Subj : Re: OT - Two Towers (possible spoilers) To : All From : Kavanagh Date : Mon Dec 23 2002 09:06 pm You are correct re Faramir character, and thats a much larger departure from the book than anything I mentioned. Cant see any reason for it even. Movie portrayed him as a shifty version of his brother, who saw the light eventually. >From a message by menudo about Re: OT - Two Towers (possible spoilers): > totally wrong portrayal of farimir....nothing like the book at all. > > >From a message by SupGx about Re: OT - Two Towers (possible spoilers): > > Also, After Farimir captured Golem, in the book Sam, Frodo, and Golem were > released and not taken into Gondor as in the movie. > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Kavanagh" > To: > Sent: Sunday, December 22, 2002 9:20 PM > Subject: [twgsdotorg] Re: OT - Two Towers (possible spoilers) > > > > > > Went to see it with my Lady Wife this afternoon. An excellent film/movie. > Several differences from the book but it would be very difficult to convey > written stuff to a movie; by and large it was very well done (I am > pontificating in an area without my competence). > > > > Two significant departures from the written Two Towers: > > > > The Ents in the movie decided that they would not intervene until the > Hobbits "tricked" them. > > > > Helm's Deep final defense is not as written. > > > > Arwen Aragorn dilemma was very well addressed. > > > > > > > > >From a message by col sanders about OT - Two Towers: > > > So, has anyone seen it yet? Anyone want to review it for me? Whats > > different from the book? What did they do well, and not do well? Are > > there any parts where I should watch for anything special or cool? > > > > > > --- FEddy 1.4.03/modPHX * Origin: http://www.twgs.org -- THE Trade Wars web forum! (1:229/522.0) .