https://daily.jstor.org/the-murder-ballad-was-the-original-true-crime-podcast/ Skip to content [j_dailylogo_header_184x60] where news meets its scholarly match * Newsletters * * * [ ] * Arts & Culture + Art & Art History + Film & Media + Language & Literature + Performing Arts * Business & Economics + Business + Economics * Politics & History + Politics & Government + U.S. History + World History + Social History + Quirky History * Science & Technology + Health + Natural Science + Plants & Animals + Sustainability & The Environment + Technology * Education & Society + Education + Lifestyle + Religion + Social Sciences * About JSTOR Daily * Newsletters * Contact The Editors * Support JSTOR Daily Arts & Culture The Murder Ballad Was the Original True Crime Podcast The 1896 version of crime sensationalism also taught the victim-blaming lesson "Stay Sexy, Don't Get Murdered." An illustration for Jesse James at Long Branch in the magazine Log Cabin Library, 1898. An illustration for Jesse James at Long Branch in the magazine Log Cabin Library, 1898. via Wikimedia Commons By: Jody Amable January 30, 2021 January 25, 2021 4 minutes Share Tweet Email Print The Deep River in North Carolina is not that deep. Rising in High Point and joining with the Haw River in Chatham County, it passes through farmland, forest, and town before it empties into the Atlantic at Wilmington. Its rocky bed and steep slopes make it ideal for hydropower-- to generate energy, water should be rushing. It must have been a surprise, then, when Naomi Wise's body was found floating in the ford in Randolph County. The swift current should have carried her away. Her lover, Jonathan Lewis, was strongly suspected of the drowning. He was tried, but acquitted. Weekly Newsletter Get your fix of JSTOR Daily's best stories in your inbox each Thursday. [ ][Subscribe] Privacy Policy Contact Us You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking on the provided link on any marketing message. You'd be forgiven for thinking this was the plot of a moody drama or a Dateline special. Actually, it's the story told in "Omie Wise," one of the many murder ballads that swept nineteenth-century America. After Wise became pregnant by an engaged man, he (allegedly) killed her to cover up the indiscretion. Court records of Jonathan Lewis' trial exist, so we know the tale is, chillingly, true. Murder ballads are "the oldest form of crime literature," as the true crime writer Harold Schechter wrote in The Yale Review. They're the first place Americans sought cheap thrills based on a true story. They were innovated by broadside balladeers of the British Isles. Broadsides were one of the first forms of printed news: as advances in printing made publishing cheap, pamphlets or posters were printed with the news of the day. They were written to appeal to a wide range of people, some of whom couldn't read. The "ballad" style--a modern-day poem or song--was a common format, as they could easily be orated or set to music. The style made the news accessible to all, and, as the English professor Erik Nebeker noted in "The Broadside Ballad and Textual Public," encouraged public debate. As art forms, they were also a form of entertainment, introducing an element of sensationalism we'd later see in tabloids. Ballads were often composed at the time of trial as a means of getting the word out about local events. Some ballads crossed the Atlantic with the wave of English and Scottish settlers to Appalachia. As cities and towns flourished, and justice systems organized, ballads became folk songs that told of the people and issues in the singer's community. Songs like "John Hardy," "Stagger Lee," "Jesse James," and later, "The Murder of the Lawson Family" covered true events. As the folklore scholar Ann Reichman notes in Folklore in Utah, ballads were often composed at the time of trial as a means of getting the word out about local events. Seeking out sensational stories is a very human pursuit because, as it turns out, a lot of us like to be scared. The scientific jury is still mostly out on why some people go looking for a fear response in the form of haunted houses and scary movies, but often cited is the dopamine that's released when we get spooked, creating a sensation similar to euphoria. As the historian Joy Wiltenburg writes in "True Crime: The Origins of Modern Sensationalism," when we read a shocking story, the violation of social norms distorts our emotional response, creating excitement. The word "sensationalism" itself was coined in the nineteenth century to denounce works meant to elicit strong emotions, such as stories of in-cold-blood killings. The sensationalism established in the murder ballad traces a direct line to the true-crime boom of today. It stayed a storytelling constant in American society, from penny dreadfuls to urban legends to Lifetime original movies. Serial established true crime as a dominant genre in the podcast industry. In 2019, true crime podcasts filled the first three slots of the most-subscribed-to shows on Apple Podcasts, and account for five of the top 15. True crime podcasts are now so ubiquitous that the phrase "true crime podcast" has become sort of a punchline, a byword for "guilty pleasure." The other function of true crime is as a cautionary tale: a warning to steer clear. It sometimes sounds like what we'd now call victim-blaming: If you don't want to end up like Omie Wise, don't follow men to the river (as opposed to making the moral of the story, say, "don't murder people"). Take, for example, the ending from a version of "Pearl Bryant:" Now all young girls take warning, for all men are unjust It may be your truest lover; you know not whom to trust Pearl Bryan died away from home on a dark and lonely spot My God, believe me girls, don't let this be your lot. Like murder ballads, many modern true-crime franchises, and podcasts in particular, assert that they exist to arm potential victims with the knowledge they need to fight back, or to honor victims by keeping their stories alive. But evidence shows there's not nearly as much to fight back against or fear these days: "The Fear of Crime in the United States: A Tale of Two Genders," published in the International Journal of Sociology of the Family, points out that although fear of crime is heightened among women, they're less likely to be victimized than in the past. And that's what makes crime sensational: Murder, especially in the largely white world of true-crime media consumers and producers, is rare, which makes it easier to seek excitement from than a more mundane topic. At its beating, bloody heart, the lure of murder media remains the same: a spooky story that could--but probably won't--happen to you. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Support JSTOR Daily! Join our new membership program on Patreon today. Share Tweet Email Print Have a correction or comment about this article? Please contact us. crimefolk musicFolklore in Utah: A History and Guide to Resources International Journal of Sociology of the FamilyMidwest Folklore Studies in English Literature, 1500-1900 The American Historical Review JSTOR logo Resources JSTOR is a digital library for scholars, researchers, and students. JSTOR Daily readers can access the original research behind our articles for free on JSTOR. The Broadside Ballad and Textual Publics By: ERIC NEBEKER Studies in English Literature, 1500-1900, Vol. 51, No. 1, The English Renaissance (WINTER 2011), pp. 1-19 Rice University Decline and "Revival" of Anglo-American Folk Music By: Samuel P. Bayard Midwest Folklore, Vol. 5, No. 2 (Summer, 1955), pp. 69-77 Indiana University Press Olive Woolley Burt, Collector of Murder Ballads By: Ann Reichman Folklore in Utah: A History and Guide to Resources, pp. 60-66 University Press of Colorado, Utah State University Press True Crime: The Origins of Modern Sensationalism By: Joy Wiltenburg The American Historical Review, Vol. 109, No. 5 (December 2004), pp. 1377-1404 Oxford University Press on behalf of the American Historical Association THE FEAR OF CRIME IN THE UNITED STATES: A TALE OF TWO GENDERS By: MICHELLE LAWTON and ROGER CLARK International Journal of Sociology of the Family, Vol. 41, No. 2 (Autumn 2015), pp. 117-129 International Journals Join Our Newsletter Get your fix of JSTOR Daily's best stories in your inbox each Thursday. [ ][Subscribe] Privacy Policy Contact Us You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking on the provided link on any marketing message. Read this next A postcard showing three trolleys at the Public Gardens Portal in Boston sometime before 1914 Arts & Culture The Folk Song That Fought against Fare Hikes "M.T.A." is a humorous ditty about a never-ending subway ride. But it began in Boston's progressive political circles. Trending Posts 1. White Women and the Mahjong Craze 2. An Archeologist's Guide to Beer Cans 3. Why Are So Many Romances Set in the Regency Period? 4. Herbs & Verbs: How to Do Witchcraft for Real 5. The Devastation of Black Wall Street More Stories Five female literacy volunteers return to Havana at the end of the literacy campaign in December 1961. Rosa Hernandez Acosta habla sobre la Campana de Alfabetizacion Cubana Armada solamente con unos cuantos libros de texto y una lampara de queroseno, Rosa Hernandez Acosta alfabetizaba en la Cuba rural sin electricidad, agua corriente ni carreteras asfaltadas. Five female literacy volunteers return to Havana at the end of the literacy campaign in December 1961. Language & Literature Rosa Hernandez Acosta on the Cuban Literacy Campaign Armed with just some textbooks and a kerosene lantern, Rosa Hernandez Acosta taught literacy in rural Cuba without electricity, running water, or paved roads. The 135th St Branch of the New York Public Library Language & Literature JSTOR Companion to the Schomburg Center's Black Liberation Reading List JSTOR has created an open library to support readers seeking to engage with BIPOC+Q-authored reading lists like the one developed by the New York Public Library. Fredi Washington and Louise Beavers in a scene from Imitation of Life Film & Media Why Didn't Movies about Passing Cast Black Actors? "Social problem" films were all the rage after World War II. So how could movies about racism be so conservative? Recent Posts 1. Rosa Hernandez Acosta habla sobre la Campana de Alfabetizacion Cubana 2. Rosa Hernandez Acosta on the Cuban Literacy Campaign 3. JSTOR Companion to the Schomburg Center's Black Liberation Reading List 4. Black Caribbeans in the Harlem Renaissance 5. After the Capitol Riot, Who Will Govern Speech Online? Support JSTOR Daily Help us keep publishing stories that provide scholarly context to the news. Become a member JSTOR Daily provides context for current events using scholarship found in JSTOR, a digital library of academic journals, books, and other material. We publish articles grounded in peer-reviewed research and provide free access to that research for all of our readers. * Contact The Editors * Submission Guidelines * Masthead * Newsletters * About Us * RSS * Support JSTOR Daily * JSTOR.org * Terms and Conditions of Use * Privacy Policy * Cookie Policy * Accessibility logo JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization helping the academic community use digital technologies to preserve the scholarly record and to advance research and teaching in sustainable ways. (c) ITHAKA. All Rights Reserved. JSTOR(r), the JSTOR logo, and ITHAKA(r) are registered trademarks of ITHAKA. Sign up for our weekly newsletter Get your fix of JSTOR Daily's best stories in your inbox each Thursday. [ ][Subscribe] Privacy Policy Contact Us You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking on the provided link on any marketing message. x