https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/dog-domestication-may-have-begun-because-paleo-humans-couldnt-stomach-the-original-paleo-diet/ Skip to main content SubscribeLatest IssuesMenu Scientific American * Cart 0 * Sign In Email *:[ ]Password *:[ ] Forgot password?LoginLoading Not yet registered? * |Stay Informed SearchSubscribe Close [ ]SearchClose Search Advanced Search * Coronavirus * The Sciences * Mind * Health * Tech * Sustainability * Video * Podcasts * Opinion * Publications * Subscribe * Current Issue * Cart0 * Sign In * Stay Informed * Share * Latest * * * * Sign up for our free newsletters. Sign Up Evolution Dog Domestication May Have Begun because Paleo Humans Couldn't Stomach the Original Paleo Diet Unable to digest large amounts of protein, hunters likely left scraps that could have led to the taming of wolves * By Rachel Nuwer on January 7, 2021 * Share on Facebook * Share on Twitter * Share on Reddit * Share on LinkedIn * Share via * Print Dog Domestication May Have Begun because Paleo Humans Couldn't Stomach the Original Paleo Diet Gray wolves interact with a golden retriever. Credit: Don Johnston Alamy Advertisement It's easy to understand why early humans domesticated dogs as their new best friends. Tame canines can guard against predators and interlopers, carry supplies, pull sleds and provide warmth during cold nights. But those benefits only come following domestication. Despite more than a century of study, scientists have struggled to understand what triggered the domestication process in the first place. A new theory described today in Scientific Reports posits that hunter-gatherers whose omnivorous digestive system prevented too much protein consumption likely shared surplus meat with wolves. Those scraps may have initiated a step toward domestication. "This is the first time that we have an ecological explanation for dog domestication," says lead author Maria Lahtinen, a senior researcher at the Finnish Food Authority and a visiting scholar at the Finnish Museum of Natural History. "I personally don't think that there is a simple, easy answer behind dog domestication, but we need to see the full picture and complexity of the process." Lahtinen did not originally set out to solve a long-standing dog mystery. Instead she was studying the diet of late Pleistocene hunter-gatherers in Arctic and sub-Arctic Eurasia. At that time, around 20,000 to 15,000 years ago, the world was engulfed in the coldest period of the last ice age. In frigid environments then, as today, humans tended to derive the majority of their food from animals. Nutritional deficiencies came from the absence of fat and carbohydrates, not necessarily protein. Indeed, if humans eat too much meat, diarrhea usually ensues. And within weeks, they can develop protein poisoning and even die. "Because we humans are not fully adapted to a carnivorous diet, we simply cannot digest protein very well," Lahtinen says. "It can be very fatal in a very short period of time." During the coldest years of the last ice age--and especially in harsh Arctic and sub-Arctic winters--reindeer, wild horses and other human prey animals would have been eking out an existence, nearly devoid of fat and composed mostly of lean muscle. Using previously published early fossil records, Lahtinen and her colleagues calculated that the game captured by people in the Arctic and sub-Arctic during this time would have provided much more protein than they could have safely consumed. In more ecologically favorable conditions, wolves and humans would have been competing for the same prey animals. But under the harsh circumstances of the Arctic and sub-Arctic ice age winter, sharing excess meat with canines would have cost people nothing. The descendants of wolves that took advantage of such handouts would have become more docile toward their bipedal benefactors over time, and they likely went on to become the first domesticated dogs. As the authors point out, the theory makes sense not just ecologically but also geographically: the earliest Paleolithic dog discoveries primarily come from areas that were very cold at the time. The new study presents a "fascinating idea about lean protein being a food that humans would have discarded but wolves may have relied on during winter months in the Arctic," says Brian Hare, an evolutionary anthropologist at Duke University, who was not involved in the work. "I think it offers another vital clue for how the human-dog partnership might have been initially fueled." [rightsPerm] Rights & Permissions ABOUT THE AUTHOR(S) author-avatar Rachel Nuwer * Rachel Nuwer is a freelance journalist and author of Poached: Inside the Dark World of Wildlife Trafficking (Da Capo Press, 2018). She lives in Brooklyn, N.Y. Credit: Nick Higgins Recent Articles * Chernobyl 'Exclusion Zone' Radiation Doses Reanalyzed * Young Ravens Rival Adult Chimps in a Big Test of General Intelligence * Rain Forest Canopy Bridges Aid Slow Lorises, Gibbons and Other Threatened Species Read This Next Evolution Ritual Sacrifice May Have Shaped Dog Domestication September 9, 2018 -- Lea Surugue and Sapiens Evolution How Wolf Became Dog July 1, 2015 -- Virginia Morell Behavior & Society How Dogs Became Our Best Friends May 1, 2015 -- Adam Miklosi Evolution From Wolf to Woof Twice June 2, 2016 -- Christopher Intagliata Advertisement Newsletter Get smart. Sign up for our email newsletter. Sign Up Support Science Journalism Discover world-changing science. Explore our digital archive back to 1845, including articles by more than 150 Nobel Prize winners. Subscribe Now!Support Science Journalism Follow us * instagram * soundcloud * youtube * twitter * facebook * rss Scientific american arabic l`rby@ * Return & Refund Policy * About * Press Room * FAQs * Contact Us * Site Map * Advertise * SA Custom Media * Terms of Use * Privacy Policy * California Consumer Privacy Statement * Use of cookies/Do not sell my data * International Editions Scientific American is part of Springer Nature, which owns or has commercial relations with thousands of scientific publications (many of them can be found at www.springernature.com/us). Scientific American maintains a strict policy of editorial independence in reporting developments in science to our readers. (c) 2021 Scientific American, a Division of Springer Nature America, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Scroll To Top * You have free articles left. Temp Paywall Img Support our award-winning coverage of advances in science & technology. See Subscription Options Already a subscriber? Sign in. Subscribers get more award-winning coverage of advances in science & technology. Sign In See Subscription Options