Subj : Re: ALLFIX dupes?
To   : Tommi Koivula
From : Nicholas Boel
Date : Sun Jun 14 2015 13:36:22

Hello Tommi,

On 14 Jun 15 18:56, Tommi Koivula wrote to Nicholas Boel:

 TK> You're welcome! :)

 TK> I was aware about this Allfix6/JAM/NoMSGID problem, and that's why I
 TK> have posted my reports as .PKT for a long time.

 TK> This hpt dupe problem is new. Maybe hpt really thinks that Allfix
 TK> messages are dupes because From, To and Subj are very often the same
 TK> and also the MSGID is the same when there is no MSGID. ;)

This may not be related to hpt at all. I actually think it's now an issue with 
my hub (which is Synchronet, not hpt), which may only be checking for MSGID. So 
if they're not present, it will pass any dupes on to my Golded+/hpt system 
where they are found by hpt. 

I believe hpt is working as it should. I'm just receiving multiple of the same 
message because Synchronet is passing them through and not catching them as 
dupes because there's no MSGID.

While it may be a bug that Allfix is not creating messages with a MSGID (which 
would probably pass through any tosser only utilizing MSGID dupe checking), 
it's also most likely a bug in Synchronet's tosser that is not catching them as 
dupes and sending them on anyways because of that missing MSGID.

This may in fact give me more motivation to reverse these two systems I have 
running here, making hpt/binkd my hub system and Synchronet just an end point 
node.

Regards,
Nick

--- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5-b20130910
 * Origin: thePharcyde_ telnet://bbs.pharcyde.org (Wisconsin) (1:154/701)

.