To Live (1994) Directed by Zhang Yimou The film portrays the daily life and struggles of one family from the Chinese civil war to the end of the Cultural Revolution. The film is an accurate portrayal in the sense that there are certainly many people who could tell stories similar to the film's. But in the end, by choosing "apolitical" protagonists, the film obscures the most important political question of the times: revolution *for whom*. And by concentrating on the sacrifices of one family the film downplays the tremendous gains the Chinese people made under Maoist leadership. Western bourgeois critics of communism are calling this film a passionate indictment of Maoism (even though they cannot tell the difference between Deng and Mao). They point to the children's deaths as examples of the Maoist state's willingness to "selfishly sacrifice its people" and claim that the state could not just allow the Chinese people "to simply live." But this criticism misses the point: China was an extremely poor nation (thanks to centuries of imperialist and feudal domination), so disease, poverty, and exhausting work were commonplace before and after the revolution. The revolution aimed to change the relationships which kept the Chinese people in poverty - and in this the Chinese Communist Party largely succeeded. For example, life expectancy doubled from 35 in the '40s to 69 in the '70s.