發信人: mcpyeung@hknet.com (Paul)
日期: Fri, 7 Feb 2003 15:52:40 +0800
標題: Re: 李筱峰：過著台獨的生活反台獨？
信群: tw.bbs.soc.politics,hk.politics,alt.chinese.text.big5    看板: 
來源: <3e43643c@newsgate.hknet.com>:798288, vp192074.kln.uac1.hknet.com
組織: 

> On Thu, 6 Feb 2003 21:26:15 +0800, "k" <k@sinaman.com> wrote:
>
> >American vote for the future of USA. Fine.
> >
> >But if Taiwanese vote for the future of Taiwanese,
> >
> >can one day Taipei people vote for the future of Taipei after forming a
> >local government? if so,
>
> Nope.  Because Taipei is under jurisdiction of 中華民國憲法。


Years ago, a group of mainland Chinese people went to Taiwan and made up "中
華民國憲法",
and attempted to seperate it from it's motherland "CHINA".

The question is at that time, Taiwan was already independent or part of
China.

If former, any evidence?

If latter, why not Taipei people can one day made up their new constitution
and request seperate from Taiwan.


>
>
> >can one day the people live in your building forming a government vote
for
> >the future of your owning building?
> >
> >Years ago, a group of Chinese went to Taiwan(part of China) and formed a
> >local government and request to
> >vote for the future of Taiwan.  Sounds funny.
>
> Nothing funny at all.  中華民國憲法 allows such legislation and
> there is a Central Government by the Constitution, *not* local
> government.

I think it quite depends on the validity of 中華民國憲法.
If today Taipei people made up a new constitution of Taipei, you must say
that it is NOT valid because of 中華民國憲法.

But the day "those Chinese people who went to Taiwan years ago" made up 中華
民國憲法, was it valid?




.