Subj : Great Replacement Theory
To   : Kaelon
From : Arelor
Date : Sat May 28 2022 05:25:14

  Re: Great Replacement Theory
  By: Kaelon to boraxman on Fri May 27 2022 09:31 am

 > non-whites in your country (again, a racist perspective) - then you need to
 > confront the demographic failures of your country.  It starts with birth rat
 > (and this is controversial) but until your country generates 2,100 births fo
 > every 1,000 women, it in effect cannot replace its population to stay
 > population neutral.  Most Western Countries have abysmal birth rates (born,

The problem I have with that argument is that the Western countries taking
immigrants from poor countries in a massive way and which have internal
demographic crisis usually have a demographic crisis because they cannot cope
with more population.

Sure, in Spain we could keep on multiplying like rabbits. However, we could not
maintain our offspring in an environment considered acceptable by current
Spanish standards. There is simply no demand for more people to exist.

If you try to think of some business to start in Spain you soon realize that
every need you could fullfil is already satisfied by an existing
infrastructure. The unemployed to vacancies ratio is not favorable either. This
translates in lots of mini-phenomena which occur in society and makes people
not have more children, because Spaniards don't want to have children which
will end up living in poverty.

Meanwhile lots of South Americans tend to produce children first and wonder
what to do with them later. I have had this conversation with Chilenans and
Argentinians so I don't think this is a reckless affirmation. Spain has some
pro-natality policies in place which attempt to cover the most common expenses
in raising a child, but Chilenans seem to produce a kid, use the natality funds
for their own purposes, and then raise their kid in a regime which Spaniards
would consider unaceptable poverty (such as without using diapers or anything).

Personally, if I loved Spanish culture I would be concerned because the
meassures the government is taking for helping make more native Spaniards are
being used for helping make more native outsiders. Put in that perspective,
that *looks* like a replacement conspiracy. Keep in mind that for most
nationalists, having the papers won't make you a Spaniard: having gazpacho and
Holy Week parties and system of ethics which is reminiscent of Roman Law kind
of does. Nationalists then don't recognize importing people whose idea of
justice is hanging thieves in the square as a way of saving their culture...
Importing talibans, for example, would make the Spanish Nation-State
demographically sustainable but would not make Spanish culture sustainable.

--
gopher://gopher.richardfalken.com/1/richardfalken

---
 þ Synchronet þ Palantir BBS * palantirbbs.ddns.net * Pensacola, FL

.