Subj : 3I/ATLAS
To   : All
From : roman
Date : Sun Jul 27 2025 07:01:44

Why is the official science that ignores alien theories so active in criticizing the idea that 3I/ATLAS is an Alien Probe?
https://sites.psu.edu/astrowright/2025/07/18/avi-and-3i-atlas/
You know, I've been in this topic for a long time, and I find this behavior strange.
And:
What do astronomical dissidents say about the comet?

1. Bizarre Appearance

Looks spherical, resembling either:
A comet with a bright nucleus and coma.
A planet-sized object (Mars/Venus scale) with an atmosphere.
Initial size estimate: ~20 km in diameter.
Official update: Glowing region spans 25,000 km-far larger than expected.

2. Highly Implausible Trajectory

a) Orbit aligns almost parallel to Earth's (within 5ø of the ecliptic).
Probability of random interstellar comet matching this: <0.2%.
b) Makes close passes to Venus (0.65 AU), Mars (0.19 AU), and Jupiter (0.36 AU).
Combined probability: ~0.005%.
c) At perihelion, positioned opposite Earth behind the Sun-suspiciously convenient to avoid scrutiny.
Statistically absurd for a natural object.

3. Statistically Improbable Discovery

Detecting an interstellar object like 'Oumuamua in 5 years: 0.0001% chance.
Finding one 20 km+ in size (or larger) should take ~50 million years.
If it's a "comet-planet," odds are lower than the age of the universe.

4. Anomalous Spectral Data

Lacks typical comet gas signatures (no atomic/molecular spectral lines).
Shows only reddened reflected sunlight, suggesting:
Cosmic dust clouds or
Surface properties akin to Kuiper Belt objects (turned red over billions of years by UV/cosmic rays).
Yet, 3I/ATLAS reddened in just a few years-or was always red.

5. Questionable "Comet Tail" Claims

Official images show a "tail," but:
At 60 km/s speed, long telescope exposures (2-3+ minutes) blur any fast-moving object (even a race car).
Likely not a real tail, just motion artifacts.

6. Suppression of Dissent

Astronomer Avi Loeb faces ridicule in media/journals for suggesting unnatural origins.
Scientific backlash forces him to seek psychological support.
Raises concerns about possible suppression/conspiracy in mainstream astronomy.

Conclusion: 8 Suspicious Clues

Combined evidence suggests 3I/ATLAS is artificial or engineered-possibly a
planet-sized spacecraft (given its 25,000 km "atmosphere").
Authorities appear to be hiding something, fueling speculation about its true nature.

9 We are not provided with the object's spectrograms.

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Linux/64)
 * Origin: Shipwrecks & Shibboleths [San Francisco, CA - USA] (700:100/72)

.