From pst@jnx.com  Thu Oct 17 09:53:56 1996
Received: from red.jnx.com (red.jnx.com [208.197.169.254])
          by freefall.freebsd.org (8.7.5/8.7.3) with ESMTP id JAA11756
          for <FreeBSD-gnats-submit@freebsd.org>; Thu, 17 Oct 1996 09:53:55 -0700 (PDT)
Received: (from pst@localhost) by red.jnx.com (8.7.6/8.7.3) id JAA25524; Thu, 17 Oct 1996 09:53:24 -0700 (PDT)
Message-Id: <199610171653.JAA25524@red.jnx.com>
Date: Thu, 17 Oct 1996 09:53:24 -0700 (PDT)
From: Paul Traina <pst@jnx.com>
Reply-To: pst@jnx.com
To: FreeBSD-gnats-submit@freebsd.org
Subject: routed installing bogus routes
X-Send-Pr-Version: 3.2

>Number:         1831
>Category:       bin
>Synopsis:       routed's rdisc mode is installing incorrectly formatted routes
>Confidential:   no
>Severity:       non-critical
>Priority:       medium
>Responsible:    freebsd-bugs
>State:          closed
>Quarter:
>Keywords:
>Date-Required:
>Class:          sw-bug
>Submitter-Id:   current-users
>Arrival-Date:   Thu Oct 17 10:00:02 PDT 1996
>Closed-Date:    Sun Aug 17 12:14:15 PDT 1997
>Last-Modified:  Sun Aug 17 12:16:10 PDT 1997
>Originator:     Paul Traina
>Release:        FreeBSD 2.2-961004-SNAP i386
>Organization:
Juniper Networks, Inc.
>Environment:

running routed -q in the presense of router discovery -- a cisco is providing
router discovery replies

>Description:


-- 12:29:25 --
Tracing actions started
Add interface de0  208.197.169.254-->208.197.169.0/24 
RCVBUF=61440
turn on RIP
Add interface lo0  127.0.0.1      -->127.0.0.1/32    <LOOPBACK> <PASSIVE> 
Add    127.0.0.1/32    -->127.0.0.1        metric=0  <IF> lo0 12:29:25
Add    208.197.169.0   -->208.197.169.254  metric=0  <IF> de0 12:29:25
-- 12:29:26 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Add    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 12:29:26
turn off RIP
-- 12:29:27 --
route to 206.158.4.4/32 disappeared before RTM_DELETE
route to 192.48.96.136/32 disappeared before RTM_DELETE
-- 12:34:25 --
RTM_LOSING: 199.249.18.22/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:38:49 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:38:49 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:34:49
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:38:49
turn off RIP
-- 12:42:39 --
RTM_LOSING: 199.249.18.22/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:42:51 --
RTM_LOSING: 199.249.18.22/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 12:43:10 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:43:10 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:39:10
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:43:10
turn off RIP
-- 12:43:44 --
RTM_LOSING: 199.249.18.22/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:44:15 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:44:15 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:40:15
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:44:15
turn off RIP
-- 12:44:18 --
RTM_LOSING: 199.4.33.17/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:44:49 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:44:49 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:40:49
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:44:49
turn off RIP
-- 12:44:52 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:45:35 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:45:35 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:41:35
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:45:35
turn off RIP
-- 12:48:45 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:49:21 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:49:21 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:45:21
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:49:21
turn off RIP
-- 12:49:25 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:49:56 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:49:56 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:45:56
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:49:56
turn off RIP
-- 12:49:59 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:50:30 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:50:30 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:46:30
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:50:30
turn off RIP
-- 12:50:33 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:51:21 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:51:21 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:47:21
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:51:21
turn off RIP
-- 12:51:24 --
RTM_LOSING: 208.197.169.146/32
punt RTM_LOSING without gateway
-- 12:51:43 --
RTM_LOSING: 208.197.169.146/32
punt RTM_LOSING without gateway
-- 12:51:59 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:52:30 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:52:30 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:48:30
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:52:30
turn off RIP
-- 12:52:30 --
RTM_LOSING: 208.197.169.146/32
punt RTM_LOSING without gateway
-- 12:52:33 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:52:53 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.55.64.117/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 12:53:04 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:53:04 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:49:04
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:53:04
turn off RIP
-- 12:53:07 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:53:29 --
RTM_LOSING: 208.197.169.146/32
punt RTM_LOSING without gateway
-- 12:53:38 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:53:38 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:49:38
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:53:38
turn off RIP
-- 12:53:41 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:54:33 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:54:33 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:50:33
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:54:33
turn off RIP
-- 12:54:36 --
RTM_LOSING: 208.197.169.146/32
punt RTM_LOSING without gateway
-- 12:55:02 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 12:55:37 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 12:55:37 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:51:37
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 12:55:37
turn off RIP
-- 12:55:40 --
RTM_LOSING: 208.197.169.146/32
punt RTM_LOSING without gateway
-- 13:00:37 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.55.64.117/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:02:56 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:02:56 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:58:56
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:02:56
turn off RIP
-- 13:02:59 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.55.64.117/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:03:41 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:03:41 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 12:59:41
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:03:41
turn off RIP
-- 13:04:25 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.55.64.117/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:04:56 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:04:56 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:00:56
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:04:56
turn off RIP
-- 13:13:56 --
RTM_LOSING: 199.4.33.17/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:44:56 --
RTM_LOSING: 128.125.51.47/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:48:30 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:48:30 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:44:30
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:48:30
turn off RIP
-- 13:48:33 --
RTM_LOSING: 128.125.51.47/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:49:04 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:49:04 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:45:04
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:49:04
turn off RIP
-- 13:49:07 --
RTM_LOSING: 128.125.51.47/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:49:38 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:49:38 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:45:38
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:49:38
turn off RIP
-- 13:50:41 --
RTM_LOSING: 128.125.51.47/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:51:32 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:51:32 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:47:32
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:51:32
turn off RIP
-- 13:51:35 --
RTM_LOSING: 128.125.51.47/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:52:06 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:52:06 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:48:06
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:52:06
turn off RIP
-- 13:52:09 --
RTM_LOSING: 128.125.51.47/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:53:08 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:53:08 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:49:08
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:53:08
turn off RIP
-- 13:53:11 --
RTM_LOSING: 128.125.51.47/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:54:12 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:54:12 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:50:12
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:54:12
turn off RIP
-- 13:54:15 --
RTM_LOSING: 128.125.51.47/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:55:16 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:55:16 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:51:16
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:55:16
turn off RIP
-- 13:55:19 --
RTM_LOSING: 128.125.51.47/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:56:20 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:56:20 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:52:20
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:56:20
turn off RIP
-- 13:56:23 --
RTM_LOSING: 128.125.51.47/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 13:57:24 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 13:57:24 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:53:24
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 13:57:24
turn off RIP
-- 13:58:34 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 14:01:11 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 14:01:11 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:57:11
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 14:01:11
turn off RIP
-- 14:01:14 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 14:01:45 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 14:01:45 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:57:45
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 14:01:45
turn off RIP
-- 14:01:48 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 14:02:19 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 14:02:19 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 13:58:19
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 14:02:19
turn off RIP
-- 14:17:19 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 14:18:13 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 14:18:13 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 14:14:13
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 14:18:13
turn off RIP
-- 14:18:16 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 14:18:29 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 14:18:47 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 14:18:47 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 14:14:47
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 14:18:47
turn off RIP
-- 14:18:50 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 14:19:21 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 14:19:21 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 14:15:21
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 14:19:21
turn off RIP
-- 14:19:24 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 14:20:17 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 14:20:17 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 14:16:17
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 14:20:17
turn off RIP
-- 15:30:50 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.26.48.151/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 15:34:32 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 15:34:32 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 15:30:32
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 15:34:32
turn off RIP
-- 15:34:35 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.26.48.151/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 15:35:06 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 15:35:06 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 15:31:06
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 15:35:06
turn off RIP
-- 15:35:09 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.26.48.151/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 15:35:19 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.26.48.151/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 15:35:40 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 15:35:40 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 15:31:40
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 15:35:40
turn off RIP
-- 15:35:40 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.26.48.151/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 15:36:11 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 15:36:11 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 15:32:11
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 15:36:11
turn off RIP
-- 15:36:14 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.26.48.151/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 15:36:15 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.26.48.151/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 15:36:45 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 15:36:45 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 15:32:45
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 15:36:45
turn off RIP
-- 15:36:48 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.26.48.151/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 15:37:19 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 15:37:19 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 15:33:19
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 15:37:19
turn off RIP
-- 15:37:22 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.26.48.151/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 15:37:53 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 15:37:53 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 15:33:53
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 15:37:53
turn off RIP
-- 15:37:56 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.26.48.151/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 15:38:27 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 15:38:27 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 15:34:27
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 15:38:27
turn off RIP
-- 15:38:30 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.26.48.151/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 15:39:25 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.26.48.151/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 15:39:56 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 15:39:56 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 15:35:56
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 15:39:56
turn off RIP
-- 15:56:29 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 15:59:42 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 15:59:42 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 15:55:42
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 15:59:42
turn off RIP
-- 16:14:42 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 16:15:13 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 16:15:13 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 16:11:13
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 16:15:13
turn off RIP
-- 16:15:16 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 16:15:29 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 16:15:47 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 16:15:47 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 16:11:47
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 16:15:47
turn off RIP
-- 16:35:47 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 16:38:07 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 16:38:07 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 16:34:07
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 16:38:07
turn off RIP
-- 16:38:10 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 16:38:15 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 16:38:41 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 16:38:41 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 16:34:41
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 16:38:41
turn off RIP
-- 16:38:44 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 16:39:15 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 16:39:15 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 16:35:15
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 16:39:15
turn off RIP
-- 16:44:15 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 16:45:45 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 16:45:45 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 16:41:45
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 16:45:45
turn off RIP
-- 16:51:23 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 16:53:04 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 16:53:04 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 16:49:04
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 16:53:04
turn off RIP
-- 16:53:07 --
RTM_LOSING: 206.158.4.4/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 16:53:42 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 16:53:42 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 16:49:42
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 16:53:42
turn off RIP
-- 17:04:45 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 17:06:08 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 17:06:08 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 17:02:08
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 17:06:08
turn off RIP
-- 17:06:11 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 17:06:16 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 17:06:42 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 17:06:42 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 17:02:42
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 17:06:42
turn off RIP
-- 17:31:42 --
RTM_LOSING: 208.197.169.146/32
punt RTM_LOSING without gateway
-- 17:33:09 --
RTM_LOSING: 208.197.169.146/32
punt RTM_LOSING without gateway
-- 17:33:25 --
RTM_LOSING: 208.197.169.146/32
punt RTM_LOSING without gateway
-- 17:34:28 --
RTM_LOSING: 208.197.169.146/32
punt RTM_LOSING without gateway
-- 17:35:01 --
RTM_LOSING: 208.197.169.146/32
punt RTM_LOSING without gateway
-- 19:58:37 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 19:59:27 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 19:59:27 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 19:55:27
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 19:59:27
turn off RIP
-- 19:59:30 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 20:00:01 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 20:00:01 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 19:56:01
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 20:00:01
turn off RIP
-- 00:20:40 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 00:23:36 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 00:23:36 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 00:19:36
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 00:23:36
turn off RIP
-- 00:23:39 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 00:24:10 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 00:24:10 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 00:20:10
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 00:24:10
turn off RIP
-- 00:24:13 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 00:24:44 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 00:24:44 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 00:20:44
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 00:24:44
turn off RIP
-- 04:54:44 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 04:55:46 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 04:55:46 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 04:51:46
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 04:55:46
turn off RIP
-- 04:55:49 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 04:56:20 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 04:56:20 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 04:52:20
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 04:56:20
turn off RIP
-- 05:18:37 --
RTM_LOSING: 208.197.169.214/32
punt RTM_LOSING without gateway
-- 05:36:20 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 05:36:27 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 05:36:28 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 05:36:29 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 05:36:30 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 05:36:31 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 05:36:32 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 05:36:33 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 05:36:34 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 05:36:51 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 05:36:51 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 05:32:51
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 05:36:51
turn off RIP
-- 08:40:07 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 08:40:38 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 08:40:38 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 08:36:38
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 08:40:38
turn off RIP
-- 08:40:38 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 08:40:57 --
RTM_LOSING: 192.48.96.136/32 --> 208.197.169.253
-- 08:41:09 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 08:41:09 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 08:37:09
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 08:41:09
turn off RIP
-- 09:41:09 --
RTM_LOSING: 204.69.248.178/32 --> 208.197.169.253
age 0.0.0.0 --> 208.197.169.253 via de0
-- 09:45:32 --
discovered route is bad--re-solicit routers via de0
turn off Router Discovery client
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=0  <RDISC> de0 
                                           metric=16 <> 
turn on RIP
-- 09:45:32 --
turn on Router Discovery client using 208.197.169.253 via de0
Chg    0.0.0.0         -->208.197.169.253  metric=16 <> de0 09:41:32
                                           metric=0  <RDISC> 09:45:32
turn off RIP

>How-To-Repeat:

	

>Fix:
	
	

>Release-Note:
>Audit-Trail:

From: Bill Fenner <fenner@parc.xerox.com>
To: freebsd-gnats-submit@freebsd.org, pst@jnx.com
Cc:  Subject: Re: bin/1831: routed's rdisc mode is installing incorrectly formatted routes
Date: Mon, 21 Oct 1996 15:50:49 PDT

 Paul,
 
   Have you run "route monitor" or "netstat -nr" to see in exactly what
 way the routes are incorrectly formatted?  Could it actually simply be
 that routed is being way too sensitive in response to RTM_LOSING messages?
 (For example, freefall seems to see about 1 RTM_LOSING every couple of
 seconds, and yet routed appears to delete the default route after only
 1 or 2 RTM_LOSING's).
 
   Bill
State-Changed-From-To: open->feedback 
State-Changed-By: fenner 
State-Changed-When: Wed Nov 27 12:16:38 PST 1996 
State-Changed-Why:  
Have you run "route monitor" or "netstat -nr" to see in exactly what 
way the routes are incorrectly formatted?  Could it actually simply be 
that routed is being way too sensitive in response to RTM_LOSING messages? 
(For example, freefall seems to see about 1 RTM_LOSING every couple of 
seconds, and yet routed appears to delete the default route after only 
1 or 2 RTM_LOSING's). 
State-Changed-From-To: feedback->closed 
State-Changed-By: fenner 
State-Changed-When: Sun Aug 17 12:14:15 PDT 1997 
State-Changed-Why:  
No response in 10 months.  As stated in the audit-trail, I believe 
that routed is being too sensitive to RTM_LOSING's, which should 
be fixed in newer versions of routed like the one in -current. 
>Unformatted:
