Subj : Back again To : RICHARD M. MEIC From : Frank Masingill Date : Fri Jul 13 2001 09:56 pm > -> Read "Debate of a Man Contemplating Suicide with his Soul" of circa > -> 2,000-2,500 BCE > Okay, Frank... > You do realize that it will take a long time to track down the piece. I > just finished a search on the net and found only 1 refference ("Eric > Voegelin Remembered") where you yourself made a number of comments. > By the time I find the reference itself and read it this topic will have > been long over and perhaps even both of us will have forgotten why it came > up in the first place. So, if you would be so kind as to quote me the > pertinent passages I would be greatful. :o) You can find it quite handily in the old and reliable Pritchard's _Near Eastern Texts_, Richard. Should be in any library of any size even those not too well stocked. You will find a number of such ancient Egyptian texts of that period, e.g., the "Song of the Harper" wherein the sentiments of atheism and resignation parallel modern ones. I judge that is what is meant by the writer of Ecclesiastes when he opines that "there is nothing new under the sun." Frank --- * Origin: Frank's House (1:396/45.12) .