CHART SHOWING EAST RIVER SOUNDINGS AND PIER LINES

In the reign of Queen Anne the Corporation of New York induced that infamous trickster and reprobate, Governor Cornbury, to give New York a charter, by which it was to be entitled to all "vacant and unappropriated land" below high water mark from the Wallabout to Red Hook. The charter was really void, for there was no unappropriated land in the region named, previous patents and charters having given them to Brooklyn as a town. In 1721 the colonial legislature confirmed Brooklyn's rights, but New York's politicians bought for a specific sum ($5000) a new charter from Governor Montgomerie confirming the pretended right of New York to ownership in land to high-water mark on the Brooklyn shore. New York secured a charter ownership in 400 feet of land under water around the whole lower part of the city, and step by step, with money and unfaltering political trickery, the city set itself against the development and independence of Brooklyn. By Section 37 of the Montgomerie charter, the ferry franchise was confirmed "forever," with a provision that no other person or persons whomsoever should have the right to establish a ferry or ferries in the premises. Legislative acts and legal decisions have been piled up around a pretense, the fallacy and injustice of which appear upon examination of the early records.

New York was not satisfied with the crafty legislation by which it sought to overawe the village across the river. It began to question the right of Brooklyn people to cross to New York in their own boats. The result was that a Brooklyn man, Hendrick Remsen, sued the New York Corporation. He won his case; the Corporation appealed to the King, and the matter remained undecided in consequence of the Revolution. Although the Constitution of the State confirms all grants of land within the State made by authority of the King of Great Britain or his predecessors, prior to August 14, 1775, New York afterward adhered to its false claims to the river rights. However, by State rulings within the present century, Brooklyn was permitted to exercise jurisdiction to low-water mark. A Supreme Court decision in 1821 declares that the City and County of New York includes the whole of the rivers and harbor adjoining to actual low-water mark on the opposite shores. It was only in 1824 that Brooklyn was able to secure from the Legislature concurrent jurisdiction with New York in the service of process, in actions civil and criminal, on board of vessels attached to its own wharves.

When Brooklyn sought to erect itself into a city, New York met the proposition with the same spirit of unwillingness to recognize in the sister town any right to individual existence. Every step that Brooklyn took toward securing municipal rights was hampered by the opposition of New York politicians. Brooklyn became a city in 1834, in spite of New York's opposition. New York retired from the fight with its fraudulent ownership of the river and the "ferry rights," by which it was and still is able to levy a continuous tax upon Brooklyn.

IV
STATISTICS FROM THE FEDERAL CENSUS OF 1890
BROOKLYN MANUFACTURES56
Federal Census of 1890

The tabulated statements presented herewith include only establishments which reported a product of $500 or more in value during the census year, and, so far as practicable, only those establishments operating works located within the corporate limits of the city.

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF TOTALS

Industries Industries Reported Establishments Reporting Capital57 Hands Employed Wages Paid Cost of Materials Used
All Industries { 1880 180 5,201 $61,646,749 47,587 22,487,457 $129,085,091
1890 229 10,561 125,849,052 103,683 61,975,702 137,325,749
Industries Miscellaneous
Expenses58
Value of Product Population City Assessed
Valuation
Municipal Debt59
All Industries { 1880   $177,223,142 566,663 232,925,699 $38,040,000
1890 $14,824,466 248,750,184 806,343 445,038,201 34,639,542

DETAILED STATEMENT FOR 1890 BY IMPORTANT INDUSTRIES IN BROOKLYN ELEVENTH CENSUS

CLASSIFICATION OF INQUIRIES60 Boots and shoes—factory products Chemicals Coffee and spice—roasting and grinding Confectionery Cordage and twine Foundry and machine shop products Furnishing goods Paper hangings Slaughtering and meat packing Sugar and molasses refining
Establishments:—  (65) (36) (13) (197) (3) (169) (67) (5) (63) (8)
CAPITAL EMPLOYED— Aggregate $1,327,119 $8,483,835 2,963,392 2,923,509 2,256,400 $13,725,518 $1,507,853 $1,790,121 2,120,822 $3,999,510
HIRED PROPERTY—Total 366,230 275,000 306,300 1,047,500   1,473,750 377,650 303,482 380,560 255,622
PLANT—Total 385,934 4,888,250 546,696 1,028,053 1,854,300 6,046,228 427,420 401,946 918,400 1,821,000
Land 56,700 1,196,800 198,400 251,085 303,000 1,617,500 110,100 31,500 317,550 399,000
Buildings 113,400 1,532,821 194,350 311,225 701,000 1,362,670 142,550 121,584 346,752 527,500
Machinery, tools, and implements 215,834 2,158,629 153,946 465,743 850,300 3,066,058 174,770 248,862 254,098 894,500
LIVE ASSETS—Total 574,955 3,320,585 2,110,396 847,956 402,100 6,205,540 702,783 1,084,693 821,862 1,922,888
Raw materials 137,612 1,365,535 721,678 207,660 175,600 1,182,099 312,438 61,890 114,907 186,214
Stock in process and finished product 154,802 878,468 930,671 269,041 60,500 1,525,807 142,902 186,974 197,490 335,016
Cash, bills, and accounts receivable, and all sundries not elsewhere reported 282,541 1,076,582 458,047 371,255 166,000 3,497,634 247,443 835,829 509,465 1,401,658
WAGES PAID—Aggregate $1,032,547 $1,140,475 $479,036 $1,096,252 $650,256 $5,641,132 $1,203,461 $445,510 $532,120 $330,558
Average number of hands employed 2,050 1,848 794 2,237 1,612 7,753 2,218 852 623 596
Males above 16 years 840 1,295 477 1,387 1,012 6,868 868 660 607 583
Females above 15 years 326 289 10 552 600 42 485 146 3 2
Children 24 31   22   2 10 20    
Pieceworkers 860 233 307 276   841 855 26 13 11
MATERIALS USED—Aggregate cost $1,432,934 $7,329,134 $11,047,538 $1,833,791 $4,352,63 $5,125,183 $1,443,218 $1,067,697 $11,769,741 $14,816,112
Principal materials 1,381,752 7,050,313 10,711,647 1,738,998 4,206,13 4,626,489 1,389,325 1,042,362 11,637,737 14,412,045
Fuel 3,888 195,545 14,752 25,621 105,00 210,767 27,893 18,045 32,256 100,342
Mill supplies   9,206 20,656 3,835 6,00 47,386 10,308 290   15,986
All other materials 47,294 74,070 300,483 65,337 35,50 240,541 15,692 7,000 99,748 287,739
EXPENSES, MISCEL­LANEOUS—Ag'gate $73,249 $612,809 $84,334 $194,993 $63,18 $799,912 $84,811 $300,754 $130,096 227,760
Paid for contract work 1,450         12,000        
Rent 25,636 22,110 21,445 73,320   117,888 26,441 22,000 34,252 20,450
Power and heat 3,720 900 3,800 120   14,664 600     900
Taxes 4,494 48,950 11,439 9,981 10,14 60,267 4,429 15,863 13,902 21,877
Insurance 4,420 29,190 11,382 5,050 7,54 36,223 10,573 7,343 9,490 21,397
Repairs, ordinary, of b'ld'gs and mach'y 5,842 149,644 6,635 5,730 25,00 74,565 9,502 1,700 8,387 29,171
Interest on cash used in the business 1,549 43,651   13,462   22,009 1,895 61,833 3,691 65,449
All sundries not elsewhere reported 26,138 318,364 29,633 87,330 20,50 462,296 31,371 192,015 60,374 68,516
GOODS MANUFAC­TURED—Aggregate 2,813,209 $10,467,109 $12,247,162 $3,731,202 $5,625,79 $15,350,776 $3,315,691 2,143,023 $13,317,789 $16,629,982
Principal product 2,770,689 10,425,949 12,044,967 3,721,071 5,622,91 14,222,090 3,268,994 2,143,023 13,118,381 16,623,134
All other products, including custom work and repairing 42,520 41,160 202,195 10,131 2,88 1,128,686 46,697   199,408 6,848

STATEMENT OF CITY DEBT, DECEMBER 31, 1893

Title of Loan Amount
Dec. 31, 1892
Amount
Dec. 31, 1893
Increase Decrease
PERMANENT DEBT PAYABLE FROM TAXATION:        
Prospect Park $8,697,000.00 $8,697,000.00    
New York Bridge 10,013,000.00 10,013,000.00    
Soldiers' Aid Fund 112,000.00 60,000.00   $52,000
Arrearage Fund 2,350,000.00 2,350,000.00    
Local Improvement 200,000.00     200,000
Certificates of Indebtedness 505,160.93 434,160.93   71,000
City Bonds (Arrearage of County Taxes) 549,000.00 549,000.00    
Main Sewer Relief and Extension Fund 1,250,000.00 1,250,000.00    
Local Improvement (Laws of 1888) 1,300,000.00 1,300,000.00    
Local Improvement (Laws of 1889) 900,000.00 900,000.00    
Local Improvement (Laws of 1892) 300,000.00 445,000.00 $155,000.00  
School Improvement (Laws of 1888) 400,000.00 400,000.00    
School Improvement (Laws of 1889) 800,000.00 800,000.00    
Public Site, Purchase and Construction 500,000.00 500,000.00    
Municipal Site 265,000.00 265,000.00    
Fourth Precinct Station House 50,000.00 50,000.00    
Soldiers' and Sailors' Monument 220,000.00 205,000.00   15,000
Park Purchase 650,000.00 650,000.00    
New York and Brooklyn Bridge, § 4, Laws of 1891 1,000,000.00 1,000,000.00    
New York and Brooklyn Bridge, § 5, Laws of 1891 1,400,000.00 1,450,000.00 50,000.00  
Public Market 750,000.00 750,000.00    
School Building Fund 304,000.00 606,000.00 302,000.00  
Certificate of Indebtedness, ch. 48, Laws of 1892 162,844.92 54,830.18   108,014
Certificate of Indebtedness, ch. 50, Laws of 1892 125,000.00 148,852.55 3,852.55  
Certificate of Indebtedness, ch. 45, Laws of 1891 15,000.00     15,000
Asphalt Repavement Fund   37,000.00 37,000.00  
Museums of Art and Science 8,000.00 8,000.00    
Total $32,818,005.85 $32,932,843.66 $575,852.55 $461,014
WATER DEBT $14,566,000.00 $15,316,000.00 $750,000.00  
TEMPORARY DEBT PAYABLE FROM TAXATION, ETC.:        
Fourth Avenue Improvement 51,000.00 34,000.00 $17,000  
Eighth Ward Improvement 650,000.00 650,000.00    
Twenty-sixth and adjacent Ward Sewers 315,000.00 499,000.00 184,000.00  
Sewerage Fund(1892) 50,000.00 119,000.00 69,000.00  
North Second Street Improvement   15,000.00 15,000.00  
Tax Certificate (Contagious Disease Hospital)   7,000.00 7,000.00  
Total $1,066,000.00 $1,324,000.00 75,000.00 $17,000
TAX CERTIFICATES 2,700,000.00 $3,400,000.00 $700,000.00  
RECAPITULATION
Permanent Debt $32,818,005.85 $32,932,843.66 $114,837.81  
Water Debt 14,566,000.00 15,316,000.00 750,000.00  
Temporary Debt 1,066,000.00 1,324,000.00 258,000.00  
Tax Certificates 2,700,000.00 3,400,000.00 700,000.00  
Gross Debt 51,150,005.85 52,972,843.66 1,822,837.81  
Sinking Fund 4,636,893.90 4,935,344.55 298,450.65  
$46,513,111.95 $48,037,499.11 $1,524,387.16  
Less 3 and 8 months' Tax Certificates   700,000.00    
Net City Debt $46,513,111.95 $47,337,499.11 $1,524,387.16  

FOOTNOTES

1 Stiles, i. p. 326.

2 In 1888 the State Legislature, at the request of the Society of Old Brooklynites, passed a resolution urging Congress to provide for the erection of a monument. A petition containing 25,000 names was sent to Washington, and the matter was favorably reported from committee, but no act was passed.

3 Historical Sketch of Fulton Ferry, 1879.

4 Furman, p. 243.

5 The state recognition of Brooklyn as a town took place in 1788.

6 In 1806, the Legislature of New York enacted a law allowing the incorporation of a State and of County Medical Societies. Under this act the State Medical Society was organized at once. The medical men of this county did not act in the matter, however, for several years, and it was not till March, 1822, that the Kings County Medical Society was organized. From the organization of the society to the present time the following gentlemen have been its presidents: Cornelius Low, 1822–1825; J. G. T. Hunt, 1825, till his death in 1830; Thomas W. Henry, 1831–1833; Charles Ball, 1833–1835; Isaac I. Rapelye, 1835; Matthew Wendell, 1836; Adrian Vanderveer, 1837–1839; John B. Zabriskie, 1839; Purcell Cooke, 1840–1842; Theodore L. Mason, 1842–1844; Bradley Parker, 1844; Purcell Cooke, 1845; J. Sullivan Thorne, 1846; Lucius Hyde, 1847; Chauncey L. Mitchell, 1848; Henry J. Cullen, 1849; James H. Henry, 1850; Samuel J. Osborne, 1851; George Marvin, 1852; Andrew Otterson, 1853–1855; George I. Bennet, 1855; T. Anderson Wade, 1856; Samuel Boyd, 1857; Chauncey L. Mitchell, 1858–1860; Daniel Brooks, 1860; C. R. McClellan, 1861; Samuel Hart, 1862; DeWitt C. Enos, 1863; Joseph C. Hutchinson, 1864; John T. Conkling, 1865; Andrew Otterson, 1866; William W. Reese, 1867; R. Cresson Stiles, 1868–1870; J. H. Hobart Burge, 1870–1872; William Henry Thayer, 1872–1874; A. J. C. Skene, 1874–1876; A. Hutchins, 1876–1879; J. S. Prout, 1879; Charles Jewett, 1880–1883; G. G. Hopkins, 1883. In 1829 there were thirty-six active members belonging to the society. In 1836 the Code of Ethics of the state society was adopted, and in 1848 the Code of Ethics of the American Medical Association. From its foundation in 1822, till the repeal of that power by the Legislature in 1881, the Kings County Society conferred sixteen licenses to practice medicine.—S. M. O.

7 The first post-office at Gravesend was established in 1843.

8 J. C. Vanderbilt's Social History of Flatbush gives some exceedingly interesting glimpses of life in this region during and after the Revolutionary period.

9 The "public whipper" received a salary of $15 a year.

10 Tunis G. Bergen was born at New Utrecht in 1806. The Cropsey family, prominent at New Utrecht, is descended from Geerte Jans Kasparse, who came from Holland, with her two sons, Joost and Johannis, in 1652. Joost, third son of this Joost, had one son, Casper, who held office in New Utrecht, and died in 1806, leaving six sons and several daughters. Other descendants were Jerome Ryersen Cropsey, Andrew G. Cropsey, and William Cropsey. The last named was for several terms supervisor of New Utrecht.

11 History of Kings County, p. 279.

12 This fine specimen of old Dutch architecture is still standing on Evergreen Avenue.

13 Historic and Antiquarian Scenes in Brooklyn and its Vicinity, p. 47.

14 The assumption that the Dutch youth required to be taught "convivial customs" by the "arrogant Anglo-American youngers" is scarcely supported by definite testimony.

15 The ancestral farm and home of the Wyckoffs is on the boundary line between Brooklyn and Newtown, beyond Metropolitan Avenue.

16 "History of Williamsburgh," in Stiles's History of Kings County.

17 Printed in the Long Island Star, February 14, 1811.

18 Furman's MS.

19 Fulton and Livingston had obtained from the Legislature the monopoly of steam navigation on all the waters of New York for thirty years from 1808.

20 Historical Sketch of Fulton Ferry.

21 Corporation Manual, 1870.

22 The Corporation of New York at one time even questioned the right of Brooklyn's inhabitants to cross the river, ferriage free, in their own boats.

23 See Appendix III.

24 Walt Whitman was born at West Hills, Long Island, in 1819. During the time of his residence in Brooklyn he did editorial writing for both the Times and the Eagle. In the following letter to Mr. Charles M. Skinner, of Brooklyn, he describes his newspaper work in this city:—

328 Mickle Street, Camden, New Jersey,

January 19, '85.

Dear Sir,—In hasty answer to your request asking me to specify over my own signature what year I worked as an editorial writer in the Brooklyn Times office, I would say that if I remember right it was along in 1856, or just before. I recollect (doubtless I am now going to be egotistical about it) the question of the new Water Works (magnificently outlined by McAlpine, and duly carried out and improved by Kirkwood, first-class engineers both) was still pending, and the works, though well under way, continued to be strongly opposed by many. With the consent of the proprietor, I bent the whole weight of the paper steadily in favor of the McAlpine plan, as against a flimsy, cheap, and temporary series of works that would have long since broken down, and disgraced the city.

This, with my course on another matter,—the securing to public use of Washington Park (old Fort Greene), stoutly championed by me some thirty-five years ago, against heavy odds, during an editorship of the Brooklyn Eagle,—are "feathers in my wings" that I would wish to preserve.

I heard lately with genuine sorrow of the death of George C. Bennett. I remember him well as a good, generous, honorable man.

I send best greetings to your staff, and, indeed, to all the Brooklyn journalists.


Walt Whitman.

Whitman's poem "Crossing the Williamsburgh Ferry" is familiar to readers of his Leaves of Grass.

25 Brooklyn Compendium.

26 The Young Men's Christian Association of Brooklyn was organized during the same year.

27 Up to the time of present writing morning journalism has never been successful in Brooklyn, the metropolitan newspapers of New York having from the outset filled the field, and prevented a financial success for any but the evening papers.

28 "Yet, although Brooklyn had thus, at a single bound, jumped from the seventh to the third position among the cities of the American Union, it could by no means claim the same relative position in point of wealth, business, or commercial importance, being outranked in these respects by several cities of less population. Nor had it risen to its eminence by virtue of its own inherent vigor and enterprise. Candor certainly compels the acknowledgment that it was chiefly attributable to the overflowing prosperity and greatness of its giant neighbor, New York."—Stiles's History of Kings County, vol. i. p. 485.

29 Martin Kalbfleisch was elected Mayor on the Democratic ticket, receiving a majority of 5136, in a total vote of 28,280, over his opponent, Frederick Scholes.

30 The statue was unveiled in October, 1869. A. A. Low presided, and the presentation address was made by James P. Wallace, on behalf of the War Fund Committee. The oration was by Dr. Storrs.

31 Mr. Beecher was appointed chaplain of the Thirteenth Regiment in 1878. Dr. Storrs had already occupied this post.

32 Colonel Meserole was made brigadier-general in 1868.

33 The same name had been chosen by Colonel Roehr's father, Edward Franz Roehr, for a newspaper first issued in 1854, and running for one year. Edward Roehr's Williamsburgh printing office and bookstore also sent forth a Masonic journal called Der Triangel, which flourished for twenty-five years.

34 In connection with the cupola of the City Hall, a very interesting incident occurred in 1852. It was noticed that this feature of the building swayed, and needed to be strengthened. The necessary steps were taken to render it firm and secure. At the time the men were engaged in the work the court of oyer and terminer was holding a session in the room known and distinguished as the Governor's room, Judge N. B. Morse presiding. One day while the court was engaged in a criminal trial, a beam which was being raised slipped from the rope, and fell upon the roof above the court-room, causing the plaster and ceiling to give way. At once the court officers, jurors, and spectators became alarmed; some ran for the door, some for the windows, and others sought refuge under the tables. Judge Morse took a position by one of the windows, and, shaking his fist at the audience, exclaimed, "The wicked flee when no man pursueth." A few of the frightened ones got on their knees and fervently prayed. The prisoner at the bar was the only one unmoved.—S. M. O.

35 Manuscript history.

36 Brooklyn Eagle, May 24, 1884.

37 The single exception to Roebling's plan offered by the commission was that they demanded a central height of 135 feet, instead of 130 feet, in the central span.

38 Samuel T. Powell had occupied the Mayor's chair for two terms, closing in 1861. He again entered the office in 1872.

39 Mr. Beecher came to Brooklyn in 1847, and died at his post forty years later, on March 8, 1887. His relations to the city of Brooklyn were exceptional, and in many respects marvelous. No other single personality in this city ever won a prominence so significant, so salutary, so momentous. One of Brooklyn's most brilliant thinkers, writers, and speakers, the Rev. John W. Chadwick, D.D., has spoken of Mr. Beecher as 'the most unique and splendid personality of our civic history; one of the most unique and splendid in the history of the United States and their colonial beginnings.' The homage to Beecher's genius as a teacher and leader of men has come from thinking men wherever the English language is spoken. The homage which belongs to him as a citizen, as a pastor, as a humanitarian, as a patriot, has been enthusiastically offered by his fellow-countrymen, and particularly by his neighbors in the city of Brooklyn. The bronze monument to Mr. Beecher, designed by John Q. A. Ward, was placed in front of the City Hall in 1891.

40 Seth Low on "Municipal Government," in Bryce's American Commonwealth, vol. i. p. 626.

41 Commenting on the Brooklyn system, Fiske says: "It insures unity of administration, it encourages promptness and economy, it locates and defines responsibility, and it is so simple that everybody can understand it. The people, having but few officers to elect, are more likely to know something about them. Especially since everybody understands that the success of the government depends upon the character of the Mayor, extraordinary pains are taken to secure good mayors; and the increased interest in city politics is shown by the fact that in Brooklyn more people vote for Mayor than for Governor or for President."

42 The increase in the bulk of the city vote since 1877 is shown by the fact that the vote for Howell had been 36,343, as against 33,538 for John F. Henry.

43 Joseph C. Hendrix was appointed postmaster of Brooklyn in 1886, and made a record in that office unequaled by any postmaster the city ever had. Indeed, his reforms and innovations made for him a conspicuous reputation at Washington. In 1892, Hendrix was elected to Congress. He has rendered highly important service to the city in the board of education.

44 See p. 166.

45 The history of the Institute is taken from the fifth Year Book, 1893.

46 The Regents of the University of the State of New York, who had granted a provisional charter in 1889.

47 The present building of the Young Men's Christian Association, at Fulton and Bond streets, has been occupied since 1885. It has a circulating library of over 13,000 volumes, a finely equipped gymnasium, running-track, bowling-alleys, and swimming-tank, two large lecture-halls, and evening classes registering 700 men. The fine building of the Young Women's Christian Association, at the junction of Schermerhorn Street and Flatbush Avenue, has been occupied since 1888. It has eighteen class-rooms for educational work, a library with about 6000 volumes, a lecture-hall seating 650, assembly-rooms seating 400, an excellent gymnasium and running-track, and medical department.

48 See p. 165 of this volume.

49 The practice of establishing classes for Chinamen in connection with Sunday-schools has occasioned many and prolonged discussions in Brooklyn, and has been strongly assailed, particularly in those instances where the teaching of mature Chinamen was intrusted to young unmarried women.

50 Eagle Almanac, 1894.

51 Corporation Manual, for 1863, compiled by Henry McCloskey, City Clerk.

52 See Appendix.

53 Leffert Lefferts was the first president of the Long Island Bank.

54 Read by Mr. Ostrander before the Long Island Historical Society, February 1, 1881.

55 Understood to have originated in the shortening of Rembrandt into Rem.

56 From compilation in Eagle Almanac, 1892.

57 The value of hired property is not included for 1890, because it was not reported in 1880.

58 No inquiry in 1880 relating to "Miscellaneous expenses."

59 The amount stated represents the "net debt," or the total amount of municipal debt less sinking fund.

60 To avoid disclosure of operations of individual establishments, only such industries as have 3 or more establishments engaged therein are included.


INDEX

Simple page numbers refer to Vol. I.; page numbers preceded by "ii." refer to Vol. II.

Transcriber's note: Links to Vol. I. are double-underlined. Support for links to Vol. I. depends on the device and software used to display this eBook.