands. Here's how it could be done. + Environment The U.S. commits to tripling its protected lands. Here's how it could be done. * Has the electric car's moment arrived at last? + Environment Has the electric car's moment arrived at last? * These 6 numbers define the climate challenge in a changing U.S. + Environment These 6 numbers define the climate challenge in a changing U.S. History & Culture * Text messages capture heartbreaking goodbyes of COVID-19 victims + History & Culture + Coronavirus Coverage Text messages capture heartbreaking goodbyes of COVID-19 victims * How do we know what ancient Greek warriors wore for battle? It's in 'The Iliad.' + History Magazine How do we know what ancient Greek warriors wore for battle? It's in 'The Iliad.' * Sentenced to death, but innocent: These are stories of justice gone wrong. + Magazine Sentenced to death, but innocent: These are stories of justice gone wrong. * 3-ton parts of Stonehenge may have been carried from earlier monuments + History & Culture 3-ton parts of Stonehenge may have been carried from earlier monuments * How ancient astronomy mixed science with mythology, Video Story + History & Culture + Nat Geo Explores How ancient astronomy mixed science with mythology * This ivory relic reveals the colonial power dynamic between Benin and Portugal + History Magazine This ivory relic reveals the colonial power dynamic between Benin and Portugal * Reconstruction offered a glimpse of equality for Black Americans. Why did it fail? + History & Culture + Race in America Reconstruction offered a glimpse of equality for Black Americans. Why did it fail? * 'I don't even know if my home still exists.' + History & Culture 'I don't even know if my home still exists.' * Old-fashioned images evoke the complicated history of Black military service + History & Culture Old-fashioned images evoke the complicated history of Black military service * This ruthless African king knew Rome was for sale. He bought it + History Magazine This ruthless African king knew Rome was for sale. He bought it * What's next for these transgender asylum seekers stranded in Mexico? + History & Culture What's next for these transgender asylum seekers stranded in Mexico? * Trouble lurks for Afghanistan's beloved 'goat grabbing' national sport + History & Culture Trouble lurks for Afghanistan's beloved 'goat grabbing' national sport Science * Watch the first-ever video of a spacecraft landing on Mars + Science Watch the first-ever video of a spacecraft landing on Mars * The eccentric scientist behind the 'gold standard' COVID-19 test + Science + Coronavirus Coverage The eccentric scientist behind the 'gold standard' COVID-19 test * Why kids need their own COVID-19 vaccine trials + Science + Coronavirus Coverage Why kids need their own COVID-19 vaccine trials * From outbreak to immunity, Video Story + Partner Content From outbreak to immunity * WHO approves AstraZeneca-Oxford vaccine for emergency use globally + Science + Coronavirus Coverage WHO approves AstraZeneca-Oxford vaccine for emergency use globally * Success! NASA's Perseverance rover has just landed on Mars + Science + Mars Success! NASA's Perseverance rover has just landed on Mars * Watch as NASA attempts a daring Mars rover landing + Science + Mars Watch as NASA attempts a daring Mars rover landing * Million-year-old mammoth teeth yield world's oldest DNA + Science Million-year-old mammoth teeth yield world's oldest DNA * Why mapping Mars completely changed how we see it, Video Story + Science + Nat Geo Explores Why mapping Mars completely changed how we see it * How these feuding map-makers shaped our fascination with Mars, Video Story + Science + Mars How these feuding map-makers shaped our fascination with Mars * Earth's mountains may have mysteriously stopped growing for a billion years + Science Earth's mountains may have mysteriously stopped growing for a billion years * After you get a COVID-19 vaccine, what can you do safely? + Science + Coronavirus Coverage After you get a COVID-19 vaccine, what can you do safely? As more people are fully vaccinated, certain activities will become less risky, but experts still recommend holding on to precautions for the near future. Travel * From 'Herbie the Love Bug' to punch buggy, the Beetle remains iconic in Mexico + Travel From 'Herbie the Love Bug' to punch buggy, the Beetle remains iconic in Mexico * 'It really is like flying.' Explore wild skating on nature's ice + Travel 'It really is like flying.' Explore wild skating on nature's ice * The legendary community that fought for its freedom in Jamaica + Travel The legendary community that fought for its freedom in Jamaica * Why this salty Massachusetts coastal town hooks artists + Travel Why this salty Massachusetts coastal town hooks artists * Families are leading a new wave for Black travelers + Travel + Race in America Families are leading a new wave for Black travelers * Winter is prime time for watching bald eagles--here's how + Travel Winter is prime time for watching bald eagles--here's how * As Lunar New Year approaches, many Asians worry about future journeys + Travel + Race in America As Lunar New Year approaches, many Asians worry about future journeys * Want dreamy winter photos? Take to the air with a drone + Travel Want dreamy winter photos? Take to the air with a drone * These World's Fair sites reveal a history of segregation + Travel + Race in America These World's Fair sites reveal a history of segregation * Can carbon capture make flying more sustainable? + Travel Can carbon capture make flying more sustainable? * Stereotypes have fueled a tourism boom in Europe's icy North. Can things change? + Travel Stereotypes have fueled a tourism boom in Europe's icy North. Can things change? * The next great whiskey trail is not where you think it is + Travel The next great whiskey trail is not where you think it is Subscriber Exclusive Content previous * Magazine Why are people so dang obsessed with Mars? Read * Magazine How viruses shape our world Read * Animals The era of greyhound racing in the U.S. is coming to an end Read * Magazine See how people have imagined life on Mars through history Read * Magazine See how NASA's new Mars rover will explore the red planet Explore * Magazine Why are people so dang obsessed with Mars? Read * Magazine How viruses shape our world Read * Animals The era of greyhound racing in the U.S. is coming to an end Read * Magazine See how people have imagined life on Mars through history Read * Magazine See how NASA's new Mars rover will explore the red planet Explore * Magazine Why are people so dang obsessed with Mars? Read * Magazine How viruses shape our world Read * Animals The era of greyhound racing in the U.S. is coming to an end Read * Magazine See how people have imagined life on Mars through history Read * Magazine See how NASA's new Mars rover will explore the red planet Explore next See More The best of National Geographic delivered to your inbox Sign up for more inspiring photos, stories, and special offers from National Geographic. Sign Up Legal * Terms of Use * Privacy Policy * Your California Privacy Rights * Children's Online Privacy Policy * Interest-Based Ads * About Nielsen Measurement * Do Not Sell My Info Our Sites * Nat Geo Home * Attend a Live Event * Book a Trip * Buy Maps * Inspire Your Kids * Shop Nat Geo * Visit the D.C. Museum * Watch TV * Learn About Our Impact * Nat Geo Partners * Masthead * Press Room * Advertise With Us Join Us * Subscribe * Customer Service * Renew Subscription * Manage Your Subscription * Work at Nat Geo * Sign up for Our Newsletters * Contribute to Protect the Planet * Pitch a Story Follow us National Geographic FacebookNational Geographic TwitterNational Geographic Instagram United States (Change) --------------------------------------------------------------------- National Geographic Logo - Home Copyright (c) 1996-2015 National Geographic SocietyCopyright (c) 2015-2021 National Geographic Partners, LLC. All rights reserved