Subj : Re: Episode III
To   : Angus Mcleod
From : Finnigann
Date : Tue May 24 2005 01:19 am

-=> With interpidation and the MAGIC of QWK Mail Angus Mcleod wrote to All <=-

 AM> Okay, just back from watching it.

 AM> Tremendous, sweeping city-scapes and planet-scapes.  Extensive,
 AM> highly detailed shots of space fleets and ground-pounding armies.
 AM>  Alien architecture of uber-gothic scope.

 AM> Tedious, artificial dialigue.  Appalling acting from
 AM> Anakin/Vader, even worse than Episode II, if you can believe it
 AM> -- here's hoping he gets the Pinnochio award at the next Oscars,
 AM> nobody else could be more wooden. Impossible-to-believe plot
 AM> devices, that depend upon the stupidity of *everyone* for them to
 AM> work.

George Lucas should have ALL writting instruments removed from his
reach.


 AM> Enormous reliance on special effects can not redeem this movie.
 AM> It is bad.  Or shall I be kind and say it simply wasn't good?  If
 AM> you have watched the other five episodes, you will want to watch
 AM> this, just so you can say you've seen them all.

I had hopes... but the hope was smashed.

Everyone knew Anikin was going to become Vader, yet Lucas made the movie
as if no one knew. He tried to make up a reason for Anikin to switch and
I hoped the padmin child birth thing would work... but as you state, the
acting was horible. I can not believe Hayden could have gotten so far
and not be able to deliver a proformance better than this. So I chalk it
up tp mass confussion on the part of the director.




 AM> One silver lining:  That jive-talkin', shuckin' and dancin',
 AM> dredlock- wearin', rastafarian arsehole "Jah-Jah Binks" never
 AM> showed up that I noticed.  Yay!  He being a "satanic masturbation

 I think he had a ten second part -- running out of the senate as it was
 collapsing. No speaking part...

 My young son and I reviewed the first three episodes yesterday.

Continuity was horrble. I wonder if GL tried to write the ---sith---
from his memory of how the first three (made) went.

Amatuer gafs abound.

And now after Revenge of the Sith... the First shows suck too.

Everyone should get a refund... going back 28 years.



  ³ James King       KC8UGV ³ 
  ³ Sysop  Bits-N-Bytes BBS ³ 
  ³ Coldwater, MI     49036 ³ 
http://www.synchro.net/sbbslist.html³

.... My girlfriend says I don't pay attention, or something like that.
--- MultiMail/Win32 v0.45
 þ Synchronet þ Bits-N-Bytes BBS    Onehellofa BBS     bnb.dtdns.net

.