From: Digestifier To: Linux-Development@senator-bedfellow.mit.edu Reply-To: Linux-Development@senator-bedfellow.mit.edu Date: Sun, 25 Sep 94 22:13:17 EDT Subject: Linux-Development Digest #227 Linux-Development Digest #227, Volume #2 Sun, 25 Sep 94 22:13:17 EDT Contents: Re: p5 code optimization for gcc (H. Peter Anvin) Re: Linux Floptical Disk Driver? (Phil Hughes) Re: elf benchmarks (getting closer) (John Richardson) Re: Linux on CD (Jeff Kesselman) Re: Special Sale On QNX! (Dan Pop) Re: elf benchmarks (getting closer) (Marc Fraioli) Re: NCR 53C406A SCSI (Mathias Koerber) Re: Special Sale On QNX! (Rob Janssen) Re: Don't use Linux?! (Darin Johnson) Re: [STATUS] Linus Floppy Driver Development (Mats 'MaDsen' Wikholm) Re: Special Sale On QNX! (Myles Williams) Re: more floppy problems with 1.1.51 (Andries Brouwer) Problem building intel gcc (Erann Gat) Re: 1.1.51 seg fault on shutdown in _floppy_release (David Flood) Re: elf benchmarks (getting closer) (Dan Connolly) Re: Digi Intelligent Boards? (Bob Salita) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: hpa@ahab.eecs.nwu.edu (H. Peter Anvin) Subject: Re: p5 code optimization for gcc Reply-To: hpa@nwu.edu (H. Peter Anvin) Date: Sun, 25 Sep 1994 19:03:24 GMT Followup to: <35v1uk$ssg@saba.rutgers.edu> By author: werche@saba.rutgers.edu (ChiWei Che) In newsgroup: comp.os.linux.development > > Hi all: > A faithful Linux user here. Recently, I got a Pentium machine, of course the > thing is dedicated to Linux. Yesterday, I am upgrading the gcc 2.5.6 to > intel optimized version of gcc 2.5.8. I use that to recompile the kernel, > the system is running faster before (although I didn't run any benchmark, and > I don't know any benchmark in Linux, but you definitely can feel it). To all > who are using the P5 CPU, try to replace the old one with pentium code, it's > better. > Are the 586 optimizations slated to be included with stock GCC 2.6? /hpa -- INTERNET: hpa@nwu.edu --- Allah'u'abha --- IBM MAIL: I0050052 at IBMMAIL HAM RADIO: N9ITP or SM4TKN FIDONET: 1:115/511 or 1:115/512 STORMNET: 181:294/1 or 181:294/101 "The Earth is but one country, and mankind its citizens." -- Baha'u'llah ------------------------------ From: fyl@eskimo.com (Phil Hughes) Subject: Re: Linux Floptical Disk Driver? Date: Sat, 24 Sep 1994 02:16:10 GMT Oliver Borowiak (root@develop1.psych.nat.tu-bs.de) wrote: : a few days ago my 3.5" FDD died, so if have to buy a new one. : My thought was why not a Floptical Disk Drive? : As I know, the were produced by IOMEGA. These drives can read : standard 3.5" 720k, 1.44M, 2.88M disks and the Floptical format : of about 21 MB. ... The story of support of Flopticals is a regular one I tell to explain to people why Linux is real. Ages ago (close to two years) someone asked on the net if they were supported. Within a day someone else posted a note that said that they required a special initialization sequence. Then, a day later someone else asked where they could get the initialization sequence. Then, a few days later there was a post explaining that the driver was now patched to support them. A sequence that overall took about a week. Expect a year or more from commercial vendors. Now, to answer your question: flopticals are SCSI devices. I have never used one but there should be special initialization code in the SCSI driver to talk to them. -- Phil Hughes, Publisher, Linux Journal (206) 527-3385 usually phil@ssc.com, sometimes fyl@eskimo.com ------------------------------ From: jrichard@cs.uml.edu (John Richardson) Subject: Re: elf benchmarks (getting closer) Date: 25 Sep 1994 20:09:17 GMT In article <363r9m$luo@news.nynexst.com>, H.J. Lu wrote: > [times where elf beats a.out] I wonder why? > >No, that is not a typo. ELF may be faster than a.out. But don't take >the result as is. 1000000 iterations are too small. The "benchmark" >varies a lot for both a.out and ELF. We need a better benchmark for >the ELF/PIC library. Also an ELF login shell makes a big diference. Wow! I guess I'll compile bash with ELF libraries! When I added -fomit-frame-pointer to my compiles of the qsort test I couldn't tell the difference between ELF and a.out qsort times. Patrick Schaaf (bof@wg.saar.de) mailed me a more scientific benchmark but I haven't looked at it yet. I'll forward it to whomever would like a look. Surely there must be a publicly available benchmark of system library calls? If not, I was thinking of writing a quick bench of the more popular calls (read, write, open, close, etc) just to see how a.out and ELF compare there. Awesome work H.J. & co! -- John Richardson jrichard@cs.uml.edu ------------------------------ From: jeffpk@netcom.com (Jeff Kesselman) Subject: Re: Linux on CD Date: Sun, 25 Sep 1994 19:14:20 GMT In article <35od4d$8jq@senator-bedfellow.mit.edu>, wrote: >:In article 9tC@pe1chl.ampr.org, rob@pe1chl.ampr.org (Rob Janssen) writes: >:=>In fagarcia@cs.bsu.edu writes: >:=> >:=>>I was having a chat with someone over the net and we came to this.. >:=>>What if Linux came fully implemented (X & all the disk sets) on a CD and >:=>>all you would have to do is boot off the CD rom and have the >:=>>settings/option files (ie ~/.seyon inittab & the rc scrips) in your HD. >:=> >:=>>I mean, this would save a lot of diskspace ;) >:=> >:=>There are several CD-ROMs available that allow you to do this... >:=> >: >:I can confirm this. I tried it with the TransAmeritech CD, release April 1994. >:[DELETED] >:I think it's more reasonable to have the often used stuff on your HD, and the >:less used stuff you can run from CD-ROM. >: >:How do other people feel about running from CD-ROM? I do like the idea of >:saving HD-space, but it becomes too slow for me to be usable. > >What I think (for what it's worth) would be useful would be >the ability to merge the CD-ROM's directory with the HD's and >the HD's files would take precedence. That way if you want to >make a change or just want the speed of the HD you could copy >the file(s) to the HD in the same spot (directory and file name). >Just a vague thought... > Thsi is how my Yygdrasil works. The stuff that is still on cd-rom exists as a link to the cd-rom on the hard-drive. When i install it, it copies over the link. Jeff kesselman ------------------------------ From: danpop@cernapo.cern.ch (Dan Pop) Subject: Re: Special Sale On QNX! Date: Sun, 25 Sep 1994 22:26:23 GMT In <364pfh$knh@martha.utk.edu> williams@martha.utcc.utk.edu (Myles Williams) writes: > Florida Datamation has been a QNX distributor for 10 years! We are nice, > knowledgable and go the extra mile for the sale. And, we promise to BEAT > ANYONE'S PRICE! > >That's quite a claim in this newsgroup! I wonder how much they are >going to pay me. > Don't wonder too much. Have a look at the headers of the original article: Newsgroups: comp.os.linux.development,comp.os.linux.development Path: CERN.ch!EU.net!howland.reston.ans.net!swrinde!sgiblab!pacbell.com!att-out!undergrad.math.uwaterloo.ca!zmailer--not-for-mail From: scheidel@gate.net () Subject: Special Sale On QNX! X-Mail-Message-Id: <849328273928.C72D265@inca.gate.net> Message-ID: Originator: root@undergrad.math.uwaterloo.ca Precedence: normal-delivery Sender: news@undergrad.math.uwaterloo.ca (news spool owner) Now, is this article coming from Florida or from Waterloo? Or is Florida Datamation doing business from the host undergrad.math.uwaterloo.ca? :-) Dan -- Dan Pop CERN, CN Division Email: danpop@cernapo.cern.ch Mail: CERN - PPE, Bat. 31 R-004, CH-1211 Geneve 23, Switzerland ------------------------------ From: mjf@clark.net (Marc Fraioli) Subject: Re: elf benchmarks (getting closer) Date: 25 Sep 1994 21:09:12 GMT Reply-To: mjf@clark.net In article luo@news.nynexst.com, hjl@nynexst.com (H.J. Lu) writes: >No, that is not a typo. ELF may be faster than a.out. But don't take >the result as is. 1000000 iterations are too small. The "benchmark" >varies a lot for both a.out and ELF. We need a better benchmark for >the ELF/PIC library. Also an ELF login shell makes a big diference. > If ELF is so much easier to develop with, and it requires significant effort to craft a benchmark on which a.out is faster, why bother? I vote for ELF. --- Marc Fraioli | "They couldn't hit an elephant at this dist- " mjf@clark.net | - Last words of Union General John Sedgwick, | Battle of Spotsylvania Court House, U.S. Civil War ------------------------------ From: mathias@unicorn.swi.com.sg (Mathias Koerber) Subject: Re: NCR 53C406A SCSI Date: 24 Sep 1994 07:10:12 GMT Reply-To: Mathias.Koerber@swi.com.sg In (<35qc63$p9u@csnews.cs.Colorado.EDU>) Drew Eckhardt (drew@frisbee.cs.Colorado.EDU) wrote: | In article <35q6ko$bnr@potogold.rmii.com>, | Pete Cascio wrote: | > | >I've got a Media Vision Pro 3D sound card with SCSI-2. The SCSI-2 chip is an | >NCR 53C406A. It looks like it's probably something new, since it's not | >mentioned in the SCSI-HOWTO. | >Does anyone know about this chip? | Sure - the NCR53c406a is a more integrated version of the NCR53c90, | very similar to what NCR did with the NCR53c400 which was based on the | NCR53c80. So, will there ever be a driver for the 53C94? I have such a beast (ICL ErgoPro D4/66dXG) smug on the motherboard, and can't use it :-( cheers (or no cheers in this case) | >Is it compatible (no changes required) with | >another supported NCR SCSI chip driver? | An alpha NCR53c406a driver is available via anonymous FTP from | tsx-11.mit.edu:/pub/linux/ALPHA/scsi/ncr53c406-0.9.patch.gz. | -- | Since our leaders won't respect The Constitution, the highest law of our | country, you can't expect them to obey lesser laws of any country. | Boycott the United States until this changes. -- Mathias Koerber Tel: +65 / 778 00 66 x 29 SW International Systems Pte Ltd Fax: +65 / 777 94 01 14 Science Park Drive #04-01 The Maxwell e-mail: Mathias.Koerber@swi.com.sg S'pore 0511 MK When anyone asks me how I can best describe my experience in nearly forty years at sea, I merely say, uneventful. Of course there have been winter gales, and storms and fog and the like. But in all my experience, I have never been in any accident... or any sort worth speaking about. I have seen but one vessel in distress in all my years at sea. I never saw a wreck and never have been wrecked nor was I ever in any predicament that threatened to end in disaster of any sort. E. J. Smith, 1907 Captain, RMS Titanic ------------------------------ From: rob@pe1chl.ampr.org (Rob Janssen) Subject: Re: Special Sale On QNX! Reply-To: pe1chl@rabo.nl Date: Sun, 25 Sep 1994 22:29:00 GMT In scheidel@gate.net () writes: >Why settle for slow and obselete Unix such as UnixWare, Sun Solaris, >SCO, Linux or BSD when you can have POWER & RELIABILITY with QNX 4.21! >Stop playing games with these inferior o/s's and switch to QNX today. Hey come on, a bit more humble announcements would be nice! Especially from someone who posts the same article twice in the same group. Done under QNX, I suppose? Rob -- ========================================================================= | Rob Janssen | AMPRnet: rob@pe1chl.ampr.org | | e-mail: pe1chl@rabo.nl | AX.25 BBS: PE1CHL@PI8UTR.#UTR.NLD.EU | ========================================================================= ------------------------------ From: djohnson@seuss.ucsd.edu (Darin Johnson) Subject: Re: Don't use Linux?! Date: 24 Sep 1994 01:39:16 GMT > >One could think > >that companies are willing to consider Linux a reasonable and serious > >platform, and that they would port and offer their products to the > >Linux community. However, they are far away from doing so, actually. Wow, this is all very deja-vu, with my experience in the Amiga community. It was always "we have X million machines out there, why won't they port such-and-such?" or something like that. I think the bottom line is that for the really big wizzy msdos programs, they won't get ported. Look for alternatives though. Number of units doesn't count when you're regarded as a fringe group. Hefty contributions can change their mind though, and is part of the reason some of this stuff gets ported to major unix players. > While I agree and disagree in varying amounts with the rest of this message > I would like to take agree with the above, in general, but object to the > statement that NO commercial companies have or will port their products.. Here, I must agree. Too often people want MS Word, but they're unwilling to consider other word processors. The number of Linux sites is *irrelevant* here! When the Amiga had fewer number of machines than Linux sites, there were many commercial offerings. When there were X million sold, people were annoyed that big-name (but low quality) PC companies weren't porting their stuff, but failed to note all the great companies that were there for the Amiga. The point is, work on your grassroots, loyal companies that have stuff for Linux rather than complain that Word or Lotus or Autocad or whatever the latest rage is hasn't yet been ported. > What are we? Chopped Liver? In many places, chopped liver is a delicacy. It's an acquired taste though. However, the biggest trouble Linux has is distribution channels. With Amiga, it was simple - you walk into your local Amiga store and see what was on the shelves. Companies had a distribution channel. With Linux you don't have that. You can't walk into most PC stores and get Linux stuff (actually, I'm just guessing, since I've never been in one) , and there isn't a company making Linux with the budget to go around and convince places to stock this stuff. Linux Journal is probably a good advertising place, but mail-order is such a pain for most people, and impulse buys are small. Perhaps a "Linux Developers Coop" that could produce a brochure of products to give to software stores and such. -- Darin Johnson djohnson@ucsd.edu Ensign, activate the Wesley Crusher! ------------------------------ From: mwikholm@at8.abo.fi (Mats 'MaDsen' Wikholm) Subject: Re: [STATUS] Linus Floppy Driver Development Date: Sun, 25 Sep 1994 23:54:17 GMT In article <35ub68$knv@imag.imag.fr> Alain.Knaff@imag.fr writes: >Larry Doolittle (doolitt@recycle.cebaf.gov) wrote: >[auto mounting a floppy as soon as it is inserted] [snip] > Unfortunately, this seems to be impossible to do on PC hardware. >There are no separate disk change and disk presence indicators [snip] >a disk is inserted would need to seek endlessly until a disk is >inserted. This would make a rather annoying noise, and would probably >wear off the stepper motor as well. I'm no programmer (yet) so hang me if I'm way off but wouldn't it be possible to automagically mount the floppy only when it is accessed. I mean that you don't have to have it mounted before you access it so when you try to access it the system checks if it is mounted and if it isn't it gets mounted. If there's no disk in it you get a flaming error. -- . . . mwikholm@at8.abo.fi / win-nt from the people who invented edlin . . . . frantzgatan 3 E 25 / apples have meant trouble since eden . . . . 20380 abo finland / Linux, the way to get rid of boot viruses . . . . @358.(9)21.377.363 / http://at8.abo.fi/~mwikholm/ (under work) . . . . ------------------------------ From: williams@martha.utcc.utk.edu (Myles Williams) Subject: Re: Special Sale On QNX! Date: 25 Sep 1994 17:18:41 -0400 Florida Datamation has been a QNX distributor for 10 years! We are nice, knowledgable and go the extra mile for the sale. And, we promise to BEAT ANYONE'S PRICE! That's quite a claim in this newsgroup! I wonder how much they are going to pay me. Myles Williams "When you see me again, it won't be me." ------------------------------ From: aeb@cwi.nl (Andries Brouwer) Subject: Re: more floppy problems with 1.1.51 Date: Sun, 25 Sep 1994 21:17:55 GMT s0017210@unix1.cc.ysu.edu (Steve DuChene) writes: > I applied the patch suggested to floppy.c (changing > if(filp->f_mode & 2) to if(filp && (filp->f_mode & 2)) and that That was not the patch I suggested. It should be if (!filp || (filp->f_mode & 2)) ------------------------------ From: gat@robotics.jpl.nasa.gov (Erann Gat) Subject: Problem building intel gcc Date: Wed, 21 Sep 1994 16:37:55 -0800 While building the Intel gcc (the one with the P5 optimizations) I get the following error during the compilation of libgcc2.a: [Much stuff deleted] _muldi3 /tmp/cca08836.s: Assembler messages: /tmp/cca08836.s:6: Error: Unknown pseudo-op: `.section' make: *** [libgcc2.a] Error 1 I am using the gnu assembler, version 2.2. Any idea how to get around this error? Thanks, E. -- Erann Gat gat@robotics.jpl.nasa.gov ------------------------------ From: dcflood@u.washington.edu (David Flood) Subject: Re: 1.1.51 seg fault on shutdown in _floppy_release Date: 25 Sep 1994 22:11:54 GMT evansmp@mb4715.aston.ac.uk (Mark Evans) writes: >What is happening is that floppy_release is being called with filp equal to 0 >If you apply the following patch umount will no longer blow up. >--- floppy.c.old Wed Sep 21 15:32:04 1994 >+++ floppy.c Wed Sep 21 15:31:48 1994 >@@ -2713,7 +2713,7 @@ > { > int drive= DRIVE(inode->i_rdev); > >- if(filp->f_mode & 2) >+ if(filp && (filp->f_mode & 2)) > fsync_dev(inode->i_rdev); > if ( UDRS->fd_ref < 0) > UDRS->fd_ref=0; I applied the above patch and now I get the following during shutdown but NOT during user execution of umount: Unmounting file systems..... floppy: timeout floppy I/O error dev 0200, sector 2 Done. This is a known good disk. Just to make sure, I copied the data off, re-fdisk'ed it, ran mk2efs on it with block checking, and then ran badblocks on it with write (and got an empty list) and finally re-copied the data back to it. According to the boot messages, the FDC is a 8272A. The controler is a WD1007 floppy/esdi hard drive controler in a 386sx-16 so I don't think that bus speed is too high. Anybody got any other ideas? For now I am going to stick with 1.1.50 -- ============================================================================= dcflood@u.washington.edu The above opinions are mine alone and do not reflect anyone elses. Besides, who wants my opinion anyway? ============================================================================= ------------------------------ From: connolly@hal.com (Dan Connolly) Subject: Re: elf benchmarks (getting closer) Date: 25 Sep 1994 22:18:47 GMT In article <364oto$5fo@clarknet.clark.net> mjf@clark.net (Marc Fraioli) writes: In article luo@news.nynexst.com, hjl@nynexst.com (H.J. Lu) writes: >No, that is not a typo. ELF may be faster than a.out. But don't take >the result as is. 1000000 iterations are too small. The "benchmark" >varies a lot for both a.out and ELF. We need a better benchmark for >the ELF/PIC library. Also an ELF login shell makes a big diference. > If ELF is so much easier to develop with, and it requires significant effort to craft a benchmark on which a.out is faster, why bother? I vote for ELF. I think I understand the sentiment, and I agree -- ELF looks inevitable. But keep in mind that there are others who are not so easily convinced... Anyway... I'm learning a lot from seeing some of the benchmarking data -- and especially the interpretations. I encourage folks to do more and better benchmarking. libc is a fairly important bunch of code to optimize. Perhaps we'll find some 1-liner optimization that will make the vast majority of linux applications run 5% faster -- or an optimization that will make one key application (like gcc) or one key subsystem (like TCP/IP) run 10% faster. Not likely, but worth the effort, if just for the knowledge gained. Dan -- Daniel W. Connolly "We believe in the interconnectedness of all things" Software Engineer, Hal Software Systems, OLIAS project (512) 834-9962 x5010 http://www.hal.com/%7Econnolly/index.html ------------------------------ From: softwork@MCS.COM (Bob Salita) Subject: Re: Digi Intelligent Boards? Date: 23 Sep 1994 14:16:55 -0500 Troy DeJongh (troyd@digibd.digibd.com) wrote: : ahmed@oea.xs4all.nl (Ahmed Naas) writes: : >madderra@myhost.subdomain.domain wrote: : > ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ : >You need to change this :-) : >: I visited the Digiboard display at Interop this week, and was told by one : >: of the sales reps that Digiboard was getting pressure from SCO not to : >: promote the creation of new drivers for Linux. In particular, I was : >: asking about thier new ISDN board they had on display. : >That might be true, but what possible leverage does SCO have over Digi? : >: --Bob : >-- : >The above is a result of random neuron activity in the writer's brain. : >Ahmed M. Naas ahmed@oea.xs4all.nl : >---------------------------------------------------------------------- : Well, I'm responsible for the maintenance/development of our SCO serial : drivers and the development of the Linux driver for our PC/Xe product, : and I haven't heard anything like that yet. Plans are to release a : Linux driver for our PC/Xe line of products this fall. : -- : Troy De Jongh Digiboard (troyd@digibd.com) Troy, do you know of any plans for isdn drivers for digiboards stuff? What do the progressive Digiboard marketing people think about Linux? Bob ------------------------------ ** FOR YOUR REFERENCE ** The service address, to which questions about the list itself and requests to be added to or deleted from it should be directed, is: Internet: Linux-Development-Request@NEWS-DIGESTS.MIT.EDU You can send mail to the entire list (and comp.os.linux.development) via: Internet: Linux-Development@NEWS-DIGESTS.MIT.EDU Linux may be obtained via one of these FTP sites: nic.funet.fi pub/OS/Linux tsx-11.mit.edu pub/linux sunsite.unc.edu pub/Linux End of Linux-Development Digest ****************************** .