Subj : Re: Episode III
To   : The Navigator
From : Time Walker
Date : Wed May 25 2005 12:25 am

  Re: Re: Episode III
  By: The Navigator to Gryphon on Tue May 24 2005 10:22 pm

 >   Re: Re: Episode III
 >   By: Gryphon to Time Walker on Tue May 24 2005 11:15 am
 > 
 >  > On 05-23-05, Time Walker said...
 >  > TW> BTW, did anyone else catch the major timeline screwup that Lucas blat
 >  > TW> put in this movie?  Granted it's obscure, but he should have watched 
 >  > TW> of the Jedi" prior to writing this script.  Just pitiful.  I would te
 >  > TW> what it is, but it would definitely be a spoiler.
 >  >
 >  > go ahead and spoil.  I'm sure it won't hurt anybody's feelings.  What did
 >  > you notice?
 >  >
 > 
 > In "Return of the Jedi", Luke asks Leia do you remember your mother?  She
 > responds that her mother was very beautiful but sad.  He then says that he h
 > no memory of his mother.
 > 
 > Going by this dialogue, Padme should have lived for at least 2-3 years after
 > the birth of the twins and then died.  Newborns cannot possibly understand t
 > concepts of beauty and sadness.  The twins would have been separated at birt
 > with Luke going to his uncle Lars with Obiwan in tow for protection.  Leia
 > would have gone with her mother into hiding for a couple of years, prior to 
 > death of a broken heart.
 > 
 > That would have made a lot more sense.

Give the man a cigar.  Nailed it.

It would have followed the original storyline and proposed timeline of the
saga.


---
 þ Synchronet þ Nostalgia BBS - nosbbs.gotdns.com

.