## ----include = FALSE---------------------------------------------------------- knitr::opts_chunk$set( collapse = TRUE, comment = "#>", dpi = 192, fig.retina = 2 ) ## ----setup-------------------------------------------------------------------- library(graphicalMCP) ## ----spending-comparison------------------------------------------------------ # Compare spending at information fractions (1/3, 2/3, 1) for alpha = 0.025 t_values <- c(1/3, 2/3, 1) spending_comparison <- data.frame( `Info Fraction` = t_values, `O'Brien-Fleming` = spending_of(0.025, t_values), Pocock = spending_pocock(0.025, t_values), `HSD (gamma=-4)` = spending_hsd(0.025, t_values, -4), Linear = spending_linear(0.025, t_values), check.names = FALSE ) knitr::kable(spending_comparison, digits = 6, caption = "Cumulative alpha spent at each analysis (alpha = 0.025)") ## ----boundaries-example------------------------------------------------------- # Compute boundaries for OBF spending at alpha = 0.025 with 3 equally spaced analyses bounds <- graphicalMCP:::gs_boundaries(0.025, c(1/3, 2/3, 1), spending_of) boundary_table <- data.frame( Analysis = 1:3, `Info Fraction` = c(1/3, 2/3, 1), `Cumulative Spending` = spending_of(0.025, c(1/3, 2/3, 1)), `Z Boundary` = bounds$bounds_z, `Nominal p Boundary` = bounds$bounds_nominal, check.names = FALSE ) knitr::kable(boundary_table, digits = 6, caption = "OBF group sequential boundaries (alpha = 0.025)") ## ----rep-seq-p-example-------------------------------------------------------- # A hypothesis tested at three analyses with OBF spending p_h1 <- c(0.05, 0.02, 0.01) info <- c(1/3, 2/3, 1) # Repeated p-value at analysis 3 (considers only the boundary at analysis 3) rep_p_3 <- repeated_p(p = p_h1, info_frac = info, spending_fn = spending_of) cat("Repeated p-value at analysis 3:", rep_p_3, "\n") # Sequential p-value at analysis 3 (considers boundaries at all three analyses) seq_p_3 <- sequential_p(p = p_h1, info_frac = info, spending_fn = spending_of) cat("Sequential p-value at analysis 3:", seq_p_3, "\n") # The sequential p-value is the minimum of repeated p-values across analyses rep_p_1 <- repeated_p(p = p_h1[1], info_frac = info[1], spending_fn = spending_of) rep_p_2 <- repeated_p(p = p_h1[1:2], info_frac = info[1:2], spending_fn = spending_of) cat("Repeated p-values:", rep_p_1, rep_p_2, rep_p_3, "\n") cat("min(rep_p_1, rep_p_2, rep_p_3) =", min(rep_p_1, rep_p_2, rep_p_3), "\n") ## ----graph-setup-------------------------------------------------------------- hypotheses <- c(0.5, 0.5, 0, 0) transitions <- rbind( c(0, 0.5, 0.5, 0), # H1 -> H2 (1/2), H3 (1/2) c(0.5, 0, 0, 0.5), # H2 -> H1 (1/2), H4 (1/2) c(0, 1, 0, 0), # H3 -> H2 (full propagation) c(1, 0, 0, 0) # H4 -> H1 (full propagation) ) g <- graph_create(hypotheses, transitions) ## ----graph-plot, eval = requireNamespace("igraph", quietly = TRUE)------------ plot(g, vertex.size = 40) ## ----p-values----------------------------------------------------------------- # P-values from Table 1 of Maurer and Bretz (2013) # Only analyses 1 and 2 are conducted (trial stops after analysis 2) p <- rbind( H1 = c(0.0062, 0.0002), H2 = c(0.017, 0.0035), H3 = c(0.009, 0.002), H4 = c(0.13, 0.06) ) p_display <- as.data.frame(p) colnames(p_display) <- paste("Analysis", 1:2) knitr::kable( p_display, caption = "Observed nominal p-values" ) ## ----repeated-p-matrix-------------------------------------------------------- info_frac <- c(1/3, 2/3) rep_p_matrix <- matrix(NA, nrow = 4, ncol = 2, dimnames = list(rownames(p), c("Analysis 1", "Analysis 2"))) for (j in 1:4) { for (k in 1:2) { rep_p_matrix[j, k] <- repeated_p( p = p[j, 1:k], info_frac = info_frac[1:k], spending_fn = spending_of ) } } knitr::kable(rep_p_matrix, digits = 4, caption = "Repeated p-values at each analysis") ## ----run-gsd-no-lb------------------------------------------------------------ result <- graph_test_shortcut_gsd( graph = g, p = p, alpha = 0.025, info_frac = info_frac, spending_fn = spending_of, look_back = FALSE, test_values = TRUE ) print(result) ## ----test-values-tables------------------------------------------------------- format_test_values <- function(tv) { tv$Boundary <- formatC(tv$Boundary, format = "f", digits = 6) tv } knitr::kable(format_test_values(result$test_values[[1]]), digits = 6, caption = "Analysis 1: nominal boundaries and rejection decisions") knitr::kable(format_test_values(result$test_values[[2]]), digits = 6, caption = "Analysis 2: nominal boundaries and rejection decisions") ## ----key-inequality----------------------------------------------------------- b_half <- gs_boundaries(0.0125, c(1/3, 2/3, 1), spending_of) b_full <- gs_boundaries(0.025, c(1/3, 2/3, 1), spending_of) cat(sprintf( "Boundary at alpha = 0.0125: %.6f\n0.5 * Boundary at alpha = 0.025: %.6f\n", b_half$bounds_nominal[1], 0.5 * b_full$bounds_nominal[1] )) ## ----paper-comparison, include=FALSE------------------------------------------ paper_repeated_p <- data.frame( Hypothesis = c("H1", "H2", "H3", "H4"), `pr_1 (paper)` = c(0.1141, 0.1683, 0.1316, 0.382), `pr_1 (ours)` = round(result$outputs$sequential_p[, 1], 4), `pr_2 (paper)` = c(0.0024, 0.0172, 0.0117, 0.1285), `pr_2 (ours)` = round(result$outputs$sequential_p[, 2], 4), check.names = FALSE ) knitr::kable(paper_repeated_p, digits = 4, caption = "Comparison of sequential p-values with paper Table 2") ## ----nominal-comparison, include=FALSE---------------------------------------- paper_table1 <- data.frame( Hypothesis = c("H1", "H2", "H3", "H4"), `alpha*_1 (paper)` = c(0.00002, 0.00002, 0, 0), `alpha*_1 (ours)` = round(result$test_values[[1]]$Boundary, 5), `alpha*_2 (paper)` = c(0.0022, "0.004 (updated)", "0.0022 (updated)", "0.006 (updated)"), `alpha*_2 (ours)` = round(result$test_values[[2]]$Boundary, 4), check.names = FALSE ) knitr::kable(paper_table1, caption = "Comparison of nominal boundaries with paper Table 1") ## ----boundary-table----------------------------------------------------------- result_verbose <- graph_test_shortcut_gsd( graph = g, p = p, alpha = 0.025, info_frac = info_frac, spending_fn = spending_of, verbose = TRUE ) # Display boundary tables for each hypothesis for (h in names(result_verbose$boundary_table)) { cat(h, "\n") print(result_verbose$boundary_table[[h]]) cat("\n") } ## ----oncology-graph----------------------------------------------------------- alpha_onc <- 0.025 alpha_allocation <- c(0.01, 0.01, 0.004, 0, 0.0005, 0.0005) hypotheses_onc <- alpha_allocation / alpha_onc hyp_names_onc <- c( "H1_OS_S", "H2_OS_A", "H3_PFS_S", "H4_PFS_A", "H5_ORR_S", "H6_ORR_A" ) names(hypotheses_onc) <- hyp_names_onc transitions_onc <- rbind( c(0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0), # H1_OS_S -> H2_OS_A c(0, 0, 0.5, 0.5, 0, 0), # H2_OS_A -> H3_PFS_S (1/2), H4_PFS_A (1/2) c(0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0), # H3_PFS_S -> H4_PFS_A c(0, 0, 0, 0, 0.5, 0.5), # H4_PFS_A -> H5_ORR_S (1/2), H6_ORR_A (1/2) c(0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1), # H5_ORR_S -> H6_ORR_A c(0.5, 0.5, 0, 0, 0, 0) # H6_ORR_A -> H1_OS_S (1/2), H2_OS_A (1/2) ) g_onc <- graph_create(hypotheses_onc, transitions_onc) ## ----oncology-graph-plot, eval = requireNamespace("igraph", quietly = TRUE), fig.height=5.5, fig.width=6, out.width="100%"---- onc_layout <- rbind( c(0, 3), # H1_OS_S c(2, 3), # H2_OS_A c(0, 1.8), # H3_PFS_S c(3, 1.8), # H4_PFS_A c(0, 0.5), # H5_ORR_S c(2, 0.5) # H6_ORR_A ) # Edge label positions: NA = auto, explicit coords to move specific labels # Edge order: 1=H6->H1, 2=H1->H2, 3=H6->H2, 4=H2->H3, 5=H2->H4, # 6=H3->H4, 7=H4->H5, 8=H4->H6, 9=H5->H6 label_x <- rep(NA, 9) label_y <- rep(NA, 9) label_x[1] <- 0.4; label_y[1] <- 2.5 # H6->H1: toward arrow (H1) label_x[3] <- 2.0; label_y[3] <- 2.375 # H6->H2: on the edge, toward arrow label_x[4] <- 1.5; label_y[4] <- 2.7 # H2->H3: toward tail (H2) label_x[6] <- 0.75; label_y[6] <- 1.8 # H3->H4: toward tail (H3) label_x[7] <- 0.9; label_y[7] <- 0.89 # H4->H5: toward arrow (H5) label_x[8] <- 2.5; label_y[8] <- 1.15 # H4->H6: on the edge, midway plot(g_onc, layout = onc_layout, vertex.size = 60, asp = 1, vertex.label.cex = 0.7, rescale = FALSE, xlim = c(-0.6, 3.6), ylim = c(-0.1, 3.6), edge.label.x = label_x, edge.label.y = label_y) ## ----oncology-p-values-------------------------------------------------------- p_onc <- rbind( H1_OS_S = c(0.03, 0.0001, 0.000001), H2_OS_A = c(0.2, 0.15, 0.1), H3_PFS_S = c(0.2, 0.001, NA), H4_PFS_A = c(0.3, 0.2, NA), H5_ORR_S = c(0.00001, NA, NA), H6_ORR_A = c(0.1, NA, NA) ) # Event-driven information fractions (events / max events per endpoint) info_frac_onc <- rbind( H1_OS_S = c(185 / 295, 245 / 295, 1), H2_OS_A = c(529 / 800, 700 / 800, 1), H3_PFS_S = c(265 / 310, 1, NA), H4_PFS_A = c(675 / 750, 1, NA), H5_ORR_S = c(1, NA, NA), H6_ORR_A = c(1, NA, NA) ) knitr::kable( data.frame( Hypothesis = rownames(p_onc), `No. of Analyses` = rowSums(!is.na(p_onc)), `Info Frac` = apply(info_frac_onc, 1, function(x) { paste(round(x[!is.na(x)], 3), collapse = ", ") }), check.names = FALSE ), row.names = FALSE, caption = "Number of analyses and information fractions per hypothesis" ) ## ----oncology-p-table--------------------------------------------------------- p_display <- p_onc p_display[] <- ifelse( is.na(p_display), "—", formatC(as.numeric(p_display), format = "f", digits = 6) ) knitr::kable( as.data.frame(p_display), col.names = paste("Analysis", 1:3), caption = "Observed nominal p-values (— indicates no data at that analysis)" ) ## ----oncology-run-lb---------------------------------------------------------- result_onc_lb <- graph_test_shortcut_gsd( graph = g_onc, p = p_onc, alpha = alpha_onc, info_frac = info_frac_onc, spending_fn = spending_of, look_back = TRUE, test_values = TRUE ) print(result_onc_lb) ## ----oncology-seq-p----------------------------------------------------------- seq_p_display <- result_onc_lb$outputs$sequential_p seq_p_display[] <- ifelse( is.na(seq_p_display), NA, formatC(as.numeric(seq_p_display), format = "f", digits = 6) ) knitr::kable( as.data.frame(seq_p_display), caption = "Sequential p-values (NA = hypothesis not tested at that analysis)" ) ## ----oncology-results-lb------------------------------------------------------ # Extract the p-value and boundary at the decision point for each hypothesis. # For rejected hypotheses, this is the analysis where rejection occurred. # For non-rejected hypotheses, this is the last analysis where it was tested. tv_all <- do.call(rbind, result_onc_lb$test_values) decision_p <- numeric(length(hyp_names_onc)) decision_bound <- numeric(length(hyp_names_onc)) for (i in seq_along(hyp_names_onc)) { h <- hyp_names_onc[i] rows <- tv_all[tv_all$Hypothesis == h, ] if (nrow(rows) == 0) next # Use the last row for this hypothesis (final decision point) decision_p[i] <- rows$p[nrow(rows)] decision_bound[i] <- rows$Boundary[nrow(rows)] } # For non-rejected hypotheses, find the last analysis where they were tested last_tested <- rowSums(!is.na(p_onc)) onc_summary_lb <- data.frame( Hypothesis = hyp_names_onc, `p` = formatC(decision_p, format = "f", digits = 6), Boundary = formatC(decision_bound, format = "f", digits = 6), Rejected = result_onc_lb$outputs$rejected, Tested.at = result_onc_lb$outputs$decision_at, First.Rej.at = ifelse( is.na(result_onc_lb$outputs$first_rejected_at), "—", as.character(result_onc_lb$outputs$first_rejected_at) ), Last.Rej.at = ifelse( is.na(result_onc_lb$outputs$last_rejected_at), "—", as.character(result_onc_lb$outputs$last_rejected_at) ), check.names = FALSE ) knitr::kable(onc_summary_lb, row.names = FALSE, caption = "Oncology case study (look_back = TRUE): rejection decisions") ## ----per-hyp-look-back-------------------------------------------------------- look_back_onc <- c( FALSE, # H1_OS_S: no look_back FALSE, # H2_OS_A: no look_back FALSE, # H3_PFS_S: no look_back FALSE, # H4_PFS_A: no look_back TRUE, # H5_ORR_S: look_back TRUE # H6_ORR_A: look_back ) result_onc_mixed <- graph_test_shortcut_gsd( graph = g_onc, p = p_onc, alpha = alpha_onc, info_frac = info_frac_onc, spending_fn = spending_of, look_back = look_back_onc ) print(result_onc_mixed) ## ----per-hyp-look-back-compare------------------------------------------------ mixed_comparison <- data.frame( Hypothesis = hyp_names_onc, `Rejected (all LB)` = result_onc_lb$outputs$rejected, `Adj. P (all LB)` = round(result_onc_lb$outputs$adjusted_p, 6), `Rejected (mixed)` = result_onc_mixed$outputs$rejected, `Adj. P (mixed)` = round(result_onc_mixed$outputs$adjusted_p, 6), check.names = FALSE ) knitr::kable(mixed_comparison, row.names = FALSE, caption = "Effect of per-hypothesis look_back on rejection decisions") ## ----oncology-look-back-diff-------------------------------------------------- p_onc_lb <- p_onc p_onc_lb["H2_OS_A", ] <- c(0.003, 0.005, 0.1) p_onc_lb["H4_PFS_A", ] <- c(0.0001, 0.02, NA) p_onc_lb["H5_ORR_S", ] <- c(0.0008, NA, NA) # look_back = FALSE: H4's repeated p-value at analysis 2 is too large result_onc_no_lb <- graph_test_shortcut_gsd( graph = g_onc, p = p_onc_lb, alpha = alpha_onc, info_frac = info_frac_onc, spending_fn = spending_of, look_back = FALSE, test_values = TRUE ) # look_back = TRUE: H4 benefits from its strong analysis-1 evidence result_onc_yes_lb <- graph_test_shortcut_gsd( graph = g_onc, p = p_onc_lb, alpha = alpha_onc, info_frac = info_frac_onc, spending_fn = spending_of, look_back = TRUE, test_values = TRUE ) ## ----oncology-look-back-diff-no----------------------------------------------- print(result_onc_no_lb) ## ----oncology-look-back-diff-yes---------------------------------------------- print(result_onc_yes_lb) ## ----oncology-look-back-diff-compare------------------------------------------ lb_diff_table <- data.frame( Hypothesis = hyp_names_onc, `Rejected (no LB)` = result_onc_no_lb$outputs$rejected, `Rejected (LB)` = result_onc_yes_lb$outputs$rejected, `First.Rej.at (LB)` = ifelse( is.na(result_onc_yes_lb$outputs$first_rejected_at), "--", as.character(result_onc_yes_lb$outputs$first_rejected_at)), `Last.Rej.at (LB)` = ifelse( is.na(result_onc_yes_lb$outputs$last_rejected_at), "--", as.character(result_onc_yes_lb$outputs$last_rejected_at)), check.names = FALSE ) knitr::kable(lb_diff_table, row.names = FALSE, caption = "Effect of look_back on oncology trial rejection decisions") ## ----spending-time-setup------------------------------------------------------ # Spending time = subgroup event fractions (same as H1_OS_S) # info_frac ensures NA positions match those in info_frac_onc spending_h2 <- spending_with_time( spending_of, spending_time = c(185 / 295, 245 / 295, 1), info_frac = info_frac_onc["H2_OS_A", ] ) # Similarly, H4 (PFS, all subjects) uses subgroup PFS event fractions spending_h4 <- spending_with_time( spending_of, spending_time = c(265 / 310, 1, NA), info_frac = info_frac_onc["H4_PFS_A", ] ) # Build per-hypothesis spending function list spending_fn_onc <- list( spending_of, # H1_OS_S: standard (info_frac = spending time) spending_h2, # H2_OS_A: spending time = subgroup OS events spending_of, # H3_PFS_S: standard spending_h4, # H4_PFS_A: spending time = subgroup PFS events spending_of, # H5_ORR_S: standard (single analysis) spending_of # H6_ORR_A: standard (single analysis) ) ## ----spending-time-run-------------------------------------------------------- result_onc_st <- graph_test_shortcut_gsd( graph = g_onc, p = p_onc, alpha = alpha_onc, info_frac = info_frac_onc, spending_fn = spending_fn_onc, look_back = TRUE ) print(result_onc_st) ## ----spending-time-compare---------------------------------------------------- st_comparison <- data.frame( Hypothesis = hyp_names_onc, `Rejected (info fraction)` = result_onc_lb$outputs$rejected, `Adj. P (info fraction)` = round(result_onc_lb$outputs$adjusted_p, 6), `Rejected (spending time)` = result_onc_st$outputs$rejected, `Adj. P (spending time)` = round(result_onc_st$outputs$adjusted_p, 6), check.names = FALSE ) knitr::kable(st_comparison, row.names = FALSE, caption = "Effect of spending time on rejection decisions") ## ----monitoring-setup--------------------------------------------------------- # Planned info fractions (used for boundaries at analyses 1 and 2) planned_if_h1 <- c(185 / 295, 245 / 295, 1) # Actual info fractions (more events than planned at final analysis) actual_if_h1 <- c(185 / 310, 245 / 310, 1) cat("Planned:", round(planned_if_h1, 4), "\n") cat("Actual: ", round(actual_if_h1, 4), "\n") ## ----monitoring-spending------------------------------------------------------ # Spending function using planned info fractions for spending, # with info_frac for NA structure validation spending_h1_monitor <- spending_with_time( spending_of, spending_time = planned_if_h1, info_frac = actual_if_h1 ) ## ----monitoring-comparison---------------------------------------------------- alpha_h1 <- 0.01 # H1's allocated alpha # Scenario 1: Planned (original design) bounds_planned <- gs_boundaries(alpha_h1, planned_if_h1, spending_of) # Scenario 2: Naive update (both use actual) bounds_naive <- gs_boundaries(alpha_h1, actual_if_h1, spending_of) # Scenario 3: Correct monitoring (spending=planned, correlation=actual) bounds_monitor <- gs_boundaries(alpha_h1, actual_if_h1, spending_h1_monitor) monitor_table <- data.frame( Analysis = 1:3, Planned.IF = round(planned_if_h1, 4), Actual.IF = round(actual_if_h1, 4), Boundary.Planned = bounds_planned$bounds_nominal, Boundary.Naive = bounds_naive$bounds_nominal, Boundary.Monitor = bounds_monitor$bounds_nominal ) knitr::kable(monitor_table, digits = 6, caption = paste("Boundaries under three scenarios", "(H1 with alpha = 0.01)")) ## ----monitoring-full---------------------------------------------------------- # Actual info fractions for all hypotheses # (only OS hypotheses affected; PFS and ORR are complete) actual_if_onc <- info_frac_onc actual_if_onc["H1_OS_S", ] <- c(185 / 310, 245 / 310, 1) actual_if_onc["H2_OS_A", ] <- c(529 / 830, 700 / 830, 1) # Spending functions using planned info fractions for OS hypotheses spending_fn_monitor <- list( spending_with_time(spending_of, spending_time = info_frac_onc["H1_OS_S", ], info_frac = actual_if_onc["H1_OS_S", ]), spending_with_time(spending_of, spending_time = info_frac_onc["H2_OS_A", ], info_frac = actual_if_onc["H2_OS_A", ]), spending_of, # H3: PFS complete, no change spending_of, # H4: PFS complete, no change spending_of, # H5: ORR complete spending_of # H6: ORR complete ) result_monitor <- graph_test_shortcut_gsd( graph = g_onc, p = p_onc, alpha = alpha_onc, info_frac = actual_if_onc, spending_fn = spending_fn_monitor, look_back = TRUE ) print(result_monitor) ## ----different-spending------------------------------------------------------- result2 <- graph_test_shortcut_gsd( graph = g, p = p, alpha = 0.025, info_frac = c(1/3, 2/3), spending_fn = list( spending_of, # H1: O'Brien-Fleming spending_of, # H2: O'Brien-Fleming spending_pocock, # H3: Pocock (more aggressive) spending_pocock # H4: Pocock (more aggressive) ), test_values = TRUE ) print(result2) ## ----gsdesign-wrapper--------------------------------------------------------- if (requireNamespace("gsDesign", quietly = TRUE)) { # Wrapper for gsDesign's Lan-DeMets O'Brien-Fleming gsdesign_of <- function(alpha, info_frac) { gsDesign::sfLDOF(alpha, info_frac)$spend } # Wrapper for gsDesign's Hwang-Shih-DeCani with gamma = -2 gsdesign_hsd <- function(alpha, info_frac) { gsDesign::sfHSD(alpha, info_frac, param = -2)$spend } result_gsdesign <- graph_test_shortcut_gsd( graph = g, p = p, alpha = 0.025, info_frac = c(1/3, 2/3), spending_fn = list( gsdesign_of, # H1: gsDesign O'Brien-Fleming gsdesign_of, # H2: gsDesign O'Brien-Fleming gsdesign_hsd, # H3: gsDesign HSD(gamma=-2) gsdesign_hsd # H4: gsDesign HSD(gamma=-2) ) ) print(result_gsdesign) } ## ----rpact-snippet------------------------------------------------------------ rpact::setLogLevel("DISABLED") repP <- function(pVals){ cum_n <- seq_along(pVals) * 2 design <- rpact::getDesignGroupSequential(typeOfDesign = "asOF", kMax = 3) data <- rpact::getDataset( cumMeans = c(qnorm(1 - pVals) / sqrt(cum_n)), cumStDevs = rep(1, length(pVals)), cumN = cum_n ) stage_res <- rpact::getStageResults(design, data, normalApproximation = TRUE) rpact::getRepeatedPValues(stage_res) } repP(c(0.0062, 0.0002)) repP(c(0.0170, 0.0035)) repP(c(0.0090, 0.0020)) repP(c(0.1300, 0.0600)) ## ----user-defined-spending---------------------------------------------------- # Piecewise spending: OBF for the first 'threshold' of alpha, # Pocock for the remainder spending_piecewise <- function(alpha, info_frac, threshold = 0.0125) { spending_of(pmin(alpha, threshold), info_frac) + spending_pocock(pmax(alpha - threshold, 0), info_frac) } # At alpha = 0.025: first 0.0125 is OBF, second 0.0125 is Pocock t <- c(1/3, 2/3, 1) comparison <- data.frame( `Info Fraction` = t, `OBF only` = spending_of(0.025, t), `Pocock only` = spending_pocock(0.025, t), Piecewise = spending_piecewise(0.025, t), check.names = FALSE ) knitr::kable(comparison, digits = 6, caption = "Piecewise spending: OBF for first half, Pocock for second half") ## ----user-defined-spending-half----------------------------------------------- # At alpha = 0.0125: entirely OBF (below threshold) all.equal( spending_piecewise(0.0125, t), spending_of(0.0125, t) ) ## ----user-defined-spending-gsd------------------------------------------------ result_piecewise <- graph_test_shortcut_gsd( graph = g, p = p, alpha = 0.025, info_frac = c(1/3, 2/3), spending_fn = spending_piecewise ) print(result_piecewise) .