Average raising of each active touch judgment, .31+
% of judgments of active touch lowered,  138⁄378 = 36+
% of judgments of active touch raised,  239⁄378 = 63+
% of judgments of active touch not affected,  1⁄378 = .2+

Transcriber Note

Above table: -3.3 Net result lowered from #10 moved to #11 and is now +3.3. No figures affected.

Under combination influences, the average is reduced to 4.14+ for colors, and 3.12 for tones.

The next Table, V, shows the color-tone results for F. as Table IV showed them for M. F.'s average for colors (Table I) alone was 4.35, and was reduced in combination with tones by .26, or to 4.19. So, also, F.'s average for tones alone (Table III), 4.33, was reduced by .74+ to 3.59. The averages in both cases show the same general tendency to a lowering of the appreciation in both series when the series are combined, but the tones are lowered more than the colors.

Table VI shows the effect of combining tones and active touches as reported by M.

The effect of this combination is clear and unmistakeable. The appreciation of the tones is raised 1.71+ points; and of the active touches, .31+ points. This result is the opposite of that shown in Table IV, where colors and tones were combined. There is this agreement, however, that the appreciation of the tones is changed more than that of the other stimuli. Relatively, the appreciation of the touches changes least.

Table VII shows the effects on F. of combining tones and active touches. The same general tendencies appear as in the case of M.; but the changes in appreciation are not so marked. This is not easy to explain, for F. estimated both the active touches and the tones higher when taken alone than did M.

Table VIII shows the effect on F. of combining tones and passive touches. The same general tendency to increased appreciation appears, but the tones are raised more and the touches raised less than in Table VII. This may be explained, perhaps, on the basis of increasing appreciation with increased participation.

Tables IX and X show the effect on M. and F., respectively, of combining colors and active touches. M. estimates both slightly higher, while F. estimates both slightly lower. This difference cannot be explained by the standards for each subject. From Tables I and III we get:

Standards.
Colors. Active Touches.
M. 4.44 4.24
F. 4.35 4.55
With M. the colors go up to 4.87
With F. the colors go down to 4.22
With M. the active touches go up to 4.41
With F. the active touches go down to 4.17

TABLE VII. TONE-ACTIVE TOUCH RESULTS. F.

No. of times tone was  
No. of     Not No of points tone was Net results
Tone Raised Lowered affected Raised + Lowered – + –
1 11 3 0 9.25 1.75 7.5  
2 10 4 0 9.5 1 8.5  
3 7 7 0 5.8 7.2   1.4
4 10 4 0 12 3.2 8.8  
5 9 5 0 9.85 4.25 5.6  
6 9 5 0 15.1 4.5 10.6  
7 10 4 0 8 6.6 1.4  
8 7 7 0 5.2 6.8   1.6
9 10 4 0 8 9   1
10 12 2 0 14.2 2.8 11.4  
11 12 2 0 16 2.5 13.5  
12 13 1 0 9.6 .8 8.8  
13 13 1 0 12.2 .6 11.2  
14 10 4 0 7 2.2 4.8  
15 6 8 0 3 4 1  
16 9 1 4 11 2 9  
17 9 0 5 14 0 14  
18 12 2 0 16.4 2.6 13.8  
19 12 2 0 27.6 2.4 25.2  
20 12 2 0 2.4 2.6   .2
21 14 0 0 4.2 0 4.2  
22 14 0 0 17.2 0 17.2  
23 4 5 5 6 5 1  
24 0 14 0 0 9.6   9.6
25 7 5 2 5.6 6   .4
26 6 1 7 8 1 7  
27 11 0 3 14 0 14  
Totals, 259 93 26     186.5 15.2
Grand Total, 378   Net raised, 171.3
Averaging raising of each tone judgment, .45+
% of judgments of tones lowered, 93⁄378  = 24+
% of judgments of tones raised, 259⁄378 = 68+
% of judgments of tones not affected,   26⁄378   = 7-

Transcriber Note

Above table: #15 Net result + 1 should be - 1. Moved. This does not affect negative figures.
However, the + figure total is 197.5, not 186.5.
Making the net raised 182.3.
Averaging raising of each tone judgment, .45 is .48+

No of times touch was
No. of     Not No. of points tone was Net result
Touch Raised Lowered affected Raised + Lowered – + –
               
1 22 5 0 2.2 6.5   4.3
2 16 11 0 8.8 8.7 .1  
3 20 7 0 7 5.6 1.4  
4 19 8 0 5.8 11.4   5.6
5 18 9 0 14 7.5 6.5  
6 16 11 0 6.8 9.7   2.9
7 13 5 9 13 5 8  
8 13 14 0 13.1 12.2 .9  
9 19 8 0 14.5 5 9.5  
10 9 18 0 8.2 7.6 .6  
11 22 5 0 8.6 3.5 5.1  
12 15 12 0 15 4.8 10.2  
13 22 1 4 35 1 34  
14 20 7 0 26 1.4 24.6  
Totals, 244 121 13     100.9 12.8
Grand Total, 378     Net raised, 88.1
Average raising of each active touch judgment,   .23+
% of judgments of active touch lowered, 121⁄378 = 32+
% of judgments of active touch raised, 244⁄378 = 64+
% of judgments of active touch not affected, 13⁄378 = 3+

TABLE VIII. TONE-PASSIVE TOUCH RESULTS. F.

No. of times tone was        
No. of     Not No. of points tone was Net result
Tone Raised Lowered affected Raised + Lowered – + –
               
1 13 1 0 17.75 .25 17.5  
2 12 2 0 18 0 18  
3 13 1 0 11.2 .6 10.6  
4 14 0 0 14.8 0 14.8  
5 11 3 0 6.65 1.95 4.7  
6 9 5 0 12.1 1.50 10.6  
7 13 1 0 6.3 .9 5.4  
8 14 0 0 17.4 0 17.4  
9 6 8 0 5 4 1  
10 14 0 0 20.4 0 20.4  
11 14 0 0 12.5 0 12.5  
12 10 4 0 7 5.2 1.8  
13 14 0 0 10.6 0 10.6  
14 12 2 0 8.4 .6 7.8  
15 8 6 0 4 3 1  
16 1 2 11 1 2 1  
17 4 0 10 4 0 4  
18 5 9 0 7 8.2   1.2
19 9 5 0 2.7 4.5   1.8
20 13 1 0 2.6 .8 1.8  
21 13 1 0 3.9 .7   3.2
22 13 1 0 8.9 .7 8.2  
23 6 2 6 10 2 8  
24 12 2 0 15.2 .8 14.4  
25 11 3 0 15.8 .6 15.2  
26 0 6 8 0 8   8
27 10 0 4 13 0 13  
Totals, 274 65 39     211.7 11.0
Grand Total, 378 Net raised, 200.7    
Average raising of each tone judgment,   .52+
% of judgments of tones lowered, 65⁄378 = 17+
% of judgments of tones raised, 274⁄378 = 72+
% of judgments of tones not affected,  39⁄378 = 10+

Transcriber Note

Above table: #16. 1 Raised is 1 Lowered. Moved. #21 Raised 2.2 is 3.2, changed.
Total Net Result needs to be changed from 11. to 12.
Total Raised net result needs to be changed from 211.7 to 221.9, making Net raised = 209.9.
Average raising of each tone judgment, .52 needs to be .55+

No. of times touch was        
No. of     Not No. of points touch was Net result
Touch Raised Lowered affected Raised + Lowered – + –
               
1 0 10 17 0 10   10
2 4 13 10 4 16   12
3 11 16 0 6.5 12   5.5
4 13 14 0 12.8 9.6 3.2  
5 12 5 10 17 8 9  
6 12 15 0 7.2 12   4.8
7 3 12 12 3 14   11
8 14 2 11 17 2 15  
9 11 16 0 12.8 20.2   7.4
10 19 1 7 19 1 18  
11 5 2 20 5 2 3  
12 27 0 0 34.5 0 34.5  
13 14 13 0 8.2 9.1   .9
14 17 10 0 25.6 2 23.6  
Totals, 162 129 87     106.3 51.6
Grand Total, 378     Net raised, 54.7  
Average raising of each passive touch judgment,   .14+
% of judgments of passive touch lowered, 129⁄378 = 34
% of judgments of passive touch raised, 162⁄378 = 42
% of judgments of passive touch not affected, 87⁄378 = 23

TABLE IX. COLOR-ACTIVE TOUCH RESULTS. M.

No. of times color was        
No. of     Not No. of points color was Net result
Color Raised Lowered affected Raised + Lowered – + –
1 5 1 8 5 1 4  
2 0 7 7 0 7   7
3 3 11 0 1.8 4.4   2.6
4 3 11 0 2.4 4.2   1.8
5 3 11 0 2.4 2.2 .2  
6 12 2 0 6 1 5  
7 2 12 0 1.6 2.4   .8
8 12 0 2 12 0 12  
9 13 1 0 14.2 .6 13.6  
10 7 7 0 5.6 2.4 3.2  
11 11 3 0 6.6 1.2 5.4  
12 7 1 6 7 1 6  
13 9 5 0 5.5 2.5 3  
14 11 3 0 13.9 .3 13.6  
15 11 0 3 12 0 12  
16 10 4 0 8 1.2 6.8  
17 12 2 0 16 1 15  
18 14 0 0 24.8 0 24.8  
19 0 0 14 0 0    
20 9 5 0 7.2 1 6.2  
21 1 0 13 1 0 1  
22 14 0 0 5.2 0 5.2  
23 14 0 0 10.2 0 10.2  
24 8 0 6 14 0 14  
25 9 5 0 6.3 1.5 4.8  
26 4 1 9 4 1 3  
27 11 3 0 4.3 .9 3.4  
28 13 1 0 10.5 .5 10  
Totals, 228 96 68     182.4 12.2
Grand Total, 392 Net raised, 170.2
Average raising of each color judgment, .43+
% of judgments of colors lowered, 96⁄392 = 24+
% of judgments of colors raised, 228⁄392 = 58+
% of judgments of colors not affected, 68⁄392 = 17+
No. of times touch was
No. of     Not No. of points touch was Net Result
Touch Raised Lowered affected Raised + Lowered – + –
1 8 20 0 3.2 15   11.8
2 4 24 0 3.4 11.6   8.2
3 18 10 0 10 5 5  
4 8 20 0 3.4 23   19.6
5 8 20 0 5 13   8
6 2 26 0 1.8 8.6   6.8
7 25 3 0 26.5 4.5 22  
8 21 7 0 10.4 4.2 6.2  
9 3 25 0 2.7 8.5   5.8
10 27 1 0 33.5 .5 33  
11 23 5 0 3.3 4.5   1.2
12 22 0 6 41 0 41  
13 26 2 0 42.6 .8 41.8  
14 19 9 0 9.6 8.4 1.2  
Totals 214 172 6     130.0 61.4
Grand Total, 392   Net raised, 68.8
Average raising of each active touch judgment, .17+
% of judgment of active touch, lowered, 172⁄392 = 43+
% of judgments of active touch raised, 214⁄392 = 54+
% of judgments of active touch not affected, 6⁄392 = 1.8+

Transcriber Note

Above table: #13. raised 41.6 is 41.8. Changed.
Total for Net Result Raised 130.0 is 150.2.
Net raised Grand total is 88.8.
Average raising of each active touch judgment, .17+ is .22+

TABLE X. COLOR-ACTIVE TOUCH RESULTS. F.

No. of times color was        
No. of     Not No. of points color was Net Result
Color Raised Lowered affected Raised + Lowered – + –
1 13 1 0 8.3 .9 2.4  
2 5 4 5 5 6   1
3 2 5 7 2 5   3
4 9 5 0 7.6 3 4.6  
5 9 5 0 16.2 7 9.2  
6 0 14 0 0 20.4   20.4
7 3 11 0 2.1 5.3   3.2
8 1 3 10 1 3   2.0
9 5 9 0 3 8.2   5.2
10 9 5 0 10.95 8.25 2.7  
11 12 2 0 8.6 1.4 7.2  
12 8 6 0 9.8 2.4 7.4  
13 4 1 9 6 1 5  
14 10 4 0 11 1.6 9.4  
15 2 12 0 2.8 3.2   .4
16 2 12 0 1.6 7.4   5.8
17 8 6 0 5 4 1  
18 11 3 0 9.85 3.95 5.9  
19 0 0 14 0 0    
20 1 13 0 .8 14.4   13.6
21 2 7 5 2 7   5
22 8 6 0 11.4 9.2 2.2  
23 0 14 0 0 11.4   11.4
24 0 10 4 0 10   10
25 2 12 0 3.8 10.2   6.4
26 0 14 0 0 11   11
27 0 14 0 0 8.6   8.6
28 2 12 0 1.8 6.2   4.4
Totals, 129 209 54     56.7 111.4
Grand total, 392 Net lowered, 54.7
Averaging lowering of each color judgment, .13+
% of judgments of colors lowered, 209⁄392 = 53+
% of judgments of colors raised, 129⁄392 = 32+
% of judgments of colors not affected, 54⁄392 = 13+

Transcriber Note

Above: Table X.
#4 Net result raised, 4.3 is 4.6 = Total 57.
Net lowered is 54.4.

No. of times touch was        
No. of     Not No. of points touch was Net Result
Touch Raised Lowered affected Raised + Lowered – + –
1 11 17 0 1.1 28.3   27.2
2 14 14 0 11.2 13.8 2.6  
3 19 9 0 9.8 7.2 2.6  
4 11 17 0 2.2 25.6   23.4
5 13 15 0 12.5 16.5   4
6 12 16 0 4.6 12.2   7.6
7 15 0 13 23 0 23  
8 2 26 0 .6 26.8   26.2
9 6 22 0 4 25   21
10 0 28 0 0 17.6   17.6
11 19 9 0 6.7 6.3 .4  
12 3 25 0 3.8 10   6.2
13 2 26 0 2 32   30
14 8 20 0 6.4 19   12.6
Totals, 135 244 13     26.0 178.4
Grand Total, 392 Net lowered, 152.4